What does Israel actually want from the new Syria?
A revealing Wall Street Journal article titled “The New Syria: The Enemy of Israel’s Enemy” argues that Ahmed al-Sharaa may not be Israel’s friend. Still, his rise in Damascus presents Israel with a major strategic opportunity against Iran and its Lebanese ally.
What makes the argument particularly significant is its author: Or Horvitz, a former lieutenant colonel in Israeli Defense Intelligence who headed its Hezbollah and Lebanon branch and later served as a senior adviser to the director of Israeli military intelligence.
In this analysis, Kevork Almassian examines what Horvitz’s argument reveals about Israel’s strategy toward post-Assad Syria.
The collapse of the former Syrian government removed one of Iran’s most important regional allies, disrupted Hezbollah’s logistical depth and fundamentally changed Syria’s geopolitical orientation. Horvitz argues that Israel should exploit the new reality rather than view Damascus exclusively as an enemy.
The proposal goes further.
Israel should support mechanisms along the Syrian-Lebanese border aimed at preventing Hezbollah’s rearmament, while Western powers could help train and support designated Syrian and Lebanese units against weapons-smuggling networks. Horvitz also sees potential for limited Israeli-Syrian cooperation under American mediation.
📌If you value independent geopolitical analysis, please consider supporting our work so we can continue bringing you these deep dives
📢 Syriana Analysis is an independent platform providing well-researched geopolitical insights, founded by Kevork Almassian. This program provides independent journalistic analysis for educational and documentary purposes, focusing on complex geopolitical shifts in West Asia and globally.
Today we are going to read a very interesting article published in the
Wall Street Journal. The title of the article
goes with the new Syria, the enemy of Israel's enemy.
But the most interesting part of this article
is that it is published by none other than
Or Horvitz. For those who don't know, Or Horvitz is a former
lieutenant colonel in Israeli Defense Intelligence,
IDI. He served as the head of the Hezbollah and
Lebanon branch between 2022 to 2024, and later he served as senior advisor to
the director of the Israeli Defense Intelligence up
until this moment, where he was centrally involved in
Israel's campaigns against Hezbollah and Iran. So this is coming from a guy
who is advising Israeli security policies in the region and especially
in dealing with Hezbollah and Iran. So what does he argue in this article? This
is interesting because it puts a context, it brings a context to the
Israeli broader policy in the region and especially
in Syria. So let's get into this article which I believe has been
essential, especially that it comes at a time when people are still wondering
whether or not Israel is happy with what they
call a Shara, Ahmad al-Shara, or on this show we call him Abu Muhammad al-Jolani.
So this is the article, the new Syria, the enemy of Israel's enemy. He argues
basically that Jolani isn't a friend in his eyes, but his
rise is a novel opportunity according to him. So
this article starts by saying that Israel has a unique opportunity in
Syria. The December 2024 collapse of Bashar
Assad's regime sharply changed the regional orientation. Of course it has
changed the regional orientation because Syria has moved from the
umbrella of the Iranian, the Russian, and the broader
let's say multipolar world into the world of unipolarity and now it is
revolving under the umbrella of Uncle Sam's unipolar so-called
rules-based international order. Syria was suddenly no longer the lifeline
of the Shiite axis on the northern front through which Iranian weapons and
money passed to Hezbollah. Instead Damascus belongs to Ahmad al-Shara,
a Sunni leader and former commander of al-Qaeda's Syrian affiliate who had
fought Hezbollah for years. So what he is basically saying here
that we have to deal, we have to treat Jolani with the
tactical lens, that he hates Hezbollah, he hates Iran,
and now that Assad is gone and what he calls the Shiite axis, although
Assad was in nowhere or shape a Shiite, he was an
Alawite, and Alawites are completely different by the way from the Shiites
and people continuously confused between them, but this is not the
topic of today's video, but what he basically says that
the collapse of the Assad government basically broke
the logistical and military channels between Syria and Lebanon and from
Lebanon which this communication has been cut
passing through Damascus, Baghdad and to Iran, and this is
we have to accept the fact that this is a blow for Hezbollah and this is a
big win for Israel when it comes to its attempt
to minimize the strength and the rearmament at least of Hezbollah
after this one and a half year of huge and barbaric clashes against Hezbollah
so he says that so far Israel has treated
