Binance got hacked, and Scott Melker says crypto now faces an existential crisis over custody. He has watched longtime self-custody believers give up and move their bitcoin into ETFs, and big holders are swapping coins into BlackRock's bitcoin fund. Melker explains why the hack is nothing like FTX and why no custody option is completely safe.
He also expects Elizabeth Warren to go after the Trump family's crypto ventures without stopping pro-crypto laws, breaks down Strategy's exclusion from MSCI indexes and explains why bitcoin dipped with tech after Jensen Huang's resignation.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The discussion explores the current state of cryptocurrency, focusing on the security risks of exchanges versus self-custody, the political landscape surrounding the Trump administration's crypto ventures, and the market impact of institutional shifts and leadership changes at NVIDIA.
The ending of that conversation,
they really lingered on the, you know, it wasn't even an
argument, I don't know, between Elon Musk and CZ,
but it kind of made me laugh at the end there.
And I just said to you, like, pay attention
to the two billionaires fighting, not to the huge
hack that happened on my platform.
I mean, you know, you are day in, day out in the crypto
industry. How problematic was that? It was problematic, but luckily it
happened to Binance. And I know that sounds
like a strange thing to say, but they were
They were very easily able to plug the hole.
CZ himself probably could have taken his ATM card out
and fixed it himself because he's probably worth $100 billion.
If it had happened to a smaller platform or had been a larger hack.
And they were not able to fill the hole
and people had actually lost money.
We would be having more of an FTX type conversation.
But CZ is very right to point out that this is nothing like FTX.
I mean, one was a fraud and one was a hack.
And those are not at all even in the same planet.
Absolutely.
But OK, so then I would ask you this.
If the thinking is like finance is one of the more solid ones
and it got hacked, there's
lots of them that are not necessarily,
that don't necessarily have the defenses and the
capital backing.
The Binance does. And it seems like that this is just sort
of a feature of our world now where you have AI enabled hacking.
So if if I'm a crypto investor,
like what do I need to how do I what do I do with that?
It's a very tough question. It's not unique to crypto.
Right. We know that this is coming for the banks.
We've already seen it in a bank in France. But right now there's
a bit of an existential crisis for custody in crypto.
Right. And I can even say anecdotally that I've spoken to people
who have been here since 2010 and were.
Not your keys, not your coins,
self-custody maximalists who have just said, forget it,
I'm moving over to the ETF, which
is like mind-blowing for someone with the sort of
original libertarian lean and, you know, opting out of the banks.
And so it really is a crazy
time. I think that Robbie Muchnick
at BlackRock just said yesterday that they'd seen $3.6 billion
in in-kind swaps of Bitcoin to their iBit ETF.
That's major size.
Those are large holders, whales
who have been here for a very long time.
So a lot of people really are giving up right now
on self-custody and exchange custody.
It's funny because CZ himself used to sort of mock.
Self-custody. He said, you know,
you're a greater point of failure as an individual if you fall
on your head or somebody hacks you than we are as an exchange.
And he actually, as strange as it is,
sort of proved it by being able to easily fill the hole.
But I don't really think that crypto investors right now can feel
100 percent secure in any of these different scenarios or solutions.
It's really challenging.
Well, even in something like an ETF or some of those other solutions?
I think they're fine in the ETF.
And I think that's the point.
But once again, if you're holding an ETF,
you still have counterparty risk to whoever's
holding that Bitcoin.
They could be hacked.
Their custody could have issues.
I think people just feel like you'd be insured
or you'd be covered if something like that
happens.
I think.
Most people who are holding any major size in crypto at this point
are diversified across multiple different custody solutions
so they can't be taken out entirely at one time.
It's scary, but like I said, it's coming
for every financial institution everywhere.
Yeah, but it hasn't happened as much in,
you know, mainstream financial institutions.
Of course, it's the tip of the spear.
Yeah, yeah, so we'll see what happens.
They didn't discuss something that's
been on my mind with regard to crypto,
and that's sort of scrutiny of the industry,
especially following the election.
As you're well aware, the administration,
the Trump family specifically,
has come under some scrutiny because of World Liberty Financial,
Because of its various crypto incentives,
Endeavors, I guess we could call them businesses, and, you know,
wouldn't be surprised to see the Democrats investigate some of that.
Do you expect that?
What is that going to look like?
And what effect could that have on the industry, maybe?
Frankly, you're being too kind.
The guy launched a meme coin three days before his inauguration.
I'm trying to be diplomatic, I guess.
And it was.
So unfortunately, you know, I think as with anything,
you get the good and you get the
bad.
And the Trump administration has been very crypto forward
with their selections of different
regulators, the CFTC chair, SEC chair,
very pro-crypto, a lot to be excited for there.
