#History#Food America once had 56 million sheep. Today it has fewer than 6 million. 🐑
In this episode of Crumb Lore, we dig into how the biggest meat-eating country on earth ended up barely touching lamb, the one meat much of the world treats as sacred.
The story runs through:
→ The first domesticated sheep in Mesopotamia, over 10,000 years ago → Lamb's place in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam → The brutal sheep wars of the American West, with roughly 120 armed clashes between cattlemen and shepherds → The class stigma that tied lamb to immigrant kitchens → Canned mutton in World War Two, and the veterans who swore off sheep for good → The industrial food system that scaled beef and chicken, then left lamb behind → How Australia, New Zealand, the Middle East, and Europe went the other way → The slow comeback driven by immigrant communities, farmers markets, and restaurant chefs
Do you eat lamb regularly, or have you never tried it? Tell us in the comments, and subscribe to Crumb Lore for more food history.
In 1942, the United States had 56 million sheep.
Today, it has fewer than 6 million.
That is not a typo.
The country lost 90% of its sheep herd in a single lifetime,
and most Americans never even noticed it happening.
Meanwhile, the rest of the planet was doing the opposite.
The global lamb
and sheep meat market hit $71.5 billion in 2024.
In Kazakhstan, the average person eats nearly 19 pounds of lamb a year.
In Kuwait, it is closer to 35 pounds.
In Australia and New Zealand, lamb is practically a national symbol,
with both countries accounting for over 80%
of the world's sheep meat exports.
And in the United States, where people consume more than 100 pounds
of meat per person every year,
lamb barely registers at just over one pound.
So how did the biggest meat-eating country on Earth
end up practically allergic to the one protein
the rest of the world treats as sacred?
The answer runs through 11,000 years of human history,
three major religions, a series of
literal range wars fought with rifles on the open plains,
one of the worst canned meals ever fed to
soldiers, and an industrial food system
that decided lamb simply was not worth the trouble.
That story starts
in a place most people would never connect to a lamb chop.
Somewhere between 9,000 and 11,000 years ago,
in the region stretching across modern-day Iraq,
Iran, and Turkey, humans figured out how to keep wild sheep
and breed them. Sheep were
among the very first animals ever domesticated,
right alongside goats and just ahead of cattle.
Those early flocks grazing the rocky hillsides
of Mesopotamia were not kept for wool.
Wool came much later, around 6000 BCE,
when generations of selective breeding started producing animals
with thicker, softer fleeces.
The first domesticated sheep were kept for their meat,
their milk, and their skins.
When an animal was slaughtered for food,
the hide was tanned and worn as a kind of tunic,
which made the sheep one of the few animals providing both dinner and
clothing in a single package. And it worked. Sheep were hardy.
They survived on rough forage that cattle could not handle.
They reproduced quickly
and provided a steady source of protein for communities that were
just learning what it meant to stay in one place
and build something permanent.
Within a few thousand years,
domestic sheep had spread from the Fertile Crescent
across the grasslands of Europe, the deserts of North Africa,
and deep into the steppes of Central Asia.
By 7,000 years ago, they had reached Europe.
By 5,000 years ago,
They were established across most of the known world.
No other domesticated animal spread that far, that fast.
The ancient civilizations that built
the foundations of Western culture ran on sheep.
In Mesopotamia, some of the oldest recipes ever recorded,
carved into Babylonian clay tablets nearly 4,000 years old,
included instructions for preparing lamb stews seasoned
with garlic, onion, and fat.
In ancient Greece, sheep were so central to daily life
that shepherds gave individual animals their own names.
The mythological golden fleece,
the object at the heart of Jason's legendary quest,
was more than just a fairy tale.
It reflected how deeply sheep and their wool were woven
into the economies and mythologies of the ancient Mediterranean.
Sheepskin, processed into parchment,
became one of the primary writing surfaces of the
ancient and medieval worlds,
carrying the texts that preserved philosophy,
Law and scripture across centuries.
Pliny the Elder, writing in Rome during the first century,
devoted an entire section of his Natural History to praising sheep,
declaring that humanity owed them thanks for both appeasing the gods
and providing the gift of wool.
But lamb was more than just food and fabric.
It became something that no other meat has ever been.
It became holy.
The Paschal lamb sits at the center of the Jewish Passover tradition.
