VocalEyes’ Lonny Evans leads this audio-described event, which provides evocative visual descriptions of 10 key works from the Tantra enlightenment to revolution exhibition, alongside images of each object.
Lonny will be joined by exhibition curator Imma Ramos as we explore this radical South Asian philosophy from its birth in India to the present day.
This event is designed for blind and partially sighted audiences but all are welcome.
Live captions provided by Stagetext, delivered by MyClearText
Part of the public programme accompanying the special exhibition Tantra: enlightenment to revolution (24 September 2020 – 24 January 2021).
We’re bringing inspiring stories of humanity’s shared histories and cultural achievements to millions of people online. Your support ensures that we can continue to make the collection and videos like this one available to as many people as possible. If you can, please donate today: http://ow.ly/1e1Y30qHebG or you can text BMLEARN to 70085. Texts cost £5 plus one standard rate message.Credit: British Museum Events
Hello and welcome to the British Museum's first ever live-streamed audio described event of
Tantra and the Enlightenment Revolution. My name is Fiona Slater and I'm the Equality and Diversity
Manager at the British Museum and I'm going to give you a very short introduction of this event
before handing over to Dr Emma Ramos who is the curator of this fantastic exhibition
and Lonnie Evans who is our vocalised audio describer. So just to give you a bit of an
explanation about what an audio described event is all about. Essentially these events are designed
specifically for blind and visually impaired audiences. So you're going to get a visual
description of some of the highlight objects from this exhibition and you're going to get
some background information from Emma Ramos about why they're so important to Tantra.
So normally we run these events as a tour through the exhibition on site at the British Museum for
a very small group of people, roughly about 10 people come on these tours.
As we're not able to meet at the moment in any groups we have decided to move to Zoom and host
this as a Zoom webinar and we're opening it up to audiences around the world. So at the moment we
have about 100 people joining us at this event which is great. We've got people from Kuala Lumpur,
Sao Paulo and Bromley. So yes as we've got such a big group of people with us today
we have turned your cameras off. We've also disabled the chat function which we hope is
going to make it more accessible to people who use screen reader software. There is a question
and answer function so if you have any questions that you want to ask us through the event then do
put them in the Q&A box and we will be monitoring them and hopefully at the end of the event we're
going to have time to respond to some of your questions. Because this is our first ever event
we're really interested to hear what your thoughts are, how it works for you, how we might be able
to develop these and make them more accessible for everybody. So there's going to be a feedback
form which will pop up at the end of the event so put in your feedback here if you have time
and this is accessible to you. Do give us your thoughts and we'll try to take them on board as
we develop this event more in the future. If you'd like that information in an alternative format
or if you want to get in touch with us with any other thoughts then email at access
at britishmuseum.org and we'll take your feedback and thoughts there. So I think I'm going to hand
over now and I'll hand over to Lonnie Evans and Emma Ramos who are going to lead you through this
Hello everyone I'm Lonnie Evans and I will be your vocalised audio describer this afternoon.
I wanted to start with a visual description of the signature image for the exhibition
Tantra from Enlightenment to Revolution which is used on all the posters and promotional materials
and which is on our screen now. It features the painted and gilded clay figure of the goddess
Kali and dates from the 19th century Bengal in eastern India. The sculpture is 50 centimetres
tall and depicts a fierce looking black painted Kali striding over her husband Shiva who lies on
the ground facing up. Shiva is pale with reddish hair. Kali stands with her front foot on his chest
and the other pressing down on his thigh. Four armed Kali is nude apart from a golden girdle,
tall golden headdress and heavy golden necklaces, bracelets, armlets and anklets. The soles of her
feet and her palms are bright red contrasting with her black body and red circles outline her chest.
Kali wears a garland of severed heads that hangs to below her knees. More chunks of red flesh adorn
her ears. Her eyes are wide and her mouth is open to devour negative forces. Her lips smeared with
blood and her tongue sticking out. Her top right hand displays a gesture of fearlessness to reassure
and protect devotees. In her top left he would have carried a sword, unfortunately now lost.
In her lower left hand she carries a severed head. The mustachioed male head dangles by a rope of his
hair dripping blood from his neck. We will return to discuss the imagery and significance of the
goddess Kali in much more greater detail later on, but first I'll hand over to the curator
Hema Ramas who's going to introduce us to the exhibition. Thank you Lonnie and thank you all so
much for coming today. This exhibition aims to explore the real meaning of Tantra. The overwhelming
image of Tantra as a cult of ecstasy in the West has persisted since the 19th century.
The erotic does play a role in Tantra but not in the way people might think and it's only one strand
of this rich philosophical tradition. The exhibition explores all of its complexity.
Originating in 6th century India, Tantra is a philosophy that has been linked to successive
waves of revolutionary thoughts from its early medieval transformation of Hinduism and Buddhism
to the Indian fight for independence and the rise of 1960s counterculture in the West.
