Allie Stange, our European Correspondent, is fresh off a run through Wine Paris, ProWein and Hong Kong, and the big surprise wasn't the dumplings. It was Asian buyers walking up to the stand saying "show me your Rieslings," almost ignoring the reds (exactly one person tasted the Pinot). They also fell hard for an aromatic German grape that even a seasoned sommelier couldn't name, one most people would swear is Sauvignon Blanc. So why does the wine trade keep sneering at the aromatic whites that actually get people into wine?
Then the main event: the VDP, Germany's invitation-only club of top estates. It has a little eagle on the bottle, roughly half the yields German law allows, and a ban on buying in fruit even in a short vintage. Its top tier, Grosses Gewächs, was never trademarked, so other producers started putting "GG" on their best bottles, and now a fight is on over who controls the name. Add a membership announcement that shocked the industry and the boom in German Sekt (nine months on lees, minimum), sitting in a golden middle price while Champagne keeps climbing.
And the stuff that drives winemakers mad. The EU now requires calorie info behind a QR code on every bottle by 2026, though nobody seems to scan it. Australia's pregnancy warning uses red ink, so every box supplier needs new printing plates. And German vineyards have no fences: three rows are yours, two are your neighbour's, because the land got split between ten kids.
Subscribe for wine talk that doesn't need a decoder ring.
TIMESTAMPS 00:00 - Introduction 01:29 - German wines in Asia 04:19 - Scheurebe and aromatic whites 09:15 - VDP origins and purpose 12:27 - Grosses Gewächs naming dispute 14:38 - VDP vs German wine law 19:52 - Odinstal joins VDP 23:11 - German sparkling wine boom 27:20 - Sekt rules and pricing 30:22 - EU calorie labels on wine 32:24 - Does anyone scan the QR code? 37:36 - When labels say too much 39:26 - Pregnancy warnings and red ink 41:08 - Vine pulls and tiny plots 44:07 - No fences between neighbours 49:24 - The growing season so far 50:53 - What's next for Allie
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Industry professionals discuss the evolving Asian wine market, the rigorous quality standards of Germany's VDP, and the technicalities of Sekt production. The conversation also covers the administrative burdens of international labeling laws and the logistical challenges of land consolidation (Flurbereinigung) in German vineyards.
What's been up in your world? Because you've just come back
from last time we chatted, you were just finished up at ProWine.
Yeah.
And then this time around...
Yeah, it was Wine Paris, then ProWine, and then now Hong Kong.
Hong Kong. So you've done all the big ones.
You would call them the majors, I suppose, of all the wine shows.
If you would like to call it like that, yeah, maybe.
It feels like that when you're there, to be honest.
I feel like the atmosphere...
I feel special in those types of moments, I think, for sure.
And it was the same organizers as Wine Paris.
And I just, but I still, I say Hong Kong, what a city.
Oh my God.
I ate my own body weight in dumplings
but like it was so good but also like their wine industry
and like how they approach like you
and how they come to your booth and what they're tasting what
they're looking for is definitely like
so much more dialed in um than I was like I don't know
I didn't really know what to expect I didn't have a lot of
or no experience with the Asian markets yet I mean we had some visits
like to where I was working before
and now but still I don't think you get a
real like gauge on it until you're in the middle of it
and it's it was kind of
incredible I mean as far like as the people
in general were so nice and so
open and I and I could have just showed up
with Riesling and that would have
been enough also
It's interesting you mention that.
So I've done VinExpo Hong Kong a couple of times and
one thing that always surprised me was the lack
of German representation. Like there would be
German wines there, you had to find them,
that would usually be in amongst like a marketing
firm that was employed just to represent in market,
like it wasn't like almost like a broker.
And they'll be a part of like a booth.
It'll be like one or two wines out of Germany.
There might be Lusen if you're lucky.
And it always surprised me because being, you know, Australian
and having much more of a, I guess, a cultural tie to Southeast Asia,
like we look at that sort of stuff and go,
dude, that is like a missed opportunity.
But, of course, the feedback was always, oh, yeah, but...
Asian markets just want red wine.
It's really driven by the momentum of China
and they'd already signaled to us a long time ago
that white wine's not even worth coming into markets,
not worth paying for.
And the last time I did VinExpo
was about two years ago.
And...
The sort of feedback that came out of it
was the visitors were like, where's the ******* Riesling?
There seems to have been this shift away, you know,
completely 180, where suddenly everyone was like,
what do you mean our red wines aren't enough?
You know, like, and it was like,
we should probably bring aromatic whites again.
Is that what's happened? Is that why you were there?
Was, has there, have you noticed that within Germany there has
been like a renewed interest in VinExpo Hong Kong?
I think it's not I don't know
if it's just like a renewed interest in it but
like it's also being supported
by the German Wine Institute so like we were
there we were like with the German wine
as was the Deutsche Wein Institute so DWI
we were there with them
and basically you are like supported like financially
to be on their booth and so then you have
like the opportunity to send your wines all together.
I mean your booth it kind of all
looks the same but then you have like
your the name of your winery like up in lights it's
really nice it's set up and so you're taken care
of with ice and your wines are cooled
and everything is kind of like organized for you
so you're not just like um with
your importing company on another booth
or something like that so you're in
Like, Germany has its own section now.
It's not as big as the Australian section,
which I walked by and I was like, Jesus Christ.
It's, like, one after the other.