Mr. al-Sharia with skepticism, Sharia's past raises
legitimate questions about whether his political transformation
from jihadist to suit-wearing rebuilder of Syria is
genuine or tactical, and I have to say something about this
because I genuinely believe that a person like him who worked for the
Israeli Defense Intelligence and those who worked for the Mossad or
the Shabak and also in the Israeli IDF they call them the IDF it's the IOF
however those who worked in the corridors of the
Israeli security and military apparatuses they
genuinely know that Al-Qaeda has been serving
the broader American strategy starting from Afghanistan
then moving into also by the way in places such as in Yugoslavia
they have tried it in Chechnya they have tried it in Xinjiang
again China they have tried it in Syria successfully so they have tried it in
Libya and they were successful as well right
so these people know that these terrorist organizations
have been and they have been assets and they
continue to be assets for the US strategy and the biggest evidence now
that Jolandi who formed the Al-Qaeda offshoot in
Syria he is being perfumed by Donald Trump who
only a few years ago he used to say that we're supporting these terrorists in
Syria who want to fly planes to our buildings
now that in his second term he's basically not only shaking hands
with the leader and the founder of the Al-Qaeda
offshoot in Syria but also perfuming him and also giving him
broader international legitimacy lifting sanctions on Syria and
the the reason for it is because probably the people who work for the
deep state inside the United States just like the people
just like the person who published this article they whispered in the ears of
Donald Trump telling him that this guy has been our guy and he has been our
asset and he has achieved enormous achievement for us in
Syria by breaking the backbone of the
axis of resistance and hence this made it possible for the United States and
Israel to wage a war of aggression against Iran now that
Syria's air defenses have been neutralized
and the Israelis now can fly their fighter jets from
Israel all the way in Syria and all the way to the northern Iraqi Kurdistan and
then bomb inside Iran so those are all
strategic gains in my opinion for the United States and Israel by
installing an Al-Qaeda regime but someone like the author of this
article who claims that yeah we don't know if he's genuine in his
transformation or not he knows deep inside that Jolani
has been an asset from the beginning and he used
this Takfiri Salafi Islamism for the sake of
regime change in Syria and now that the regime change happened he all of a
sudden just put the makeup on his face and he's trying to play
and masquerade as a president of the country so he goes saying yet
Israel appears to be missing a strategic window Mr. Ashara is no friend
of Israel but he is a clear enemy of Hezbollah
and while the previous Syrian government relied on Iran and Russia Mr. Ashara
depends on western and gulf support foreign
investment and international acceptance Damascus needs quiet on the Israeli
front many many times already the officials
the current officials of Jolani have been clear about this case they've been
telling to the public in the UN to American
officials to Israeli officials that we have no interest
in clashing with Israel in fact we want to strike
a security deal with Israel and then normalize ties with Israel
basically to sign a so-called peace treaty
and afterwards open Israeli embassy inside Damascus
and this week guys by the way this is for the first time this is now in public
this is Reuters saying that they have
exclusive news or it's a scoop basically that the the head of Israel's spy
agency so the Mossad he held a phone call with
Syria's foreign minister Ahmad al-Shibani
during which they discussed Turkey's military presence in Syria
and this is according to three people familiar with the matter told Reuters
just days before Israel bombed a Syrian air
base in Idlib so this was a call this call
happened between the both sides on August 14
the Mossad spy agency chief Roman Goffman
and Assad al-Shibani and this is considered one of the highest level
contacts yet between Israel and Damascus administration
led by president Ahmad al-Shibani and notice the
the wordings and the terminologies they use in Reuters
Damascus administration like they're talking about Trump administration or
Biden administration it's not a regime it's an administration in their eyes
and it is led by not the transitional president but the president Ahmad al-Shibani
and those are of course inaccurate because he's a transitional
self-selected president and he's not been elected by anyone therefore he's
not the president of Syrian Arab Republic then the author
also explains to us some of the overlaps here
he says this overlap of interests seems to
already be yielding results actually according to Axios the US
in July brokered an understanding involving Syria
