René Descartes - Meditation #1 - The Method of Doubt
Definitely you have hands. Just have some.
These six papers or chapters written by René Descartes in Latin originally in 1641,
these are maybe the most famous, most influential work of philosophy from the 17th and 18th centuries
in Europe. Okay, so let me say something about the author, René Descartes. He was a French
mathematician and philosopher. His name is pronounced Descartes, and when you're talking
about stuff having to do with him, philosophers often use the word Cartesian. Cartesian means
similar to or relating to René Descartes. This guy, French guy, wrote in Latin. He wrote
six meditations. These are six chapters. He calls them meditations, but they're just chapters of a
philosophy book. And in this video, in this video lecture, we're going to talk about the first one,
and then in subsequent lectures, we're going to go through all six of them. So if you're
going to understand what happens in this first meditation, in this first chapter,
then you're going to have to understand the distinction between beliefs that are probably
true, things that you believe that are probably true, and things that you believe that are 100%
guaranteed to be true, definitely true. Let me start with some examples. Here's an example
of a belief that I have, something that I think is true, and it's probably true. I believe
that the speed of light in a vacuum is 299 million meters per second. Okay, that's something that I
believe. Why do I believe that? Well, I believe it because I read it on Wikipedia this morning.
So it's probably true. Like, some very trustworthy scientists, they discovered that
using some experiments, good experiments, and then Wikipedia has some very good procedures in place
for checking the accuracy of the information in their articles online, right? And some articles
are less trustworthy than more articles. Like, Wikipedia has this whole thing where, you know,
they have trouble with articles about people who are still alive. Human beings who are still alive,
they get abused a lot, these articles, and people write false things in them. But this is about the
speed of light, so it's very unlikely that the information in this Wikipedia article is false.
So my belief that the speed of light in a vacuum is 299 million meters per second, that belief goes
in the probably true category. It's not guaranteed to be true because there could be a typo, or
maybe the scientists made a mistake. Scientists can make mistakes. Every claim that science makes
seemingly goes in this category because it is possible for any scientifically based belief
to be false, although probably not. So, probably true beliefs. Those are the sort of things that
go in this category. What sort of things go in this category? Well, we don't know. I can't tell you.
That's because part of Descartes' whole project in the meditations is to figure out what goes over
here. That's what he's going to try to do. Indeed, he's going to try to see if he can support all of
the important things that he believes and demonstrate that they belong in this category.
He's going to try to prove, for example, that the existence of God, he was a religious Christian
French guy in 1640 whatever, right? He's going to try to prove that the existence of God
falls into this category, and a whole bunch of other things, ordinary things about his life,
like that he lives in France or whatever. He wants to prove that that is in this category as well,
if he can. So, in order to figure out what goes in this category, Descartes is going to take
all of his current beliefs, and even if they fall into this category, he's going to stop believing
them. He's going to, as he puts it, treat them as if they're definitely false, and what you do with
definitely false beliefs is you stop believing them. So, all the stuff in this category, he's
going to stop believing them, and he's going to, in that way, wipe out all of his beliefs, and then
he's going to slowly rebuild his system of beliefs. He's only going to believe the things that he
thinks he can prove for certain. This is the word certain here, right? And this is the word uncertain.
