Rene Descartes
Welcome to the session on René Descartes. René Descartes, the father of modern philosophy,
was a gentleman scholar. Having born into a wealthy family, he received the best education
possible at the time, first in the Jesuit college of La Flèche in Maine and later in Paris.
After a period of service in the army, which enabled him to travel across Europe,
Descartes settled in politically liberal Holland, where he wrote his most important works,
including Discourse on Method, published in 1637, Meditations in 1641, and Principles of
Philosophy in 1646. The Latin name for Descartes being Cartesius, his works and thought are often
referred to as Cartesian philosophy. Broadly, Descartes' contributions to philosophy can be
classified under two heads, the first being a comprehensive physico-mathematical reductionism
and the second, a conception of mind as lying outside the purview of physics,
as a phenomenon whose nature could be grasped only from within, that is, via introspective
reflection. In the former pursuit, he made some important mathematical discoveries, such as
analytical geometry, wherein he combined the principles of algebra with geometry and thus
became a key figure in scientific circles. In the philosophic circles, he is more famous for
the latter pursuit, the outcomes of which set the themes for further philosophical inquiry in
the modern time, which still define the major problems of philosophy to be followed up, and
the ambition and methodology of which characterized the turn to modernity in epistemology and
philosophy at large. The Cartesian Project
Descartes' contribution to science culminated with the publication of Discourse on Method in 1637,
wherein he lays down the vision of science as a unified system which is based on secure
metaphysical foundations. Although true to the scientific fervour characteristic of his times,
he insists there on the importance of observation and experiment in deciding between rival
hypotheses. He maintains that the fundamental axioms of the new science are to be uncovered
simply by the innate powers of human intellect.
I noticed certain laws which God has so established in nature, and of which he has
implanted such notions in our minds that, after adequate reflection, we can't doubt that they are
exactly observed in everything which exists or occurs in the world, he claims. This appeal to
God as an implanter and, in a certain sense, guarantor of the relevant laws is what, in fact,
forms the metaphysical foundation claimed. And consequently, the Cartesian Project in
philosophy takes off from this ambition of placing a newly formulated scientific system
on secure metaphysical foundations. The discourse itself outlines the route to
such secure foundations proceeding from Descartes' celebrated method of doubt.
In the discourse, customary routes to knowledge, such as the deliverances of the senses,
are rejected as unreliable and, instead, a basis for certainty is sought in premises
that cannot be shaken by any sceptical hypothesis, however extreme.
There then follows what is probably Descartes' best-known contribution to philosophy,
the famous Kojito argument, put thus,
An amplified form of these reflections are what form the text of his metaphysical masterpiece,
The Meditations on First Philosophy. In the Meditations, Descartes lays down
the philosophical procedure which characterized the modern approach. Admittedly, he was a devout
Christian. But without abandoning his faith, in his Meditations, he turns to philosophy to answer
all his questions, and in that endeavor, he regards the human mind as the instrument of
knowledge and discoverer of truth. His method is radical and thoroughgoing.
It starts with complete scepticism, but a methodological one, in the sense that,
unlike other sceptics, instead of claiming that all knowledge is unreliable or impossible,
he proposes to examine all his beliefs and their sources in order to test their validity and
reliability. Should it happen that none of his beliefs were found to be trustworthy,
then he would be justified in becoming a sceptic. But if his examination should present him with
knowledge which could not be doubted, his method would lead him to truth. Furthermore,
having discovered some indubitable truth, he could then use it as a criterion of truth,
as a test of truth for other propositions. With these assurances, Descartes starts
treading the path of a lonely meditator. The Cogito Argument
Having doubted the very existence of the world around him in the first meditation, using the
fiction of a supremely powerful deceiver who employs all his cunning in order to deceive
the meditator, the meditator discovers one irrefutable certainty expressed in the second
meditation. Thus, let him deceive as he can. He will never bring it about that I am nothing,
so long as I think that I am something. Thus, defeating all scepticism, the Cogito Argument
comes to its culmination, in the bold statement, I think, therefore, I am. Cogito Ergoson
Now, scrutinizing this one proposition which is true and which is known with absolute certainty,
he lays bare a characterizing feature of the same, that is, it is intuited without any possible
doubt, and it is distinctly set off over and against any other proposition. Since this is
the feature which brings out the truth of the Cogito, it can be used as a criterion for any
truth, he then argues. Clear and Distinct Ideas
True propositions are those which can be thought clearly and distinctly, asserts the meditator.