Israel and the International Atomic Agency to secure and remove nuclear
material from a clandestine site linked to the Assad regime's nuclear
program the episode demonstrated that where
interests converge Israel and the new Syrian government can
address concrete security threats through US mediated verifiable
arrangements rather than confrontation and I have to make a few explanation
here for you guys what happened is with this secret nuclear
site which Israel destroyed in 2007 apparently
the former Assad government has been developing a secret
nuclear reactor in eastern Syria around Deir ez-Zor and
the Americans and the Israelis were completely
absent from this process they didn't know about it it was in secret
and the Mossad and the Israeli intelligence they found
this reactor they detected it and they called George W. Bush this was in 2007
and George W. Bush rejected to bomb the site
alone and however he didn't mind the Israelis to bomb it of course so the
Israelis flew several F-16s they flew all the way in
the Mediterranean they went into Turkey and from the Turkish borders they bombed
inside Deir ez-Zor and they destroyed this nuclear reactor
and allegedly killed also several North Korean
researchers and scientists there or experts allegedly because this was
supervised by North Koreans and they wanted to give this expertise to the
Syrian side and back after this bombardment it seems that
some of the enriched uranium there have been transferred and they were
relocated in a secret site and this is when
after the regime change the Israeli side
didn't bomb this secret site that they found where
this enriched uranium is located and exists because they didn't want to
create a nuclear basically poisoning for the entire region
which is also not far away from Israel and they have been negotiating with
Syria with the mediation of the United States
to put these nuclear materials under the supervision of the International Atomic
Agency and once the International Atomic
Agency has put its hands over this enriched
uranium you know better than I do guys that the
International Atomic Agency is not some neutral organization which means
the Americans by proxy will have their supervision and control over this
enriched uranium in any ways this Al-Qaeda regime they
cannot use this enriched uranium in any way
in any beneficial way in any helpful way they don't have the infrastructure
to generate any sort of power or electricity with it
and first of all they should probably build
the power plants before thinking about nuclear power but all
what is important about this case is that
the former Syrian government built this insecrecy they wanted to create the
deterrence against Israel and now the current Syrian
regime they are just giving everything for free to the Americans in exchange
for international recognition and once the
Americans take everything from the current regime in Syria and squeeze it
like a lemon like they usually do with other
partners and other allies then they will throw them in the bin
so this is the issue of the nuclear let's go back to the article
because this overlap which we spoke about is about this nuclear
issue he says Israel should exploit this overlap of interest in two areas
weakening the Shia axis and preventing Sunni terrorists from establishing
themselves in Syria two for the first time in years there is
a government in Damascus that can sharply reduce the flow of weapons
and money to Hezbollah Israel should promote the US-led security mechanism
along the Syrian Lebanese border to impede Hezbollah's
rearmament an essential part of any effort to weaken the group
and listen to this is very important because he's suggesting that western
forces including Israel should or could train and support
the designated Syrian and Lebanese units so they
Israel they want for Israel he wants for Israel to train Syrian units to target
smuggling networks with the help of advanced monitoring systems the US
would ensure that Syria and Lebanon make secure
the border and disrupting smuggling a priority
so the two countries should also prevent Syria from serving global jihadist groups
or Hamas I mean already the current Syrian
regime has cut relationship with Hamas they have even expelled their leadership
from Damascus not only Hamas but the PLO
and the Islamic Jihad and they Shara himself or Jolani himself
told Al Jazeera a few weeks ago that he has
given guarantees to the American side that he will not support any of these
what he called the terrorist groups and he meant
Hamas and other Palestinian factions and also Hezbollah
so all in all the new Syria also considers
the parties that Israel considers terrorist as terrorist
so the two countries should also prevent Syria from serving global jihadist
group or Hamas Israel can support reconstruction assistance
conditions or on excluding Iranian forces preventing terrorist
infrastructure and ensuring that Syrian territory isn't again used to threaten