Yeah.
Uh-uh.
But I think that because Riesling is picking up momentum,
I think people are seeing that.
Thank you for that.
But in general, I think the Asian market is important
for a lot of wine regions, not just German wines.
I think in general, like it's growing and they're still moving
forward where other places might be a little bit more unstable.
Asia just keeps trekking through.
So, but yeah, and Riesling was every single person that came
to everybody was like, oh, show me your Rieslings.
Show me your Rieslings.
No interest in Pinot Grigio
or something along those lines, Chardonnay, ciao.
It was only, or what came on really well,
or like what people liked was the Scheuerebe,
which is also a very aromatic grape.
The what?
Scheuerebe.
It's a cross between Riesling and Bouquetrebe.
I don't know the exact English word for it, believe it or not.
Bouquetrebe, bouquet is like a bouquet.
So it's like a very aromatic.
A very aromatic grape, and that also performed pretty well,
because it, I mean, I'd say when
you smell it, I would say you first have a little bit of,
like, thought of a Sauvignon
Blanc in that direction, as far as, like,
the nose is on it, and they loved it, so,
but, like, red wine, I think,
I think one person tried a red wine, the Pinot that we
had, one person.
How, how insane, like, I'm loving it.
I'm loving the sort of sheer anarchy,
you know, pushing completely against like what
it was and what we sort of assume it was,
you know, we've been saying for ages that
aromatic whites, you know, Gewurztraminer,
for example, just gets a bit of a bad rap
in the industry a little bit.
Yeah.
Like, like us in the industry,
inside the industry bubble, love to like rip on these
great varieties that are just...
For me, amazing tools to get people into wine.
And then when we wonder why people don't get into wine,
it's because we're taking away all
these amazingly tasty things from people.
We should probably think about doing more of them.
Our number one wine we produce is a Zibibo.
By volume and value, and especially going into Southeast Asia,
it's absolutely massive.
I think it's a missed opportunity if people sleep on them.
Are there many other sort of,
because Riesling is aromatic or semi-aromatic in some cases,
are there other aromatic grape varieties within Germany
that the Germans are re-looking at?
I mean, Gewürztraminer is always pretty popular between Germany,
Austria, and Alsace.
I think that's something, but I mean,
that's kind of like a love or hate sort of thing
for a lot of people.
Sauvignon Blanc is pretty much everywhere.
People love it.
Um...
I would say that that...
Performs really really well.
Pinot Grigio I would say like outside of actual winemakers people drink
a ton of it but Pinot Grigio or like Caldwell does
not have like the best reputation and it's kind of like
It gets a bad rep, but sometimes, like, you have a really good one.
I'm like, guys, don't be so rude.
Dude.
But it's, like, really, like, some people are like,
no, I'm not going to drink that ----.
I don't drink Pinot Grigio.
I don't drink Pinot Grigio.
I'm not okay.
But I think there was some of them just got, like, really fruity.
I mean, you know, it can get pretty warm here as well.
Maybe they were, like, a little bit too broad, not enough acidity.
Um...
But I feel like it's unfair to...
completely ruin it for all Pinot Grigios.
Oh, yes.
Um...
But Scheurebe, I mean, like,
that's something that you see quite often here.
But when I went, when I was, like,
showing the wine in Asia, nobody knew what it was.
So I was even, and, like, there was also a guy,
he was a very trained sommelier,
and he also didn't know what it was.
And I assumed that maybe he would at least know,
but I think that, um...
but here we have all these kind of like random varietals
that the people seem to like love but
Nobody knows what they are somewhere else.
I'll be honest with you.
I've been in the industry nearly 20 years, and I'm a nerd.
And there'll be a lot of viewers
on the channel here that are also equally as nerdy.
And I'm pretty confident most people have never heard
of that, let alone been able to spell it.
I'll need to actually go back through and get you to spell it for me,
because I have no idea.
And I think it directly translates to shy vine.
Like when someone's shy.
Yeah, shy.
S-C-H-E-U-R-E.
You lost me. Already. Already.
It's too early in the morning. More coffee.
One German lesson today. That's it for you guys.
Yeah, but it's, you know, it's really good.
It can also have, like, a good amount of acidity on it.
So, like, it's really nice, too, for, like, a semi-dry wine as well.
So, like, if you want, like, something a little bit spicier.
So a few more grams of, like, residual sugars,
a little bit on the sweeter side,
but with a good acidity.
It could be really, really good.
I mean, I think it's just, like, try it.
But the smell is like, if you don't know the grape either, though,
I would say, like, you might just think it's a Sauvignon Blanc.
Right.
I've often smelled it and been wrong.
So expanding it across, because obviously you're based in Germany,
and I've been dying to talk to you about something.
I've been dying to talk to you about the VDP.
Okay.
Like, because I was in Austria recently,
and then went on to Spain.
And there seems to be a bit of a,
like a, maybe a trend, a rising trend.
It's not really like, it's, a lot of things
in the wine industry move quite slowly, don't they?
For good reason.
And VDP is a very old thing.
From the 20s, I think, isn't it?
I think as early as 1910.
Wow.
Maybe even that, yeah.
It's these sort of private groups.
That almost, in a weird way, give the middle finger to other
governing bodies, regulatory bodies, to do their own thing, to set
a different standard that they themselves want to self-regulate by.
And they grow quite powerful in terms of being consumer-facing.