The central aim of the show is to present the first historical exploration of Tantric visual
culture from its origins in India to its reimagining in the West. So what exactly is Tantra?
Tantra affirms all aspects of the material world as sacred and infused with divine feminine power.
It teaches that enlightenment can be achieved rapidly by actively engaging with spiritual
obstacles such as desire, aversion and fear in order to ultimately transcend them.
Tantric imagery is therefore unique in its inclusion of erotic and macabre symbolism.
Centering on the power of divine feminine energy, Tantra inspired the dramatic rise of goddess
worship in medieval India and went on to influence contemporary feminist thoughts and artistic
practice. From its inception to the present day, Tantra has challenged societal norms and
expectations around the world. The exhibition showcases objects from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh,
Nepal, Tibet, Japan, the UK and the US from the 7th century to the present.
The British Museum houses one of the biggest and most comprehensive collections of Tantric
material in the world. The exhibition is divided into three major sections, taking visitors on a
journey from the roots of Tantra, its rise and spread across Asia, through to its reinterpretation
from the 18th century to the present day. Examples of Tantra's radical and subversive
nature are woven throughout. This is Lonnie again and there are over 100 marvellous objects on
display in the show. We've selected eight key objects to tell the story of the exhibition
which we will describe in the order in which you encounter them in the show. To start I'd
like to offer a description of the style of the exhibition which is divided as Emma said into
three sections with different themes in each. At the beginning display panels are dark grey,
floor is black. Featured objects are shown on saffron yellow plinths. There's a short three
minute film screening from the late 1960s featuring Tantric imagery and golden quotes
on the wall. In the next section there's an immersive installation featuring a recreation
of the Kherapoyogini temple. Moving through the exhibition the background display colour turns to
a rich vibrant red with some text displayed in English and Tibetan. And in the final part of the
exhibition which shows more modern works the background colour is bright white with sculptures
showing interesting shadows against the bright white background. As visitors enter the show
they're introduced to the story of Tantra with an opening display of some of the earliest surviving
Tantric palm leaf manuscripts. The manuscripts date from early 12th century Nepal and are written in
ancient Sanskrit. Information panels on display here tell us that the Sanskrit word for Tantra
derives from the verbal root tan meaning to weave or compose. These instructional religious texts
are composed to invoke powerful Tantric deities and are often written in the form of a conversation
between a god and a goddess. Two of the manuscripts or folios on display contain the nectar of the
Thunderbolt Tantra. Folio one concerns sexual union and folio two transgression. The narrow
rectangular manuscripts look very similar. I will describe a single folio an image of which is on
our screens at the moment if you'd like to zoom in on it. The delicate pale brown coloured palm
leaf manuscript is just five centimetres wide and 31 centimetres long and is mounted onto a piece of
pale plywood in the museum. The manuscript is worn with age and a little afraid at either end.
There are two panels of text on each folio separated by a perforation about the size of
a nail hole in the centre. Both text panels are six lines long but the panel on the right is almost
double in length. The black inked Sanskrit letters pearl and loop and are tightly packed together with
very few gaps in between the words. Lima could you tell us a little bit more about these sacred texts
and their value to the practitioner? So the Tantras outline a variety of rituals invoking all powerful
tantric deities. These rituals which include visualisations and yoga require guidance from a
teacher or a guru and if carried out successfully are said to grant worldly and supernatural powers
from long life to flight as well as spiritual transformation as well. Many texts contain
rituals that transgress existing social and religious conventions such as sexual rights
and engagement with intoxicants and the taboo. Tantra challenged distinctions between opposites
by teaching that everything is sacred. There is no sacred versus profane or impure versus impure.
