Savonarola and the Bonfire of the Vanities: The Renaissance Botticelli Walked Away From | S1 EP5

Art of the Renaissance Period
59 followers
29 Video Views·Oct 9, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the life of Sandro Botticelli, tracing his trajectory from a celebrated master under the Medici to a man consumed by religious fervor under Savonarola. It further explores his 19th-century rediscovery, contrasting the superficial trends of the Victorian era with the rigorous, archival scholarship of Herbert Percy Horne.
February 1497. In the central square of Florence,
a bonfire the size of a small building goes up
in flames. What went into it?
Mirrors, jewellery, extravagant clothes, secular books and paintings.
History remembers it as the bonfire of the vanities.
And the story goes that one painter
walked up and threw in a picture of his own.
Meet the old masters. His name was Sandro Botticelli.
The same Botticelli who painted The Birth of Venus and Primavera.
Why would the painter of beauty burn beauty?
Today we're going to meet the most dazzling
and the saddest painter of the Renaissance.
And later, another man in London,
the one who dragged him back out of three centuries of obscurity.
The Birth of Venus and Primavera live in the Uffizi in Florence.
But a sibling of theirs,
another mythological panel from the same hand, lives in London.
At the National Gallery, Venus and Mars,
the goddess of love and the god of war.
The composition does the talking.
Venus is awake, calmly present in the world on her side of the panel.
Mars has stripped off his armour and is dead to the world.
Asleep so completely that a swarm of little satyrs can blow
a conch shell right in his ear and he doesn't stir.
The usual reading is that love has conquered war.
To me, it looks like a slightly meaner joke than that.
The goddess is wide awake.
The man is out cold. Some things never change.
The details don't slack off either.
Right beside Mars' sleeping head,
if you look closely, there's a wasp's nest.
A god of war, snoring within earshot of a buzz that should wake anyone.
Botticelli's elegance keeps this kind
of small mischief close by at all times.
The elongated shape of the panel suggests it was made
for a piece of wedding furniture or a bedroom wall,
which means this picture of love defeating war once hung
in somebody's newlywed bedroom.
15th century Florentines, it turns out, had a decent sense of humour.
Botticelli's early career is the Florentine Golden Age in miniature.
He worked in the orbit of the Medici family,
particularly Lorenzo de' Medici,
whom we've met before in this series.
Primavera and The Birth of Venus
are both believed to have been commissioned
for members of the Medici family.
It's also well established that Botticelli painted
actual Medici faces into his religious scenes,
including his Adoration of the Magi.
And in that painting, tucked into the right-hand edge,
there's a young man who is the only figure
looking straight out of the picture at you.
This is generally accepted as Botticelli's own self-portrait.
500 years later, and a painter looks you in the eye.
This series is called Meet the Old Masters,
but painters who genuinely meet your gaze
are rarer than you'd think.
I'd cross a crowded Uffizi gallery just to stand in front of that
one face. It's also, if you think about it,
another version of a trick we've seen before,
a painter written into his own picture.
A patron once inserted himself as a devout donor,
kneeling, offering up a model of the building he paid for.
Botticelli does something almost
cheeky by comparison he slips into the edge
of his employer's family portrait in his working
clothes staring straight back at the viewer
the devout patron kneels the painter stares you down
where you stand inside a picture can quietly reverse
who actually holds the power outside it
Florence at the time was intoxicated with rediscovering Greek
and Roman philosophy and art
A naked Venus could be painted and hung in polite company
because a new intellectual framework, Neoplatonism,
allowed her to be read not as a pagan goddess,
but as an allegory of divine love.
For one brief window, beauty and faith were holding hands.
That balance was broken by one monk, Girolamo Savonarola.
The ground for that collapse was already laid.
The church itself was rotting from the top down.
In Rome, Pope Alexander VI openly kept a mistress and children,
and clerical office was bought and sold for money.
The men entrusted with God's word were living
the most extravagantly of anyone.
If that's true, divine punishment can't be far off.
What Savonarola's sermons denounced first was exactly this,
the clergy's own corruption,
which is precisely why they landed hardest in a city built on luxury.
Through the 1490s, Savonarola's sermons shook Florence,
denouncing luxury and vice,
prophesying divine punishment.
When the Medici were driven from the city in a political upheaval
in 1494, Florence effectively became a city ruled
by this preacher's words. This is documented,
textbook history. The bonfire of the vanities was the high point of it.
In 1497, on the day of
carnival, vanities really were burned in the square.
Multiple sources confirm it. What went in?
Mirrors, cosmetics, masks, gambling equipment,
luxurious clothing, manuscripts of love poetry,
– everything that isn't an ornament of the soul –
all of it stacked into a tower
in the middle of the square and set alight.
Carnival is supposed to be the one day
a city lets its hair down completely, and on that
day of all days, to burn the things made for merriment.
Even the choice of date has a certain theatrical precision to it.
So what about Botticelli?