Telma Rodriguez's Matador Manifesto,
pushing away from the DO, and not necessarily being
as organized as the VDP is, but in Kanthal,
they've got a similar deal where there's a
bunch of private businesses,
companies that have come together to go, we want to do things
better, and we need to set a standard
for how things are being done better.
Something interesting is happening with,
because it was always the sort of German,
This sort of regulatory system
and systems for rightness etc has evolved concurrently
with the VDP and its membership and its agenda and none of its,
what's the best word for
it, none of its really
I want to say salacious, but it's not,
that's not the correct word either, but none of it's
like nefarious.
None of it's like evil.
Like everyone's got their own sort of agendas
and their own beliefs philosophically.
But now there seems to be an adoption
of sort of VDP's position into German law.
They seem to be sort of merging together.
Is that?
Yeah, but there's a specific reason for that as well.
And I think it's, um, I'll try to explain this the best I can.
And I don't work for a VDP winery, but...
From, like, talking to other people, so, you know,
I would say most people see it as, like,
you have, like, your systems, like, in France,
you know, they have their allocations, and
so, cru, premier cru, grand cru, you know,
all of those, and I think, like, that is basically
what VDP kind of, like, installed here in Germany,
but for, so it's, they have, like,
Like they're board for...
All of that oversees all of the regions, every single region.
So, all of them.
And then they also have, like, individual boards for each one as well.
So, like, they kind of, like,
are a small government within a larger government.
So, but it's overseen.
So, but I don't know how many years ago this happened,
but, like, that's when they, like, founded,
like, this, like, Grosse Lage sort of thing.
So that was kind of like the highest standard for
Wine, so if it's Grosse Lage, it's like, should be in the best vineyard.
That's what we would know.
And that was basically, that's our proof.
So we would know that it's like GG when we say,
oh, this is a GG wine, Grosses Gewächs.
Yeah.
But they didn't, yeah, but they didn't patent this name.
And this was a mistake.
So what happened is over the years, other wineries...
even if they didn't have like a vineyard like
that had been registered as a GG vineyard so
they still could use this name
and say okay well this is our top wine this is our GG
but that's like a pretty gray zone
because they're not in VDP so VDP is like as basically
uh like uh like an organization of like the top wineries in Germany
and you have to be invited in
So it's not there is not there's no application process
or something like that and then you have
to be vetted over a certain amount of years
um and every wine that you send in as like a
VDP winery gets tested too
so like you there's like a lot of ratings along the way
um so but I think when they didn't patent this
So, the name just kind of got, like, used a little bit too loosely
with people who didn't have those types of vineyards.
They just used it to classify their best wine.
So, like, more like co-ops and those sorts of things.
And now, I think they're trying to, like,
get that into control a little bit.
I think that...
You can only use the name GG for wines that are specifically allocated,
approved, registered as a GG vineyard.
But I think right now it's in talks
of who's going to do the controlling of that.
Is it going to be like the people
who control the German wine laws or is it going to be VDP?
And I think they will decide like next week or the week after next.
And from what I understand,
it would make the most sense if VDP controlled that also.
Because I think that's who wants to kind of get everything.
Organized.
All right.
Let's zoom out here.
So what is the VDP versus German Wine Law?
VDP is basically a club that was founded
to set the standards for German wine.
And so basically, I have to make sure I say this correctly,
sets the standards for the best wines and how they are made.
And, um...
Basically like a control system for selling
the best wines that go out there
and they get like and you're constantly having to prove that I believe.
And like I said, I don't work specifically for a VDP winery,
but I think, I mean, it's definitely the highest standard and you know
that and that they have that reputation and I think that's...
They are not, when you go to a restaurant
and you see a wine with VDP, you're like,
okay, they're being held to the highest standards.
They take care of their vineyards.
That's, it is the gold standard, basically.
And so German wine laws, I think, go more into also agriculture laws.
So, and I, that's more about like how many,
I think the difference would be, so.
For an example, how many hectoliters
are you allowed to harvest per hectare, basically?
So how much grapes can you take home?
And obviously, the numbers for VDP are quite, like, a lot lower.
And it ranges from there, like, Ortswein to GG.
So I think when you produce a GG at maximum, it's like...
I don't know, like 5,000 or something.
It's not very much.
And then when you have just normal
German law, we're talking about 10,000.
So it's basically like a more structured,
more based on quality to increase the quality,
to like make sure that quality standards are being met.
They're like laws inside of the German laws.
So like obviously they still have to follow all German laws,
agriculture, wine laws.
Thank you so much.
But then they have their like strict laws.
Yeah.
And this is really denoted on wine bottles with that.
They have like symbolic or symbols and
icons on their bottles that are regulated
so you can't use the little eagle. You can't, if you see
that you know that's a VDP member.
And you also, they're not allowed to buy wine into like, they
They can't purchase wine.
Like, well, no, like, yeah, so, like,
it has to be wine only from their own vineyards.
So, like, even if it's a year where they didn't have a lot of yield
and some winemakers will buy wine to, like,
accommodate, they're not allowed to do that.
They can't put the eagle on their bottle.
I think they can do it, but that, like,
that wine won't be classified as one of their VDP wines.
So they have to sell that with a label without that,
without the eagle on it.
One thing that I read, and you can tell me whether or not this is true,
That's true.
GG vineyards, VDP, they have to be bone dry.
