When will we do more research on humans in low gravity? Which are scarier, space lasers or space nukes? Can we have space babies? And in Q&A+, which are the most interesting upcoming celestial events to see with the naked eye?
00:00 Intro 00:26 [@iancudmore9795] when do we get research on what low G does to our health as compared to micro gravity? 05:27 [@JacobBouchard] Could we use Buoyancy Tests to simulate low gravity? 07:28 [@604Nighthawk] and can humanity breed in low gravity? 08:28 [@alextruffle] Space nukes vs space lasers 12:06 [@kimbarron4239] Could you 'drop' a bomb from orbit? 14:09 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
When will we do more research on humans in low gravity?
Which are scarier, space lasers or space nukes?
Can we have space babies?
And in Q&A Plus, what's the most interesting upcoming celestial events
to see with the unaided
eye? All this and more in this question show.
It's time for the question show. Your questions,
my answers, as always, wherever you are across my channel.
If a question pops in your brain,
just write it down. I'll gather them up
and I will answer them here. All right,
All right, let's get into the questions.
In Q&A more, when do we get research
on what low gravity does to our health as compared to
microgravity?
When we have the ability to have sustained low gravity.
So, you know,
If you go to the International Space Station
and you're in orbit around the Earth, you are
essentially in weightlessness.
You're not experiencing any gravity. Now, you are experiencing
gravity. You're experiencing 90% of the gravity
that you would experience down on the surface
of the Earth, but you also happen to be traveling sideways at
28,000 kilometers per hour, and so you experience this
weightlessness. You're falling constantly, and you just never
hit the ground. But for us to be able to experience
Low gravity.
Then either you got to go to the moon, which means we need
to have a base on the moon, which, you know, we're going to have,
you know, NASA is going to return to the moon by 2028,
the Chinese are going to get to the moon by 2030.
The Chinese will probably build a long term habitat on the moon during
the 2030s. I'd say into the 2030s, we will have people
who are doing long stays on the moon. And so that's when we'll start
to learn about what low gravity does to the human body.
Then the next place would be Mars.
And, you know, probably maybe in the 2040s,
we will have some kind of base on Mars.
Depends on whether or not SpaceX actually decides
to send rockets to Mars,
because that's the plan, right?
Wasn't that the plan?
That the whole purpose of SpaceX
was to send rockets to Mars
to begin the colonization of Mars
and not just to make an enormous amount of money?
Wasn't it?
Anyway.
So then if in the 2040s,
then we see some kind of scientific base on Mars,
then we will know what being in one third
or 35% Earth gravity does to the human body.
So we've got one sixth on the moon and one third on Mars.
The other option is they have to build some kind of centrifuge,
some kind of spinning space station
where you can create artificial gravity.
And that has just not been done yet.
You know, there was a test during
the Gemini program where they tried spinning
a spacecraft, two spacecraft,
and we're able to generate like a tiny amount of gravity
between these spacecraft, but nothing seriously has been,
has been done. And it's just incredibly
expensive, a lot of moving parts
and the scientific payoff has just not been there.
So I think we have all of these, these unknown questions.
Like the biggest question that we
don't know the answer to is can a human being survive
in one third gravity? Like, can you go
to Mars and be there, you know, like the whole idea
of a city on Mars is dependent on the possibility of
whether or not human beings can live in one third gravity.
Like what if we can't? What if, what if
you are on Mars in one third gravity and within three,
five years you die,
there's no solution to this problem, right? You can't live on Mars.
That we can't produce artificial gravity on the surface of Mars.
Now, people are going to be like,
what about some kind of gravity train?
Yes, you could build some giant rotating cyclotron
that people sit on,
a gravitron that people spend their days on,
which is slightly angled and mimics full Earth gravity
because this thing is just going around.
And we're like, really?
That's a lot of work to just live on a worthless rock.
What about the moon, right?
One-sixth gravity, is that going to work?
Or maybe that's just lethal
to the human body over a certain amount of time.
So people will go to the moon,
they're only allowed to go there for six months,
and then they have to come back.
It's kind of like being in the death zone on Mount Everest.
That's a real possibility.
We don't know.
What happens to the human body in gestation, right?
If you try to gestate a fetus?
To term on Mars or on the moon, which people are going to totally do.
Is it just, you know, is it a stillbirth every time?