Israel so the last paragraph he says a comprehensive peace treaty isn't
currently realistic but Israel's strategy need not run only
through the barrel of gun in Mr. al-Shara's Syria an opportunity
is emerging for limited cooperation against the Shia axis
which could lay the groundwork for broader arrangements
foremost a security agreement in southern Syria he says Israel should
pursue the opportunity cautiously following Reagan's
approach to Gorbachev trust but verify so he's basically saying
Israel should deal with Al-Qaeda regime basically for tactical
level and be cautious of them but use them
in a strategic conflict against Hezbollah this is the premise
and I think talking about just blocking the
supply chains of Hezbollah is again disingenuous
disingenuous but the word is quite complicated
and I think they also mean that Jolani should participate in a broader
military conflict against Hezbollah something that is not mentioned yet in
this article probably in the next article we will see that
now this reminds me of course to this conversation of debate with the
former Mossad head of Mossad An al-Jazeera with Mahdi
Hassan and I've been saying this several times if Mahdi Hassan has done
one one genuine journalistic work
or one brilliant journalistic work this is
this is the one when he presses the former head of Mossad
who told Al-Jazeera yes we treated Al-Qaeda militants
in Israeli field hospitals in the Golan Heights but this is all for tactical
reasons according to him because Al-Qaeda has
never attacked Israel he says and in Israel they are so
humanitarian that they would like to help the wounded
Al-Qaeda fighters in Israeli hospitals and this was six seven years ago when
the Jolani fighters used to go to Israeli field hospitals in the Golan
Heights and that was you know it's okay because those are poor people
and we need to help them against the brutal Assad regime and then send them
back to continue fighting but what if those wounded fighters were
from the Hezbollah side what do you think the
answer was so let's take a look and see the hypocrisy here
there have been reports that Israel has been treating wounded Syrian rebel
fighters in its hospitals on the border including fighters from Nusra Front
which is of course the Al-Qaeda proxy in Syria
do those reports worry you that Israel's helping
wounded Al-Qaeda aligned fighters as I said before
in a different context it's always useful also
to deal with your enemies in a humane way and I think that when you have
people who are wounded and you can deal with them in a humane way
the considerations as to whether to take them in are not simply
whether it's politically useful or whether it's politically
it's purely humanitarian you say there's no tactical or political
strategic I didn't say there's no tactical I said the
main consideration the immediate consideration is
humane but the tactical issues involved I mean you know better than me the
phrase blowback you don't think there's going to be blowback against Israel if
you get into bed with a group like Nusra Front
no I don't think so I don't think there's going to be blowback
why because I think that the unfortunately the rules of the game in
Syria are such that you can do anything that is not
possible to be done anywhere else yeah I think people said that in
Afghanistan too would you also treat Hezbollah fighters
no I would not treat you not just contradicted what you told me
but humanely treating your enemies no no I think as far as Hezbollah
fighters concerned with them we have a different account
so let me be clear you would you're happy to treat Al-Qaeda fighters we have
but not Hezbollah we have we have a different account with Hezbollah
he's right a totally different account because Hezbollah has carried out
the type of actions against us which preclude us
from going into what the Al-Qaeda has done Al-Qaeda to the best of my
recollection has up to now not attacked Israel so
Al-Qaeda according to his recollection has never
attacked Israel and I think the question should be why
Al-Qaeda exited on the borders with Israel for several years
they have not attacked Israel ISIS occupied the border line with Israel
they didn't attack Israel they went all the way to Brussels
to Spain allegedly to New York all around the world
but few miles away from Israel but they don't attack
look for those who watching especially from
as Tarek says from the statutes I am not calling for Al-Qaeda or ISIS
attack against Israel I'm just raising a legitimate question
and that is why and this is a journalistic question
but I hope this video was helpful for you guys if you like this format
kindly hit the like button subscribe to Syriana Analysis
and check the description for all the relevant
links and I will see you on Friday with our dear friend Tarek Chevy Lamar
doing our show Cold War 2.0 at 5 p.m Central European time 11 a.m
Eastern American time I wish you peace peace be upon you upon your families
Salam