There's no sweet, sweet wines allowed at a GG level.
I don't know if that's true.
No? I could have sworn it was.
I could have sworn it was, that if you've got a Grosskovec's VDP wine,
it must be bone dry.
But I would think that Grosskovec's is like...
Is the vineyard itself open?
I don't know the answer to that question
because that could be true, though.
But I know you can have, like, a cabinet,
but you can have a dry cabinet as well.
That only has to do with, like, the cabinet is more about,
like, the Oechsle degree that it had when it was harvested.
That's, like, what that refers to.
But I'm sorry, I actually do not know that.
I don't know that answer.
At the moment there is effectively
the German wine law is almost flexing a little bit to
what the VDP is doing because it
is quite I would say it's quite powerful when we were in Germany
there was a lot of you know it's powerful
when producers who wish they were in the VDP but
aren't and haven't been invited have had
a degree of I would say friendly animosity
you know towards where they're like it's
professional jealousy in a weird sense.
Yeah, and I think if anyone says they don't want
to be invited, I'm not sure if that's
actually true.
I'm sure anyone who has ever been invited has said yes.
I don't know if anyone has declined.
Not that I know of, but...
There are producers that you wouldn't expect
to have been in the VDP because the VDP wines
are, I mean, overtly conventional for the most part.
And is it Odenstahl is VDP now as well?
Which is quite a, like it's almost a signal, isn't it?
To where the VDP is flexing towards.
Yeah, Schätze is also in there,
which is kind of like a little bit more in that direction as well.
But I don't, I think for them, for example,
I don't think all of their wines are VDP wines.
So I think they only do some of their wines, some of their vineyards.
Like I said, it's dependent on the vineyard
that has to be registered as well.
So if you have 25 hectares,
it doesn't mean that all 25 of your hectares are eligible at all.
So, um...
But yeah, that's also something I thought about
because I was like, okay, well,
that doesn't really follow the typical trend for BDP,
but I think they are looking to be a bit more modern in some ways,
not that it's too one-dimensional,
No, because it is
I think it's also important to talk about what Odinstal does,
their respect to nature and how they farm and how they produce wine.
And I think that is also to the highest standard
when you think about production
and wine production and agriculture.
I mean, we were there together.
You saw.
I mean, that's almost like for me as far as respecting nature,
that's perfection.
Perfection.
It takes a special person to be able to do that, but it's definitely...
I'll tell you what, I've never seen anyone
cover cropping using hemp before and that was
very impressive.
Me either.
That's insane.
Yeah, but I think it's definitely,
I think that's also important and I think that they
wanted to bring kind of that style in.
Yeah, maybe kind of like broaden the horizons a little bit and I yeah,
which I think is important
But I was also as shocked as anybody.
I think the majority of people were shocked
By that announcement, but you know what? I mean the wines
Are so loved and I they're everywhere too
Especially like in like like really high-end restaurants gastronomy
is like star kitchens around the world
I mean, they're almost always on the list. So and I've seen them
It'll be interesting to see over time, again,
like trends in the wine industry tend to go
for a long time and take a while,
but how much of that sort of knowledge and position
and ideally commercial success
for a company like Audemond sort of blends and bleeds into
VDP ways of thinking and seeing whether
or not it opens the doors to sort of other producers
doing sort of similar stuff, I guess.
Yeah, I'm curious to see how it goes, and I mean, what I, I have
to say, I am a fan of, like, this quality system of holding people,
like, to this standard, because I think it's easy to blur
the lines sometimes of what's good and what's not good,
but I think it's good to have this system in place, and that now
that it's kind of, like, come to the attention that, okay, we,
We don't want to, like, abuse this type of, like, system and naming it.
So I think it's a good thing that it's,
like, really kind of being reeled in,
that we're setting, like, some guidelines, setting some standards,
and kind of making it, like, law, I guess you would say.
And I think it's great.
And they are the best wines.
I mean, you can like what you like,
and I'm sure there's a ton of other wineries that are not VDP,
and they're amazing, do not get me wrong.
But VDP is VDP for a reason.
And they do well for a reason,
and they do really well in export because they really
focus on holding that high standard,
but also marketing themselves at that high standard.
What about sect?
What about, is sect part of VDP?
It's coming up, yeah, yeah, yeah, that's like,
um, but like sparkling in general, German
sparkling in general is like having its moment.
It's amazing.
I was really, what was the producer I
discovered over there was, was crack, crack.
So good, man.
That's so good, yeah.
It is really impressive stuff.
It seems like there's, I mean, globally,
if you look at consumption statistics,
sparkling wine is one of the, like, higher-priced wines,
so premium and fine wine tends to be pretty well insulated
from sort of economic downturn.
But it seems like sparkling wine as well,
just globally is having sort of a bit of a moment.
It continues to thrive.
We see it in Spain with Carver and now Corpinnat,
Corpinnat, you know,
you know, this sort of...
Raising a direct sort of, again,
Corpinnat's a very similar situation to the VDP.
A bunch of producers come together and they go,
we want to do things differently and better.
We want to effectively move out of appellation
to create our own sort of whole new style
that's much more revered globally and it's working.
Is there this sort of camaraderie
amongst German-sect producers to kind of push quality
Are Germans drinking more Sekt than they are drinking champagne?
Are we starting to see like a shift towards things
that are a little more local?
What's going on with German Sekt?
I...