Um,
So these are the scientific questions
that we don't have the answers to.
And a lot of people are like, yeah, I don't care.
I just want a city on Mars.
Like, really?
Maybe there's some science that needs to be done, some research,
some very careful research that needs to be done before then.
So we can find out if this place is even safe
before you have the incredibly difficult
engineering challenge of building
some kind of civilization on Mars
where there is no financial incentive to do so.
We've got to find out if it's even healthy
for the human body.
So what were we talking about?
Oh, right, microgravity.
I believe I got the answer there.
Jacob Bouchard, could we use buoyancy tests
to simulate low gravity?
No, unfortunately, you can simulate
Like you can simulate various methods
of low gravity on the human body by bed rest.
And this is a thing that space agencies do.
The International Space Agency is always looking
for volunteers for bed rest studies.
So they'll put you in bed for a month.
And then measure, they take blood tests
and sort of see what happens to your muscle mass and
strength, your bones, like it's kind of invasive,
but you know, you get to lay in bed for a month
watching TV, I guess. So that does some mimicking
of what it's like to be in weightlessness. But
even if you're, say, floating in a pond,
you know, for a month, you're floating in a tank
water for a month.
You're still experiencing gravity on your internal organs.
So it's not true weightlessness.
You can test weightlessness on parabolic flight for one minute
at a time while you fly on this sort of parabolic trajectory.
But of course, the best way is to go
to the International Space Station.
So, yeah, there's like so many experiments that need to be done.
For us to understand the impact of long-term spaceflight,
spaceflight from being away from the magnetosphere of the Earth
and being at different levels of gravity that need to be done.
They just have not been done.
And so anyone who is telling you what the future of humanity
and space is going to look like
should really want to wait or to get those experiments done.
It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above.
Scott Nixon, Glenn Samuel, Fultz, Trailberg.
Joe Mansfield, Jerry Drozd, Dave, Brad Bryant,
Wade Lee, Edward Kramer, and Ben Calo.
Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Nighthawk, can humanity breathe in low gravity?
We don't know.
We have no idea.
Nobody knows.
Like, the people speculate that it could be possible
and give plenty of reasons why it
would not be possible.
And there's been like,
like in zero gravity, there have been some.
experiments, but they're bad experiments.
Well, they're not bad experiments, but they are not
the right kind of experiments.
There have been some science experiments where researchers have
sent mice to space and then had the mice come back to earth
and they get pregnant and the
pregnancies were fine.
I don't even know if they've had the mice go through a full cycle.
I don't think so. So just nobody knows. We just don't know.
Could be fine, could be a death sentence, we don't know.
Alex Truffle, people fear nukes in space,
I saw you debunk that, but what about space lasers?
I always thought that the first to have
a fully functional space laser will win everything.
Not condoning weapons in space, of course.
So, I don't know if I debunked nukes in space.
Nukes in space are a terrible idea.
Something to be extremely afraid of if it ever happens.
But there is the Outer Space Treaty, which has been signed
by pretty much all of the spacefaring nations, that they will
never put nuclear weapons into some kind of orbiting facility.
Because, you know, like obviously if you have
a nuclear weapon that is orbiting above your enemies.
Then you can drop this nuclear weapon on them in a minute,
you know, a couple of minutes.
Well, right now, you know,
if you want to create mutually assured destruction, you have
to fire your intercontinental ballistic missiles
from halfway across the planet.
It's going to take you, whatever,
45 minutes for you to bring on Armageddon.
And anybody who launches their missiles,
then their enemy is going to launch their missiles
and then everybody's going to be dead.
And so there's no point to launch your missiles.
But if you could have your nuclear weapons
on orbital platforms,
as their orbital platform flies above your enemy,
you just quickly drop your nuke on them
and no can defend.
So what about space lasers?
Yeah, so space lasers are a terrible idea
for a similar reason,
but they are useful,
which is that
As we get more and more space junk in orbit around the Earth,
a laser in space is the
best tool to be able to clean this kind of stuff up.
You have this laser that's tracking space debris,
it fires, it vaporizes a little bit
of debris off of the...
chunk of metal or plastic
or whatever it is and this creates a little thrust and so you could
then de-orbit a ton of junk with a single laser just fires
at a target, fires at a target, fires a
target, you're slowly decreasing the orbits of all
of these things that you're seeing and you're
cleaning up space and so there's a lot
of really good reasons why you'd want to put these really
powerful lasers in space
or as we talked about sending a spacecraft to another star system.
