The Clarity Act died. Crypto is getting it one rule at a time.
In five days the SEC approved the first 3x leveraged Bitcoin and Ether products, the CFTC proposed a federal rulebook for leveraged retail crypto trading, and the Treasury withdrew two proposed rules that would have put reporting requirements on self-custody wallets and mixers.
Scott Melker called this the day the bill failed, and he walks through what each agency can and cannot do without Congress. He also covers Strive buying six times more Bitcoin than Strategy did, and why a 3x ETF is not what most buyers will think it is.
Timestamps 0:03 What was supposed to happen after Clarity failed 0:57 Strive quietly outbuys Strategy 3:24 Debt free is not obligation free 4:03 The SEC clears the first 3x Bitcoin products 5:48 Why a 3x ETF eats itself 6:56 The CFTC writes a rulebook with one commissioner 10:22 Treasury drops the wallet and mixer rules 12:14 More crypto firms file for bank charters 13:29 Tokenized pre-IPO exposure arrives
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Clarity Act failed. I told you that the regulators would likely step in with rulemaking
and that we would get most of what we wanted from the Clarity Act from the CFTC and the SEC.
Well, that is happening very quickly and in real time. We're going to talk about that and
everything else happening in the crypto news right now on The Daily Wolf. Let's go.
What is up, everybody? Welcome to The Daily Wolf on Yahoo Finance. I am your host, Scott Melker,
also known as the Wolf of all streets. Now, every single Monday, I tell you about what Michael
Saylor and Strategy do with their very complicated balance sheet. But yesterday, I was a bit remiss
when I did not tell you about their competitor, Strive, who's actually been quietly buying a lot
more Bitcoin than Strategy. Here was the story. It dropped right after the show yesterday.
Strive expands Bitcoin holdings with 2,000 Bitcoin purchase. So Strive purchased 2,000
Bitcoin for approximately $169 million, which is nearly six times Strategy's 334 Bitcoin
purchase that they announced yesterday. Now, Strive holds 29,462 Bitcoin, which is
within 6,000 Bitcoin or so of Marathon, which is the next largest holder of Bitcoin in the
treasury space. Marathon, of course, is a Bitcoin miner that is pivoted to becoming AI data centers,
so likely will be reducing their Bitcoin exposure while Strive increases theirs,
so they will likely catch up very quickly if you are keeping track.
This week, they paid an average of $84,422 per Bitcoin. Now, according to CEO Matt Cole,
who we've had on my shows many, many times, Seda, which is their STRC competitor,
the Seda preferred stock sales accounted for 61.5% of the capital raised and warrant exercises
generated another 56.7 million to buy all of this Bitcoin. So Strive now has approximately 1.29
billion of preferred stock in Seda, carrying around 168 million in annual dividend obligation.
So what's interesting here, once again, to reiterate is that Strategy started as a company
that simply found creative ways to take on debt using preferreds and convertible notes, etc.,
so that they could just raise capital and buy Bitcoin. Strive and their CEO Matt Cole had the
luxury of watching everything that Strategy did and avoiding a lot of the pitfalls that
Strategy fell into by naturally being first. Strategy did nothing wrong, to be very,
very clear. They tried a lot of things, and they finally found one that stuck with STRC.
Well, Strive was able to basically look at that playbook, say, we just wanna copy the STRC part
and none of the other parts and use that. And so Seda, for them, has been trading at or above par
for quite a while. They've been able to use issuance of that preferred to continue to buy
Bitcoin at a faster rate than Strategy. And they obviously continue to say that they will remain
debt-free. They don't have the convertible notes or any of the other drags that Strategy might have.
But it's important to remember that debt-free does not mean obligation-free. Preferred shared
holders still get paid before common shared holders, and they still have the obligations
to pay out that 12% plus dividend, which they do on a daily basis. I think it's very clear,
though, that with the publicly traded Bitcoin treasury companies, we've come to a world of
have and have-nots. We can really just watch Strive and Strategy. They seem to have largely
figured it out. The Bitcoin miners are tired of a world of their own. And then there's the
everybody else in the Bitcoin treasury space, all trying to figure out what to do next.