I don't know if they're drinking less champagne,
don't get me wrong, they're gonna get their
education from somewhere, so, um, but I think it,
I think it comes down to a few different things,
first of all, you have, like, kind of, like,
this new wave of younger winemakers who have, like,
kind of taken over, so we're talking about, like,
definitely a more modern approach, a more open
approach, a more, like, I would say,
so international way of thinking, so open to ideas from other
other places, champagnes,
It is, and getting expensive, more expensive,
it's, it's, um, and I think, like, it's a
lot to do with education, like,
now we have the education of, like, this traditional bottle
fermentation, um, we have those grapes, those,
like, traditional grapes, Chardonnay, Pinot
Blanc, Pinot Meunier, Pinot Noir,
they grow really well on our soils, and we have many
types of soils, so, um.
We have the opportunity
to produce really incredible sparklings here, and the young
people love it, because everyone, and I think,
I mean, you could buy champagne, or you could
buy...
Also champagne from Germany, which is just not called champagne.
But, like, because, like,
we've been really open to this type of education.
Because, like, it's not like when you go
in France and they only drink their own wine.
Germans drink wine from everywhere.
And I would say that's, like,
a massive difference between going to other countries sometimes.
You go to Italy, they mostly also drink wine from Italy.
But Germans drink wine from everywhere.
We're not, like, really stuck on our own wine.
So we've been open to...
Learning other stuff and other types of grapes
and also I think this education for the
making sparkling is just like
really pushed this ability to do it well ourselves.
And like I said, we have the soils for it.
Do you, like, I don't know, when I think of German sparkling,
this is from an Australian perspective, right?
Because we just don't get there. Be careful.
No, I think of Henkel. I think of, I think of one brand.
You know, and that's the, well, that's all we really get exposure to.
Thank you.
Like we don't, dude, I'm sure there
is German Sekt imported into Australia, but I don't know
who imports it.
Thank you very much.
You know, I think it might be expensive, probably, right?
Probably.
Is that, and that juxtaposition between,
and I think it's sort of like gets back to even
the Cuvée-Corpore art thing where, you know,
when people thought of Spanish sparkling,
they go straight to Cuvée, which is,
you know, not deemed, you know, prestigious.
Um, and because of that really drove
the corporate art sort of movement forward is German Sekt.
I also wouldn't call, I don't know, Henkel.
I've never, Sekt is like a relatively new word for me.
Like I'm sure it's one of those like, uh,
Well, it's all German Sekt is sparkling wine,
but not all sparkling wine is German Sekt.
I mean, are there rules for Sekt?
It's called a Schaumwein and it's like, yeah, there's rules for you.
Basically, Asti, which is basically Prosecco
and you have like added the CO2 to a still wine.
And then you have Schaumwein, which is like anything that was...
In, like, a certain amount of bars.
I'm starting to speak.
I'm starting to speak.
But anything that's under nine months on the yeast is,
like, not considered a Sekt.
So, like, you have to be, like, I think it's nine months.
I might have moved it up to a year.
I haven't really.
So it needs to hit nine months and then it becomes a Sekt?
Yeah.
So, like, you have, like, it needs to sit,
like, on that, like, on the lees.
It needs to sit on that yeast for, like,
at least nine months to be considered a German Sekt.
So when I'm talking about Henkel,
most people will be like, dude, that's not Sekt.
That's just...
It's probably Schaumwein, but I don't know, but maybe they do.
They probably have both, but I'm not really sure.
And I don't think I've drank that since I
was like 18, so I have no idea.
But, well, and I think that's still like relatively like affordable.
What I think...
It's really interesting is the price points
for really good German sparklings are not cheap but not expensive.
They're, like, somewhere, like, in that,
like, middle range, especially, like,
so it's going to be cheaper than maybe, like,
a super well-known or really good, like, expensive champagne.
So, but you still know that it's quality here,
but you can still, so, I don't know,
it's like that weird sweet point of a price.
You know what I mean?
Like, you know, okay, I'm about to get something good.
And I think it's also really important when
When a winemaker also knows their worth,
that they don't make it too cheap.
So I think that's, I know it's like probably just like marketing,
like, like mental, I don't
know, mental games, but you know what I mean?
I still think it's important that they don't make it too cheap.
Um, I need to find my train of thought here for a second,
but, uh, basically I think that
you're getting point.
to like to introduce this thing at high quality
because if you know anything about how wine is
made and then how it can't be super cheap yeah it's
not allowed to be cheap it's so weird that
we think it would be but i understand like why
and that's the success of these you know um uh
you know bulk sparkling producers their ability
to better do what they do at scale and then
Um, give the, the halo effect of champagne kind
of allows everyone to be able to have
these amazingly successful commercial models.
Um, but it's just, but you can't make it at that price point.
You can't make a good sparkling at that price point.
I can't make sparkling at all.
Like I, I think it is, I think people
that do that ---- are like wizards.
That is an incredible, incredible feat.
Um, the labeling.
In Europe, it's something that I'm
not sure about how you guys are tackling it, because
we send some wine across to Poland, right?
And you work in export,
like you understand that labeling to different markets better
than anybody, it is like, it's almost a full-time job
if you're sending to many different countries,
and some countries are better than others.
Like, if anyone who's watching this works in export,
tell me how you handle Brazil,
because that is, that's another whole kettle of fish.
I ain't got that one yet, that's on you.
