The New Tesla Motor Will Disrupt The Entire Industry

Machine Engine
3 followers
This video looks at a new motor from Tesla that uses no rare earth magnets. By speaking to experts and digging into their technical documents, I think I have found the most likely explanation for the new tesla motor.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
1:05 Online Theories
2:43 Permanent Magnet Motors
3:33 A New Type of Magnet?
7:00 Dealing with Weak Magnets
#machine #Equipment #Engine
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTesla has unveiled a new electric motor for the Cybercab that is 18% smaller and 25% lighter than competitors. Most notably, it achieves this without using rare earth materials like neodymium, reducing reliance on unstable supply chains. By combining ferrite magnets with advanced rotor design, Tesla aims to maintain high efficiency and power while lowering costs.
On the 3rd of September, Tesla revealed details about their new electric motor,
and one feature got a lot of attention. The new motor is for the Tesla Cybercab,
and it's said to be 18% smaller and 25% lighter than its competitors,
all without using any rare earth materials. This is what got people really excited because
the permanent magnets that are in most modern EVs use a material called neodymium,
which has unstable prices and a supply chain about 90% concentrated in China. Therefore,
if Tesla has pulled this off, their new motor system will have a huge impact on the transport
sector. But they haven't made too many details public. So as usual, I've been digging through
the technical documents and speaking with experts to try and use the available clues
to figure out how their new motor actually works. So let's see what we can find.
I'm Ryan Innes and this is a Xeroth Deep Dive.
Early speculations around the motor have highlighted a few existing designs that don't
use any rare earth materials, including induction motors and externally excited synchronous motors.
The exact details of these motors isn't particularly relevant for the rest of this
video, as we'll shortly see, but a quick overview helps provide some useful context.
See, the most common type of EV motor is a permanent magnet motor, which has two core
components. Firstly, the stator, which is the stationary part with copper coils that act as
rotating electromagnets. And secondly, the rotor. The rotor has permanent magnets on it and it spins
around when the motor is powered, following the rotating magnetic field of the stator.
For induction motors and externally excited synchronous motors,
the spinning rotor in the middle doesn't contain permanent magnets. And although there are a few
different flavours of these motors, they often have the copper coils on the rotor too, which
act as electromagnets during operation. This is the big clue that the new motor from Tesla
isn't an induction motor or an externally excited synchronous motor, because we know that the new
motor uses permanent magnets. It just does it without any rare earth material. This is based
on images shared by Tesla, calling it a permanent magnet motor. And they said that this was a big
engineering challenge, but induction motors and externally excited synchronous motors have been
in cars for years already. The reason Tesla has chosen permanent magnets is likely because these
motors generally have higher efficiencies and make more power for the same size. I also have a feeling
that Tesla has found motors with permanent magnets slightly faster to manufacture too.
This is based on them celebrating their rapid production speeds for these new motors. However,
it seems like Tesla wants its cake and to eat it too. They want the higher efficiencies and power
available from the permanent magnet motors, but without the issues typical magnets bring due to
their rare earth materials. And to be honest, you can understand why when you look at the price of
neodymium over the last decade or so. The price goes up and down quicker than Elon gets into a
political controversy. Therefore, the only answer for Tesla's new motor is just a different type
of magnet. This isn't a new idea. Scientists and engineers have been researching motors
with different types of magnet materials for years. And rare earth free magnets are everywhere.
In fact, this fridge magnet uses a ferrite permanent magnet on the back that contains
no rare earth materials. And if you want to make one of these, it all starts with iron oxide,
which is chemically very similar to the rust you would find on an old car. This is then processed
with other additives in a chain of firing, milling, pressing and magnetizing. The process of
magnetizing for me is where the real magic happens. Before this point, the material is essentially just
a solid gray block with no real magnetic pull. And every microscopic particle inside it is pointing
in random directions, cancelling itself out. A powerful external magnetic field is therefore used
to force all of the particles into alignment. So they're all facing the same way. Only then does
it become recognizable as a magnet. However, the elephant in the room and the big problem with
ferrite magnets is that they're much weaker than the ones that contain rare earth materials.
Which is an issue when you're trying to make a motor powerful enough to move a car. Although
other rare earth free magnets are available, I think Tesla are using ferrite magnets due to
supply chain availability and cost. Plus some extra reasons I'll add to the end of this video
for those who are interested. So this leaves a big question. If Tesla are using these ferrite
magnets, what have they done to account for their lower strength? All the current evidence
seems to point in one direction. So let's look at that after a quick message from today's sponsor
Whisperflow. I use automated transcription or notes for every meeting I have and it's so much
better for productivity and makes everything so much smoother. But I often find that important
technical words get misspelt and that can really mess up the follow-up emails or action points I
have after it. That's why Whisperflow note taker is so good because it links with your other apps
so it knows the names of everyone in the call thanks to the calendar invites and it will know
the technical terminology you'll use from your dictionaries. And it means in the transcript
you're not just left with speaker one, speaker two, but the actual names of people. You don't
get any bots joining your call and it runs on your device on any platform and can even be booted up
for an impromptu unplanned call as well. And to show you how it handles words from my dictionary
I could say connect the energy company to Xeroth about the NMC battery project and it actually works
with the correct words. You can also add your real-time thoughts into note taker as the meeting
goes on and look back at things you might have just missed in a long meeting. Note taker can
then take everything from the meetings and feed it straight into Claude or ChatTBT which has made
meetings for me so much smoother and easier to keep track of. Note taker is free to use and with
the link in the description or the on-screen QR code you can get a month free of Whisperflow Pro.