But of course, you know, the family has profited massively from it.
We saw it in the previous administration
when there were no checks and balances,
just how aggressively the administration
or the government could come after the crypto industry.
I think now it's going to be a mixed bag.
There will actually be checks and balances.
We know that Elizabeth Warren is going
to very aggressively come after the Trump family
as the chair of the Senate Banking Committee,
which blows my mind that she's kind of back.
And that level of power.
But I think it's just going to be a lot of talking
and subpoenas and problems, but very
little will get done.
At the end of the day, it still has to come
to President Trump's desk for a veto if there's
actual legislation, right?
Well, and like, is there a scenario where you could see
a lot of scrutiny of the family
and its dealings and still have pro-crypto legislation passed?
That's what I think is going to happen.
I think that it's become...
Too politically contentious to be outright anti-crypto
for most candidates, right?
They've seen how effective the crypto lobby is,
how much money they'll throw behind a
candidate who they like or against a candidate that they don't.
And also, I think that the people are not passionately anti-crypto.
I don't know if there's an anti-crypto voter.
What would that look like, right?
So it seems like there's no reason to be anti-crypto.
Maybe just Liz Warren?
I don't know.
Yeah, you know, and for curious reasons, right?
Since she's supposed to be anti-bank,
but clearly there's some angle of it there.
I just think that it's going to slowly move forward as it has.
I think that it's already sort of jumped the creek as far as adoption.
We're talking about the DTCC settling $4.5 quadrillion
in transactions on blockchains
by the end of next year.
Don't put that cat back in the bag.
Right, right, right.
So I don't think there's really a hunger
to legislate the industry away or to regulate
the industry away.
I think they just want to...
Get rid of the gratuitous grift that obviously has been a part
of the industry and some of that, obviously, from the top.
Yeah. OK. Couple more things I want to ask you about.
One of them is MicroStrategy, which is not going to be an MSCI indices,
which is something that had been.
I mean, was it priced into the stock?
Was it I mean, it seemed like it was sort
of expected that it wasn't going to happen.
I mean, last I checked, I think it was down a few percent.
I don't think it's.
Big issue for the stock, but I do think
that it's a signal to other indexes and it could
become more problematic if they're getting delisted across the board.
Very important note. This is not just a Bitcoin thing.
It's not just a strategy thing.
MetaPlanet, another Bitcoin treasury company,
was also going to be removed from MSCI. But you
also saw Yellow Cake, which is a uranium fund,
an agriculture fund in the UK. So it's not just
Bitcoin. They're really just taking a position on operating income
and what kind of business.
I think it's a bit disingenuous, if we're being honest.
I mean, what does Warren Buffett do? What
does Berkshire Hathaway do? It's a company that owns stocks.
They're a treasury company for
for stocks as a treasury company for
for Bitcoin or a treasury company.
So I think it might cause a $2.8 billion in selling.
I think JP Morgan sort of
That was their estimate,
but that's not even a day of volume on strategy stock.
It's one of the most highly traded, most liquid stocks on Wall Street.
So I don't think it's a problem, but it would
be nice to see them still included.
Finally, I got to ask you about the big story of the day,
which is Jensen Huang stepping down from NVIDIA.
And it doesn't seem like there's any sort
of direct impact for the cryptoverse,
except just that maybe we're seeing, you know,
highly volatile environment risk off today as a result of this,
at least to some degree.
And so is there a relationship between
that and what we see in terms of crypto?
I mean, Bitcoin's down a little bit today.
I think you really nailed it.
I think, you know, Bitcoin in the very short term
on a bad trading day definitely suffers
alongside everything else
when there's a risk off sentiment, when tech sells off.
But it tends to very quickly uncorrelate over the longer term
or over the next few days.
I think Bitcoin has been traveling largely in its own cycle.
There's no CEO to get caught in a scandal.
So I think that it's not going to be problematic in that way.
I think that the whole world is just reeling right now.
And honestly, to me, it's just a bigger signal
that one man's impropriety could have such
an effect on global markets and have everybody watching.
That makes me a bit more you know nervous
or anxious about what's going to happen with markets.
But I think Bitcoin is going to do what it's always done,
which is be exceptionally volatile,
but generally trend up and to the right over a cycle.
Scott, it's good to see you here.
Welcome, by the way, for the first time
to the Yahoo Finance studios.
Unbelievable.
This would have been you know my Daily Wolf slot normally on today,
and I've never been in the studio in New York.
It's unbelievable.
We're doing Daily Wolf from here.
It's great.
Amazing.
Thank you so much.
SCOTT GOLDBAUMER, CTO, Thanks so much.
Appreciate it.