And in the third meditation, from a reflection on the ideas found in his conscious self,
the meditator identifies one idea, that of an infinite and perfect being, namely God,
whose content so far exceeds his capacity that he could not have constructed it from his own
resources. Having known himself as a doubting and uncertain being, the source of such an idea
cannot be himself. Also, it cannot be the world either, for many things that could be found in the
world are rather imperfect and could be improved further. Then the meditator reasons that such an
idea should have been placed in my mind by God himself as it were the mark of the craftsman
impressed on his work, wherefrom it follows that the infinite being God really exists.
The Ontological Proof of God's Existence
A further proof of God's existence is later offered in the fifth meditation, based on the
claim that existence is contained within the very definition or essence of a perfect being.
This is Descartes' version of the so-called ontological argument first formulated by
What is the reality of the idea of perfection? The meditator asks. First, it cannot contain
any limitation, because a limitation could be a sign of imperfection. Second, it cannot be
composed of parts, for partial dependence again is a defect. Now if God is perfection,
then he must be unlimited and his substance should be single, simple and infinite. As unlimited,
uncomposed and infinite, God cannot be dependent upon anything else, whereas all things which are
composite and finite stand in a relation of dependence to God. Then, as the perfect being
so conceived, the idea of his existence should be contained among his necessary attributes.
For to conceive of perfection and yet to conceive of it as non-existent is to conceive an
impossible contradiction in terms. A non-existent perfection would not be perfect. Hence, God must
exist. Thus, the concept of God includes his existence, just as triangularity includes the
idea of three angles being equal to two right angles. The failure to see this is a mistake in
logic, not a mistake in faith. Thus, it comes about that Descartes' investigations led him to
prove logically the existence of a being who for other believers was but an object of faith.
However, a logical foul cry is due at this juncture. If God is to be used to underwrite
the reliability of mind's perceptions, how can we rely on the premises needed to prove his existence
in the first place? This worry, known as the Cartesian circle, was first raised by
Descartes' own contemporaries. Taking into account the whole of Cartesian argument, the logic of the
issue is not so simple as it sounds. So, the debate on the same is still alive. One possibility of
circumventing the issue would be to say that the entire argument which we have tried to trace
is a seamless whole which constitutes an analysis that lays out the whole conceptual setting of
logically related and mutually supporting concepts. Solid foundations for knowledge.
Having established the existence of God, the meditator is able to reconstruct
solid foundations for knowledge based on the mind's clear and distinct ideas
whose reliability is guaranteed by God. This opens the possibility of full and certain knowledge,
both of God and other things, whose nature is intellectual and also concerning the whole of
that nature which is the subject matter of pure mathematics, he claims. Continuing with the project,
now what is the epistemological status of the knowledge of the material world? This is the
meditator's next concern. Status of the material world. Can we say that our knowledge of the
material world is on the same epistemological footing as that of God and ourselves as minds
and the clear and distinct ideas contained during? The meditator answers to the affirmation and just
like the ontological argument cited, he has an ingenious reason for this too. We have perceptions
and they must have a source. The source could be either ourselves or God or some third reality.
It could not be ourselves because most perceptions persist no matter how hard we try to think them
out of existence or deny their reality. They stubbornly intrude themselves on our experience
and persist in their being. God could not be directly manifesting himself in external things
because by now we know that God is no deceiver. If he were directly present in all these things,
we would be aware of his presence in them. But we are not. So God is not the source of
our perceptions. Then the only remaining possibility must be true. Namely, the external
world exists in its own right. Thus the rational demonstration of what can be known is completed.
The methodological doubt has paid off handsomely. Now comes perhaps the most controversial part of
Descartes meditation which is rather metaphysical. Res cogitan and res extensa. In the sixth
meditation, through splendid reasoning again, the meditator comes to the conclusion that
the nature of the mind as a pure thinking substance or res cogitan is entirely distinct
from the nature of body which is extended substance or res extensa and consequently
concludes that it is certain that I am really distinct from the body and can exist without it.
Thus the meditator comes to the radical dualist stance that all material objects including human
bodies have extension that is they exist in space whereas mind has no existence in space
but has the essential property of thought and thought has no extension. Interestingly,
the celebrated mind-body problem takes its formal birth at this turn of the thought adventure.