By engaging with the taboo which could be done literally or imaginatively
a practitioner could confront and overcome obstacles to enlightenment such as desire,
fear and aversion by engaging with rather than repressing them. Some tantras like the one Lonnie
has described outline sexual rights for achieving enlightenment which can be interpreted both
literally and symbolically. If carried out literally a couple assumes the roles of deities
in sexual union, the woman often being the focus of worship. When interpreted symbolically a
practitioner visualises this union within their own body, the deity symbolising qualities such
as wisdom and compassion. One of the folios from the Nectar of the Thunderbolt Tantra for example
recommends the union of the thunderbolt and lotus which can be interpreted as the phallus
and revolver. Tantric texts also often include mantras which are Sanskrit syllables embodying
the nature of a deity. Mantras play a fundamental role as power words in tantric practice and are
passed from guru to disciple. We move into the next section of the exhibition now, the rise of
tantra in India from the 6th century onwards. Tantric practice probably began on the margins of
society among devotees of the Hindu god Shiva, destroyer of the universe and Shakti, the universe's
all-pervasive energy. By the 8700s the tantras were being studied in Hindu and Buddhist monasteries
across India, reflecting the fluid exchanges between Hindu-Buddhist traditions. Our second
object is a sculpture of the tantric god Bhairav, created during the Hoysala dynasty in India between
1200 and 1250 AD. This delicately carved sculpture is just over half a metre high and made from black
schist, a silvery dark grey stone and we have an image of it at the moment on screen. Bhairav is
considered to be the Hindu god Shiva's most tantric and fearsome manifestation. According to
he beheaded the orthodox Hindu god Brahma and wandered across cremation grounds as penance
using Brahma's skull as an arms bowl. Bhairav has four arms and is depicted seated on a throne
on a stone plinth. His pose is relaxed, his left leg is bent at the knee and drawn up on his seat
and his right leg rests on the floor. The throne is in a stone niche which curves up on either side
of the figure. It may have arched over the figure's head but the top is now missing. The figure is
draped in jeweled necklaces, bands and a girdle which conceal his nakedness. He wears a breastplate
with round shoulder sections and a long necklace featuring ghoulish severed heads which hangs down
to the floor. He wears heavy looking plate-shaped earrings that graze his shoulders, jeweled
bracelets and anklets and chunky rings on his slender expressive fingers. Bhairav gazes out
at the viewer through wide almond-shaped eyes and a prominent sweeping brows. He has a third eye,
an upright oval shape in the centre of his forehead. His features are finely carved, a long slender nose
and perked lips with two protruding fangs. The front of his hair is parted centrally and twisted
into rows of plaited knots. The back section of his hair is gathered in a bun fastened by a cobra
headpiece. In his top right hand Bhairav holds up a tall trident and in his top left a ceremonial
two-headed drum. With his lower right hand he raises a long sword and his lower left palm up
holds a small severed head by the hair. The male head has a beard and a curly moustache.
Two diminutive skeletal figures stand to the left and right of Bhairav reaching to the height of his
knees. They have prominent bony rib cages and are known as the demonic dead. Beneath his left knee
are small dog shelters ready to lap up spilled blood and another severed head with knotted hair
rests on the floor close to his right foot. A quote on the wall above the sculpture is from
the Netra Tantra dated between 800 and 850 AD. If a man has been marked by terrible ghosts
then a tribute should be offered to Bhairav, the lord of the demonic dead. Emma what is the role
of this kind of fierce imagery? Well the role of such ferocious imagery adopted by tantric deities
like Bhairav reflects certain tantric ideas. These fierce and weapon-wielding deities were regarded
as protectors of the realm with the potential to drive away its enemies. Simultaneously these
enemies could be understood as internal obstacles such as misplaced pride and ego which only the
ferocious deities have the power to obliterate. Such co-existing tensions in meaning altered
depending on who was approaching the deity, whether that was a ruler, a lay householder,
or a monk. Early tantric practitioners imitated Bhairav's appearance and behaviour by carrying
their own skull cups. Like Bhairav they dwelt in cremation grounds, covered their bodies in ashes
and carried skull cups which symbolised their overcoming of disgust, fear and attachment.
Rulers worshipped Bhairav in order to strengthen their political positions drawing on his immense
power. The stone carving that Lonnie described was made for a temple commissioned by a member
of the Hosala court in southern India. It shows how fierce tantric deities were brought
into the public and popular arena of temple worship during the medieval period. Bhairav
would have been considered a great source of power. Ultimately the role of such wrathful imagery
highlights the tantric belief that only the most ferocious deities can abolish the obstacles to
enlightenment. Thank you. So we're moving on to our third key object and the image has just changed
on screen to show us this 9th century sandstone temple relief from central India depicting the
ferocious goddess Chamunda dancing on a corpse. The sculpture is 89 centimetres high and 61
centimetres wide and rectangular with the top right corner missing. The sandstone is pale brown,
darker than worn in places where finer details of the carving have been lost. Chamunda is the
central figure depicted in a powerful frozen moment of exuberant dance. Nude apart from her
girdle and jewellery she sways to one side, her right hip thrust out and her right leg bent.
Her left leg is missing. Her head is cocked to the right. Her hair worn up in a high dome shape
and augmented by a skull pendant. She has large square shaped earrings. Her multiple arms weave
skillfully around one another occupied with various different tasks and she's surrounded by
smaller ghoulish attendants holding fragments of flesh. With her two upper arms Chamunda holds a
thin piece of flayed elephant demon skin over her head. With one of her right hands she hugs a skulk
up to her chest. In her lower right hand she holds a sword of wisdom to destroy ignorance and in her
lower left a severed head. Beneath the head a small sow-headed mother goddess feasts on the
blood that drips into her skull cap, sorry skull cup. The male corpse which represents the fragile
human ego lies beneath Chamunda with his head to the left. He's naked apart from some stone
jewellery. He lies on his right side his head lifted resting on his right hand as if he were
gazing up at her. The goddess stands on a round stone plinth resting on his upper hip. A small
jackal kicks at the corpse's heel suggesting the setting of a cremation ground at night.
