Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, House of Lords, United Kingdom_Dec 10, 2021

DAFOH
609 followers
9 Video Views·Oct 2, 2026
DAFOH Webinar - Humankind at a Crossroads: Universal Human Rights versus Commercialized Forced Organ Harvesting from Living People
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis presentation addresses the crisis of forced organ harvesting in China, framing it as a severe violation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The speaker advocates for legislative changes in the UK to prevent citizens from participating in \"organ tourism\" and to stop the exhibition of plastinated bodies sourced from prisoners of conscience, ensuring the UK does not remain complicit in these crimes.
Hello. On the 10th of December 1948, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
was proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris. The first time it set out
fundamental human rights to be universally protected. Notably, this happened after the
devastation of the Second World War and Hitler's murderous regime, when the international community
vowed never to allow atrocities like those of that conflict to happen again. As we commemorate
the 10th of December, 70 years on, severe human rights abuses are still happening in our world.
Arguably, the worst of those abuses is still taking place in China today. My interest in
issue of forced organ harvesting in China came about after I was a sponsor of the Opt-out Organ
Donation Act, which is now in UK legislation. I took the view that in our opt-out system,
if we are asked by the public to have full confidence in it, it was essential that its
ethical basis was assured and overseen with rigorous inspection and regulation. When I first
heard about forced organ harvesting in China, forcibly extracting organs from prisoners of
conscience, I was horrified. Organ donation is a precious act of saving a life, but forced organ
harvesting is commercialised murder, and without doubt among the worst of crimes. Article 3,
subsection 2 of the Universal Declaration on Combating and Preventing Forced Organ Harvesting,
states that killing of vulnerable prisoners for the purpose of harvesting and selling their organs
for transplant is an egregious and intolerable violation of the fundamental right to life.
My Organ Tourism and Calibers on Display Bill, which had its second reading on the 16th of July
this year in the House of Lords, serves to prevent UK citizens from complicity in forced organ
harvesting by amending the Human Tissue Act to ensure that UK citizens cannot travel to countries
such as China for organ transplantation, and to put a stop to the dreadful travelling circus of
body exhibitions which sources deceased bodies from China. I come from Birmingham, where in 2018
an exhibition called Real Bodies by Imagine Exhibitions visited the National Exhibition
Centre. It consisted of real corpses and body parts that had gone through a process of
plastinisation, whereby silicone plastic is injected into the body's tissue to create real
life mannequins or plastinated bodies. The exhibit advertised that it uses real human specimens
that have been respectfully preserved to explore the complex inner workings of the human form
in a refreshing and thought-provoking style. Dig deeper, however, and it becomes clear that those
deceased human bodies and body parts are unclaimed bodies with no identity documents or consent.
Sourced from Dalian Hoffmann Biotech in Dalian, China, notably Dalian Labour Camp from 1999 to 2013
was notoriously known for its severe torturing of Falun Gong practitioners. The commercial exploitation
of body parts in all its forms is surely unethical and unsavoury. When it's combined with mass killing
by an authoritarian state, we cannot stand by and do nothing. In 2019, the China Tribunal,
led by Sir Geoffrey Nice QC, stated this. The Tribunal's members are certain, unanimously,
and sure beyond reasonable doubt, that in China, forced organ harvesting from prisoners of conscience
has been practiced for a substantial period of time, involving a very substantial number of
victims. Falun Gong practitioners have been one and probably the main source of organ supply.
In regard to the Uyghurs, the Tribunal had evidence of medical testing on a scale that
could allow them, amongst other uses, to become an organ bank. China has always denied the claims,
brushing them off as rumours, and the WHO has continuously backed this up. The UK Foreign
and Commonwealth and Development Office has stated that the WHO shares its view
that China was implementing an ethical voluntary organ transplant system in accordance with
international standards, although it has concerns about overall transparency. However, it was revealed
by the UK government in 2019 that the WHO's assessment is based on China's own self-assessment.
The WHO has not carried out its own assessment of China's organ transplant system. It does not have an
independent expert compliance assessment mechanism in place to carry it out. Over the years, evidence
of forced organ harvesting has continued to build and whistleblowers have stepped forward.
The body of evidence is becoming vast, including detailed statistical analysis of transplantations
and donations, numerous recorded undercover telephone conversations, legal and policy statements,
and the practice of government and the party, advertisements, admissions of university and
personnel, and a large number of very brave personal testimonies. Most recently, further
evidence was heard during the course of the Uyghur typhoon, including Saragol Sarpeh,
who testified during the June hearings that she discovered medical files detailing Uyghur detainees,
blood types, and results of liver tests while she was working at a Uyghur camp.
Ethan Gutmann, senior research fellow at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation,
spoke about his recent reports on the forced organ harvesting from Uyghurs
and other ethnic minorities in Xinjiang, including his witness interviews, human organ fast lanes in
the Anke and Kashgar airports, and the construction of vast crematoriums throughout the region.
In June this year, 12 UN special procedure experts raised the issue of forced organ harvesting with
the Chinese government in response to credible information that Falun Gong practitioners,
the Uyghurs, Tibetans, Muslims, and Christians are being killed for their organs in China.
I've always believed that the UK government could be a powerful advocate for changing these
practices, but also that we should put our own house in order and deal with current gaps in our
own human tissue legislation. Currently, human tissue legislation covers organ transplantation
within the UK, but does not cover British citizens travelling abroad for transplants,
and British taxpayers' money will pay for anti-rejection medication regardless of where
the organ was sourced or whether it was forcibly harvested from prisoners of conscience. According
to NHS Blood and Transplant, between 2010 and July 2020, there were 29 cases on the UK
transplant registry of patients being followed up in the UK after receiving a transplant in China.
Now, our Human Tissue Act of 2004 has strict consent and documentation requirements
for human tissue sourced within the UK, but it does not restrict imported human tissue in this way.
It merely is advisory, and so my bill aims to amend the Human Tissue Act in five ways.
First, it will prohibit a UK citizen from travelling outside the UK and receiving any
controlled material for the purpose of organ transplantation when the organ donor or the organ
donors next of kin had not provided free informed and special consent. Second, it would prohibit a
UK citizen from travelling outside the UK and receiving any controlled material for the purpose
of organ transplantation when a living donor or third party receives a financial gain or
comparable advantage or if from a deceased donor a third party receives financial gain or comparable
advantage. Third, it will provide for the offences in section 32 of the Human Tissue Act 2004
to be prohibited even if the offence did not take place in the UK if the person had a close
connection to that country. Fourthly, it will provide for regulations for patient identifiable
records and an annual report on instances of UK citizens receiving transport procedures outside
the UK by NHS blood and transplant. Lastly, it will provide for imported bodies on display
to have the same consent requirements as those sourced from the UK. Article 4 of the
Universal Declaration on Combating and Preventing Forced Organ Harvesting says this. All governments
should combat and prevent forced organ harvesting by providing for the criminalisation of certain
acts and facilitate the criminal prosecution of forced organ harvesting both at the national
and international level. I think we must take action and in my country, in the UK,
in order to do all we can to prevent these most abhorrent of practices. My Bill, I hope,
will take us a little way forward and I'm so pleased to be able to explain this to you.
Thank you.