In the book of Exodus, God commanded the Israelites to sacrifice a lamb
and mark their doorposts with its blood
on the night before their liberation from Egypt.
That act of sacrifice
and deliverance became one of the most sacred rituals in Judaism.
And when Solomon's temple was built in Jerusalem,
priests oversaw the slaughter
of sacrificial lambs during the Passover festival.
The Hebrew word for sacrifice, korban.
which most often described an offering of a sheep
or goat appears 160 times in the Hebrew Bible today
a lamb shank bone still sits on the Passover seder plate
in Jewish homes around the world a reminder
of that original covenant Christianity carried that symbolism forward
and deepened it Jesus Christ is
referred to as the Lamb of God throughout the New Testament
and the Gospel of John presents
He presents his crucifixion
As the ultimate fulfillment of the Passover sacrifice,
eating lamb at Easter became a tradition
that endured across centuries and continents,
from the rooftop tables of Jerusalem
to the parish halls of rural England.
In Islam, the holiday of Eid al-Adha, the festival of sacrifice,
commemorates Abraham's willingness
to sacrifice his son at God's command.
A lamb is ritually slaughtered,
and the meat is shared with family, neighbors, and the poor.
Divided into thirds,
with one portion reserved specifically for those in need.
For over a billion Muslims worldwide,
this act of shared sacrifice is one of the holiest moments of the year.
Three religions, billions of followers,
and at the center of all three, the same animal.
No other meat on earth carries that kind of spiritual weight.
Beef has no scripture.
Chicken has no covenant. Lamb does.
So when European settlers began arriving in North America,
they brought their sheep with them.
Spanish conquistadors introduced
the first flocks to the continent in the 1500s,
establishing herds in what is now New Mexico.
The Navajo people, who had no prior tradition of sheep herding,
adopted the animals and built an entire pastoral economy around them.
Including the weaving traditions that produced some
of the most celebrated textiles in North American history.
English, Dutch and Swedish settlers followed in the early 1600s,
bringing sheep to the East Coast.
For the next two centuries,
sheep were a basic part of American frontier life,
providing wool for homespun clothing and meat for the family table.
But sheep in America never had an easy ride.
The country was already developing
a very different relationship with its livestock,
and that relationship was being shaped
by something bigger than food preference.
It was being shaped by land, power, and violence.
By the mid-1800s, cattle ranching
was the dominant force in the American West.
Cowboys had become cultural icons,
featured in dime novels
and newspaper stories that reached audiences back east.
Cattle barons controlled enormous stretches of open range.
And the mythology of the frontier
was being written around beef, not lamb.
Then the sheep started arriving in larger numbers,
driven westward by demand for wool during and after the Civil War,
and by the simple economics of sheep ranching.
Unlike cattle, which took four years to reach market weight,
sheep provided an immediate return through annual wool clips
and fast-growing lambs.
Wool was fetching 50 to 80 cents a pound in those years.
And the math clearly worked in the sheepman's favor.
The cattlemen did not see it that way.
What they saw was a threat
to the grasslands they had claimed as their own.
Sheep grazed differently than cattle.
They cropped grass close to the ground and traveled
in tight flocks that could strip a hillside bare,
which cattlemen claimed destroyed the range and
polluted the water sources their herds depended on.
Whether or not the science fully supported
those claims, the rage behind them was very real.
Between 1870 and 1920, a series of violent
Conflicts known as the Sheep Wars erupted across the American West.
These were not polite disagreements settled in courtrooms.
They were armed attacks.
Cowboys and cattlemen organized raids against sheep herders,
slaughtering flocks, wholesale, burning camps,
and killing the men who tended the animals.
In Texas, Arizona, Wyoming, Colorado,
and several other states and territories,
roughly 120 separate engagements were recorded.
At least 54 men died in the fighting. And
Somewhere between 50,000 and 100,000 sheep were killed outright,
shot, clubbed or driven off cliffs
by organized bands of cattlemen defending territory that,
in most cases, they did not actually own.
The Pleasant Valley War in Arizona,
fought between the Tewkesbury and Graham families
through the 1880s and 1890s,
was among the bloodiest range conflicts in American history.
The novelist Zane Grey later fictionalized it
in his book To the Last Man.