In this section of the exhibition we explore the concept of Shakti and the many shades of
divine feminine power. Yes well power is absolutely central to Tantra. It's a power
described and visualized as feminine and known as Shakti as we say. So all Tantric goddesses are
seen as manifestations of Shakti and they often have overlapping identities. Tantra introduced
many new goddesses into the Hindu and Buddhist ambience often ferocious and sexually charged.
They challenged traditional models of womanhood as passive and docile in their intertwining of
destructive power and maternal strength. According to many Tantric texts mortal women are natural
embodiments and transmitters of Shakti. This contrasted with earlier orthodox Hindu and
Buddhist traditions which taught that the female body was an impediment to achieving enlightenment.
The earliest known text to describe the idea of Shakti is the Devi Mahagnya or glory of the goddess.
It tells the story of the goddess Durga who defeats a series of demons embodying ignorance
who the gods had been unable to defeat. Chamunda helps her defeat these demons.
Their martial abilities were harnessed by rulers to ensure victories on their own battlefields.
Chamunda is portrayed as skeletal to signal her constant hunger which she satisfies by consuming
demonic forces. With her sort of wisdom she destroys not only demons but also obstacles
to enlightenment. So although she appears fierce she therefore also conveys compassion and a desire
to assist followers on their spiritual path by releasing them from ignorance. Her ferocious
appearance also reflects her role as a devourer of the world driving time's continuous cycle
of destruction and recreation. This is Loni. According to tantric texts through yoga the
body can be turned into a sacred instrument and our fourth key object is a colourful goash painting
of a male yoga practitioner or yogi and it's just come on screen now. The yogi has symbols
delineating the position of chakras or yogic energy centres in a central line running up this
small detailed work is 54 centimetres by 44 centimetres and was painted in Rajasthan in the
early 1800s. The yogi is depicted as if he were viewed as if we were viewing him through an
arched window which has curvaceous cream coloured frame enclosed by a red border. He's sitting in
lotus position with his legs crossed in front of him on a cream coloured floor with a vibrant
orange wall behind him. On the floor either side of him rests a bottle with a stopper and a small
brown pot. The yogi has pale skin and is bare chested. He wears a pale pink sarong or dhoti
wrapped around his waist and his hands are in his lap with his left hand cupped in his right.
He wears a bead necklace and bracelets, subtle rings and earrings and a pair of decorative bands
on his upper arms. The yogi has a large head and wears his fine shoulder length brown hair
scraped right back from his face and tucked behind his ears revealing his full forehead to us.
He has a strong nose and an open mouth under a thin brown pencil moustache. His expression
is meditative, his gaze fixed, eyes partially open under heavy eyelids and sweeping black brows.
Three white parallel vertical lines are painted on the yogi's chest. These indicate the three
main channels of the yogic body which allows the life force to flow. The two outer lines contain
the painted chakras on his torso and the central white line links the chakras on his chest to others
on his face and forehead. He also has a white snake symbol on his upper chest, its head emerging
from below his left neck. The seven chakras are located in the perineum, genitals, solar plexus,
the heart, the throat, between the eyes and at the crown of the head. Kundalini is understood as an
individual source of power located at the base of the spine and often imagined as a sleeping serpent
which rises up through the body infusing the chakras. Here the chakras are represented by
multi-petaled lotuses sometimes inhabited by gods and their consorts. At the bottom by his waistline
is a bright green tortoise, an incarnation of the god Vishnu and a grey multi-headed serpent.
Above the serpent and linked to it by a golden chain is the elephant-headed Ganesha and a gold
petaled chakra. Rising up there are two more flowers then three chakra circles. The lowest
is within a blue lotus shape, the middle pink and the upper throat chakra is white with a green center
and all three contain deities. A white flower encloses the yogi's mouth. Above his eyebrows
rests a wish-fulfilling cow goddess, a mythical beast with a pink animal body and long green wings
like a dragonfly and on the yogi's forehead a final chakra, a lotus in full bloom with multiple pink
and purple petals radiating from it. I believe these vibrant paintings are old practitioners
of hatha yoga were often commissioned by members of the royal court in this time. That's right, so
the allure of tantra really retained a hold over those in positions of power right, you know, the
way through between the 16th and 19th centuries and one form of tantric practice that became
particularly popular was hatha yoga which means the yoga of forms. Where earlier forms of yoga
focused on concentration and mindfulness to escape the body, hatha yoga harnessed the body
itself as a sacred instrument to channel and master cosmic energy. The main competing powers
at this time were the Hindu Rajput rulers of the northwest, the Islamic rulers of independent
sultanates to the south and the Mughal rulers of an empire that came to dominate India by the late
17th century. Members of these courts commissioned works representing the practice of hatha yoga
as well as the lives of the men and women who practiced it. Yogis used complex postures and
muscular contractions to direct the flow of breath. As Lonnie described, techniques included visualizing
the goddess Kundalini, an individual source of Shakti, as a serpent at the base of the spine.
Around her is that network of chakras and together they make up the yogic body.
Through breath control, Kundalini rises like a current, infusing the chakras with power. Awakening
Kundalini became the practitioner's ultimate goal. This is a cosmic vision of the body.