He's only going to believe the things that he knows for certain, and he's going to slowly build
back up all of his beliefs, believing new things only if he can support those new beliefs with,
you know, guaranteed, 100% foolproof arguments. That's the plan. Now, this plan takes all six
meditations. In the first meditation, which we're talking about today, and which you read for today,
in the first meditation, he just wipes everything away. That is, he demonstrates that all of these
things that he believes are only probably true, and when he shows that they're only probably true,
that it's possible to doubt them, he stops believing them. That's what he does in meditation
one, is he wipes everything away. He starts with a clean slate. Then, in meditations two, three,
four, five, and six, he brings everything back, demonstrating that all of these beliefs are almost
all of them, right, are actually guaranteed to be true. Okay, so I'm now going to read for you
the two sentences early in meditation one, where Descartes explains that this is his plan. The plan
that I just explained to you, he explains it in two sentences. Here they are. Ready? Reason now
leads me to think that I should hold back my assent from opinions which are not completely
certain and indubitable, just as carefully as I do from those which are patently false,
right? So the idea in this sentence is that, well, what do you do with beliefs that are patently or
obviously false? You hold back your belief from them. That is, you don't believe in those things,
right? If I told you that I rode a unicorn here this morning, you'd say, well, that's obviously
false. I'm not going to believe it. Well, that's what he's going to do for anything that can be
doubted, right? Reason now leads me to think, so this is what I should do if I want to be rational,
right? I should hold back my assent from opinions which are not completely certain and indubitable,
just as carefully as I do from those which are patently false. So hold back my agreement or my
belief in those claims. That's what he's going to do. And then he says, so for the purpose of
rejecting all my opinions, it will be enough if I find in each of them at least one reason for
doubt. So for the purposes of figuring out what's definitely true and for the purposes of wiping out
all of the merely probably true beliefs that he has, all he has to do is find one little sliver
of doubt. And that's enough. If he finds that, he's going to toss that belief out. That's what's
going to happen in the first meditation. But notice there's a problem already, which is that
we've got a lot of beliefs, like way too many to test each one. How many beliefs do you have?
Like a trillion, a trillion, trillion. I mean, you believe now that I told you and you trust me,
you believe that the speed of light in a vacuum is 299 million meters per second. You believe that.
And you believe, I don't know, that North America includes multiple countries. And you believe that
grass is green. You believe lots and lots and lots of stuff. And you can't go through each one of
them and check, oh, is it possible to doubt that? Is there even a sliver of doubt? Is that certain?
That would take forever. And so Descartes comes up with a plan. He has a method, a way of wiping
out all of these beliefs that won't take forever. The name of this method is the method of doubt.
Here's the method. I wrote it out. Consider big groups of beliefs and doubt all the beliefs in
that group. That's the plan. So he's going to take whole swaths of beliefs and prove of all
of them that it's possible that they are false, all the beliefs in that big group. And then once
he's done that, he's going to toss out that whole group. OK, well, how is he going to identify the
groups and toss them out? Well, here's what he says. And to do this, I will not need to run
through them all individually, which would be an endless task. When he says them all, he means all
of my beliefs. It would take forever. It would be an endless task to go through all of my beliefs
and see if I could doubt each one. Once the foundations of a building are undermined,
anything built on them collapses of its own accord. So I will go straight to the basic principles
on which all my former beliefs rested. OK, those two sentences, that's where he explains the method
of doubt. So and that's it. That's the only explanation of the method that we get is those
two sentences. Now, if I read those two sentences and you're thinking to yourself, I don't really
fully get it, don't worry. I'm just going to explain it to you right now. Here's what it is.
The method is to pick out groups of beliefs by the basic principles on which they are based.
How do we understand this whole basic principles bit? I believe a whole bunch of stuff, let's say,
because my grandmother told me those things and I'm using a basic principle, something like this.
Trust whatever my grandmother tells me. That's a basic principle. If I discover that my grandmother
sometimes lies, sometimes, well then I've doubted this basic principle. I've shown that even though
my grandmother, you know, typically leads me towards the truth, it's possible that she's been
lying to me. And so all of the things that I believe because my grandmother told me those
things, they all fall into this category of merely probably true. And if they fall into this category,
then Descartes is going to toss them. And so I'm going to toss them in this example. Right. And so
by doubting this one basic principle, I've doubted a whole bunch of beliefs like, let's say, a thousand
or two thousand or ten thousand things that I believe because my grandmother told me those
things. That's the method of doubt. So Descartes is going to try to figure out what basic principles
underlie all of his beliefs. And then he's going to see if he can doubt the basic principles and
he will be able to doubt them. They won't be certain. And then once he's done that, he's going
to stop believing all of the things that are based on those basic principles. And he's going to go
through enough basic principles to get rid of all of his beliefs. That's the plan for this
meditation. That's the method of doubt. And in this quote, these two sentences that I read about
the method of doubt, he gives this metaphor with like a building and the foundation of the building.
