The Monty Show: Is James Harden the Best Player in the NBA?
2 Video Views·Oct 9, 2026
James Harden just delivers a 38-point triple-double,
and I'm watching Giannis Antetante Capumpo last night.
I'm watching Giannis, and they're not even guarding him.
The Clippers are just letting him stand
by himself at the three-point line.
Evicka Zubats is like, no,
I'm not even going to cross the free-throw line.
Yeah, and he's being told to do that.
And I know that we argue about Giannis a lot on this show.
Okay, I totally get that.
Well, I think as a player, he's argued about in the big picture a lot.
Like, a lot, a lot.
Not just us.
Like, I think it's a deep conversation.
Yet, people will hand him MVP trophy after MVP trophy.
He scores, what, 30-something points last night?
They get blown out in L.A. against the Clippers.
Yeah.
And the guy, to me, his only success is,
I'm going to run as fast as I can at the basket.
It's a skill.
Zion Williamson is proving that.
I'm going to run as fast and as hard as I can at the basket,
and I'm going to shoot as many free throws as I can.
All right, cool trick.
You're not going to win games doing that.
Oh, but this is a different Milwaukee Bucs team.
Fear the deer, motherfucking duck.
Okay, no.
How about no?
I don't fear the deer.
This isn't a different Bucs team,
and they're going out early in the playoffs again this year
because I think the East is actually much better.
And when I look at the Sixers, when I look at the Nets,
those two teams are superior in my opinion to the milwaukee bucks
and if you put them in a
seven game series i think the bucks will lose nine out
of ten of those series yeah i think that the
the major issue here with with yannis getting all these mvps
and the reason it happens is because
everyone just looks at the stat sheet they don't look
at whether the team actually won or lost a
game they don't look at you know how his lack
of ability to shoot a three is impacting the rest of
team because that's the real that's really where
the rubber meets the road think about it you were
just talking about it Avika Zubats
is standing you know essentially in the paint behind the three
bar behind the free throw line not having any fear
that Giannis is going to shoot a ball and
make it make a three no fear
so what does that do that allows the other four guys on the floor
to play really tight to their man
because Zubats is going to fill up the middle so defensively
You've got an easy life playing the Bucs, and that's why they lose.
And I think that, you know, some of the other players
that we're going to get to here,
they don't have that problem, mainly
because they can shoot a basketball.
You're an NBA, like I've said
this many times about many different players.
You're an NBA player.
Even if you come into this league and your jump shot is just awful,
Lonzo Ball or any of these other guys,
you literally every day you come to the practice facility
or the arena where you're playing on the road
and you have shoot around work on your shot man like work it like
if Giannis had a shot he would
be like way better like they would be a way better team
and I agree with you that you know the MVP
it is a popularity contest and I guess that he's marketable
but I just don't think he's he's a lot
of people say he's a top five player
in the league I guess it depends how you define the best player
in the league that's what this comes down to oh certainly
and I think when I look at James Harden
last night putting up a 38 point triple double
in a dog fight where every basket matters yeah
and he's hitting threes he's dropping dimes like he
was unbelievable in this game without James
Harden they don't win that game without Giannis
the the Bucks still lose that game yeah James
Harden's the best player in the NBA right now
and looking at some of the statistics I'm a big
believer in espn's real plus minus um i think
that lebron james has to be in this discussion
i think he's the second best player in the league
and really quick just the real plus minus stat
just some of the things that go
into that um your teammates um you know it essentially is
how much impact do you have per 100 possessions okay
and they take a wide variety uh of factors
into account um and the exact definition
is net point differential per 100 possessions
offensive and defensive real plus minus takes
into account teammates opponents and additional
factors home road arena things like that got it lebron james
when it comes to real plus minus
is a 9.20 the next closest is steph curry
at 7.95 okay lebron james where's james harden james
Harden is down the list quite a bit okay um James Harden
is 12th at 4.72 a lot of that was Houston
though yeah so I think there's some he's definitely taken
a step up in Brooklyn there's yeah you can't
dispute that and I think he deserves credit
for that is the roster around him better yes it is
but there's no way to discount what James Harden means
to the Brooklyn Nets they're better with
him they're not great without him especially
with KD never playing for that team yeah you look at
Kyrie and James Harden together, they're a dominant force.
James Harden makes Kyrie Irving.
He makes him.
And that's why I think they really were aggressive with Blake Griffin,
who again gave him a nice performance last night.
They went out and got a LaMarcus Aldridge,
because I don't think they believe they can count on Kevin Durant.
