The Pros And Cons Of Shallow Depth Of Field

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
This video is sponsored by Squarespace, the all-in-one platform that you can use to easily
craft and manage a website for your business. Ever noticed how some shots in movies have a
blurry background, while in others everything is pin sharp across the entire frame? This is due to
the depth of field of an image and is more often than not a conscious choice that is made by
filmmakers. Shots with a super soft out of focus background have what we call a shallow depth of
field, while those that have large areas of the image in focus have a deep depth of field.
Let's break this down a bit more as we dive into what depth of field actually is,
the factors and settings that can change it and then go over some of the pros for shooting with
a shallow depth of field as well as go over some of the reasons why shallow focus may actually
be undesirable. Depth of field is a measurement of the distance between the nearest point that
a lens renders in sharp focus and the furthest object that is sharp. For example one could shoot
a close-up shot of a character on a telephoto lens where the nearest point of focus are their eyes
and the furthest point of focus are their ears. In this example the distance between these two points,
the depth of field, is a measly three inches. This is what we'd call shallow focus.
In another example a camera may shoot a long shot on a wide-angle lens where everything
from the foreground to the horizon is in sharp focus. In this example the distance between those
points is so far that we'll just call it infinity. This is what we call deep focus. Based on those
examples we can establish that there are a few different variables that change how much depth
of field an image has. In fact there are three variables. The focal length, the distance to the
in-focus subject and the aperture of the lens. Shots captured with a telephoto lens that has a
long focal length, such as a 290mm zoom, have a much shallower depth of field than shots that
use a wide-angle lens, such as an 18mm lens, which will create a deeper depth of field.
So one way to create a background with more blur is to choose a longer focal length.
The second variable for depth of field is determined by where the focus distance is set.
The nearer to the camera that the subject is and the tighter the shot, the shallower the depth of
field will become. This explains why when you shoot an extreme wide shot that focuses on the horizon
most of the frame will be sharp. Finally, the third variable that filmmakers can use to change
the depth of field is the aperture or stop of the lens. The wider open the iris on the back of the
lens is, the lower its T-stop will be and the shallower the depth of field it will produce.
One reason why fast lenses such as T1.3 cinema lenses are desirable are because cinematographers
can shoot them wide open to create a background full of soft bokeh. When a long focal length lens,
a subject close to the camera and a fast aperture are all combined, much to the horror and disgust
of the focus puller, the depth of field that a camera captures will be very shallow.
Inversely, a wide focal length lens, a subject far away and a closed down stop will mean that
depth of field will be very deep and the focus puller can relax. There's also a fourth variable,
the sensor size, which doesn't directly affect the image's depth of field but does affect it
indirectly. Shooting on cameras with a larger sensor size produces images that have a wider
field of view. To compensate for this extra width, cinematographers will either shoot on longer focal
length lenses to produce a comparable field of view or are forced to physically move the camera
closer to maintain a similar frame. As we now know, those two actions, using a longer focal length and
focusing on a subject closer to the camera, will both make the depth of field shallower.
Before we get further into the cinematographer's delight and the focus puller's nightmare that is
a shallow depth of field, I'd like to thank the sponsor of this video, Squarespace.
These days there's an upward tick in people pursuing side hustles, freelance work and
starting their own business, particularly those people in the film or creative industries.
In order to get your business off the ground and have a contact point for clients and collaborators
to reach you, having a website is a must. Squarespace is an all-in-one platform that
can be used to easily create a stylish and functional website using their drag and drop
templates. Squarespace makes it easy to display your creative portfolio and film work using their
photo and video libraries and has e-commerce tools to get your business off the ground.
I use their blogging tools every week to write and schedule posts on the In-Depth Cine website
so that I can stay on top of uploading content for you guys. So to set up your online presence,
be sure to head to squarespace.com for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch,
go to squarespace.com slash indepthcine to save 10% of your first purchase of a website or domain.
The biggest cliché about images with a blurry background is that they look cinematic. The
idea of a cinematic shot can't only be tied down to a specific image characteristic. I mean,
obviously there have been plenty of gorgeously shot pieces of cinema that don't use a shallow
depth of field. However, some clichés have an inkling of truth to them. To understand the link
between images with a shallow depth of field and cinema, we need to go back to the days before
digital cinema cameras. In the early days of video, most cameras had little sensors,
wider lenses and slower apertures. While movies captured on 35mm film used a larger film plane,
longer, faster lenses. So the ability to capture images using a shallow depth of field was
technologically limited to filmmakers that shot for the big screen, while deeper focus had
associations with a less highly regarded video format. Although this has now changed, with
advances in digital technology making it easy for even entry-level cameras or smartphones to simulate
a shallow depth of field, I'd argue that there's still an unconscious mental association that
persists between a shallow depth of field and cinematic movies in the mind of the audience.