Now back to the big question. How is Tesla going to make up for the fact that ferrite magnets are
weaker than rare earth magnets in their motors? For the answer we can have a look at a motor that
Tesla makes for the Model 3 called an interior permanent magnet synchronous reluctance motor.
That is a bit of a mouthful so let's break it down and see why it's useful here. The general idea for
these types of motors is that firstly the magnets are inside the rotor, hence the interior part of
the name, and they don't just rely on the magnet's strength to produce the torque. They also tap
into a second method called reluctance torque. If we look at the rotor from a pure reluctance motor
you'll notice it looks a little bit odd. There are no magnets and no copper coils, just a disc
of steel with curved slots cut through it. These slots aren't there to cut weight, they're actually
there to guide the magnetic fields and decide where they can and can't go. This animation shows
how the missing segments match the shape of the magnetic fields flowing through the rotor. The
reluctance torque comes from a simple fact that magnetic flux is lazy so it always wants to take
the shortest path. If we look at a metal bar between two magnet poles north and south you can see how
when it's tilted the magnetic flux lines in green are longer than when it is straight, so therefore
the metal bar will want to turn and become straight. So if you cut air gaps into the rotor,
making some directions easier for the flux and others hard, the rotor will twist itself to line
up with the stator's magnetic field, therefore causing the rotational torque. Here's also an
editable CAD model of one that I made by simply writing a text prompt with Onshape using their
feature script MCP, so check them out in the description. So why not build the whole motor
as a reluctance motor? Well, to oversimplify it, pure reluctance motors have their own challenges
too. Reluctance motors produce less torque for their size and generally have higher noise and
vibrations, needing a bigger or more complex inverter to drive them. But by adding magnets
into the air gaps it helps balance out these drawbacks. The two torques kind of add together
and the magnets smooth out the vibrations and the torque ripple. Motor designers will probably be
throwing things at the screen right now because in practice this is much more complicated and
this is an incredibly difficult thing to achieve, so please forgive me for my sins.
This image shows the rotor from a Tesla Model 3 motor. You can see two magnets arranged in a V
shape with some air pockets around them. The air pockets and magnets work together as barriers
that guide the magnetic flux lines and create the reluctance torque. Now we can compare the
rotor of the Model 3 to a rotor design in a recent Tesla patent. There's still a V of magnets,
but now there's also another layer above it with a flat magnet sitting closer to the surface.
Having two layers here instead of just one should mean that the reluctance torque is increased,
which is probably what you'd want if you were working with weaker ferrite magnets.
Another clever bit is this region in the middle. In a normal reluctance rotor, that middle bit
would be steel and it's a support to stop everything exploding as the rotor spins faster.
However, the problem is that steel gives a shortcut for the magnetic flux to go through
and that shortcut reduces the amount of reluctance torque you get out.
With weak ferrite magnets, this could seriously affect your performance, so Tesla's patent
replaces that steel with an injected non-magnetic filler like plastic or epoxy. It holds together
the rotor as it spins without creating a shortcut for the magnetic flux. I will say that in this
patent it never directly refers to ferrite magnets or the Tesla Cybercab, but the design seems fitting
and the timing is right too. Tesla also appear to be running the motor faster. Their EPA filing
shows the motor spinning at 131 rpm for every mile an hour the car moves. This is about 13%
faster than the motor in the Model 3 and because overall power is the torque times the speed,
increasing the speed could make up for the slightly lower torque. As for the 18% smaller and
25% lighter claim, it's a little bit vague because we don't really know which competitor it's
benchmarking itself against but it's still very impressive and likely refers to the whole motor
unit including the inverter and any transmission systems and Tesla are known for really doing good
system optimization. And finally, this motor really just suits the job. The Cybercab is a
light two-seater that doesn't need huge torque. It won't be doing 0 to 60 runs at the traffic lights
whilst the passenger drinks their matcha latte. Now, as promised, a little extra detail on why
I think they're ferrite magnets and not other available options. The first alternative I
considered was manganese bismuth, however it's still mainly a research material and the modest
supply chain is still currently concentrated in China and I can't find anything about any new
factories making it. The second was iron nitride which was a lot more interesting and on paper
could actually outperform neodymium magnets on raw magnetic strength but the company that's
furthest ahead called Niron was still sampling from a pilot line when Cybercab production started.
Also, their first real factory doesn't open until 2027. Technically, Tesla could have been working
on their own iron nitride magnets but it seems like a high-risk play and there's nothing I've
seen in any technical documents or otherwise that have hinted towards them doing that. And I think
it would be a pretty hard project to completely keep under wraps for this long. But as you're
still watching, please consider subscribing. It's free and helps the channel a lot. You might also
like some of our other videos like this one on a battery we tested that was the first ever to
surpass 500 watt-hours per kilogram. And, as always, thanks for watching.