According to tantric texts, all aspects of the body can be embraced and harnessed on the path
to enlightenment. Through tantric yoga, the body can be turned into a sacred channel. This is very
much about transformation in the world via the body rather than transcendence of the world.
Various yogi sects in India came to practice hatha yoga, but the one most popularly associated
with its development was the tantric Nath order. They held political sway with rulers who consulted
them as advisors to empower their sovereignty. Aside from the alchemical transformations they
enacted within their bodies, Nath yogis also became famous for producing alchemical concoctions using
mercury, which promised longevity. This was regarded as the seminal fluid of the god Shiva,
a major source of his power, which the Nath yogis were believed to be able to harness and distill.
Thank you. The next section of the exhibition focuses on the spread of tantra across Asia
from AD 800 onwards, with particular focus on Tibet and Nepal. Our key object here is a long,
vibrantly painted textile scroll, which is on our screens now. It features a tantric practitioner
called Saraha and other enlightened tantric masters known as Mahasiddhas. The scroll was
painted in Tibet in the 18th century, and the entire piece is two meters long, with the painting
in the center is about 80 centimeters by 50 centimeters. Tibetan paintings on fabric like
this are known as tangas, and this one is part of a set that may once have hung in a
monastic assembly hall. The central painting has three floral fabric borders in gray, blue,
orange, and gold. The painting itself is a busy, colorful, detailed scene depicting Saraha large
in the center, surrounded by six small tantric masters, three below him and three above. Each
of them is shown with artifacts from their individual stories. The dense background
features a body of blue water below with green hilly land rising up behind it. Unusual looking
vegetation grows up from the land. On the left, a gnarly tree with a twisting brown trunk,
white blossoms, blue leaves, and lush roots. To the right, a curling pale green plant with bright pink
blooms, and at the top of the painting, blue sky and fluffy white clouds. Saraha sits centrally on
the leopard print blanket facing right, with his knees bent and his legs pulled up in front of him.
His body is framed by a large dark blue circle behind him, with a second smaller bright red
circle, a little like a halo, behind his head. Saraha is naked, apart from an orange sarong or
His face has character. He's wide-eyed, with prominent red lips jutting out below his curling
brown mustache and light beard. His long back hair is gathered into a high dome shape, with one fat
curl trailing down his back. He wears beautiful jewelry, large golden earrings and bracelets,
a long crystal necklace, and a multi-tiered headdress made of crystal beads and decorated
with four white skulls with ruby red eyes. Saraha is holding a white feathered arrow, more of which
in a moment, which is symbolic of single-minded concentration. The six tantric masters surrounding
Saraha appear to float in a cloud or colorful halo of their own. They're seated cross-legged,
facing right. Some look serene, with shaven heads and orange robes resembling Buddhist monks.
Others look more eccentric, with exaggerated features including straggly hair and beards,
hunched bodies and bushy eyebrows. The Mahasiddha in the lower left corner pets a tiger. The one in
the lower right corner sniffs a large red flower. Hima, can you tell us a little more about the life
of Saraha and his guru? Yes, so Saraha is known as the Arrow Shooter. He was born in eastern India
in the 8th century. Though formerly a Hindu Brahmin, he secretly followed the Buddhist path
and eventually became a monk. The arrow that he holds is a reference to his guru, who's known as
the Arrow Making Yogini. A Yogini is a female practitioner of yoga. According to versions of
his hagiography, she was a female arrowsmith. He first met her in a market where she was making
and selling arrows. Attracted to her single-minded concentration as she aimed one, he approached to
ask what she was doing. She replied, the Buddha's meaning can be known through symbols and actions,
not through words and books. This led Saraha to interpret the arrow as a symbol of non-duality
that must be fired into the heart of dualistic grasping. Recognizing that she was a great
tantric Yogini and stunned by her wisdom, he abandoned his monastic vows and became her
disciple and consort. He composed many songs, including the following one about his guru,
which I'll read to you now. This Yogini's action is peerless. Enlightened spontaneity
shines forth. Beyond passion and absence of passion, here sun and moon lose their distinction.
In her, the triple world is formed. Perfecter of thought and unity of enlightened spontaneity,
know this Yogini. He also stressed the importance of the body as a channel to enlightenment,
rather than an obstacle to it in its microcosmic mirroring of the universe. He once said,
never have I seen a place of pilgrimage and an abode of bliss like my body.
Well, we started this conversation with the description of the signature image from the
show, which was the painted clay sculpture of Kali. And we move on to a section entitled
Kali, Antra, and Revolution in Colonial India. We have a new image on screen, which is our sixth
object, a colorful lithograph featuring Kali, produced by the Ravivarma Press between 1910
and 1920. It's 50 centimeters high and 35 centimeters wide and was one of the firm's
most popular images. In it, the ferocious four-armed goddess is bright blue. She's standing
on the chest of Shiva, who lies on the ground beneath her, whilst clutching the head of a demon
who lies decapitated by her right foot. Kali dominates the scene, which is played out against
a pale blue liquid background, as if she was standing by the water side. Kali strikes a
fearsome pose, her vibrant blue body bristling with energy, a spiky golden halo of light radiating
She's naked, apart from beaded necklaces, golden anklets, and bracelets, with a girdle of severed
arms worn at her waist, and a long necklace of severed heads, which reaches below her waist.