I just don't think whether you believe or not, you can't,
because he's always hurt.
But I don't buy into this idea that Kevin Durant,
oh, he's just saying it's a hamstring so he can rest.
I don't buy into that.
But I think he just isn't durable right now.
Next year, I think he'll take a big step forward durability-wise
because he will be out of the haze of the Achilles
and the leg injuries,
and he will actually be rested.
But right now, I just don't know that you can count on him.
Oh, by the way, I think the Brooklyn Nets
are still the best team in the NBA.
Let me ask you this.
When players are hurt, whether it's Anthony Davis, Kevin Durant,
any of these guys, should we be holding it against them
if they're out for a longer period of time
because their team can hold their water without them.
Like the Brooklyn Nets, to be specific,
the Brooklyn Nets don't even,
like I think we could agree that the Nets
don't need Kevin Durant to go ahead and win a championship.
They don't need him.
Would it be great to have him?
Yes, absolutely.
I don't know if I can agree with that.
So you don't think they're good enough?
I think Brooklyn needs James,
or they need three of those guys on the floor together
to win a championship.
Yes, I do.
And I think that James Harden is a guy who's shown you that,
yeah, he can play, but he's relying on the three-point shot.
And I think this is a three-point league, so I get that.
I mean, I look at what Luka Doncic did last night
in Dallas, and I get it.
It was OKC.
He wrecked the Thunder with a three ball.
That's what this league has become.
I mean, Memphis shot 31 threes last night.
My point is, when you live and die on the three,
a lot of times you're going to die on the three.
And nobody's died a more morbid,
terrible, public death on three-pointers
than James Harden in the playoffs.
0-27.
Yeah, so I mean, he's got a track record for this.
And I think they need guys like KD.
They need him to be the slim reaper.
Shoot in the three, get into the basket.
He puts him over the top for sure.
Yeah, because you can't tell me that Kyrie, Joe Harris, James Harden,
and Kevin Durant are going to all go cold at the same time from three.
no that ain't happening no so i i think they need kevin durant
to win a championship yes i do
yeah i i think without him they're good enough to get there for sure
and i think that i think that
your point about him resting longer because of the rehab
and because he's not as durable right
now is is well taken and i think that you know i just feel like
the nets are good enough without
him that it affords him and and his rehab process
the luxury of not having to to come back sooner
and they said at the all-star break they said it
was going to be about two weeks we're about 10
days removed from the all-star break now
or whatever it's been so he should be back soon
probably mid-april at this point
and if that happens i think they're fine because if you can
come back in mid-april you've got six weeks left till the playoffs
which is the stretch run of the
postseason and that's enough time for a team to come together
so hopefully he comes back everything's
cool and and they can do their thing
but i to get back to what we were talking about yeah i think
James Harden is the best player
in the league right now I certainly think in terms of the MVP
award that he is the front runner and if he's not I don't know
who would be because I just don't
think it's Giannis or if it is it shouldn't
be and other guys would yeah would be LeBron and
and that's basically it
because of KD's injury yeah I think right now Kevin Durant's not even
in the conversation and I think until he plays 70 games
at a very high level I don't think he'll be
in the conversation. I think right now,
the argument of the two best players in the NBA
is James Harden and LeBron James.
I mean, based on the numbers, based on the impact,
based on their all-around abilities,
LeBron's playing at a very high level defensively.
James Harden, I have never seen
this effort defensively out of James Harden. I don't ever
remember him playing at this level defensively
that we are seeing James Harden play out in
Brooklyn I don't ever remember that um so I I think
my personal opinion is James Harden's best
player in the NBA yeah and I'm not sure even
with LeBron I'm not sure there's a close second yeah
and I think it's a lot of credit to James Harden again
that the defensive side is the biggest
improvement I mean we always knew he could score
we always knew he could distribute but I think in
in Mike D'Antoni's Houston Rockets offense it
was a little bit different of a setup than in Steve
Nash's offense in Brooklyn, and I think that
Steve Nash is a guy who
understands that he just wants to put James
Harden in a position on almost every possession
to make a play. Whether that is the
one-on-one matchup and doing his between
the legs dribbling and all
that on the perimeter, whether that's a drive
and he kicks to Joe Harris, basically
just give James Harden the ball, let him
read the floor, and let him make
decisions. And they've been doing that, and that's why
he's getting his triple-doubles, and that's why Kyrie
Irving is getting great looks.
You know, I look at...
I look at James Harden,
and I don't think he's ever going to get enough credit
because he did what Kevin Durant did at Golden State.