Indonesia, Philippines
and Brazil definitely take the cake as some of the most difficult
ones to get a label to.
But in Europe they've introduced something that vexes me a little bit,
which is the energy.
The energy values that you see on the back of,
I don't know, packets of chips and all
kind of pre-packaged food items, how many kilojoules of calories.
The nutritional values, okay, yeah.
Which, I don't know, for me, when I'm looking at,
say, dry wine at, like, 12%, 13%,
like, how different are they, right?
Like, you've basically got thousands upon thousands of producers
who make tens of thousands of collective products
that all have the exact same nutritional values,
but now we all need to make sure that we put them on a label
and, you know, let customers know,
which more transparency is obviously a good thing.
But
But...
There are just numerous studies that have shown like, for example,
you know this also equally well, in the States, in the USA,
there's that big block of government warning text on the back
of every single label and it's been going for 35 years and it hasn't
affected a change in behavior or consumption behavior at all.
Well, my question is like, well, you don't see,
we don't print it on the back of the
bottle.
It's a QR code.
Well, that's, that's the thing.
You have a choice, right?
You have a choice.
You can do, but who's going to print it instead?
Yeah.
And it's honestly, it's like a thousand extra steps in like work.
And also like, cause that stuff has to be like digitally like made,
downloaded somewhere
and made somewhere.
Um, you need a data bank for all of that.
Like, but.
It's literally not doing anything.
I would say, okay, if you printed it on the bottle,
like actually had to print it and it was visible,
but like no person picks up a bottle of wine, scans the code,
like, oh, that's got a few carbs.
Like I said, it vexes me.
The
Like if there is...
Undoubtedly, there will be people in the comments that go,
I find this really useful, I'm, I don't know,
trying to lose weight or something like that.
I get that and appreciate that,
but I would say they are in the vast minority of people that,
you know, if you just let it to open sort of market, right,
where you go, look, if a winery wants to put it on...
Great. If the winery doesn't want to put it on, that's cool.
All those people that are looking for low-carbohydrate anything
aren't going to buy your wine,
and they're probably going to preference the company that does.
But forcing everyone is an incredible amount of infrastructure.
Incredible amount of change
and I know on an individual producer level it's
just hey dude how hard is it to put a QR code
the back label? Not that hard. When
you look at the aggregate of the entirety of the industry of any bottle
of wine from I believe it's enforced right now
so any bottle of wine must now
have from 2026 there was like a transition period.
For us it was already
before I think it
was like already starting 2000 everything
After 2024, I think, already, with the QR code.
When we do QR codes, which we do for various things,
for events, for sign-ups, for, you
know, sometimes we'll throw, like,
---- into boxes to give people access to bottlings or
something they can't get elsewhere.
QR code's a great little technology to do that.
But our QR codes, the system we use,
helps us track how many times and where it's been
scanned.
And I would be interested to see if anyone has done that,
like, and actually can go,
look, we've printed, you know, hundreds of thousands,
millions of these things, and they've
been scanned, like, ten times.
Please get back to me on this one.
I want to know who's scanned it.
And I want to know who they are.
In Australia, we're quite liberal with a bunch of things.
We have, in, like, building and planning laws.
And for good reason, it's like political correctness
is what we're talking about here, but like
when you build a building and you want to,
you know, it's a commercial building, you
need to have, say, disabled toilets, you know,
and that is good for accessibility, no one's
done that.
At the top and bottom of every set of stairs,
we have these like little, like rubble strips,
so blind people know that there's stairs here.
If I have...
I do, we've been operating our cellar door just there
for the last 15 years and you know,
I don't know any blind person that's ever rocked up
to look at my distillery. It's never happened
and so if you, on the individual level,
the ability to put a rubble strip on the ground,
it's not that hard, but like on the aggregate,
how many, how much infrastructure in rubber,
You know, across and the expectation
and then you've got the consultants that are paid
to come out to make sure that, oh yep, cool,
a blind person will recognize this, it's the
right distance away from the stairs.
Or even just like real estate in terms of disabled toilets.
I reckon I've had in 15 years like two people
in wheelchairs come and visit.
Yet tens of thousands of non-disabled people.
It's one of those political correctness things,
which by all means I'll be counseled for mentioning,
but it is kind of like there's a lot of investment in the minority.
It doesn't seem to move the ticker.
But I don't know if counting calories counts as a minority,
and I think that, I get it.
I think it's, like you said, it's good to be completely transparent,
It's completely transparent.
and I support anyone who wants to watch
their health and stuff like that,
but I don't think it's a secret when you drink a wine.
That alcohol turns into sugar,
that it's going to be calories, and I don't know, it's like
eating a chocolate bar and wondering why you
didn't lose five pounds, you know what I mean?
So I don't think it's, it's good that it's on there,
it's good to know it, but I don't,
if you're going to do it, then why make it a QR code?
That's just not visible. That's just to save space, I think.
But I think they created more work than anything else for everybody.
I know.
And I wouldn't be surprised if a German came up with that idea.
Well, it's funny you mention that because there's a study
that's been done about the efficacy of government warnings
or just information on a label.
Thank you.
And there is a point, a tipping point,
where the more information that you put on, the least clear it becomes.
So you have these two sort of forces
working together where you're like, look.
And case in point is the whole,
what's the word for the German sort of classification system?
It's like amazing amount of information.
You can navigate.
But, you know, the Moselle, so well, right?
