Footage: Rise of Empires: Ottomans (2020) Napoleon (2023) Charlemagne (2021) Catherine: The Ascension (2016) Catherine (2014) Catherine: The Pretenders (2019) Catherine the Great (2019) Vikings (2013 - 2020) Viking (2016) Cyril and Methodius. The Apostles of the Slavs (2013)
Music: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Clemency of Titus Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - Voyage Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - New King Arrives Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - Ride Forth Victoriously Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - Battle of Lepanto Imperator Rome: Soundtrack - Mediterranean Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - The Empire Divided Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - At The Gates of Constantinople Europe Universalis IV Soundtrack - Off To War
Literature:
- Sergey Ivanov, Catherine the Great’s Byzantium, Quaestio Rossica 9, June 2021 - Ragsdale, Hugh. “Evaluating the Traditions of Russian Aggression: Catherine II and the Greek Project.” The Slavonic and East European Review, vol. 66, no. 1, 1988, pp. 91–117.
- Catherine II. (1787). Zapiski kasatel’no Rossiiskoi istorii v 7 ch. [Notes on Russian History. 7 Parts]. St Petersburg, Imperatorskaya tipografiya. Part 1. 416 p. - Catherine II. (1878). Pis’ma Imperatritsy Ekateriny II baronu Mel’khioru Grimmu (gody s 1774 po 1796) [The Letters of Empress Catherine II to Baron Melchior Grimm from 1774 to 1796]. St Petersburg Tipografiya Imperatorskoi Akademii nauk. 734 p. - Catherine II. (1901). Sochineniya imperatritsy Ekateriny II na osnovanii podlinnykh rukopisei v 12 t. [The Writings of Empress Catherine II from her Genuine Manuscripts. 12 Vols.]. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Imperatorskoi аkademii nauk. Vol. 2. Dramaticheskie sochineniya. 547 p.
00:00 Intro 00:36 Russia in the XVIII Century 01:33 The Ottoman Empire in the XVIII Century 02:33 Catherine 04:43 The First War 05:47 The Greeks and the Southern Ambitions 07:50 Hellenic Fashion 10:50 European Diplomacy 13:14 The Plans 19:57 The Second War 21:28 Catherine's "Byzantium" 24:49 Legacy of the Greek Project 26:33 Outro
Most of the historical plans to restore the Roman
Empire placed their authors as the new Roman Emperors.
From Charlemagne to Mussolini, the wannabe restorers envisioned themselves at the helm
of Rome Reborn, basking in all the glory and prestige that comes with it. But there
is one particular restoration plan that stands out. It’s comparatively pragmatic,
not overly ambitious and doesn’t even put the planner on the Empire’s throne. This
unique plan is known as the Greek Project of Catherine the Great.
The 18th century was the time of Russian ascendance. The country entered the
17-hundreds as the backwater of Europe. Its access to the Baltics was blocked by
the powerful Swedish Empire. To the west was the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth,
ever eager to challenge the Russians for dominion over the lands along the Dnieper
river. To the south, the Black Sea was more of an Ottoman Lake. Its southern shores were
controlled by The Sublime Porte directly, while the northern banks were the domain of its vassal,
the Crimean Khan. But in the first half of the 18th century Russia has gained an upper-hand over
two out of three of its major rivals. Sweden was decisively defeated in the Great Northern War and
effectively ceased to be a great power. Poland was neutralized through diplomatic influence
to a point where Russian rulers had a final say in electing the next Polish king. The remaining
big target was the mighty Ottoman Empire. And the Ottomans were no longer as mighty
as they were at the times of Mehmet and Suleiman. Their Empire wasn’t “The Sick Man of Europe” yet,
but it started showing some signs of weakness. Ever since their defeat at the hands of the Holy
League in the Great Turkish War, the Ottomans were struggling to reassert themselves on the
European stage. The loyalty of the Janissaries was in decline, revolts were springing up in the
provinces, and a newly resurgent Persia was threatening the eastern frontiers. However,
the Sublime Porte was still a force to be reckoned with and possessed the largest army in Europe. The
first round of the Russo-Turkish wars in the 18th century ended inconclusively. The sum total of
Russian gains on the Black Sea was the fortress of Azov, and even that one was forbidden from
being fortified by the treaty signed in 1739. When Catherine II ascended the Russian Throne,
the Empire’s progress on its southern strategic goal was fairly unimpressive.
