In this clip, Lewis Howes & Macken Murphy discuss the profound impact of infidelity, particularly focusing on PTSD-like symptoms experienced by those who have been cheated on. Our guest explores how past betrayal can manifest in future relationships through behaviors like reassurance seeking and chronic anxiety. We delve into the concept of "post-infidelity stress disorder" and its implications, and debate whether it's riskier to date someone who has cheated or someone who has been cheated on. The conversation also touches on the psychological attraction to narcissistic traits and the importance of healing personal wounds to make healthier relationship choices.
what about if someone has been cheated
on in a previous
relationship what should you look out
for in dating someone who has been
cheated on by someone else well that's a
really good question gosh you're really
you're really nailing these questions
trying to set you up for the success of
the rest of the interviews you'll do
with the hardest questions up front yeah
no I think these are excellent and uh
and is there any research on that or how
to approach how to approach a potential
partner where in the first few days they
say you know what I've been cheated on a
lot in my past and it's a big concern of
mine and I have a lot of worries you're
not going to cheat you're not going to
do this you know or someone who's had
that type of trauma yeah how should you
approach entering a relationship with
someone's been cheated on well you're
already signaling it's it's very
perspicacious of you to notice that in
your imitation you're performing
reassurance seeking which is a behavior
that's very commonly exhibited by people
who have been cheated on right so you
know you go through your r this is like
a typical kind of romantic career
everything you know you're you're dating
someone in high school dating some
people in college da d d and then you're
you're never even thinking of the
possibility that you could get cheated
on and then you you know see a text pop
up on your partner's phone and it's like
oh my go and then you find out whatever
D D and that's a traumatic event for
many people I mean it's a betrayal Well
it Well I'll even go so far as to say
traumatic just because it's certainly a
betrayal but to take it to kind of into
the psychological space PTSD is
generally term only assigns to physical
threats and it's kind of unclear whether
you can really categorize infidelity
that way but the symptoms of PTSD are so
common right such as reassurance seeking
ruminating Etc are so common among
people who have been cheated on that
some psychologists have coined the term
and used the term P SD right post
infidelity stress disorder wow right my
advice here would be to proceed with
caution and understanding and Goodwill
that you're dealing with someone if you
don't know what that's like you're
dealing with someone who is dealing with
something quite um quite severe and this
is another thing that I just want to
know I mean I see I mean you might be
mercifully tucked away from this corner
of the internet but there's a whole
corner of the internet right now that's
like men cheating is fine women cheating
is not and it's like we we've we've done
the research on this and women who get
cheated on are often severely
traumatized right like about half of
women who and in some studies more than
half of women who are paired with men
who are Unfaithful exhibit these
symptoms right so to say just callously
like oh it's different you know some
nonsense about you know a key that opens
many locks versus you know some some
stupid platitude and it's like what a
what a careless thing to say about the
uh about the feelings of the women that
you're with and you know I just wonder
like do these men even have mothers the
way they the way they speak about these
things wow wow I'm curious what is what
we should be more cautious of getting
into a relationship with someone who
cheated
before or getting into a relationship
with someone who's been cheated
on well I would be more cautious about I
would be more cautious about the worried
about but it depends what your concerns
are if you're worried about being with
someone who's
completely like if someone who's got PD
and they're struggling with that and and
they can never trust the person they're
with and they're always stressed and
anxious and they're always ruminating
and reassurance and where are you and
yeah that's not attractive after a while
no it's a isue it's a huge you might
feel exhausted and you be like I don't
want to be this person yeah if they
can't trust me if they're always
checking where I'm at if they're always
calling me saying FaceTime me where are
you who are you with who is that person
that's not a a sex quality in a mating
partner and so is that a bigger red flag
if someone who hasn't dealt with I'm not
saying it's okay what they went through
yeah but if they haven't processed and
and started to heal that is that more of
a red flag versus someone who you know
in their previous relationship cheated
on their
partner you've made such good points
here and some research on this yeah well
it cuz my gut reaction was obviously I
don't want I'm thinking yeah I'm like oh
I don't want to be cheated on so I'm
going to go with that but you've brought
up a good
point I don't even know if I should
share this but there
okay in I believe it was in the same
study that I'm referencing um about you
know once a cheater always a cheater
that kind of thing and there's also
indicative evidence and you know it's
just one study so let's not
yes let's not go to the bank on it
you're really you want to look for you
know cumulative bodies of research when
you're assessing a finding but there's
indicative evidence that people who have
been cheated on in the past are more
likely to be cheated on in their next
relationship yeah that's crazy now
that's a disturbing finding and you
might think well that doesn't make any
sense right how could how could that
affect my probabilities and I'll give
you a couple examples that could be not
saying that this has been studied enough
to make conclusions but
if you're the sort of person who
is attracted
to narcissism let's say plenty of people
find narcissism quite sexy good luck
right yeah it's but narcissism is
associated with infidelity letting
people find sexual narcissism sexy right