Giorgio Vasari wrote that Botticelli became
a fervent follower of Savonarola, and threw
his own paintings into the fire with his own hands.
And that afterwards he set down his brush,
stopped working, and fell into poverty.
We can't say whether that's true.
Vasari wrote it half a century after the event,
and no surviving record identifies which paintings,
if any, actually went in.
but it wouldn't have taken much to move him.
Botticelli's brother, Simone,
was reportedly a devoted follower of Savonarola
and lived in the same house as the painter.
A chronicle in Simone's own hand survives.
Every night, someone was carrying
that sermon's heat back to the same dinner table.
The times were on the preacher's side too.
Lorenzo's death, foreign armies on Florentine soil.
His prophecies kept, one after another, seeming to land.
And above all, Botticelli was a painter of luxury.
Nobody had painted
the very vanities under attack more beautifully than he had.
It may have been hard not to feel that the sermons were aimed at him.
Look at his late masterpiece,
which also happens to live in London, at the National Gallery.
There's something wrong with this picture.
It's dated 1500
but the style is old, the ring of angels is flat, figures are
sized by importance rather than
by how far away they are, perspective, the very
tool that made Uccello's battle scene
so proud of itself has been all but
abandoned, it's the picture as symbol
not as window mode we talked about back at
the very start of this series before Giotto changed
the rules, a painter who
had stood at the cutting edge
of the Renaissance stepped back off it on purpose. This isn't a man
who lost his technique. It's a man who threw it away.
And it's the only painting Botticelli ever
signed and dated. Along the top, in Greek,
there's an inscription that sounds like the end of the
world. The painter's last signature comes bundled
with a premonition of apocalypse. That much
doesn't rest on anyone's word. The picture itself says so.
In the troubles of Italy, in the year
1500, I, Sandro, painted this.
That's the inscription, roughly translated. It goes on to
quote the Book of Revelation,
that this is a time of tribulation and that the devil will soon be
bound in chains. And in the picture itself,
angels and humans embrace at ground level, while overhead
Angels Dance in a Ring of Pure Joy,
Earthly Anxiety and Heavenly Celebration,
sharing one small panel.
Two years after Savonarola's fire went cold, this is where
Botticelli had arrived.
After Botticelli died, his name all but vanished from art history.
Overshadowed by Raphael and Michelangelo,
he was a forgotten painter for over 300 years.
The man who dug him back up worked in an unlikely city,
19th century London,
the same circle of Pre-Raphaelite painters
and their orbit that closes out this season.
In 1870, the critic Walter Pater published an essay on Botticelli.
Ruskin followed, and that particular grace
of line found itself at the centre of a search
by a group of young painters for a beauty that predated Raphael.
The reason The Birth of Venus is one
of the most famous paintings on earth today
traces straight back to that Victorian London rediscovery.
That rediscovery was itself a kind of mania.
Botticelli turned up in poems, on wallpaper, even as a hairstyle.
In London drawing rooms, Botticellian became a word people used
without ever having seen a single one of his paintings.
enthusiasm can bring a painter back from the dead
but enthusiasm on its own doesn't write a
biography, somebody has to work out who painted what
when and for how much, the man we're bringing
along today was standing inside that trend at the time
and he's the one who did exactly that
Herbert Percy Horne, born in London 1864, he didn't
start out as an art historian at all, he trained
as an architect and designer: wallpaper patterns, typefaces, book design
in the 1880s he joined the
Century Guild, a decorative arts movement
and edited its journal The Hobby Horse, a publication
with Oscar Wilde and Ruskin among its contributors, right
at the center of the aesthetic movement
which is to say he wasn't just alive during
the decade Botticelli became a London buzzword
he was sitting in the editor's chair while it happened.
If earlier episodes have shown us people who stand near a painting,
as patron, as collector, Horne is a new type entirely.
Not a patron, not a collector.
A man who stood at the factory floor of the trend,
and noticed the trend was hollow.
He wrote later of that peculiarly English cult of Botticelli,
and more sharply still the name of Botticelli became
a catch word among persons to whom the
real significance of early Italian art can hardly be said to appeal.
That's a rare thing,
someone willing to describe with that much detachment
a fad he himself had been swimming in,
and he chose the opposite of the fad.
In the autumn of 1889 he made his first trip to Italy,
Lucca, Pisa, Florence, Orvieto, Assisi.
Something on that first trip seems
to have settled the matter.
Before long, he'd given up London for Florence entirely.
And once there, he did the one thing
the fashionable crowd back home never bothered with.
He went into the archives.
Contracts, ledgers, tax filings.
The kind of work this series itself is built on,
done more than a century earlier for one single painter.
Day after day, that mountain of paper.
The publisher's original brief, apparently,
was for a modest volume in an affordable series.
It grew and grew, well past modest.
Writers who blow past their deadline
and their word count are nothing new.
But in his case, everything he failed
to keep went straight into the depth of the book.