Of course, price is going up, will help their stock. But that doesn't mean that they actually
have a viable strategy moving forward. So public companies continue to manufacture,
leverage Bitcoin exposure. Wall Street has now decided regular Bitcoin
is simply not dangerous enough. What a segue. SEC approves a 3x fix for Bitcoin and Ether traders
who missed the wild swings. 1x leverage, 2x leverage, we're babies. We need to get up to
3x leverage. So like I said before, we didn't get the Clarity Act, but we're getting a lot
of rulemaking and decisions from the SEC and the CFDC. Of course, we've talked about
red crypto from the SEC, talked about the innovation exemption, and of course, OKEx and
ICE's move yesterday. Well, now in the ETF space, the SEC has approved 3x leverage.
So this is the CBOE's request to list the first U.S. products with three times Bitcoin and Ether
returns. Until now, U.S. crypto funds were capped at a low, low 2x leverage. This will be operated
by volatility shares that will use regulated Bitcoin and Ether futures, not actual Bitcoin
or Ethereum. To be clear, these are not trading yet. So they target three times a daily move,
not three times Bitcoin's long-term performance, which is really, really important.
Because with products like these, the leverage resets every day, which creates massive
volatility decay. There will definitely be people who buy these thinking that they're
buying an ETF that gives them 3x exposure to Bitcoin over the long term.
And then Bitcoin's gonna go up massively, and they're gonna wonder why they're broken,
their account is at zero, because that is not what these work. These are trading instruments,
and you almost wanna get into them in and out, basically, in a day.
Let me give you an easy example if you had 100 bucks. Let's say on day one,
there's a $100 investment. Day one, Bitcoin rises 10%, right? So the 3x ETF rises 30%,
your $100 becomes $130. On day two, Bitcoin falls 10%. So the ETF falls 30%, which means
it goes from $130 losing $39 and becoming $91. So meanwhile, Bitcoin itself, remember,
went from basically, let's say $100, and Bitcoin rose to $110. $110 falls 10%, goes to $99.
So Bitcoin finishes down 1%, while the 3x ETF finishes that same period down 9%,
just a matter of days. These are instruments you are going to want to be extremely,
extremely careful with, and that you'll need to absolutely rebalance on a daily basis.
A powerful short-term trading instrument, and an absolutely terrible long-term
Bitcoin investment thesis. And so we have the SEC here allowing leverage
through brokerage accounts, which is nothing new. They're just increasing the leverage.
But the CFTC now wants a federal framework for exchanges offering leverage directly. Here's
the story. CFTC proposes new federal framework for leverage retail crypto trading. The agency
floated a new crypto asset market, CAM, CAM Newton, CAM, exchange category, but said it can't
require crypto to trade on CFTC platforms without Congress. So this is where that push and pull of
the Clarity Act comes in. When the Clarity Act failed, the SEC moved immediately. The Friday
after, we saw that the CFTC and their commission of one, Mr. Mike Seelig, the commissioner,
who's the only CFTC commissioner right now, that he submitted some rulemaking proposals
to the White House, but we did not know what they are. Presumably, this is what they are.
And the CFTC now is developing these rules for leverage margin and finance retail
crypto transactions. This is where they know they are allowed to make rules,
and they're gonna do everything they can within the letter of the law to bring crypto exchanges
and other platforms into a compliant manner to make life easier for them.
Here, like I said, exchanges offering leverage products could register under a new federal
category called a crypto asset market. So here's what the proposed framework contemplates. Crypto
specific token listing standards, which we don't have, market surveillance and anti-manipulation
rules, proof of reserves for pooled customer assets, very, very important. In fact, Seelig
dropped a video on X that showed all of the FTX scandals and all the problems created by the lack
of rules. It was pretty scathing. Capital requirements, segregation of customer assets,
risk disclosures, KYC and anti-money laundering, which is AML controls.
So they're getting pretty deep here. Token reviews of what is allowed to be listed,
not to consider supply concentration, insider holdings, vesting schedules, programmatic issuance
and buyback. And the CFTC apparently is also considering clarifying that delivery
into a customer's external wallet within 28 days counts as actual delivery.