But the new Russian Empress herself, on the other hand, was very impressive. Catherine, born Sophie
Friederike Auguste, came to rule Russia after overthrowing her unpopular husband, Peter III.
The Imperial couple were both German by birth, but unlike Peter, Catherine embraced the faith
and customs of Russian people, which earned her the support of both the populace and the nobility.
The new empress was ambitious, energetic and well-educated. Her ascension marked the beginning
of the Golden Age for the Russian Empire. Catherine’s reign started with a diplomatic
victory in Poland. In 1764 the Empress managed to get her former favorite, Stanislaw Poniatowski,
elected to the Polish throne with the backing of the Russian Army. The Polish nobility were split
in their support of the new king. The cornerstone of the disagreements was the “dissident question”,
the issue of the rights of non-Catholics within the Commonwealth. Russia and Prussia were pushing
for more rights for the Orthodox and the Protestants, while France and Austria were
opposing this reform. In February 1768 Russian ambassador Nikolay Repnin forced the Sejm to
pass the religious tolerance act in exchange for a constitutional guarantee from Catherine. This
triggered a revolt from those among the Polish nobility, who were opposed to the King and
Russian Influence. With the diplomatic backing of Austria and France, they formed a confederation at
the town of Bar near the Polish-Ottoman border. The heavily outnumbered confederates could not
withstand the combined forces of the king’s loyalists and the Russian army for long and
were desperate for foreign support. Austria and France were hesitant to join, so the only
option on the table was the Ottoman Empire. In June of the same year, the fortress of
Bar was taken by the Russian forces. When the defeated confederates fled
across the Ottoman border, the Zaporozhian Cossacks followed in pursuit and triggered
a diplomatic incident. Egged on by the Austrian and the French envoys, the sultan used this as a
pretext to imprison the Russian ambassador which amounted to a declaration of war.
But the war did not go the Sultan’s way. He and his ally, the Crimean khan, could field
bigger armies, but they had nothing to answer the superior artillery coordination of the Russians.
On land, the Turkish forces suffered a series of defeats and lost several key fortresses. At sea,
the expeditionary fleet of Alexey Orlov reached the Aegean and destroyed the entire Ottoman force
sent to stop him in the Battle of Chesma. For the next 4 years Orlov’s force became a nightmare for
the Turks. They blocked the straits, sparked the revolts in Morea, Egypt and the Levant and even
managed to capture Beirut. Austria’s entrance into the war on the Sultan’s side might have
turned the tides, but Catherine managed to secure Habsburg neutrality with the First Partition of
Poland. By 1774 the situation was hopeless for the Ottomans. The Treaty of Küçük Kaynarca,
that which ended the hostilities, marked a major blow to Turkish influence and prestige.
At the same time this war was a huge victory for Russia, despite it being started by the Ottomans.
The Empress broke the Sultan’s stranglehold on the Black Sea, gaining two coastal outlets at the
mouth of the Dnieper and on the Kerch peninsula in Crimea. The Ottomans were forced to renounce
their suzerainty over the Crimean Khanate and to allow the passage of Russian ships through the
straits. This privilege was also extended to the Orthodox Christians within the Ottoman Empire who
could now sail under the Russian flag and enjoyed the protection of Saint-Petersburg. These included
the Moldavians and the Vlachs in the Danubian principalities, and most notably, the Greeks.
The Greeks played a unique role in the war. I have already mentioned the revolt in Morea, sparked by
the arrival of Alexey Orlov and his fleet. This was one of the key events of the whole war. It
distracted the Ottoman forces and helped the Russian army advance on other fronts. The Orlov
rebellion was suppressed after a year of fighting, but it succeeded in establishing diplomatic
connections between the Russian Imperial court and the Greeks of the Peloponnese and the Aegean.
During the war Alexei Orlov even established a so-called “Grand Duchy of The Archipelago”,
a semi-official state consisting of 18 islands with its own laws, tax code and school system.