He wound up on a team that is a super team built to win a championship.
So I think there will always be a knock on him.
Make sure you hit subscribe on the old YouTube machine.
Just search us on Google, The Monty Show.
M-O-N-T-Y, The Monty Show is where you find us on Google.
Any podcast, YouTube, you name it, we're there.
The Monty Show, M-O-N-T-Y, The Monty Show.
What did you see last night?
I saw the Jazz literally, I think.
I honestly think the NBA contracted the Cavs last night.
I think they said, you guys suck so bad.
The Jazz embarrassed you so much.
We're going to have to go ahead and pull your card.
Shame!
You're out.
The Jazz destroyed the Cavs last night.
What did you learn in that game, if anything?
The first thing I want to say is I don't remember
the last time I saw an NBA game
with a 40-point spread on it in the third quarter.
like they were up legitimately 40 points like
that's insane um in terms of what we learned
last night like i the jazz just they're a dominant team
when they when they don't when they're not
playing a good team like just like any other any other best team
in the league like when these when
teams like the jazz or the warriors of old
or any of these great teams when they play crappy teams
they're going to dominate them
because those crappy teams turn the ball over they don't run
good offense so like last night i wasn't impressed
by the win i expected it like what like what else
do you expect you know yeah they shot the hell out
of the ball i think i think the biggest takeaway
from last night is guys like ursan iliasova
and thomas and and all these other reserve guys like
that was a nice run for them i think they got eight
and a half minutes at the end of the game
to play together that was nice you know that was cool
um again i just will maintain that matt thomas
built another brick wall last night don't think he's made
a three yet in a game for the jazz so
i don't know this guy is supposed
to be a great shooter you know i'd like to see him start making
some shots when he gets some minutes
that said i don't think he's going to get minutes um in the
postseason or in close games i think that he's just
a filler on the roster and they'll move on
from him at some point so i don't really think there
was a lot to take away from last night well
and the thing that i say about
that is is that you know i i look around the league at the additions
and I know we've talked about this a lot,
I was really excited when the Jazz added Ursan Ilyasova.
I thought it was a great pickup that could help this team.
I think they're going to release him.
Yeah.
That or he's just going to languish at the end of the bench
because I don't see any usable quality there.
I mean, Oney's athletic, can shoot the three.
Like, okay, cool.
He's long.
He runs.
Okay, great.
And they need to develop him.
Yeah.
What is, you know, like any of these other guys,
mac can shoot um what's her son do because he ain't shooting
the ball well yeah they they put
him in the post a couple of times
and he you know had some interesting moments he took a couple of
threes you know there wasn't like a he again he's
a stretch five he's not he's not quite a seven
footer but he can guard seven footers
and he can play the center position and he used to be able
to really shoot the three now there probably should
be something said for the fact that hey
he hasn't played for a minute they got to get back
into the flow of an nba game they got to
get their you know their groove back okay i can level
with that but at the end of the day
the the ursan matt thomas signing those signings
were kind of you know painted to us as like hey
we're trying to make the roster better
but then don't look at denver adding you know an all-star
don't look at any of these other teams getting
way better you know i just i don't know that's
where i go every time i talk about
this jazz roster now every time i'm like dude like wow
look at what Aaron Gordon did for Denver.
You know,
like there's now media yesterday for the first time in a long time on
Twitter.
I saw several outlets talking about how the nuggets are an NBA finals
contender now that they have Aaron Gordon.
And I'm just telling you,
that's real,
man,
that that is absolutely real.
And it's something to be respected.
And I,
and I,
and I hope that maybe,
maybe the,
maybe the silver lining here with this Cavs game and,
and these next few games that they have that are pretty much a cakewalk
is that they can get their,
their,
their,
as a team,
they can get their shooting percentage back up to where it was.
Don did what Don does.
He made a bunch of shots.
But I'm talking about guys like Jordan
Clarkson getting out of this slump.
I'm talking about Bogdanovich starting to make more shots again,
like these guys that they need.
I'm really worried about Bogdanovich.
Yeah.
I think the confidence is not there.
And if we're keepsin' it real, as we tend to do on this show,
they don't win a championship without, you know,
Boyan Bogdanovich shooting the ball well.
Yeah.
they need it and they got to figure that out
and i don't know how you figure that out other than
i think you have to play him heavy minutes every night
and you have got to bake into that boy's
brain shoot the ball yes every chance you get boy
on shoot the ball yeah bogey bogey yes shoot the
ball yeah you know like he's hesitating he's passing he's trying
to get to the basket he's
not athletic enough to finish
and i think it is a real weakness for this jazz team right now
that he's not doing what other forwards are doing.