So now we are very clearly in the comment phase here. This is where we now,
they propose the idea, people are allowed to give comments and discuss it. But the main
point here is that most of these products are offered offshore. Americans either use VPNs or
an exchange that is not heavily regulated to participate in the activities. The CFTC is saying
they want to bring that all into a very obvious, very rule-based regime in the United States where
these exchanges can offer these products and the customers using them will know that they are
protected by the CFTC. We know that Congress could not finish this rule book. So the CFTC
basically grabbed a cocktail napkin and started taking notes.
Don't worry, we'll do this ourselves. That's what's happening here. So the SEC,
CFTC very much stepping in where Congress failed and doing everything that they possibly can.
And it's not just the SEC and the CFTC, Treasury making a huge move for the industry very quietly
here yesterday. So Treasury withdraws crypto mixing rule, citing concerns over chilling effect
on legitimate activity. So if you've been around for a while, you probably remember these.
To be clear, they were never actually put into law, but now the idea of them is being dropped.
But it's very, very important for your protections in crypto. There's a 2020 self-hosted
wallet rule and a 2023 crypto mixer reporting rule. So the wallet proposal would have required
banks and exchanges to verify identities and maintain records for self-hosted wallet transactions
above $3,000. That would have been literally impossible as everyone in the industry pointed
out. But every transaction above $10,000 would have been reported to FinCEN.
Even if you sent 10,000 to yourself or to a friend in crypto, somehow someone would be
responsibility for those to be reported to FinCEN even though it was in a self-custodied wallet with
no KYC and no AML. The implications of this went even deeper, of course, because crypto miners and
brokers and exchanges all move money around tons of transactions and very few of those are tracked
directly to an individual person. So as May pointed out, this is basically impossible to do
in the first place. The mixer proposal would have required reporting of wallet addresses,
transaction hashes, and potentially IP information. They basically would have forced people to
divulge all of their private transactions when mixers can be used for very, very legitimate
purposes. Some of the ordinary privacy practices that should be protected by the Constitution,
pooling funds, splitting transactions, and using fresh addresses.
So as it said there, FinCEN acknowledged that the proposal could shill legitimate activity
and have killed these rules entirely, and that is great news. So Washington, even without the
but the banking industry is still fighting over who gets access to the federal system.
Now, here's the story. RAINN files application with the OCC to establish RAINN National Trust
Bank. That doesn't seem like a big story unless you watched the show yesterday when I discussed
how community banks were suing the OCC over federal trust charters for crypto companies.
And now, too, RAINN and Modern Treasury have filed applications for those exact same charters
today. So now you have the banks suing the OCC and the industry and the OCC moving forward
with more filings and probably more approvals down the road. Again, the real fight here is
that the banks say that these are gonna operate like banks but are gonna be able to circumvent
all the rules. These FinTech companies are saying we're not taking on deposits,
so why do we need to operate under the rules of the FDIC insurance and deposits, right?
So this is the ongoing battle that continues to happen between both the banks and the government.
This will also go down to the states and the federal government. You can tell that there's
a lot of contention around almost everything right now in the crypto space. Now, I think that the OCC
is going to just continue to give these charters where appropriate. Very unlikely that the banks
or anyone else is going to stop this. But once again, it just really shows that push and pull.
And the last story that I have today, not really a huge one, but it's novel.
Ondo Finance launches Ondo Private Markets with tokenized pre-IPO AI exposure. We've
talked about the idea that everyone wants to offer everything to everyone 24-7, 365. Now,
you can get pre-IPO exposure in a number of ways, including on hyper liquid and leverage exchanges.
Obviously, none of those give you any underlying rights to the assets, but neither do these.
What Ondo here is offering is tokenized exposure to private companies beginning with an
unnamed pre-IPO AI business. Anthropic, chat GPT, hell, could be anything.
So investors receive tokenized notes linked to the company's economic performance,
not the actual company shares. So once again, no direct ownership, voting rights,
or normal shareholder protectants. This is basically a new wrapper for an existing product,
which is exposure to pre-IPO. The CFTC and the SEC and the Treasury all moving forward
sensibly because we could not get it done in Congress. We're going to see how that is all
affected by the midterm elections coming in 30 days. That's all we got for you today.
I'll be back tomorrow on the next Daily Wolf.