Sir Geoffrey Nice KC_Dec 10, 2025

DAFOH
609 followers
116 Video Views·Dec 12, 2025
Sir Geoffrey Nice, KC, is one of the U.K.’s most distinguished human rights lawyers. He is a professor of law and advisor on many human rights committees. He was knighted in 2007 for services to International Criminal Justice. In 1998, he was recruited to the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia and prosecuted a number of cases relating to genocide. In November 2001, he undertook the prosecution of Slobodan Milošević until the end of that trial in 2006. Sir Nice chaired the China Tribunal from 2017 to 2019 into the forced organ harvesting of prisoners of conscience, primarily Falun Gong practitioners, and the Uyghur Tribunal from 2020 to 2022 into the persecution of Uyghurs where one form of Genocide was found proved.
Thank you for inviting me to contribute to this significant gathering.
My name is Geoffrey Nice and my involvement in affairs concerning the Falun Gong
is that I chair the tribunal, China tribunal, the judgment of which was delivered five years ago.
And in that judgment no finding of genocide was made. There were findings of crimes against
humanity and torture. I've been asked today to focus on genocide in a more theoretical way
and I assume that some in the audience will know very little of the detail of the law
concerning genocide and some will know a great deal. It's probably therefore sensible for me
to summarize the position and then to say what I want to add that's particular to the problems
of the Falun Gong. The term genocide arose effectively because of the failure of the
United States of America in the First World War to respond to known massacre of the Armenians by
the Turks. Efforts to get the Americans to take action in another country to stop the massacre,
800,000 to a million people, came to nothing. And after the First World War an Armenian activist
called Sogutman Kalyan found the principal generator of the massacre from the previous
regime in Turkey, now living in Berlin, having been convicted in his absence of crimes by the
new regime in Turkey, but Germany having no extradition treaty with Turkey, so Pasha Talap
lived in Germany in Berlin and a young or fairly young Armenian activist Sogutman Kalyan
found him shot in dead, was tried and acquitted. The trial was the subject of newspaper reports
around the world, including Tel Aviv, then in Poland, where a young philologist
by the name of Raphael Lemkin was appalled at how this was the only method of achieving justice,
where injustice of the worst possible kind had been the subject of no action by the United States
of America, largely because of their implacable belief in sovereignty. And Lemkin went on to
become, he gave up being a philologist and became a lawyer and became obsessed by the problem that
worried him, escaped to America in the Second World War, he being Jewish, and all his family
being massacred in the Holocaust, returned to the Nuremberg trials and worried the prosecutors with
his new term that he'd written about in a book in 1944, I think, the term was genocide.
Different from the present formulation of the term, but that's how the term came to be used by
all of you watching this presentation and attending to the meeting of which it will be a part.
The term was not converted into a law at Nuremberg trials of Nazi leaders,
but Lemkin went to New York for reasons that we can go into perhaps in the discussion
and led to the Genocide Convention being formed. The Genocide Convention is very particular in
what it requires to be proved for genocide to be proved. And what it requires is a particular
intention in the mind of the perpetrator. The intention is the intention to destroy in whole or
part a group, and the Falun Gong are clearly a suitable group for this purpose, to destroy
a group in whole or part simply because of whom they are. And that is the wickedness
of genocide. Genocide does not require the proof of killing people in large numbers.
It can be established in other ways that result in no actual deaths. It's the mental state
that is critically important. And in the China Tribunal where we'd been commissioned,
I and six other people, having no interest in the Falun Gong, no interest in China,
just as citizens of the world, to look into the facts and the law.
We, though some of us may have had legal training, forgot that. We treated ourselves as citizens and
jurors, if you like, to decide what facts were proved and what the law was. We found all the
facts necessary for proof of genocide to have been established. But we took advice on the law
from outside. We allowed ourselves to be directed by highly authoritative lawyers on what the law
was. And what was made clear to us was this, the widespread killing of Falun Gong for the purpose
of extracting their organs for sale on the commercial transplant market was in part,
or maybe in principle, a commercial purpose to use their organs to make money.
Now, there may have been an associated genocidal intention to destroy the group as such.
But we noticed also that some Falun Gong who'd been arrested and detained were released
rather than killed. And so we found that we were unable in the circumstances and on the evidence
then available to be satisfied that the intention was the genocidal intention
rather than in principle the commercial one. It's of no concern to us, and I don't mean that
to sound harsh, it's of no concern to us that this may have been a disappointment
because we were not there either to satisfy or to disappoint people reading our judgment.
What we were concerned to do and did was to create a judgment that could not be attacked
and it has not been attacked or deconstructed. It stands unchallenged, of course,
People's Republic of China damns it but without explanation. Other than that, it is unchallenged.
It is a platform from which others can work. Later evidence can be added. Further conclusions
can be drawn. The law can be expanded. All things we should not do simply as citizens
applying the law on genocide to the facts as we found it. And so that is where I will start in the
discussions on Wednesday, and I look forward to being a part of those discussions. Thank you.