In Oregon, the Crook County sheep shooters left written warnings nailed
to shepherds' cabins,
threatening violence if sheep were not removed from land,
the cattlemen claimed.
And nearly all of this was happening on public land,
territory that legally belonged to no one.
but that the cattle industry had decided was theirs,
by custom and by force.
The range wars ended in the early 1900s
when the United States Forest Service stepped in to
regulate grazing on federal land,
assigning permits and drawing boundaries between cattle
and sheep territory.
The violence stopped, the shootings ended, but the cultural damage ran
deeper than any grazing permit or boundary fence could fix.
Sheep had been branded as the enemy of
of the West's dominant industry
And the bias was set in the national imagination.
Cattle were American, sheep were a nuisance,
and then came a second blow, this one quieter but just as damaging.
As the cattle and sheep industries sorted out
their territorial disputes, lamb and mutton developed
a class stigma that further pushed them to the margins.
By the early 20th century, lamb was increasingly seen as the meat
of immigrants, particularly those from southern and eastern Europe.
Greek, Italian,
and Jewish communities were America's most reliable lamb eaters
and in a country that was
already anxious about waves of immigration
that association did not help lamb's reputation among
the broader middle class. A 1924 Better Homes
and Gardens article noted that few American
housewives were familiar with lamb cuts beyond the leg
and the ribs lamb was disappearing from
mainstream American tables even before
the event that would deliver the final blow
That event was World War II.
During the war, the American military needed to feed millions
of soldiers spread across multiple continents.
The logistics alone were staggering.
Canned and preserved foods were the backbone of military rations,
and one of the meats that canned well
and was available in large quantities was mutton.
The tougher, stronger flavored meat from adult sheep,
large shipments of canned mutton came
from Australia, packed into tins
and sent forward to the front lines by the ton.
The problem was that canned mutton from the 1940s was,
by virtually every account,
absolutely terrible.
Military buyers were not picky about quality, so the meat that
ended up in those cans was often the worst cuts
from the oldest animals cooked down.
And sealed in tins that sat on supply lines for weeks
or months before anyone opened them.
Soldiers ate this greasy, gammy,
almost sulfurous protein multiple times a week,
sometimes multiple times a day, for years on end.
Brad Anderson, a livestock manager
for the Mountain States Rosen Cooperative,
summed up the legacy years later.
Those troops were fed canned mutton, he said,
and when they came home they told their families no more lamb,
No more sheep. Do not eat any of it.
That was where the steady decline began.
Bob Kennard, the author of Much Ado About Mutton,
confirmed the pattern from the other side of the Atlantic.
Wherever he traveled,
he heard the same story from veterans and their families.
The canned mutton of World War II was so deeply unpleasant
that an entire generation of American men came home
and swore off anything that came from a sheep, forever.
And they did not just swear it off for themselves.
They swore it off for their families.
The men who came back from the war
were the ones stocking the refrigerators
and deciding what showed up on dinner tables
in kitchens across post-war suburban America.
When a returning veteran smelled lamb roasting in the oven,
the memory that came back was not a holiday meal.
It was a mess tent in North Africa or a foxhole in France
and a tin of greasy mutton that was barely edible.
Lamb and mutton, which had been rising through
the late 1930s, collapsed.
The United States sheep herd,
which had hit its all-time peak of 56.2 million head in 1942,
dropped to fewer than 30 million by 1950.
That was a nearly 50% collapse in just eight years,
and it never recovered.
Through the 1950s, the herd briefly stabilized.
But by the early 1960s, the slide resumed and never stopped.
Per capita lamb consumption,
which had peaked at around £5 per person in the mid-1940s,
fell to about £4.5 by 1960 and kept dropping.
By the 1980s, the sheep inventory had fallen below 11 million head.
By the mid-1990s, it dipped under 10 million.
The long, slow bleed continued decade after decade,
and nobody outside the shrinking community
of sheep ranchers was paying attention.
Beef alone did not push lamb off the plate.
The entire industrial food system rebuilt itself at
a scale lamb could not match.
After the war, the beef, pork, and poultry industries underwent a
revolution in efficiency that left sheep producers in the dust.
Cattle research turned beef production
into a precision operation with controlled genetics,
massive feedlots stretching across the Great Plains
and a nationwide cold chain distribution network.
Chicken farming industrialized even faster.