In the following years thousands of Hellenic immigrants moved to Russia and many prominent
Greeks assumed offices in the imperial administration. This created lines of
communication which provided a significant strategic advantage. Russia could now
foment unrest in the Orthodox regions of the Ottoman empire more easily in case of another
confrontation with the Sublime Porte. And such a confrontation was sure to come. Catherine’s
ambitions by far exceeded a couple of ports on the Black Sea. Without direct control of
the straits, the Russian shipping and trade could not never be fully secure. With the first
phase of the Southern thrust now complete, the Empress set her sights on the Bosporus.
But the role that the Greeks played in Cathrine’s plans wasn’t purely
geopolitical. Catherine’s reign was also marked with a fascination with Greek culture.
The empress was a woman of the Enlightenment and like many of her friends loved classical
antiquity. The Greek influx into the Empire played well into it. Many Hellenic scholars and artists
were invited to the Russian capital to share their knowledge and skills. Russian architecture and art
of this period were was heavily inspired by Hellenistic and Byzantine traditions.
Many cities founded in the newly acquired territories were given Greek names. Kherson
was founded in the mouth of the Dnieper, bearing the same name as the ancient Greek colony where
prince Vladimir received his baptism, starting the Christianization of the Rus. The Crimean trading
port of Caffa was given back its historical name Theodosia. Colonies with names like Mariupol,
Stavropol and others sprung up around the Azov Sea coast and the Pontic steppe and
became the new homes of many Greek immigrants. This Greek naming fashion even found its way
into the Romanov imperial dynasty. The first grandson of the Empress was named
Alexander. In her correspondence Catherine revealed that his name was inspired by
both the Russian warrior-saint Alexander Nevsky and the legendary King of Macedon.
Russian poet and senator Gavriil Derzhavin composed a poem in his honor called:
“To the Purple-Born child of the North”,
“Purple-born” being the ancient epithet of the Byzantine emperors.
Catherine’s second grandson’s name was chosen to be even more conspicuous.
“They asked me, who’s going to be the godfather.”, writes Catherine in her autobiography.
“I said, only my best friend Abdul-Hamid can fit that role. But since it’s improper for a
Turk to baptize a Christian, at least we can honor him by naming the baby Constantine.”
“Constantine” was an unusual name for a member of the Romanov dynasty. But it was the most popular
name of the Eastern Roman emperors. For the Greeks, Constantine was the name of both the
founder of Constantinople, and the last Byzantine Emperor Constantine XI. The reincarnation of
the Marble King was fabled to herald the restoration of the Empire. Of course now,
the city of Constantine was ruled over by the Ottoman Sultan Abdul Hamid, whom Catherine
mockingly calls “my best friend” in her notes. Young Constantine Pavlovich was slated to
receive a Hellenic upbringing. Even his wetnurse was a Greek woman.
At the feast celebrating the birth of Constantine the choir sang songs
in ancient Greek to the guests, many of whom were foreign dignitaries. The only
more obvious way to signal the intention to take Constantinople would’ve been to say it out loud.
The foreign diplomats, however, weren’t too enthusiastic about Catherine’s ambition. Sweden
and Prussia were wary of the growing Russian might. Other European powers might also have had
something to say about the unchecked expansion in the Black Sea region. But despite these concerns,
the empress thought that the time was ripe for such an endeavor. The attention
of Western Europe was focused on the American War of Independence. Great Britain was trying
its hardest to put down the revolt of the Thirteen Colonies, while France,
Spain and the Netherlands were working to make it even harder for the Brits.
The Prussian king Frederick II was getting old, and would not intervene on the Sultan's
behalf without strong Western backing according to Catherine’s estimation. Plus,
the empress had just found a willing partner for her plans at the court of Vienna.
But why would the Austrians be willing to ally with Russia? Wasn’t Austria just recently trying
to foil Catherine’s plans in Poland and egging on the Ottomans to declare war on the Russians?