so that's someone who believes that
they're the best lover ever and is you
know totally confident and bad that also
predicts infidelity right and so you're
attracted to a trait and that makes you
that predicts your partner selection and
then the types of partners that you're
attracted to you you happen to be cursed
by being attracted to co-variates of
infidelity you got a bad picker you're a
bad picker another thing would be just
physical attractiveness if you really
prioritize that people are more
physically attractive tend to have more
options tend to be more interested in in
suitors Etc tend to be less satisfied in
relationships so if you're really
interested if you're really prioritizing
like oh I just want to date the hottest
girl possible it's like maybe that's why
you keep getting cheated on is because
you're not think thinking about deeper
qualities and then so not to victim
blame but it could be picking and then
it I hate even saying this but it could
possibly be what you're talking about I
know of an anecdotal case where I know I
know a woman who told me she was like my
boyfriend was accusing me of cheating so
much that I actually just did it like
she was being falsely accused so much
that it was like I'm going to be yeah
it's like I'm the believe I'm the I'm
the bad guy regardless of what I do so
what's the point in being good you know
so so I'm not saying that that's what
causes it but I'm saying that there's a
some people hear that they hear oh if I
was cheated on my last relationship I'm
more likely to be chea in my next
relationship and they just think what
that couldn't be true and it's like well
there's actually several ways that it
could be true and we just talk about too
gosh this is so fascinating you know I
really think
about when we choose out of a wound you
know you're talking about you're
attracted to narcissism maybe there was
something your parent one of your
parents had this trait and it was
attractive to you or just maybe it was
unattractive but you're trying to fix
that parent or whatever it might be but
when we when we are attracted based on a
wound a psychological
wound it typically ends up having more
challenges and problems we need to
overcome in that relationship because
we're trying to fix someone we're trying
to we're attracted them and then we want
to change them as opposed to being
attracted and saying I accept you for
who you are obviously we're going to
grow and evolve but I accept the
personality the values the qualities
that you have and I think if we haven't
healed something with in us we're going
to keep
attracting that thing that chemically
sexually stimulates us and makes us feel
something but then we're going to also
be afraid of it or we're going to be
needing reassurance on something so
we're attracted but you're not going to
hurt me are you as opposed to oh I see
you for the whole person that you are
I've asked all the
questions I'm allowing my gut to also
have intuition and be like is he being
honest and is is she following through
on what she's saying and you know is
there
congruency then you're able to choose
based
on the whole person versus oh I'm just
getting this chemical Feeling by what I
see or what I'm attracted to what's your
thoughts on that I think you put it
quite well and I don't I don't have much
to add yeah I I I would also note that
with my specific
example narcissism is interesting
because there are very good reasons to
so narcissism pretty consistently has a
small effect predicting attractiveness
in general really what do you mean by
that meaning that if someone's super
cocky versus someone who's average
Cockiness or insecure right the cocky
person generally has a slight
competitive advantage in like a speed
dating setting more options I think it's
more yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
yeah yeah yeah so and you can talk about
why that is and one of it is just that
who doesn't want to be around someone
confident right and also it gives you
this veneer
of being able to take care of yourself
and others I think that some people I
think that I think that to be honest
it's like I'm I'm not saying that I'm
that I prefer that I don't but I do
understand that a trait that is in some
ways negative
narcissism in many ways negative
actually I'll be
frank in certain environments and maybe
such as a speed dating study you sit
down with someone they sit down at the
table they're full of confidence they're
relaxed they want to chat with you they
want to flirt with you and they're you
know taking all your compliments in
their stride that's a lot of fun to be
around and so it might not be that that
person is wounded and choosing you know
sexual narcissists let's say but they
haven't spent enough time with them yet
spend time with someone get to know them
before you and maybe yeah I would say
that my so so this podcast is very big
on you know helping people add value to
their lives improve and and I'm not
really much of an adviced person but I
will say one piece of advice that if you
find yourself getting cheated on over
and over and over again right if you're
if you're listening to
this it would be worth taking a step
back and saying look it's not my fault
that this happened but what can I change
about my future Behavior to avoid this
happening again right and I think one
set to look at changing would be in
picking it's like okay well I keep
getting cheated on Who Am I who Am I who
am I dating well I'm only dating hot
narcissists let's say right I'm only
dating you know socially socios sexually
unrestricted party animals right um
maybe I can pick someone more settled
down more reliable and and maybe they
don't have that same sexy Cockiness and
party atmosphere but maybe they're
they're going to be more reliable and
then on the other end the the other set
of things so that's choosing and then
maybe there's Al also I mean humans
naturally perform a suite of mate
retention behaviors right it could
partially be a skill issue it's like
you're you're creating an atmosphere
that pushes people away in your
relationships and it's like how can I
create an atmosphere that you know uh
very much like you were saying earlier
about your kind of Jour personal Journey
with jealousy we're creating an
atmosphere where people want to stay yes
as opposed to creating a cage that
they're they feel trapped in yeah
exactly