She wears large elephant-shaped ear ornaments, a red flower garland, and a bright red and gold
three-pointed headdress. Kali has a third eye in the center of her forehead, and her long dark hair
tumbles exuberantly down her back, reaching her thighs. Her expression is exultant, her eyes wild
and staring, and her tongue thrust out. In her top right hand, Kali is brandishing a sacred sword
called a ramdao, with a curved blade to ensure decapitation in a single stroke.
In her top left, he holds up the severed head of the demon by his curly brown hair. His eyes are
closed, his tongue poking out. Blood from his neck drips into a golden bowl that Kali holds beneath
the head. Below Kali, Shiva lies on his back with his head in the foreground. He's naked apart from
a wrap around his waist and some jewelry. Kali has her left foot on him, her heel pressing down on
his chest. Shiva is pale-skinned and lies with eyes closed, a sacred drum clenched in his right hand.
A white cobra is wrapped around his left hand, the snake's head rearing up menacingly, as if
ready to strike. To the left of Shiva lies the decapitated body of the demon. He has dark skin
and lies sprawled on his belly. Blood gushes from the demon's neck wound onto the ground.
He's still grasping a small shield in his left hand and a sword in his right, but Kali's claim
is clear. She presses her toe firmly down on the back of his blade. A quote on the wall here by
Bipin Chandra Pal in New India in 1907 reads, this symbol of Kali may arouse the energies of the nation
and lead it on to realise its highest destiny. Shiva, can we talk a little about how the goddess
became a symbol for the revolution in colonial India at this time? Yes, well Kali's popularity
became a focus for revolutionary politics during the late 19th century. At the time Bengal was not
only a tantric centre, but also the nucleus of British rule. Kali gripped the British psyche
as an icon of horror and irrationality. Colonial officials completely misunderstood her symbolism
and assumed she was demonic. Colonial anxieties around Kali would escalate with the rise of
anti-colonial movements in Bengal. In 1917, a report was published detailing the terrorist
activities of Bengali revolutionaries and their allegiance to Kali. The author, who was the
director of criminal intelligence, was disturbed by rumours surrounding their secret cult-like
rituals, believed to involve the consecration of bombs to the goddess. Indian revolutionaries in
Bengal effectively exploited British fears and misconceptions of the goddess as a bloodthirsty
demon mother and harnessed her as an anti-colonial symbol. In another print of Kali in the exhibition
produced around 1895 by a studio in Calcutta, which was the capital of Bengal, her sacrificial
head assumed an alternative meaning. A colonial administrator anxiously described the image
as featuring what appeared to be British looking heads, a prediction of the fall of the British
empire. This led to its censorship. Perhaps he was right to be concerned. By this time Kali was
regarded by many as a symbol of mother India rising up against her colonisers. In 1905, a
writer for a seditious Bengali newspaper proclaimed, rise up oh sons of India, the foreign empire draws
to an end but behold Kali rises in the east. I think it's the synthesis of modern politics and
religious myth that make these images of Kali so fascinating. Moving now into the final part
of the exhibition which is called Reimagining Tantra Art and Counterculture and we will explore
two objects here. This section investigates how artists, writers, curators and filmmakers in Asia
and the West from the 20th century to the present day have been inspired by Tantra, interpreting it
as a movement that could liberate oppressive attitudes to gender, sex and politics. And it's
here, and this isn't one of our objects, but we get to explore the wonderful Rolling Stones logo
with the mouth and the sticking out tongue from Mr Keating's album. But our penultimate object here
is a very beautiful small untitled painting, a Ghulam Rasool Santosh. It's 59 centimetres high
and 49 centimetres wide and made in acrylic paint. It's painted in India in 1974. Santosh's work engaged
with the symbolism of Tantric rites, mirroring the union of Shiva and Shakti. In this work two bodies
made of abstract shapes merge and glow in colours. The background of the painting is dark blue with
a light blue border. The two figures are enclosed within an oval shape that fills the canvas.
The oval is divided in half horizontally into contrasting colours. The upper half is pale
yellow and the lower dark brown. The two bodies appear to merge in sensual union. This is indicated
by two pairs of legs in the lower half of the oval, suggesting one figure straddling the other.
The upper figure may be female, although their gender isn't emphasised. The lower figure is
by bronze coloured legs and haunches. The upper figure has brown legs, a red torso and a luminous
round blue head. The upper figure holds its red arms overhead, connecting into a circle.
Where the lower bodies meet, there radiates a vibrant orange circle with a golden centre.