Here's what's going on. Let's say you've got a house and the house is made of sticks. These are
the sticks of the house. OK, here's the door, I guess. Whatever. OK, that's your house. It's made
of sticks. It's a crappy house. You don't like it. The roof leaks and, you know, the wind, it's
drafty. Whatever. You don't like this house. You want a new house, a firmer house, a sturdier house.
Well, what do you do? First thing you got to do is you got to demolish your old house and then
you're going to build a new house with like bricks or something better. It would take too long to
pluck off each stick individually. So what you do is you go to the foundation. The foundation is the
bottom of the house. You go to the bottom and you find the sticks that all the other sticks are
resting on. And if you just pull this one out, well, then a whole bunch of the other sticks are
going to fall. And then you find another one down here. You pull that one out and then this side
falls. Next thing you know, you've done your first step. You've demolished the house. That's what
Descartes is doing, except for he's doing it with his beliefs. In Meditation One, he's finding the
basic principles on which the other beliefs are based, doubting those. Everything falls down. He
stops believing everything. And then starting in Meditation Two, he's going to build everything
back up again on a firmer foundation. That's the idea. So far, we've only talked about four
sentences of this whole meditation. We got the big plan for all the meditations. That was in
those first two sentences that I read that appear in the second paragraph or whatever. We had
those two sentences. And then we had the two sentences explaining the method of doubt. In the very
next sentence, Descartes immediately starts to go through his basic principles. He's not doing
anything with principles about his grandmother. That was just an example that I gave. He's
going to immediately introduce a principle and he's going to immediately
undermine it in the next two sentences. Here's what he says. Whatever I have up till now accepted
as most true, I have acquired either from the senses or through the senses. Okay, let's stop there.
All right, that's the first basic principle that he's going to consider. The idea is that he believes
things because he discovers those things, those facts, putative facts. He discovers them through
his senses, through his sense of sight and smell and taste and touch and hearing and whatever other
senses there are. That's the first principle. The first principle is trust whatever my senses tell
me. Okay, in the very next sentence, he doubts this principle. Here's what he says to doubt it.
But from time to time, I have found that the senses deceive and it is prudent never to trust
completely those who have deceived us even once. The idea is that sometimes your senses get things
wrong. I see a spider on the wall and I jump back because I see it with my eyes. But then it turns
out that the spider wasn't really a spider. It was just a smudge on the wall. So my senses deceived
me. It seemed like there was a spider there. But then on closer inspection, it turns out it's not
a spider. The idea is that anything that Descartes believes because he sees it or hears it or smells
it or tastes it or touches it or anything like that, well, those things aren't guaranteed to be
true. They're just probably true. The senses can get things wrong and so he's going to wipe out those
beliefs. What he then does in the next couple sentences is he actually pulls back. He says,
that was too quick. I don't want to get rid of everything that my senses tell me. Not all at once
because some things that my senses tell me are more reliable than other things. Here's what he
says. Yet, although the senses occasionally deceive us with respect to objects which are very small
or in the distance, there are many other beliefs about which doubt is quite impossible, even though
they are derived from the senses. For example, that I am here, sitting by the fire, wearing a winter
dressing gown, holding this piece of paper in my hands, and so on. Again, how could it be denied
that these hands or this whole body are mine? What he's saying there is, look, it's true that
I shouldn't trust whatever my senses tell me, he says, about
small or distant things. So the spider, in the example that I gave before, the spider is a
about small things like spiders, but my hands, I sense that I have hands. Or Descartes is like some
rich French guy, so he's in like a, I don't even know if he was rich actually, sorry. Forget that
he was rich, but he's some French guy and he's sitting in his winter dressing gown, whatever that
is. The fact that you're wearing clothes, that's not like a little spider, something far away that
you can be wrong about. Definitely you have hands, just have some. Definitely you are wearing
clothes, sitting by the fire, or sitting in your house, or whatever. That stuff is not
undermined. Those beliefs, the beliefs about the fact that you have hands, that sort of stuff,
that isn't undermined by the fact that your senses can deceive you. Only the things that
you believe about small or distant things. So the first principle, he sort of revises it. He's still
doubted a lot of things. He's doubted his beliefs about far away things or whatever,
right? And he's doubted them based on the fact that, well, senses can deceive. Did I spell deceive
right? I don't know. Whatever. Anyway, so we've got a principle, it was a revised principle,
and now we've doubted it. So we've wiped away, Descartes has wiped away all of his beliefs
about small or distant things. Things that he's seen only from a distance. But if he got up close
to something, or if something was large and he could see it clearly, or smell it clearly without
anything in the way, or hear it without any distortion, or I guess, or whatever, right?