But you could absolutely turn this laser down
and face the earth and then cause damage.
Now, I don't think you're going to win everything
because militaries of the world have been
trying to make lasers work as a weapon,
you know, something you put on a battleship.
or something you would put on an airplane.
And you can, you know, blind people and that has been
considered a violation of the Geneva Convention,
you know, people have banned blinding weapons
from lasers. But you know,
to actually have a laser weapon that causes damage to infrastructure
is, has not been cracked. You know,
firing a laser from 20 kilometers away to blow up your enemy. So
Having a space-based laser isn't necessarily going to do that as well.
Now, you could blind people on the surface of the Earth.
You could cause mayhem, but you're not going to win everything.
And then one missile fired
from an airplane will blow up your space laser.
So I think.
You know, this is the kind of thing that it has both military
and genuinely useful civilian
applications. So this is the kind of thing
that people are going to have to come up with some
kind of agreement, arrangement,
put in safeguards to make sure this thing is used safely for
removing space debris and not blinding aircraft pilots,
you know, during a conflict.
Okay, Marin, could you drop a bomb from orbit?
I think it would take time for the orbit to decay.
Yeah, you wouldn't drop the bomb from orbit.
You would have a,
your nuclear weapon would be on a rocket and the platform would be in
orbit around the earth and your rocket would fire
and essentially cancel out its orbital
momentum and you would be, but you'd be firing down towards the target.
And so you would just come out of the sky at rocket speeds.
And detonate in the air above your target.
And again, you don't have to get to the surface.
You want to airburst.
You want to detonate in the atmosphere,
tens of kilometers up in some cases.
So yeah, these would be devastatingly effective.
And this is why the Outer Space Treaty was signed.
It was just like everybody could see.
This is where it was going to go.
This was the inevitable path that this was going to take,
was that people would put a nuclear weapon on a rocket,
put it on an orbiting platform,
wait until you're flying above your enemy, and then you just launch
your nuclear weapons at them with a couple of minutes notice.
Did you know that you can watch the same video
with no ads and get a bonus question
over on Patreon, completely for free?
We call it Q&A Plus. This week's bonus question,
which are the most interesting upcoming celestial events to see
with the naked eye? I'll put a link in the show notes.
Alright, those were all the questions we had this episode.
Thank you everyone who asked your questions into the
YouTube comments, everybody who joined me for the live show,
everybody who asked your questions on Patreon.
I am going to talk
about a sort of feature series
that we're running right now, but
first, I'd like to thank our patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Bejardy, Bolda Zarg,
All Your Bases Belong to Us, Brian Bode, Kerwin,
Chuck Hawkins, Benedict Bailock, Davy Gilton,
David Matz, Evan.Pro, James Clark, Jeremy
Madden, Jim Burke, Marcel, Samitza, Michael Purcell,
NasaOceanGuy, NordSpace,
Onestepforanimals.org,
Mankaidu, Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Team49,
Tales of Canada, Vlad Sheplin, Wolfgang Klotz, and Zelda,
all your silence is fooling no one.
Who support us at the Master of the Universe level and all our patrons.
All your support means the universe to us.
So we've been running a new series here on our channel,
and that is that we are highlighting
what we think are the best interviews
that we have done in recent history.
Of course, I talk about this all the time.
The interviews are my favorite part of the channel.
This is the thing that I, you know,
this is my chance to fulfill my curiosity about the
topics, but really it's a way for me to be able
to boil down the kind of zeitgeist, the
questions that you're asking me, and then find an expert.
And then ask them your questions and then my questions.
And then we get like a bunch of answers
and it's coming directly from the horse's mouth
and not from me trying to interpret it.
And it's just, it's the best.
And these are the people right at the cutting edge,
people who are leading the missions,
leading the experiments.
Designing the new telescopes and we get to hear from them directly.
And so we're running a series here on our channel.
If you go to the post tab every day,
we are highlighting a different interview
that we think is the best of the best of the best
and you can go and follow along.
And so if you're wondering like, man,
you know, I know Fraser keeps talking about
the interviews, but, you know, watch some
and sometimes they're hit or miss.
Well, these are the best.
So go into the post tab and check that out.
I'll put a link down in the show notes.
All right, we'll see you next time.