With that out of the way, I'd say that the single greatest practical use of shooting with a shallow
depth of field is because it allows filmmakers to control what they want the audience to see
and focus their attention to. The smaller the depth of field, the less information in a frame
will be in focus and the more power the focus puller has to show where the audience should
direct their gaze. It makes it possible to more easily isolate a certain character or detail in
a frame. The more you isolate a character from the background, the more they stand out and become the
central point of the story. A shallow depth of field therefore empowers filmmakers to visually
tell stories from a more subjective viewpoint. Depending on the context, a shallow depth of
field can also be used for other more creative applications. Because a super shallow drifting
focus makes images feel dreamy, it can be used as a tool to chronologically differentiate certain
scenes from others, such as using it as part of a different visual language for flashback scenes.
Shots that drift in and out of focus may also be used as a deliberate technique to emulate
a less controlled environment and make certain sequences, like action, feel faster, more panicked
and more dynamic. From a purely technical point of view, shooting a lens wide open also lets in
more light and makes it easier to achieve exposure in darker shooting environments.
This also means that smaller lighting setups will be needed for scenes in darker spaces,
like night exteriors, where shooting at a deep stop is rarely practically possible.
Another technical point is that cinematographers choose certain lenses over others because of
their visual characteristics and how they render an image. The wider the aperture and the shallower
the focus, the more pronounced these characteristics, such as their bokeh and focus falloff,
become. It's almost seen as a bit of a waste to shoot a beautiful vintage set of lenses at a deep
stop. As you close down to around T8 or T11, most lenses will become increasingly sharp across the
frame and will be more difficult to differentiate from each other. So for those who want to create
a level of soft texture to their images, shooting at a faster stop is preferred.
While shooting with a shallow depth of field is wildly popular in the film industry,
there are also some reasons and situations where it may not be desirable. I mentioned before that
shallow focus can be used to tell stories by guiding the audience's gaze towards a specific
part of the frame. But inversely, a deeper focus can also be used to tell a story in a different
way. Shooting a film with a deep stop, where more of the frame is in sharp focus, allows the
audience to peruse the environment and pick out information from it themselves, rather than having
those details spoon fed to them with shallow focus by a filmmaker. In this way a deeper focus presents
stories in a way that is subtly more objective. Another persuasive case for a deeper depth of
field is that it allows you to see more of the set and environment that the character is in.
I remember a focus puller that I used to work with who would voice a surprise,
especially at younger DPs who would always shoot every shot with the aperture wide open
and make the background as blurry as possible. Why travel all the way to a beautiful location
or spend loads of money constructing an incredible set only for the audience to not see any of it
because the background is so out of focus? Deeper focus shots that see the background
are a useful tool for the audience to place where exactly the character is in their minds.
Moving on to the practical side, and being fully transparent, that focus puller may have advocated
for a deeper depth of field because it makes their job of keeping the subject sharp much easier.
The shallower the depth of field is, the less margin for error focus pullers have to accurately
pull focus and maintain a higher ratio of shots that are usable. This is why if there's a
particularly challenging focus pull, the DP may chat to the first and stop down the lens a couple
of stops to help achieve more accurate focus. If you're short on shooting time, sometimes it's
better to sacrifice a smidge of buttery smooth bokeh in order to maximize the number of takes
that will have usable focus. Rather have four usable takes for the director to work with in the
edit than one take that is in focus that has a shallower depth of field. Another case where
deeper depth of field may be preferred is when shooting a two shot. As the name suggests this
is a single shot with two people in the frame. Sometimes these two characters may be placed at
different distances apart from the camera. When shooting with a shallow depth of field,
this may mean that only one of the people can be rendered in sharp focus,
because the depth of field doesn't extend far enough to the second character.
A solution to this is to shoot with a deeper depth of field and get the focus puller to do
what is called splitting the focus. This is where the lens is stopped down and focused to a distance
in between the two characters, so that the depth of field extends nearer to get the first person
in focus and further to get the back person in focus at the same time. Before I mentioned that
shooting wide open accentuates the interesting optical qualities of the lenses. However for
certain films the look may be more suited to sharper images. The more that a lens is stopped
down the deeper the depth of field becomes and the crisper and more accurately resolved the image
will be. This is particularly useful when shooting with certain old wide angle anamorphic lenses
such as the Cooke Crystal Express set. The wide focal lengths in the set have a huge amount of
focus fall off when shot wide open, with the sweet spot of the lens only rendering sharp focus in the
very center of the frame. So to minimize actors looking soft on the edges of a shot and to sharpen
up the lens to an acceptable level, some DPs prefer to shoot these lenses with a deeper focus
at a stop such as T5.6 or T8. So there you have it, some reasons for and against using a shallow
depth of field. If you enjoyed this video please give it a thumbs up and subscribe. Also a continued
thanks to those members of the Patreon community for their support who make it possible for me to
keep making these videos. Otherwise until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