The reason for this pivot was the change in Austrian leadership. The previous head of the
Habsburg family was Maria Theresa and she wasn’t overly fond of Catherine’s Russia. She viewed the
Orthodox Empire as a competition and still had some grudge over the Russians quitting during
the 7 years war. But the Mother-in-law of all Europe was getting older and was transferring
more of the imperial responsibilities to her son and successor Joseph II. Joseph had another
vision for the future of Russo-Austrian relations. For him, Russia was a valuable
partner in dividing the spheres of influence. In 1772 Joseph lobbied the Austrian entrance into
the tripartite pact to partition Poland, and he remained in correspondence with Catherine
ever since. It did not take long for them to find common ground on the Eastern question. In 1780,
Joseph and Catherine met in Mogilev to discuss their shared vision for the future of the
Balkans. In November of the same year, Maria Theresa died, and Joseph assumed full control
of Austrian foreign policy. In 1781 the alliance between Russia and Austria was formalized. The
Ottomans now had to be on guard against both their Northern and the Western neighbors.
To finalize the plan, Austria and Russia needed to determine who gets what in case of a victory
over the Turks. Bickering over the spoils was the last thing the allies needed to distract them when
the war would come. The Grand Chancellor of the Russian Empire, Alexander Bezborodko, presented
Catherine with “A Memorial on Political Affairs”, a document outlining the totality of Russian
foreign policy. Among other things, he included different scenarios for carving up the Ottoman
possessions in Europe between Austria and Russia. “If the war between the allies and the Sublime
Porte would be going with moderate success”, wrote Bezborodko, “then it may be prudent to offer the
sultan peace on modest terms”. According to these “modest terms” Russia was supposed to
get the Crimean Peninsula and all the lands and fortresses east of the Dniester, while Austria
was to be given back their former possessions in the Balkans, ceded by the treaty of 1739.
In addition, Bezborodko proposed the creation of a buffer state on the Danube. This buffer state
would’ve been formed out of Moldova, Wallachia and Bessarabia and would be
given the name Dacia. Essentially this would’ve meant creating Romania some 80
years ahead of schedule. However, Bezborodko also
had another, more ambitious plan. Here’s what he wrote on this topic:
“But suppose the stubbornness of the Porte on one hand, and our successes on the other, would
offer ways for the annihilation of Turkey and the restoration of the Greek Empire with your Imperial
majesty’s grandson at the helm. Here, we’d also need to determine the exact borders of this
empire beforehand, assigning them in the Turkish possessions in Europe as well as in the islands
of the archipelago. We’d need to assume that the court of Vienna would like to have some privileges
for their Mediterranean trade, that England, France and Spain may also demand some concessions,
that the Republic of Venice would present their claim on Mo rea, which we shouldn’t give them, but
better substitute it for some islands. It may be that France and Spain would intend to take ports
in Egypt or elsewhere on the African coastline, for which we shouldn’t be objecting much.”
The empress evidently liked her minister’s work. In a letter to Joseph II sent on September 21,
1782, she relayed both his moderate and ambitious plans almost verbatim. The only difference for
the first variant was that she didn’t mention the fate of Crimea at all. Catherine planned to annex
the khanate before going to war and didn’t want to ask Joseph’s permission to do so. Other than that,
every point in Catherine’s ‘moderate variant ’ goes in accordance with Bezborodko’s “Memorial”.
The ambitious variant followed the chancellor’s outline as well. In case the two empires managed
to expel the Turks from Europe, Catherine proposed the revival of the ancient “Greek Empire” with her
3-year old grandson as its emperor. Constantine would renounce all his claims on the Russian
throne, and his empire would remain neutral in all affairs concerning Austria and Russia.
Funnily enough, Constantine wouldn’t have become the youngest Byzantine emperor even if the whole
thing happened the next day. The record of the 2 year old Michael III was very hard to beat.
According to the plan, Constantine’s Neo-Byzantium would get the Ottoman possessions in Europe and
the islands of the Aegean. To appease Joseph, Catherine gave him a carte-blanche on drawing the
new Empire’s western border, so that the Habsburgs could claim as much of the Balkans as they wanted.