Companies like Tyson and Perdue built vertically integrated operations
that controlled everything from the hatchery to the grocery shelf,
driving poultry prices down to levels
that lamb producers could never compete with.
The infrastructure gap widened every single year.
The beef and chicken industries had modern processing plants,
national distribution chains, massive marketing budgets,
and serious political influence in Washington.
The lamb industry had almost none of that.
Meanwhile, the wool side of the sheep business
was collapsing too.
Synthetic fibers like nylon, rayon, and polyester had been flooding
the textile market since the war ended, and by the 1960s,
the price of raw wool was falling steadily.
Sheep had always served a dual purpose in America.
Farmers kept them for both the annual wool clip and the lamb crop.
When wool stopped paying,
there was one less reason to keep sheep at all,
and flocks that had been profitable for decades
were suddenly costing more to maintain than they
earned. The basic math on the meat side was just as punishing.
A market-ready lamb yields about
40 to 50 pounds of meat. A single steer yields over 600 pounds.
The economics of scale were
were crushingly simple, and they only got worse
As fewer farmers raised sheep, fewer processors handled lamb,
and fewer grocery stores bothered to stock it, the cycle fed on itself.
Less supply meant higher prices at the butcher counter.
Higher prices meant fewer customers willing to try it.
Fewer customers meant less reason to produce lamb in the first place.
And so the herd kept shrinking, year after year,
while the cattle and poultry industries grew into some
of the most efficient protein factories on the planet.
By 2011, a survey by the American Lamb Board found that nearly half
of American consumers had never eaten lamb at all.
Not that they had tried it and disliked it.
They had simply never encountered it in their entire lives.
In a country with more than 300 million people
and one of the most abundant food systems on
the planet, half the population had never once tasted one
of humanity's oldest foods.
While all of this was happening in America,
the rest of the world was moving in the opposite direction entirely.
In Australia, lamb had become something close to a national identity.
The Australian sheep industry
Built on the back of vast pastoral stations
stretching across New South Wales, Victoria,
and Western Australia, grew into a global force.
By 2024, Australia was producing over 600,000 tons of lamb per year,
and had overtaken New Zealand as the world's top lamb exporter.
The country's domestic per capita consumption sat
at around 7 kilograms per person,
roughly five times the American figure.
Meat and Livestock Australia ran annual campaigns
that turned lamb into a cultural touchstone,
including a famous Australia Day lamb advertisement
that became a national event in its own right,
debated in living rooms and on social media every January.
New Zealand's story was even more tightly braided with sheep.
When refrigerated shipping became possible in the 1880s,
lamb exports transformed
the young colony's economy virtually overnight.
By the mid 20th century,
Wool and lamb were New Zealand's most valuable export categories,
and roast lamb on Sunday was a family tradition that endured
for generations in homes from Auckland to Queenstown.
The country celebrates National Lamb Day every February 15th,
marking the anniversary of that first frozen meat shipment to England.
Beef and lamb exports still earn New Zealand more than three
and a half billion dollars a year,
and the phrase New Zealand lamb carries instant recognition
in butcher shops and
restaurant kitchens from London to Tokyo.
Across the Middle East and Central Asia,
lamb never needed a marketing campaign or a national holiday.
In countries like Turkey,
Iran and Syria, lamb consumption is woven into daily life,
served at ordinary weeknight dinners,
and not reserved only for holidays or special occasions.
Turkey alone consumed over 500,000 tons of sheep meat in 2024.
In Kuwait, per capita consumption reached 16 kilograms per person.
In Turkmenistan, it topped 20 kilograms.
These are not niche markets catering to food enthusiasts.
These are entire food cultures feeding hundreds of millions of people
Built around a single animal,
that has been on their tables for thousands
of years without interruption.
And then there is Europe, where lamb sits comfortably alongside beef
and pork as an everyday protein.
The European Union averages about 2.5
to 3 kilograms per person per year,
with countries like Greece,
Ireland and the United Kingdom consuming considerably more.
In Britain, roast lamb with mint sauce
is as traditional as Sunday itself.
Served in pubs and family kitchens from Cornwall to Edinburgh.
In Greece, whole spit roasted lamb
is the centerpiece of Easter celebrations
that shut down entire islands for days.
