During the House Committee on Education hearing on May 19, 2026, Rep. Sherry Roberts (R District 29 - Coventry, West Greenwich) addresses concerns regarding 2026 House Bill 8531. This legislation relates to compulsory attendance and proposes significant changes to the approval process for homeschooling. Rep. Roberts highlights how the bill introduces subjectivity by allowing school committees to deny or defer a family's homeschooling request if they deem it is not in the "best interest of the child".
The discussion emphasizes that applying this standard against fit parents contradicts established Supreme Court precedent and treats families as "suspects first". Furthermore, Rep. Roberts points out constitutional flaws in the bill's trigger provisions, which penalize parents for unproven or pending truancy allegations and force indefinite public school enrollment while the school committee deliberates without a strict timeline.
House Bill No. 8531 BY O'Brien, Dawson, Shanley, Noret, Serpa, Fellela, Azzinaro, Kennedy, Corvese, Solomon ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO EDUCATION -- COMPULSORY ATTENDANCE (Authorizes school committees to deny or defer approval of a homeschooling proposed plan in certain circumstances.) {LC6240/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText26/HouseText26/H8531.pdf
This discussion examines the legal and constitutional concerns surrounding bill 8531, specifically regarding homeschooling approval. The speakers argue that the bill improperly applies the \"best interest of the child\" standard to third-party school committees, mandates problematic public school enrollment during review periods, and utilizes flawed truancy triggers that ignore the presumption of innocence.
I wanted to the organization that you came from.
So I just want to recap some of what you said, make sure that I heard it clearly and to see if there's any place else you could expound upon further.
I know that in some of the writings that you have put out regarding this bill in particular,
I did read that it says 8531 introduces subjectivity by allowing school committees to deny or defer homeschooling if they deem approval would not be in the best interest of the child.
The problem comes in when the best interest of the child standard was designed for a very different context.
Would you expound upon that just a little bit, please?
I believe that gets to what I was talking with Representative Donovan about, which is that, again,
that best interest standard is designed and it's used in situations where either two parents disagree and so they have equal rights,
so you have to look at some other standard, or a situation where the family is broken.
It could be a divorce situation, again, where the parents disagree,
or it could be a situation where the state has taken custody of a child because of an abuse or neglect or other terrible situations.
So the standard has uses, but the Supreme Court has said for over 40 years that you don't use that standard.
It's the wrong standard when a third party, in this case a school committee, disagrees with the decision of parents.
And so the concern that we would have is that, again, this statute uses that standard without defining what it means,
and it's very difficult to define what that means.
Most states, they don't have a definition.
They have 15 to 20 factors that a judge has to weigh, and the judge can weigh them in any order it wants,
and it's not a strict math competition.
One factor may trump all the others, depending on the nature of the circumstances.
And so it's a very complicated thing to do.
It's a very difficult determination to make.
And, again, the Supreme Court said you shouldn't be using that standard in a situation where, you know,
unless you've got those limited situations that I talked about.
Okay, thank you.
And I think you're talking about where the Supreme Court has repeatedly warned in cases like Parham v. J.R.
and Troxell v. Granville that the best interest standard is not the standard when a third party,
such as a school committee, is challenging a fit parent's decisions.
The law presumes that fit parents are acting in the child's best interest, not the other way around.
You're talking about Blattery.
That is correct, yes.
I thought you also said during your testimony that the bill also requires that a child already enrolled in public school
must remain enrolled in public school.
That's what the language says in here, right?
That is correct.
Okay.
And that's for as long as it takes the school committee to make the determination,
which I don't believe is capped in time by the bill.
Okay, so, yes, so I think this court case did state that it would, I think,
I'm sorry, I'm just trying to refer back to my notes.
That court case, oh, actually it was another one.
Maybe you could respond upon this a little bit.
The Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts held in the care and protection of Charles
that the state couldn't force parents to keep their children enrolled in public school
until homeschooling approval without violating the family's constitutional rights.
Yes, that is correct.
And while that's Massachusetts,
I'll just note that Massachusetts is the only other state in the country that has an approval statute.
And so those two states, Rhode Island and Massachusetts, are unique in that respect.
And, again, 40 years ago the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts,
even though their statute says you have to get approval in advance,
their interpretation was that to interpret that literally would create a constitutional problem.
And so they used the doctrine of constitutional avoidance and said we can't actually,
the school district can't actually force you to keep a child in public school
while the school district is deliberating.
I would also note as well that I believe it was the Supreme Court of Vermont back in 2000
in a case called Ingrid T.M. decided a case where there were indefinite periods of time
to make a determination and held that it was both constitutionally
and statutorily required that school committees issue, in that case,
the recognition letter within 45 days.
And so if you have situations where there is no outside timetable or an indefinite period of time
as well as requiring parents to remain in public school while the approval process is going on,
they are from sister jurisdictions, but there are two state Supreme Courts relatively close to here
that have concluded years ago that there were serious constitutional problems with that.
Okay, so I know that there was a couple of other things some other people had written
in some emails to me.
They were saying, and perhaps maybe you could expand a little further
of what they're talking about if you can, but it says 8531 has trigger provisions
that are also flawed.
Of the three, three of the four triggers relate to formal truancy or attendance proceedings,
pending truancy petitions, petitions filed within the previous 12 months
or civil and criminal attendance-related charges.
But the bill makes no distinction between allegations that were proven,
those that are currently pending, where the accused is innocent until proven guilty,
and where the parent prevailed in court.
Yeah, that's accurate.
And that's referring to page four, so that B1 section that I talked about.
So 1, 2, and 3, which the judge talked about in the bill, I just want to note,
and I think this is what you had talked about.
There is no requirement in those three sections that there be any finding
or conviction for any of these offenses.
The triggers are that a truancy, habitual truancy, or other attendance petition
has been filed, not adjudicated, not determined to be accurate.
The second one, the child's been subject, the subject of such a petition
within the preceding 12 months.
Third is that the parent has been charged civilly or criminally with an offense,
and the charge remains pending, which by definition means not adjudicated,
or was filed within the preceding 12 months, again, without any requirement
that you actually be convicted under the charge.
So, you know, again, I don't know that the intention of the bill is to penalize
parents in a situation where they've been exonerated of the claim of truancy,
but under the plain text of the bill, that is a possibility.
You would be barred, even if you were exonerated, unless the charge was expunged
for some reason, removed from the record.
Yeah, I think probably the sponsor, it wasn't his real intent to do anything like that,
but I think it's important to point these things out anyway,
because some people are feeling that families are treated as suspects first
and forced to prove themselves innocent later.
So there are some real concerns with this bill, even though it may not have been,
I'm sure it wasn't the intent of the sponsor, but there's a lot of work to do,
I think, on this, a lot of concerns.