From the crown of the upper figure's head emerges what appears to be a third eye of enlightened
awakening. A golden v-shape rises, supporting a red diamond with a pale green eye in the centre
with a bright blue pupil. Santosh said that Tantra was the truth that fashions the contours of our
creative expression. Seema, can you tell us a little bit more about this artist? Santosh was
born in Srinagar in Kashmir to a Shia Muslim family. He eventually settled in Delhi in 1960
after marrying a Hindu woman, much to their parents' disapproval, and assumed her surname.
His family name was Da. Santosh had experienced a spiritual breakthrough during a pilgrimage in 1964
to a famous cave shrine in the Kashmir Himalayas, revered as a Tantric site. Inside the cave is a
large ice-formed stalagmite that's regarded by devotees as a Shiva Lingam, which is a symbolic
representation of the god's phallus. Santosh subsequently immersed himself in the philosophies
of Tantra. His work frequently evoked Tantric sexual rights as mirroring the union of Shiva
and Shakti. The painting that Lonnie described is influenced by images of Kali straddling Shiva,
suggesting her creative thoughts and his static consciousness, their interaction sustaining
the universe. As he put it himself, I was in search of an image as an artist, an image that
smacks of its soil, its tradition. Many other artists felt the same way. Before and after
Indian independence from British rule in 1947 and the emergence of India and Pakistan as independent
nation states, South Asian artists forged modern national styles rooted in the art of the past.
Several artists were inspired by the Delhi-based writer Ajit Mukherjee, who owned a vast collection
of Tantric sculptures and paintings. He emphasised their philosophical content and sought to reclaim
Tantra from its colonial era association with hedonism and black magic, and he published on this
throughout the 60s and 70s. This inspired the Neo-Tantra art movement and went on to have a
major impact on perceptions of Tantra. Santosh was one of the leading Neo-Tantra figures.
Sorry everyone, I lost you for a moment there, but I hope you can hear me now.
Okay, our final object is a contemporary sculpture and an image of it is on your screens at the
moment, and the sculpture is by Bharti Kher and it's called All the While the Benevolent Slep.
Kher creates sculptures made from casts of real women to produce dramatic urban goddesses.
This life-sized female figure is naked, crouching on top of a large wooden log.
The work is two meters high and was created in 2008 from fiberglass, copper and mahogany.
We are confronted with the self-decapitated goddess Chinnamasta with 14 copper wires
spurting from her neck like jets of blood. The body of the goddess is black fiberglass, slender,
muscular and small-chested. It's connected to the log by a short metal rod that attaches to
the figure from below. The thick shiny copper wires differ in length, some short, others long.
One arches from the figure's neck and touches the floor. The goddess holds a delicate teacup and
saucer in her right hand, a witty allusion to British civility. The white cup has a delicate
floral decoration and is lined on the inner rim with real teeth. In her left hand, she holds a
cast of the skull of Lucy, the oldest known human ancestor. The skull has an elongated jaw and two
rows of sharp teeth. Bharti describes the goddesses she's attracted to, including popular
images of Kali, as ones that are powerful and androgynous. Bhima, can you tell us a little bit
more about the impact of Tantra on her work and that of other female artists? Yes, contemporary
female artists like Bharti have been inspired by Tantric iconography and have also playfully
subverted it. Although many, if not most, Tantric traditions emphasize the role of women and
goddesses, their traditional representations have sometimes been described as male constructions
of femaleness. Certainly their often ambivalent characteristics, veering between overt eroticism
and destructive violence, can be read as reflecting a male fear of feminine power.
Nevertheless, this same ambivalence which challenged traditional models of womanhood
has been a source of empowerment for modern women who continue to reclaim their spiritual
authority in creative and emancipatory ways. Bharti's goddess sculptures are made from casts
of the bodies of friends and acquaintances whose naked, muscular, fleshy and dimpled features
are infused with a powerful gravity blurring the boundaries between mortal and divine.
The menacing, violently graphic but simultaneously playful nature of the figure that Lonnie
described is made all the more unsettling by the sculpture's uncanny realism and immediacy.