Then he thinks he can trust it, right? That's the second principle. The next principle is that he
can trust whatever his senses tell him about large and nearby things. We've already eliminated all
the beliefs that were based on this principle, because we doubted this principle based on this.
And now we've got this principle. So Descartes is looking to see if there's any reason to think,
any sliver of doubt, any reason to think that this principle might not be a good one on the
basis of which to acquire beliefs. Trust whatever your senses tell you about large, nearby things,
like the fact that you have hands. Well, he does think that there's reason to doubt this basic
principle, and it happens only like three or four sentences later. Here's what he says.
How often, asleep at night, am I convinced of just such familiar events that I am here
in my dressing gown sitting by the fire, when in fact I am lying undressed in bed?
Right? The idea is that we have dreams at night, and it's possible to dream that you are
sitting by the fire in your dressing gown, when really you're not sitting by the fire,
and you're not in your dressing gown. Really, you're in bed, and you're naked, undressed,
or maybe in your French pajamas, or whatever. I don't know. Okay? The idea is that I could
be dreaming. We can't trust our senses for sure. We can't be sure that our senses are giving us
guaranteed true beliefs about even large and nearby things, because we could be dreaming.
He even points out that we have no way of telling that we're dreaming while we're dreaming,
so we can't just check to see if we're dreaming, and then on the basis of that,
you know, if the test goes right, then just believe all the stuff about large and nearby
things. Here's what he says. As I think about this more carefully, I see plainly that there are never
any sure signs, by means of which being awake can be distinguished from being asleep. There are
never any sure signs. There's nothing you can do while you're dreaming, like pinch yourself,
or whatever, that would prove that you are either dreaming, or awake, or whatever. Because here's
the thing. You could always just dream that you pinch yourself. Whatever test you might try to run
to determine that, you know, oh, I'm not dreaming, and I can trust my senses, or whatever.
You could just dream that you ran that test. So the fact that it's possible to dream
means that this basic principle is undermined, and now Descartes has doubted away all of the
things he believes based on his senses, like that he owns a dressing gown and lives in France,
all that stuff. That's all gone. Oh, I forgot some things. Things that I was going to mention
earlier in the video, and I just remembered them now, so I'm going to say them now,
and maybe I'll edit the video so that this comes at the beginning, or maybe not. I don't know.
Anyway, that quote that I just read, that comes from page A.T. 19. A.T. 19. Let me just tell you
about these page numbers, which I will occasionally be referring to, right? It stands for Adam and
Tannery. Those were two French guys in like 1890-something, I don't know. They were the
editors of a big, long, multi-volume book in French of all of Descartes' writings. Okay,
so they wrote this book, and the book had page numbers. And modern scholars, modern philosophers,
when they're talking about Descartes, they're all using different translations and different
versions of Descartes' writing that were different publishings and all that sort of
stuff in all these different languages, and they need to know that they're on the same page.