On the 13th of November, Joseph sent Catherine a response. He did not object to the creation of
Dacia and the Greek Empire, but he wanted to get a whole bunch of stuff in the Balkans: Khotyn in
Moldavia, Nikopol in Bulgaria, Belgrade with parts of Serbia, Albania and just the whole of
Bosnia. According to his plan, the border between Austria and Byzantium south of the Danube would
be one of those classic straight lines, like the ones you can see on the maps of colonial
Africa. Surely drawing a straight line border in the Balkans wasn’t going to create any problems
in the future. To add to all those gains, Joseph was also planning to annex Istria and Dalmatia.
The fact that Istria and Dalmatia were owned by Venice and not by the Ottomans didn’t bother him
much. He proposed to reimburse the Venetians by giving them Cyprus, Crete, Morea and a couple
of random islands in the Aegean. Truly, Joseph II was a geopolitical genius ahead of his time.
Sadly, we’ll never know what Catherine and her ministers thought of Joseph’s visionary plan.
The two monarchs never mentioned the issue in the mutual correspondence again. You can
see that the point of contention between the plans of Bezborodko and of Joseph was Morea.
Bezborodko was staunchly against giving it away to anyone except the restored Empire, while the
Habsburg wanted to use it as a bargaining chip in his own negotiations with Venice. Morea was
the heartland of the Greek independence movement, so Bezborodko’s stance on this question was much
more reasonable and informed then what Joseph proposed. But even if they’d manage to polish
out the details, the Austrian ambitions were disproportionate to their abilities. Plus,
the perfect diplomatic conditions to put the plan in motion were quickly disappearing. The
American war of Independence was winding down and in January 1783 France, Spain and Britain
signed a treaty to end the hostilities. Catherine suspected that France was rushing to defend the
Ottomans from the combined Russo-Austrian threat. The opportunity for an aggressive move was gone,
so now the planners had to bait the Turks into declaring war themselves. The biggest
test for the Sultan’s patience came in 1783, when Russia annexed the Crimean Khanate. The treaty of
Kucuk-Kainarlji guaranteed the independence and neutrality of the Khanate, but in reality
it remained a diplomatic battleground. Both the Russians and the Turks were spending a lot of
money and resources trying to get their preferred candidates into power, and both were accusing
each other of interference. In 1783 Catherine decided to flip the board, intervened in the
ongoing civil war in Crimea and just annexed the peninsula into Russia. The Sultan didn’t
take the bait immediately, but in 1787, when the Empress went on tour around the Crimea, the
Ottomans started issuing protests and demanding the restoration of the khanate. Emboldened by the
promises of backing from France and England, Abdulhamid once again declared war on Russia.
For Joseph and Catherine, this was the best chance to implement their designs. However,
while the Russians were again victorious on both land and sea, the performance of the Austrian army
was less than stellar. The Austrians failed to make any significant progress, lost a number of
battles and, when Joseph II died in 1790, sued for a separate peace. The Russian army was advancing,
but the Ottomans offered significant resistance, so the progress was slower than
Catherine desired. Still, in a couple of years the Turkish military was its last leg. However,
by this time major Western powers like Prussia and Britain had started gathering
forces to save the Sublime Porte from a complete collapse. The Austrian alliance should’ve been a
precaution against this turn of events, but the Habsburg military had turned out not to be up
to the task. With outside pressure mounting, Catherine decided to quit while ahead and be
satisfied with some limited gains. The Ottomans were forced to recognize Crimea as the part of
the Russian Empire and cede the lands east of the Dniester, with the valuable fortress of Ochakov.
The Russians secured all the land they wanted for themselves, but no independent Byzantium or
even Dacia were on the agenda this time around. The chance to revive the Medieval Roman empire
on the Bosporus was gone. With the ideas of the French revolution sweeping across the continent,
restoration of old empires was falling out of fashion.
It is interesting to theorize what this Neo-Byzantium of Empress Catherine would
have looked like. The information we have about Catherine’s knowledge on the topic
may give us some idea. The Empress was a big Roman history fan, but quite like most of the
modern day romaboos she was more interested in the classical Empire, rather than all that Byzantine
stuff. Most historians just assume that her plan was supposed to be a revived Byzantium, because
it would have been a Christian empire centered around Constantinople, but Catherine doesn’t use
the word “Byzantium” or “Byzantine” even once. She just calls it “the Greek Empire”. Catherine’s idea
of the Medieval Roman state was a mix of knowledge about Greco-Roman antiquity and of the old Russian
image of Byzantium as the source of the Orthodox Christianity. The Empress loved Roman history,
but only the fun parts. She read Polybius and Plutarch, and even helped to translate a
French book about Belisarius, but didn’t bother with any ancient sources on the laws and the
administration of the Empire. There were no books on Byzantine ceremonies and political structure
in Catherine’s library, but there was Procopius’ “Secret History”, cause that stuff is fun to read.