As an interesting aside, many women in the States and the UK during the 1960s and 70s,
which coincided with the rise of the second wave feminist movement, were drawn to Tantric
goddesses as powerful agents with the capacity to destroy and who are often portrayed in sexually
dominant positions from Kali to Chinnamasta, appearing to confront patriarchal constructions
of the ideal woman as passive and obedient. Well thank you Ima, I think we're going to pass over
now back to Fiona who's got some questions that people have been writing. Yes I do,
so we've got 10 minutes left to go and there's a few questions here from the audience so
I'm going to dive right in. I think this one might be for you Ima, it's a question from
Vishal who's asking if there's any more information about where Tantra emerged from,
from folk Hinduism, mainstream Hinduism or Shaivite and aesthetic communities outside of the Vedic
mainstream? Thank you for your question, that's a fantastic question. So the latter really,
what you described, that the third description, so Tantric practice probably began on the margins
of society we think. We're not absolutely certain about this due to the lack of textual evidence,
there is some archaeological evidence to suggest this, but we believe it probably began amongst
those who were on the margins and specifically among devotees of Shiva and Shakti. So I mentioned
when we were talking about the sculpture of Bhairav, I mentioned these early followers of
Bhairav who would imitate his appearance, this group, this community of ascetics were known as
Kathalikas which means skull bearers, they are amongst the earliest groups of Tantric
aesthetics that are described in textual sources. And then the political context of the origins of
Tantra is also interesting to note. So in the 6th century, many new kingdoms were vying for power
across South Asia after the breakdown of two major dynasties, including particularly the Gupta
dynasty. And these new rulers were attracted to Tantra in order to legitimate their power,
legitimize their power, and they built new temples across the subcontinent to ensure victories on
their battlefields and to ensure territorial expansion. So they would incorporate images of
Tantric deities into these temples for that reason. And then from about the 7th century
in India, Buddhism creatively adapted Hindu Tantric deities. One of the reasons for that
was to secure patronage from rulers, so there was actually an element of competition there.
And then Tantric Buddhism spreads across Asia by the 8th century, and instrumental in that
transmission were the Mahasiddhas that we talked about a bit earlier. So hopefully that answers
your question, but there is still so much to learn and discover actually about the early
origins of Tantra, and there are many scholars publishing great work in this area. Fantastic.
We've got another question, Emma, I think this might be another one for you, from Ross,
who asks what the significance of the third eye is and whether it's exclusive
to Tantra. Thank you for that question. So this is the third eye of wisdom, essentially.
You often see it, and this is not exclusive to Tantric iconography, you see it in
orthodox Hindu and Buddhist images of deities, and essentially that's what it
represents, it's the third eye of wisdom and enlightened perception. So when you see that,
when you see that in any images orthodox or Tantric, that's what it represents essentially,
in a nutshell. Great, okay, we're gonna try and squeeze in one last question, and that is,
it's anonymous, and the question's whether you've got any tips or whether there's any
reading suggestions around the political context connected with the emergence of Tantra.
Oh, great question. So I really recommend the work of Hugh Urban in this area, he's written
really brilliant books and articles on Tantra's links to revolutionary activity
during the colonial period and how Kali was harnessed as this symbol,
this anti-colonial insurgent symbol, during imperial rule in India. So I highly recommend
all of his books, Hugh Urban, he's written, I'm trying to remember some of the titles,
so he's written Power of Tantra, and one is called, you'll have to look him up actually,
there's a particular book that he wrote which is specifically looking at
the colonial period and highlighting Kali's role in particular, and I think it's called
something like Tantra and Revolution or something like this, but he's the go-to person for this
subject. Okay, I think we might try one last question and then I'm going to wrap up, but
we've got sort of five minutes left, so I think we can just squeeze in, Ross has got another
question which just says, if you're able to say something about how Tantra is recognisable and
distinct from Vedanta? Say this again? How Tantra is recognisable and distinct from Vedanta?
Oh okay, yeah, oh that is a rather big question. Sorry, that's the one to end on.
So, I mean I would definitely recommend, look, actually a fantastic book on this that explores
this is by Gavin Flood, just his book on Hinduism, that actually untangles some of the tensions
and distinctions between Vedanta and Tantra. I mean Vedanta is rooted in obviously Vedic
Hinduism, and Tantra in a way emerges as a reaction against Vedic Hinduism, which is
Hinduism or Brahmanical Hinduism. But you know Vedanta is also a philosophy that does have a
lot in common with Tantra, so there are actually some really interesting overlapping, often Tantra
is seen as a sort of singular religion, or sometimes it's seen as a kind of cult,
without overlap with some of the other Hindu philosophies. But there are actually a lot of
interesting strands in common with Vedanta, but equally the sort of transgressive nature of Tantra
makes it particularly distinctive from Vedanta and other sort of orthodox philosophies or strands
of Hinduism. So transgression is really the thing that is at the heart of Tantra,
whether that's playing with notions of purity versus impurity, for example. But I would recommend
reading, if you want to find out more about that, I would recommend reading
Gavin Flood's book on Hinduism, which is a good sort of introduction to some of those tensions.
Great, okay, so I think we're at the end of the time that we have with you now, so
just to say thank you to VocalEyes and to Lonnie Evans for fantastic audio descriptions,
and the stage text for providing our captions today that we had through the event,
and for Dr Emma Ramos for giving us all that background and information and all those
answers to your tricky questions at the end. So I'm sure if we were all here together we'd be
giving everyone a round of applause, so I'll just do a solitary round of applause, but thank you
everybody, and I hope you can join us at our next audio described event, which is on the 5th of
December, and that will be exploring the Arctic Exhibition, Arctic Climate and Culture. So do
give us your feedback, and also get in touch at accessatbritishmuseum.org if you want to
find out more about these events. So thank you all, and goodbye.