So everyone uses the page numbering from this edition, this Adam and Tannery. These are two
people. I can't remember their first names. Whatever. One guy's last name is Adam, and the
other one's last name is Tannery, right? And so they say A.T. 19. That means in the Adam and
Tannery volume that was published in whatever year, or it could have been a little later,
I think volumes were published over the course of like a decade or whatever.
Anyway, in that book, it's on page 19 in that book. And so all of the decent current translations
of Descartes' work from Latin, all of those, they'll note the A.T. page numbers. And so
occasionally I will note the A.T. page numbers. Notice something. We've gone through a lot. Like
a lot's happened already. We're not done with meditation one yet, but we got Descartes' plan
for the whole, all six meditations. We got that. Then we got Descartes' method of doubt that he's
going to use in the first meditation to doubt away all of his beliefs, right? And then we got the,
right? And that was the idea that he's going to use basic principles, undermine the basic principles
or doubt them. And that's going to allow him to doubt all the beliefs that were based on those
basic principles. So we got the plan for all six meditations. We got the plan for meditation one.
And then we've gotten most of the way through executing this plan. We've already got two basic
principles and the reasons to doubt those two basic principles. All of this so far has happened
in like eight sentences. So the work is dense. And occasionally when I'm teaching this material
in a regular in-person classroom, which is how most of my teaching occurs, you know, and I try
to like make chitchat with the students in the first few minutes of class before everyone gets
there, everyone's coming into the room, and I'll say, how was the reading? What did you think of
the reading for today? The students will often say it was repetitive, but it's not repetitive.
Actually, the text moves very fast. Things change in one sentence or two sentences. He's giving us
the plan for the whole meditations. Then he's done with that and he's already moved on to the next
thing, which is explaining the method that he's going to use in this first meditation. So the pace
is actually very quick. Things don't repeat. They move on to the next thing, but it seems like
they're repetitive. The reason that it seems like they're repetitive is that, for example, Descartes
will keep talking about deception over and over. And so it seems like, well, it's just the
same stuff. He says, deception and deceiving, it's all about deception and deceiving. Yes, that's right.
It is all about deception and deceiving and the possibility that you're mistaken or whatever, but
he's saying importantly different things. And this is true of not just of Descartes, but of all the
philosophy that we're going to read in this course, right? Very different things at very different
points. And so you're just going to have to read these texts with an incredible degree of focus,
because if you miss just one sentence, we could have moved on to some very important next thing.
Anyway, that's just a side note. We've now doubted, we've gotten two principles on the board and we've
doubted each one of them, right? So I'm building a sort of little chart over here, right? And this
little chart on this side, it has the principles and then over here it has the reasons to doubt
those principles and thereby doubt the beliefs that are based on those principles. Okay, so we
have the principles and the doubt. At this point, we've doubted away a lot. We've doubted everything
that you believe based on your senses, right? So we've doubted, you know, that you, I don't know,
are wearing clothes, that you've ever worn clothes. We're doubting that you have a family.
We're doubting that the continents exist. We're doubting everything because all of that stuff,
you only believe those things because you've either seen them or you've seen someone who
told you about them. I believe that the speed of light in a vacuum is 299 million meters per second.
Yes, I believe that, but I believe it because I like listened to an audiobook or read the Wikipedia
entry and all of that requires my senses. So we've doubted a lot. We don't know that we have hands.
We don't know that we have clothes. We don't know that the earth exists. We don't know that
the speed of light is 299 million meters per second. What do we have left? What are the
beliefs that Descartes hasn't yet doubted so far at this point? A few paragraphs into Meditation 1.
He then lists some stuff that he hasn't yet doubted. Here's the list. The first thing that
he thinks he hasn't yet doubted, this happens by the way on AT19, he makes this point, is that
colors exist. Colors exist. Now, he's not saying that any specific things have any specific colors.