In Morocco, slow cooked lamb tagine,
simmered for hours with preserved lemons and olives in a clay pot,
is a dish that has barely changed in 500 years.
The global average for sheep meat consumption
is about 1.4 kilograms per person per year.
The American figure is roughly half of that.
That gap did not open because Americans found something better.
They were simply trained, over the span of about 80 years,
to forget that lamb existed.
But there are signs that the forgetting might be starting to reverse.
Over the past decade, immigrant communities have become
the single biggest driver of lamb
consumption growth in the United States.
Peter Orwick, the executive director of the American
Sheep Industry Association, explained it in an interview with NPR.
Every major metropolitan city
in the country now has large immigrant neighborhoods,
and the people in those neighborhoods come
from places where lamb is the preferred meat.
It is their meat, as Orwick put it. Middle Eastern, North African.
South Asian, Greek and Latin American communities
have brought their food traditions with them
and those traditions put lamb at the center of the table.
One third of all lamb sold in the United States today
moves through direct sales, farmer to consumer,
at farmers markets, through specialty butchers
and at halal meat shops.
These outlets have become the primary distribution channels
for domestic lamb,
bypassing the mainstream grocery store system
that never made room for it on the shelves.
Small and mid-sized sheep operations,
the kind that could not survive trying to compete
in an industrial commodity market,
have discovered that selling direct to consumers
who actually want lamb can be a viable business after all.
The restaurant world has noticed too.
Lamb shanks braised until they fall apart,
thick cut lamb chops seared over open flames,
and lamb burgers seasoned with cumin and sumac
have appeared on menus from casual dining chains to white tablecloth
restaurants in cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago.
The rise of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cuisine
in American food culture has pulled lamb along with it.
Chefs who grew up cooking with lamb in their home countries
are opening restaurants that serve it proudly,
and American diners, especially younger ones
who did not inherit their grandparents' wartime aversion,
are more willing to try unfamiliar
proteins than any previous generation.
The numbers, while still modest, reflect a real change in direction.
United States per capita lamb consumption,
which had been flat or declining for decades,
ticked upward for the fourth consecutive year in 2025,
reaching a projected £1.17 per person.
That is still a tiny fraction of what people consume in Australia,
or the Middle East, or even Europe.
But it is movement, and the direction matters.
In an industry that has been in free fall for 80 years,
any sustained upward trend is something
the remaining sheep ranchers in Wyoming
and Colorado and Texas have been waiting a very long time to see.
The irony of the whole story is hard to miss.
Lamb was never an exotic ingredient
that Americans needed to discover for the first time.
It was here before the country was.
It was on colonial tables before the revolution.
It fed frontier families across the West.
It was rising in popularity right up until a world war
and a can of terrible mutton knocked it off the map.
The rejection had almost nothing to do with taste.
Circumstance started it, inertia kept it going,
and an industrial food system that
found it cheaper and easier to scale chickens
and cows than sheep made it permanent.
The rest of the world never had those same circumstances.
In the Middle East,
lamb has been eaten continuously for over 10,000 years.
In the Mediterranean, it survived every empire and every occupation.
In Australia and New Zealand,
it became the economic foundation of entire nations.
And in the kitchens of immigrant families across
the United States right now,
it is being cooked the same way it has been cooked for generations.
Seasoned with cumin and coriander
and slow roasted until the meat falls from the bone.
In homes where nobody ever had
to convince anyone that lamb was worth eating.
Whether America will ever fully come around is an open question.
The industry is small, the processing infrastructure is thin,
and over 60% of the lamb Americans do eat
is imported from Australia and New Zealand,
shipped frozen across the Pacific Ocean to fill a demand
that domestic producers cannot meet on their own.
The sheep herd today is roughly one-tenth
of what it was during the Second World War.
At one point, the state of Ohio alone had more sheep than
the entire country has today.
That is a very deep hole to climb out of.
But then again, lamb has been around for 11,000 years.
It survived the fall of Babylon, the collapse of Rome,
and the rise and decline of empires across three continents.
If any protein on Earth has earned the right to a comeback,
It is probably the one that has
been feeding civilization since civilization began.
If you found this one interesting,
hit subscribe and leave a comment telling
us whether lamb is a regular part of your meals
or something you have never tried.
We have more food history coming soon, so make sure you do not miss it.