But equally, just trying to understand that system
is such a heavy amount of friction
that a lot of the terms start to lose their meaning
when you have no idea what Spätlese or Auslese even is.
Thank you.
The Qualitätswein system.
Yeah.
And that's I think the reason why they opted with giving you
the QR code because there's already so many different
Mandatory things on there.
Yeah, I mean, I I think I mean they're like the principle behind it.
I understand it's like
Obviously, I'm well read enough to understand why they did
the first idea of why they okay
Okay, Kat, sorry, sorry.
Sorry
but I mean I get it and it's just sometimes I
Things are better as ideas than when they're actually set into motion.
Yes.
And then once you set them into motion,
you can't walk backwards anymore.
I think the reality of it is, okay,
this was just a lot of work for everybody.
And I, like you said, with other things,
I don't know if it acted like the massive warning label in the US.
I don't think it changed consumption whatsoever.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Well, it seems to be more signaling than anything else.
It's funny you talk about the difference between ideas and
And like when they put into practice recently, we had in Australia,
the pregnancy, mandatory pregnancy sort of warnings come in and they,
um, which is a pretty common thing anyway, around the world.
Um, this one in particular is quite, quite big.
And it's also, and this is where the pragmatism came into it.
It's multicolored. So it's like, it's black and white and red.
And the black and white thing is, is one thing when you incorporate
the red, it actually becomes problematic because they rely on, um,
You need to put it on your label
but you have to put it on your box as well and so if you've got a
box which is just black ink
on say brown cardboard something very simple you still need to have the
little circle around the lady in red
which means that now all your like box suppliers are like we
now need to charge for new plates for every single wine producer ever.
Oh my god that cat is so cute.
I know, he was actually like, Charlie, say what's up?
He's actually so cute.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Yeah, and so it's, I don't know, if we were smarter people back then,
we would have bought shares in Red Ink, you know,
because there's going to be a run on red ink.
And I think what, I mean, but think about, like, the cost of that.
Hmm.
For a small winery, for a small production, like, those things add up.
Changing your labels, having to do everything new,
like, it seems like a small change, but
like, over, like, amount of thousands of boxes,
I mean, it does get expensive.
That never really sort of gets considered.
What are other things happening in Europe at the moment?
Vine pools, that seems to be a big, a big topic at the moment.
Is there, is there, when I was in Germany last,
what, a year ago now, it's been a year,
Um...
Yeah.
In Baden, I was quite surprised that there were,
you go through the Moselle, right, and it's just like, wow,
there's vineyards everywhere. And in Baden, there was this really
quite surprising thing happening where people, it was at harvest,
it was this time last year, so just before harvest, and...
Like people had run out of money and so they just stopped working
the vineyard and so there were these overgrown vineyards,
they were not pruned, they, you know, effectively the wineries
that manage those blocks just walked away so there was this weird sort
of patchwork of like vineyard that was still sort of in operation
and then others that were just like effectively abandoned.
And there was all this talk about vine pools
and government-sponsored vine pools.
Is that now in effect? Is that happening across Germany?
I mean, we see that all the time. It's called Flurbereinigung.
It's a...
You have this, but it's...
But it's totally normal.
I mean, I think every village decides on it
and how they're going to do it,
and I think when everyone just says, okay, we'll do it.
But, I mean, it has a few benefits as well.
I mean, I think I told you this when you were here.
So we have a lot of, like, tiny different plots.
So, like, you can have three rows here, then there's,
like, next two rows belong to your neighbor,
and then you have, like, a bunch of other,
like, here's, like, two more, here's five more,
and it's, like, really kind of, like,
sporadic sometimes how it's, like, laid out.
Um, and this happened more because they're like,
I think the, the laws in France, like
when someone died and they were giving
their vineyards up to their children, the oldest
son got everything in Germany.
If you had 10 kids, they split it up into 10 kids.
Well, that depends on where you are, isn't it?
Like, isn't the Moselle slightly different?
It could be, but like where from like,
this is like the example from like where I am.
I'm not exactly sure if it's different,
but I know that like at that time, and I don't know how it is now,
but they would split it up the vineyards between all 10 kids.
So like you had these really like tiny plots everywhere.
So what you do when you do this like vine pulling, you basically
First of all, it has a little bit to do with overworking the soils
and overplanting.
So from an agricultural, environmental standpoint,
that would be the benefits.
But also, you have the chance to kind of reallocate everything.
So instead of all these tiny, like a bunch
of tiny different plots, you have a few big ones.
So they like relay the...
The paths, and the different plots, basically.
Because they were split up between so many people
at that time, and not just one child,
so this is what happened, so.
I always wondered how that system worked,
because like in Australia, it's really obvious,
because we put big fences around our vineyards,
so you know who owns what, right?
Yeah, no. But like separating
in the middle of the row.
Is, you know, how can you end up having, say,
these rows are organically managed, but these ones are not?
You've got all sorts of things with overspray.
That's tough, and that's, well, and you, that's really,
like, tough, because if your neighbor is not organic,
I believe you have to, like, skip a row.
I don't think, I think you have to set up, like, a parameter.
Like, for what grapes are your granite grapes?
I don't know if it's still like that, but I,
um, it's also difficult because, like,
we hang pheromones out against, like,
the bugs, and actually everyone is supposed to
do it, but some winemakers are like, no,
I'm just not going to do it, and they, like, basically
reap the benefits of everyone else doing it,
of setting up these, like, perimeters.