The mind-body problem. Granted that there are two metaphysically distinct substances
while the thinking non-extended mind and the non-thinking extended matter, the question arises
immediately that how do they interact as they do pretty evidently in the human existence itself.
It is obvious that bodily states, for example, cold or hunger do affect mental states. Conversely,
thought leads to bodily action. If the two substances, the mental and the material,
are fundamentally distinct, how can they interact? This is a so-called mind-body problem.
Descartes was bothered by the problem and did attempt but could not quite solve the problem.
A critic of the project now. The meditations had been pre-circulated in manuscript to some of the
leading philosophers of the day and their critical comments together with Descartes'
responses formed the six sets of objections and replies which were included with the first
edition. Along with the mind-body problem as rightly pointed out in the objections,
there is another important problem with Descartes' dualistic theory of mind and body.
Granted that Descartes has managed to form some conception of himself as a conscious being
without reference to the body, it remains to be shown that the conception so formed is logically
complete and adequate so that we can really have a coherent conception of the thinking self apart
from any physical substrate. Evaluation. Whatever criticism may have accrued,
the boldly self-confident endeavor of the meditator remains a timeless exemplar of the
affirmative and optimistic use of reason in philosophy. It freed philosophy from the grip
of scholasticism and paved way to a whole new series of thoughts responding to the problems
it brought back to focus, thereby proclaiming the beginning of modern era in philosophy.
In it, the rational demonstration of what can be known was conducted true to the spirit of the age
of rising natural sciences, and that very exercise could re-establish the centrality of man in the
cosmos and illustrate the fact that rational capacity of man was pivotal in all further
progress of the mankind. Although the tenor of philosophy today is largely anti-Cartesian,
Descartes' method and writings have exerted an enduring influence in shaping the post-Cartesian
course of philosophy. It remains a fact that the framework of the mind-body problem is still
very largely structured by the set of problems which Descartes uncovered about the nature of
consciousness and its relation to the physical world. In spite of asserting the primacy of minds
over bodies, Descartes had no doubt that we could get reliable knowledge about matter.
Since, for him, the essence of matter is extension, and since extension is an arrangement
in space, to know the essence of material things is to study the mathematical relations governing
those things. And evidently, the developments which have taken place in the physical sciences
ever since endorse this valuable insight. Summary
Marking the dawn of modern era in philosophy, the Cartesian project in philosophy takes off
from the ambition of placing the newly formulated scientific system on secure metaphysical
foundations. As the reclusive meditation of a lonely meditator, he proposes to examine
all his beliefs and their sources in order to test their validity and reliability.
Starting with complete skepticism, but a methodological one, through systematic and
thoroughgoing argument, defeating all skepticism, Descartes reaches one irrefutable certainty,
the cogito, and establishes it as the bedrock of all knowledge. Now, from among the clear and
distinct ideas found therein, he isolates one idea of a perfect being and, focusing around it,
develops the ingenious argument for the existence of God. Having established the existence of God,
the meditator is able to reconstruct solid foundations for knowledge based on the mind's
clear and distinct ideas whose reliability is guaranteed by God. Then, arguing that the
source of perceptions which are real cannot be ourselves or God, but should be the material
world itself, as the only alternative, he establishes the reality of material world as well.
Then a distinction is drawn between the nature of the mind as a pure thinking substance,
or res cogitan, as entirely distinct from the nature of body which is extended substance,
or res extensa, paving way to the mind-body problem and allied issues.
Now, here are some assignments. First, do you find the Cartesian project to be honest to the
spirit of the scientific fervour characteristic of his time, especially when he bases the
reliability of all knowledge on the existence of God? Another, I think therefore I am. Analyse this
Cartesian proposition in the light of personal experience. And one more, do you agree with
the Cartesian metaphysical dualism? If yes, how will you solve the mind-body problem?
If no, what would be your alternative view? Elucidate.
Now, some references. The Philosophical Writings of Descartes. It is a three-volume
set published in 1976, translated by John Cottingham. Another, Descartes by John Cottingham
itself. And one more, The Cambridge Companion to Descartes, published in 1992 by Cambridge
University Press. Thank you for watching this session. We will meet in another session
with a newer topic. Till then, good bye.