He just thinks that you couldn't dream that there was some color that didn't exist. You could only
dream of a color if there really was such a color, he thinks. Okay, so he thinks that the fact that
some colors exist is not something that one, you know, well, one only discovers because of one's
well, could deceive him about. Then he thinks that he still knows that corporeal, corporeal means
coming from a corpse or a body, right? Corporeal or material stuff is extended. Bodily stuff,
physical stuff like a human body or a table or a chair or a mountain or whatever, that stuff
is extended. This is going to be a very important term in this course. Extended means stretched out
in space, located and distributed through space. Like, you know, this marker is extended. It's like
it extends from here to here, like it's stretched out and then it extends from here to here.
That's its extension. That's what Descartes means by extension, stretched out in space. He's not
saying that he knows about any specific physical stuff, any specific bodies, human bodies, tables,
chairs or anything. He's not even saying actually that any physical stuff exists. It's just that
if it does exist, it takes up space, right? And he thinks that that's just because it's the
definition. That's the definition of corporeal or material stuff. This all happens on AT20,
page AT20 in the reading. Anyway, so that's, he thinks is true by definition and so he didn't
learn it through his senses. He also thinks that the truths of arithmetic and geometry,
those truths, they are not yet called into doubt. He thinks that we don't learn, he's right about
this by the way, we don't learn arithmetic or geometric truths. We don't demonstrate that
they're true through the senses. Now, this might seem weird to you. Like, you might think, look,
the way that I know or demonstrate or come to believe truths of arithmetic, like, you know,
one plus two equals three. The way that you came to know that is through your senses. Like,
you listened in elementary school or whatever when the teacher told you that one plus two
equals three and that's how you came to learn this fact. So, why aren't arithmetic truths
called into doubt by the fact that you could be dreaming? Maybe you were dreaming back when your
teacher said this thing. Descartes thinks, and he's right by the way, although that's the way
that we sort of learn about mathematical facts, that's not the way that we support them. That's
not the way that we demonstrate that they're true. We don't demonstrate that they're true
through the senses. This right here, this is not the number three. Take a look. It's not.
It's the numeral, the Arabic numeral three, the Arabic numeral three, which represents the number
itself, right? The number three, you've never seen the number three. The number three isn't in space.
You can't find it in, like, your bedside drawer or whatever. The number three, if it exists at
all, whatever that means, it doesn't exist in space. This is a numeral. This is a bunch of
ink on a board. Here's another numeral. This is called the Roman numeral. You may be familiar with
these from the Super Bowl or whatever. Roman numeral three, Arabic numeral three. The number
three is a totally different thing. When we figure out facts about the number three, we figure those
facts out not by, you know, smelling a numeral or whatever. We figure these facts out by just
defining what three is in our minds and then thinking very, very clearly in a way that does
not rely on the senses. Thinking very, very clearly about the nature of the number three
and the number of two and one and addition and whatever, right? So, arithmetic and geometric
truths, the same is true for a triangle. Like, this is not a triangle. This is a drawing of a triangle.
Triangles don't exist in the world because they are, well, triangles are supposed to be
two-dimensional enclosed polygons or whatever, but this isn't two-dimensional. It's just a bunch of
ink and the ink has depth to it. This is not a triangle. Anyway, the facts about triangles and
the facts about numbers, triangles and numbers, those facts, we discover them not through the
senses or we demonstrate that they're true not through the senses but by pure thought, Descartes
claims. So, we've got all of these beliefs that still have not been doubted. Here's what Descartes
says next. And yet, firmly rooted in my mind is the long-standing opinion that there is an omnipotent
god who made me the kind of creature that I am. How do I know that he has not brought it about,
that there is no earth, no sky, no extended thing, no shape, no size, no place, while at the same
time ensuring that all these things appear to me to exist just as they do now? Descartes points out
that it is possible for a creature to trick him. He thinks even about all of these things. He
doesn't actually go through these three as clearly as I would have liked, but the thought is that if
there was a creature powerful enough, like God, then that creature could trick Descartes into
thinking that colors exist, even if colors don't exist, or that there's material stuff that
is extended when really there is no material stuff and nothing is extended and that sort of
thing. And also, Descartes doesn't say this in that passage, but he also thinks that God could trick
him about arithmetic and geometry, right? Even though he doesn't come to believe those things
because of his senses, he does come to believe them because he thinks about them and a sufficiently
powerful creature could plant in his mind some incorrect geometrical or mathematical thoughts.