I look at who's a real dangerous team, like the Sacramento Kings.
I don't want to see that team in the playoffs.
That's a real dangerous athletic team.
Where does Bogdanovich fit against the Sacramento Kings?
I don't know the answer to that question.
I look at the Lakers.
Andre Drummond looks really excited to be an L.A. Laker.
I would be excited.
Well, yeah, but right now, who's going to guard Andre Drummond?
because well it's Rudy Gobert you would think
that's a really tough matchup for Rudy I think
well that's just uh again not to be an asshole about it
but that's his job like that's his job
I'm not going to sit here
and say oh well it's a really tough matchup for you no you're you're
paid and you're a defensive minded player get it done like
that's what it is yeah I think it is
I think it's really difficult.
I think the ability for Rudy Gobert to, you know,
to have a big impact in the postseason is going to be fascinating
because one of two things is going to happen.
Every jazz fan who tells us to, you know, lick our feet is,
somebody told us to lick our feet yesterday.
You think you know it all?
I'm not really sure what that means.
Like, do you want me to actually on the show take my sock off
and lick my foot?
What's wrong with you?
I probably haven't had that ability since I was like 11,
And if I did, I'd never leave the house.
But the point is, the point is, and it wouldn't be on YouTube.
Okay.
It would, you know, on fans only or whatever, only fans.
Anyway, the point is, now I've gone too far.
I think the real on the Utah Jazz is, one way or the other,
we're going to be proven right or wrong.
We haven't been wrong yet.
No.
Right?
So if you look at the Jazz and you look at the way they match up
against certain teams, I don't want anything to do with Sacramento.
I don't want anything to do with Denver.
I think their best matchup is probably the Lakers or the Clippers.
The Suns?
Oh, I think the Suns are a terrible matchup for the Jazz.
In a long series, I think, A,
Mike Conley and Chris Paul's pretty close.
I think Chris Paul's better.
Okay.
I mean, if you're the Suns, do you put Mikael Bridges on Donovan?
Yes.
Okay.
Then it's probably Royce O'Neal and Book.
Yep.
Right?
And they'll probably try to switch that to get Book on Bogdanovich.
And I think that's exactly what's going to happen.
And I think that's a nightmare.
Because I think Devin Booker has figured out
that when you become something more than a three-point shooter,
and you add in what is now a lethal mid-range game,
because his mid-range game used to be good.
It's now elite.
I mean, Devin Booker's got an entire bag of tricks,
and it's all Chris Brickley's doing, I guess.
the summer run this past summer
and the summer prior have absolutely changed who Devin Booker
is as a player and I think
when you look at their depth that's the other thing that is really
troublesome about the Jazz they're playing eight
guys yeah it's concerning and I don't when you
struggle the way Jordan Clarkson has struggled
thank god it's Memphis yeah right thank god it's
Cleveland and you have a nice stretch of games at home
and by the way the Jazz I think are are the
best home team i've ever seen yeah i mean it used
to be the lakers in the early 2000s this jazz team
just does not lose at home well i think
that the that's true they don't lose at home but the depth
thing is is i think it is possibly the biggest issue with the roster
because if you think about
it this way let's say that let's say
the starting five come out they get you out to a 15 point lead
heading into second quarter right let's just say
that everything's going perfectly in a in a game
one of the first round of postseason
but then your second unit comes in they're not as good
or they're not playing as well
and now your starters come back in with a two-point lead
well they're all that hard work
is just disappearing it's evaporating because the
second unit is not up to snuff
and that's the thing that i think is just is really troublesome
you know i look at again not to keep going back to the nets
but i look at the nets and i say man
dude that team is deep as hell like that team has guys for days
and i'm not just talking about the
starting five i mean you go down that roster you've got
a bunch of dudes that can score the
basketball and probably would start on other teams
and that's what makes a team like the
nuts so dangerous you know you look at again you look
at denver they're kind of in a similar
position to the jazz where they don't have you know
a ton of depth they've got enough to get by
but not a ton and so i guess for for me
this jazz team i think the expectation is an nba finals
appearance that like that's where they
are i i don't think the expectation quite yet is to win
an nba finals but it is the expectation to get there
and see what you can do and i think i don't
think that it's just some yellow brick road some some easy cakewalk
to get there with with the
roster that they have yeah i look at clarkson
um critical contributor yeah joe ingles i mean just
does not miss three pointers right now he's like impressive bro
this stretch of three-point
shooting for jingles is probably as good
as the jazz i've ever had three-point shooting yeah um
and then i i look at uh george niang
and i think he's he's giving you some real quality minutes
Um, but you're, you're playing those,
those guys, your six, seven, eight guys are, are
less than 20 minutes.