Um, so...
That's kind of tough but I mean everyone just kind
of knows where everything is at. I don't know how to explain it to you.
Like when you work at a winery long enough you're like go to this one,
go to this one, this one. Oh you know those four rows over there.
I'm like oh yeah. And you head over and you just kind of know.
And nobody really messes with the other ones.
But, um...
I mean it is tricky when
also your neighbor doesn't take care of his stuff
and you have like these like bacterias
or whatever these like things that affect
the plants and you know you get too much rain
or the wind comes through and it
blows these spores of disease onto your plants that happens
and I know that is
an issue and probably a topic
for a very heated discussion between neighbors.
To give people perspective,
if they're unaware of how this is working, how close
are a lot of these vine rows, like between neighbors?
Like how, how, they're all right,
no, they're on top of each other. They're all right next to each other.
It's like a meter and a half. It's like 1.8 meters spacing.
Or 1.5 sometimes, but like, wait,
you mean like how far are the rows apart?
Or to the neighbors?
Yeah, no, but like your neighbor's row
might just be your, next to your row.
So like you stop here, 1.5, 1.8 meters,
one more and there's your neighbor.
And there's no fence or anything in between, there's no demarcation.
No, sometimes there's a rock and it says, oh, that's where mine starts.
Or they like put a little paint on the middle.
and it's like or some people put like a little like
a little sign okay from this to this i mean
you see it people use different types
of metals sometimes people still use a little bit of wood
um how you just see it i don't know you just
feel it you just walk by and you're like oh
that's a new one you see it from how they work
the ground you see i don't know you just get
used to it also
but it's not like there's no fences no wow that must be fences
Well, I mean, we have whole blocks.
It's just because for a lot of people watching,
they haven't traveled to Europe before.
They're not really, when you're talking about your neighbor,
I think like really understanding.
He's really right there.
Yeah, it's like right there.
And if your neighbor isn't pruning or looking after the grass
and it's growing through the vines themselves,
the disease pressure is astronomical.
And it's there.
And so I guess you have to hope
or maybe hope that he'll give up his vineyard and you can buy it
or take over it to do a 10-year contract or whatever for it.
But I think that's also a little bit a point
of the vine pulling is to eliminate that kind of thing
that you don't have five winemakers on top of each other with...
Five little tiny plots.
So I think that is also like a benefit of vine pulling.
To kind of eliminate all these tiny little ones.
You just, yeah, reallocate and make them bigger.
So is it more, so you're saying like vine pulling,
at least in the context of Germany,
is more about reallocating sort of resources,
like you're looking at efficiencies
and less so about trying to correct the oversupply.
Yeah, I think it's more about not overworking the soils.
It's more about just like...
Not having too many small vineyards,
but like everyone pretty much agrees to it.
I mean, as far as I know, I mean, it's like,
I mean, we just had one when I was working
in Niederkirchen, which is like between here,
my village and the next one where Schöllmann is.
So we, like that whole right side of the street went through.
The vine pulling.
And it's like a massive plot.
And so everyone's also responsible for taking their own posts out.
So all the metal, ripping up the vines and that.
But I believe a lot of the logistics
and organization are financially supported by some agriculture.
Yeah, something along those lines.
But you're still responsible for a lot of it.
And whatever you plant, when it's done.
What's happening in the next couple of months where you are?
Well, budding just started.
So we got about 100 days about until harvest already.
Our buds are already there.
They shot up like crazy.
It got so warm.
It's early June.
It started last week.
It's May last week.
And the buds are already there.
So it got so warm so fast.
I know, like, as far as, like...
Here in Germany, you know, we've seen that before,
but now it's gotten a little bit cooler again, it's raining
a little bit, so I think anything can still happen, but I know,
like, you're talking about, like, Bordeaux or something like that,
it's, like, double hot there, they're probably panicking, so.
Issues with frost, is that the concern?
No, that's, I think the last chance of frost is done now.
Really, that's good news.
That's more like beginning of May, I would say.
But I didn't see anything or hear anything too much about it.
I think there's even a day when they say,
on this day always happens frost.
And there's some weird German saying about it.
They were talking about it.
But nothing happened.
It did get really cold like one more time.
But that was like towards the beginning of May.
But it happens almost every time.
It just gets like randomly super cold.
But now the buds are there.
Are you off to any more giant wine shows around the world?
Not giant ones, not at the moment, but I am going, on Monday I'm going
to Hamburg on, in two weeks I'll be in the Netherlands for four days.
Doing a couple of master classes there for a small wine shop
and then going to, it's called Riesling, Pinot and...
company, I believe. Also with the German Wine Institute.
And we are going to be a part of
Shanghai and Sao Paulo, but I'm not attending those.
The father of my boss is attending those
because he also has like another company where he sells spirits
and he has another company,
like a small winery that is like sparkling, I believe. And
I think another project in Luxembourg now.
And he has a lot of contacts already there,
so he's going to attend those shows.
And it's okay.
I mean, I think Yannick would be happy
if I stayed home a little bit this year,
to be honest.
Yes.
I think he's forgot what I look like.
It's like...
Well, Ali, thank you so much.
It's been a good little three-month check-in.
We'll probably check in with you
probably after European Harvest.
Fingers crossed it all goes well.
Ciao, ciao.
Ciao.