Descartes, you know, thinks, well, God, God wouldn't deceive him, but he realizes that it is at least
coherent to imagine a creature that is as powerful as God but is not good. And so here's what he says.
This is one of the most famous passages in the meditations. Here he goes,
I will suppose, therefore, that not God, who is supremely good and the source of truth, but rather
some malicious demon of the utmost power and cunning has employed all of his energies in order
to deceive me. Okay, let me pause there actually. The idea is that, well, we've got this lingering
principle and that lingering principle is going to be doubted by the possibility that there is a
malicious demon that is as powerful as God but not as good as God and it's trying to fool him. So
here's the remaining principle that all of his remaining beliefs are based on. Okay, this is the
last basic principle. Trust the truths of arithmetic, geometry, the general nature of corporeal
objects, the existence of shapes and colors and that sort of thing. That's just this stuff, right?
Okay, that's the lingering principle and he thinks he can doubt this principle too.
And the way that he doubts it is by considering the fact that he might be currently under the
deception of some all-powerful malicious demon. So now he's doubted everything. He's even doubted
this stuff because it's possible that he could be wrong about all of these things, not because he
came to these beliefs because of his senses but because he came to these beliefs because of
something about his mind and that's all stuff that a malicious demon, an all-powerful creature
that was evil, that's all stuff that that sort of creature could fool him about and there could be
such a creature. He doesn't think that there is such a creature. He's operating under the assumption
that there's such a creature. He's assuming that there's such a creature and when you assume that
you get rid of all these beliefs just like when you assume that you're dreaming you get rid of
all the beliefs that are based on your senses like the belief that you're, you know, wearing
your dressing gown by the fire or whatever. I'll just read this last passage. It's a sort of longer
passage and I just read the first sentence but here goes.
...which he has devised to ensnare my judgment. I shall consider myself as not having hands or eyes
or flesh or blood or senses but as falsely believing that I have all these things. I shall
stubbornly and firmly persist in this meditation and even if it is not in my power to know any
truth I shall at least do what is in my power, that is, resolutely guard against assenting to
any falsehoods so that the deceiver, however powerful and cunning he may be, will be unable
to impose on me in the slightest degree. He's going to stop believing all of this stuff.
That's where meditation one ends. He stops believing everything and so if there were a
malicious demon at least this malicious demon wouldn't be tricking Descartes into believing
in the existence of things that don't exist. We're at the end of meditation one and Descartes has
wiped out all of his beliefs. This is everything. He's got nothing left. What's going to happen at
the beginning of meditation two is that Descartes is going to find one belief, one claim that he
thinks a malicious demon could not trick him about, couldn't fool him about. There's one thing
that he thinks he knows has got to be 100% guaranteed, certain, has to be true. There's
going to be one thing at the beginning of meditation two and then from that one thing
he's going to try to build up all of the beliefs that he has now just doubted away. One last note
before we end this video on meditation one. Notice that there are different basic principles and that
they were doubted on the basis of different, right, so like his belief in geometry and arithmetic
he didn't undermine those beliefs because he could be dreaming. No, he undermined them because
there could be a malicious demon and the beliefs that his senses are reliable sources of truths
about large and nearby things, that wasn't doubted based on the malicious demon or that senses can
deceive but that he could be dreaming. So make sure you've got all this straight, right. Which
principles are the foundations of which beliefs and then which doubts undermine which principles?
Get all this straight. I'm definitely going to put some questions on the exam about that.