The same applies to the culture and customs. Among other things,
Catherine revived the old Roman tradition of victory titles in the Russian military.
Her star generals and admirals had received this special award for the most impressive victories,
like Suvorov of Rymnik, Potemkin of Tauria and Orlov of Chesma. She thought that this had been a
persistent tradition in Roman history, going back all the way to the likes of Scipio Africanus, but
in reality it had been abandoned after Heraclius with few rare exceptions. A glimpse of Catherine’s
vision of what life in Medieval Byzantium was like can be found in a historical
play that she wrote. It is called “The Early Reign of Oleg”. One of its episodes describes
the Russian prince’s visit to Constantinople, and it’s full of anachronisms. Emperor Leo
entertains Oleg with classical Greek theater and Olympic games. It’s not quite Netflix “Cleopatra”
level inaccurate, but would’ve still warranted a full-length “debunking” video. On the other hand,
the empress seems to have known a lot about the Varangian guard. She had started to read Gibbon,
but got bored by his “Decline and Fall” around volume 8, right at the beginning of the Byzantine
era. All this reinforces the notion that Catherine only cared about the “cool bits” of Roman history.
This knowledge disparity isn’t surprising. Catherine, like most of her learned friends
throughout Europe, valued classical Rome and Greece very highly. Many of them were excited
to see their fellow enlightened monarch topple the decadent Ottoman empire and establish a haven
for classical culture in its place. Even Voltaire was cheering her on to restore the Greek Empire;
probably more due to his dislike of the Ottomans, rather than his love for
Byzantium. Medieval Eastern Rome, on the other hand, was only interesting to the empress from
the perspective of Russian history. She didn’t commission any research into Byzantine society
for her Greek project, even though there were plenty of experts at her disposal.
It all probably means that Catherine’s “Greek Empire” would have been less of a revived Eastern
Rome and more of an 18th century enlightened despotism with some Hellenistic flavor.
In the end, “The Greek Project” of Catherine the Great didn’t pan out the way that the
empress wanted. Her grandson never sat on the throne of Constantinople. After Catherine died
and the turbulent years of the Napoleonic wars had passed, the Russian emperors did
not give up their struggle for influence in the Balkans. But in keeping up with the times,
their new initiatives were driven more by popular principles, like ethnicity and religion,
rather than old dynastic claims. The 19th century Tsars positioned themselves as the
protectors of the Slavs and the Orthodox people, so nonchalantly trading the lands of the Serbs
and the Bulgars from one Empire to another couldn’t be their policy. In 1780 Catherine
II was content with giving all of Serbia to the Habsburgs. In 1914 Tsar Nicholas II had
to decide what to do about the Habsburgs trying to annex Serbia, and we all know how that ended.
Catherine’s Greek project has a peculiar legacy. On one hand, it was an opportunistic plot to
carve out buffer states in the Balkans which was abandoned as soon as its participants got
distracted by more important events. On the other hand, the Russians have succeeded in
establishing a geographical, diplomatic and cultural connection to the ancient cradle of
their faith. The settlements established in those decades still stand today as the big urban centers
of the region, populated by the Russians and the Ukrainians, but bearing the same Greek names. It
also turned out to be a major influence on the Greek independence movement. So, while the stated
geopolitical goals of the plan were not completely met, we shouldn’t be underestimating its long term
effects because of the lack of a flashy triumphal procession through the streets of Constantinople.
I hope you enjoyed the video. If you have any questions left on the topic
feel free to put them in the comments. I’d like to give special thanks to my Patreon
supporters Moulay Cherkaoui, Conventus Orbis, Pyykkimies, Micius Porcius and others. And for
the rest of you, thanks a lot for watching to the end, and I will see you in the next one.