The result, published in 1908, was Alessandro Filipepi,
commonly called Sandro Botticelli, painter of Florence.
The colophon states it plainly,
printed in an edition of 240 copies, of which 225 were for sale.
The definitive biography of a painter who had become a household name,
and he released it as a book almost nobody would ever own.
240 copies, while the whole of London
was consuming Botticelli by the yard.
That was his answer. Time proved the book right.
The art historian Leopold Ettlinger later called it
one of the finest
and still unsurpassed works in the whole literature of art history.
And in his own day, the critic Roger Fry praised its detached,
almost scientific tone.
A book that barely lets personal taste creep in.
Not a book that talks beautifully about a painter.
A book that checks the facts.
The phrase source discipline didn't exist yet,
but that's exactly what he was doing.
Here's one small, slightly wicked example.
The poet and painter Dante Gabriel Rossetti bought
a portrait of a woman
attributed to Botticelli at auction in 1867
and treasured it for the rest of his life.
That painting now hangs at the V&A,
and in his 1908 book, Horn rejected its attribution.
A poet had fallen in love with a picture.
A man of documents and eyesight told him no.
That story deserves its own telling another time.
His choice of home in Florence was just
as deliberate. He bought a 15th century palazzo near Santa Croce,
and using his own training as
an architect restored it with scholarly precision to its original state
then lived in it studying
renaissance paintings in a renaissance house surrounded
by renaissance furniture call it a
hobby if you like taken this far it's a method
and the ending on the 12th of April 1916 on his sick
Berenson drew up a will leaving the palazzo
and the entire collection he'd spent 30 years assembling
to Italy. He died two days later at 52.
His house in Florence is now open to the public
as the Museo Horn. One quiet fact to close on.
The museum's own website listing its highlights
names Giotto, Simone Martini, Gozzoli,
Filippino Lippi and hold on something seems to be missing.
At least in the official summary
of the collection Botticelli's name doesn't appear. A man who gave
his life to Botticelli, left behind in the end
not Botticelli's paintings but Botticelli's method.
A painting can have only one owner at a time.
A way of studying multiplies with every person
who takes it up.
I can think of few greater legacies to leave.
Right, how to go and meet them?
The National Gallery, Sainsbury Wing.
Venus and Mars and the Mystic Nativity, the height of his
powers and the very end of his career hang
in the same building one suggestion for the order
see Venus and Mars first then the Mystic Nativity it's hard
to believe both came from the same hand
only 15 or so years apart that distance
is really the whole story i've told you today
the obvious answer is the Uffizi the Birth of Venus Primavera
and that Adoration of the Magi
with the self-portrait that looks straight back at you.
Botticelli's room is the most crowded in the entire museum.
So here's what I actually did about that.
Book the first entry slot of the day,
and the moment the doors open,
walk quickly straight to the Botticelli room.
Running isn't allowed indoors, so it's more of a determined power walk.
I probably looked faintly ridiculous doing it.
But it bought me a few minutes alone with Venus,
in an empty room before anyone else arrived.
That kind of quiet doesn't come from queuing.
See Venus first in the silence,
then double back and take the other rooms slowly.
It's the wrong order by the museum's own logic,
for the actual experience of looking,
I still think it's the right one.
Horn, I suspect, would have done exactly the same thing.
He struck me as someone
with strong opinions about how to use an empty room.
One more quiet spot.
Botticelli is buried at the Ognissanti Church in Florence.
The same church, so the story goes, where Simonetta Vespucci is buried,
the woman he is said to have loved his whole life.
And near Santa Croce, at Via dei Benci 6, the Museo Horn.
It keeps short hours, so check the official site before you go.
While the Uffizi queue stretches down the street, this place is quiet.
A small Giotto panel, 15th century furniture, a staircase banister
that's still exactly what it was in the Renaissance.
No Botticelli, but the house of the man who practiced connoisseurship
discipline before it had a name, standing just as he left it.
Not an Englishman living in Florence,
in the words of the museum's own site,
an Englishman who chose to become a Florentine.
A man who mastered beauty, came to doubt it and let it go.
Botticelli's life carries the whole light
and shadow of making beautiful things in one career.
In his later years, he was left behind by fashion.
Commissions thinned out and he died quietly.
For over 300 years, he was mostly forgotten.
Two things brought him back.
One was fashion, the Pre-Raphaelites rediscovering his line.
The other was paperwork, a man named Horn rewriting his biography,
not through admiration, but through record.
Longing brought the paintings back to life.
Ledgers brought the painter back to life.
We only know about the night he supposedly threw
a painting into the fire through Vasari, at one remove.
But that he never once, to the end, put down his brush,
that's something the surviving paintings themselves can tell us.
Next time, a complete change of pace.
The strangest painter the National Gallery has.
A man who, for reasons nobody has ever quite settled,
tucked a cucumber into the corner of his pictures.
Crivelli. This was my favourite episode to make.
I'm not confident I'll manage any restraint at all.
Meet the old masters. Until next time.