Um, so you're asking guys like Boyan Bogdanovich to play 30 minutes
when he's not contributing.
You're asking guys like Donovan Mitchell in,
in this, I guess is my main point.
I look at Donovan Mitchell
and it turns into Donovan versus everybody else because you
don't have a legitimate number two
and all this stuff where they're not playing guys
and all this stuff where you're able to celebrate
and have fun on the bench and stuff, that's all great.
But at the end of the day, you've got to have guys off the bench
who give you instant offense
but also can contribute in the fourth quarter
when you need a bucket.
Because in the playoffs, half-court defense gets much more difficult,
much more unbearable.
And so I think that's going to be the real issue.
Some of the other things that I saw last night,
at what point does Brad Stevens get whacked?
Yeah.
In Boston.
Boston.
They're not good.
This has to be, and I don't know you tell me,
this has to be one of the most disappointing teams in recent memory.
This Boston Celtic team getting beaten by New Orleans last night.
And granted, I think Brandon Ingram's turning
into this incredible shot maker.
He is growing before our eyes.
I'm looking at Zion Williamson dropping
a euro step last night evolving growing more tools in
the bag he's more than a dunker now
which is the step we've all been waiting for New Orleans is
coming there's no way they should
be on Boston's level especially at the garden there's just no
way and last night we saw BI hit a real critical shot for them late
and New Orleans winds up
winning and it's this question of at what point
do you want to be the Boston Celtics again because
this team is not right now yeah they're they feel like
a team that's just like a rudderless ship man
it seems like when they're playing games
that they're just kind of they're just sort of floating
floating along with the tide of the game you know they're just kind
of trying to to exist right now
and I in terms of Brad Stevens I look back
to when they signed Kyrie Irving the signing of Kyrie
Irving took them to a level where, where it was like,
okay, you're going to win the East.
You're going to, you're going to have
to go up against Braun, who was a Cleveland Cavalier
at the time.
And they had that epic series and they lost that series,
you know, Braun beat them and
inevitably goes onto the finals and does his thing.
But I think that this organization really needs a breath of fresh air.
They need, like, I'm not saying to burn the whole thing down,
but I'm saying you got to
move Brad Stevens and that whole coaching staff.
You may consider moving Jalen Brown,
and I think you've got to build a team around Jason Tatum.
Or if you don't believe in these two, then it's time to move on
and get to getting, like get to burning it down and rebuilding.
But this stuff about losing to New Orleans at the Garden,
not really being a high-end Eastern Conference team,
not living up to the Boston Celtics brand,
let's not forget the Kobe, Paul Pierce, Lakers, Celtics battles
that these two organizations had.
I mean, I can remember when I was,
I think I was in high school and we would go over
to Mrs. Grammy's house and we would have,
there was one Christmas where it was Lakers,
it was Celtics, and Kobe and Paul Pierce were just going back
and forth the entire game.
And I'm just left with this Celtics team being like,
dude, like, is Jason Tatum that guy?
Is Jalen Brown going to show for an entire season?
or are you just going to keep giving
me 20-game spurts where you're the guy
and then another 20 where you're not?
Like, that's the issue with this team.
They're a rudderless ship.
At least with the Jazz, let's say, there's direction.
We know who we are.
Every guy knows what he's supposed to do.
Whether he's doing it or not is a different story.
But, like, with the Jazz, there's direction.
There's teams like the Celtics just have nothing going for them.
There's no nothing.
Yeah.
Yeah, and I look at Brad Stevens,
and I know that he was critically acclaimed coming out of Butler.
Yeah.
This is a guy, young gun, hot shot, and then what?
And I think it's interesting you bring up
the Kyrie Irving failed experiment.
I mean, it just, it was never close to working.
So I look at that situation.
I look at, he has not figured out how
to get the best out of Jason Tatum.
Yeah.
He has not figured out how to develop Jalen Brown.
They've made changes roster-wise.
they've stuck with Marcus Smart
the only thing that's been static
there is Brad Stevens
and I think it's time to make a change
there because at some point
I mean you
at some point you'd like to win I would think
I don't know maybe I'm making too
much of it but at some point
you would like to win there I would guess

