Ranking Member Peters' Questions - April 15, 2026 - Second Amendment Hearing

HSGAC Dems
31 followers
Apr 20, 2026
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
You know, the Constitution guarantees each of us certain liberties, including the freedom
to speak our mind, practice our religion, receive due process, and the right to bear
arms, as we've been talking about here today.
Our framers knew that the freedoms protected under our Constitution, however, would be
at risk if any one branch of government was allowed to go unchecked.
They didn't trust anybody in government, figured you had to make sure there were checks and
balances.
Ronald Reagan, I think, explained the importance of this system of checks and balances very
well, and I'll just quote Ronald Reagan.
The genius of our constitutional system is its recognition that no one branch of government
alone could be relied on to preserve our freedoms.
The great safeguard of our liberty is the totality of the constitutional system, with
no one part getting the upper hand.
Professor Vladek, as you noted in your testimony, President Trump has gone to war with Iran
without congressional approval, as required in the Constitution, usurped Congress's appropriations
powers under Article I powers are being usurped, and turned federal agencies against American
citizens, all, well, unfortunately, most of my Republican colleagues have either cheer
him on or they just kind of look the other way.
So my question for you, sir, is, is Congress currently functioning as a co-equal branch
of government, as outlined in the Constitution, and if not, what is the danger that we're
facing right now?
What should the American people be concerned about?
I mean, the short answer, of course, is no, and I think the danger is both a short-term
danger, Senator, and a long-term danger, and just briefly, the short-term danger is that
without Congress, without the President having to look over his shoulder, there is nothing
to stop him from engaging in ever more aggressive usurpation of appropriations, spending money
he doesn't have, not spending money he's supposed to, violating individual rights in
context in which there's no way to challenge that in court, and going on ever more misguided,
misbegotten military operations, all to the detriment of our national security, of our
economy, of our rights.
Senator, in the long term, this destabilizes the ability of Congress to ever exercise those
powers again.
We have a Supreme Court that has interpreted the separation of powers by reference to what
Justice Frankfurter called historical gloss.
If the gloss of the 2020s is that the President can do whatever he wants, as long as a majority
of Congress isn't going to stop him, that is a gloss that can be deployed by future
presidents, Senator, with whom you and I might agree more, to do plenty of things that I
think would be deeply problematic for our rule-of-law society.
Well, you mentioned the courts as a possible check.
Obviously, Congress is a major check, and I would argue that our founders always thought
Congress was the preeminent of the three branches.
We are Article I.
But the courts are important, and unfortunately, we've seen this administration, based on recent
actions, believes that they are above the law, including court decisions.
Time and time again, judges have found that the administration has violated court orders.
One federal judge found that the Department of Homeland Security had, quote, utterly disregarded
the court's earlier order and made, quote, no attempt to offer any justification for
their blatant lack of effort to comply, thumbing their nose at the court.
Another found that ICE failed or refused to provide information ordered by the court.
Another case found that DOJ, quote, elected to simply ignore valid court orders.
And I want to be clear.
These are not liberal activist judges, as President Trump and some of my colleagues
would claim.
All of these quotes come from judges that were appointed by Donald Trump.
These are judges he appointed who saw how outrageous it was for them to ignore these
orders.
So what does it mean for Americans if there is not a consistent adherence to the rule
of law and some laws just simply don't get followed?
Yeah, I mean, you know, John Adams at the founding said, ours is a government of laws,
not of men.
A world in which the executive branch doesn't abide by court orders and faces no repercussions
in Congress for violating court orders is a world in which that's not true.
And it's a world in which the president can do what he wants.
And Senator, we may not care.
Too many people may not care about those cases because those are immigration detention cases.
But if the government puts one of us in immigration detention and says you're not a U.S. citizen,
even if it's a mistake, the only way to get out is a government that's going to comply
with an adverse court order.
That's the problem.
That's the slippery slope.
And it is very slippery.
And it's one that we're falling down way too quickly.
Thank you.
The Fourth Amendment protects us from unjustified invasions of privacy by the government.
However, this administration has basically disregarded decades-old privacy protections
to combine and share Americans' most sensitive tax, health, and social security data.
It's tracking Americans' location using data brokers.
It's monitoring their social media activity and potentially even using spyware to break
into the phones of Americans.
It's very concerned about these activities.
So my question for you, sir, or Professor Lattek, is at the time when so many people
choose to share all kinds of details online, why should we be concerned about information
the government is collecting right now, and how might they use these tools against us?
I mean, I think that the concern, Senator, has been driven home by what we've seen this
administration do, which is retaliating against people because of, for example, what's in
their social media profiles, denying visas to non-citizens who have done nothing wrong
other than perhaps express sympathy for Palestinians.
That is not supposed to be how the government uses our data.
And there is a rich tradition, Senator, as you well know, of this Congress actually stepping
in to protect Americans' privacy rights even before the courts have had a chance to do
so.
The Wiretap Act was a response to the Supreme Court's refusal to apply the Fourth Amendment
to wiretaps.
That's the kinds of conversations we should be having about what's happening in our government
right now, not the possibility that some state laws might be subject to challenge in court
where those challenges are deeply available.
I agree.
The chairman and I agree.
I mean, this has been an issue with both parties over time.
In my opening comments, it was very clear that we have seen Congress give powers to
the executive on a continuous basis.
I think we could argue whether or not it's accelerating or not, which was part of your
point, Professor.
But to that point, with War Powers, I know, Mr. Chairman, I would actually like to hear
your answer to the question our colleague asked about War Powers.
We're actually interested in learning about that, not just giving a speech.
Yeah.
I mean, I think the point I was trying to make to Senator Johnson is that I think presidents
of both parties have abused the War Powers, and I don't think it's a particularly Democratic
or Republican or conservative or liberal phenomenon.
Presidents are going to use the powers they have, Senator.
And so I think part of the problem is that we have seen perhaps more aggressive pushback
when the president was a Democrat, perhaps because those were periods when you had some
cross-party control.
And so we have seen more aggressive pushback when a different party has controlled one
or both chambers of Congress than when it's been the same party.
And that's been true in both directions.
It seems to me the result should not be to say so-and-so is a hypocrite, but rather to
say, well, then let's fix the problem, period, as opposed to let's fix the problem when someone
else is in charge.
Yeah.
I think that's right.
And the checks and balances works.
Sometimes when you don't have one control, one party in all control based on the partisanship
that we're seeing in the country right now, unfortunately.
Professor, you also state in your testimony that the Trump administration has taken sweeping
actions to undermine the First Amendment.
The chair of the Federal Communications Commission threatened ABC for airing a comedian who criticized
the administration.
This administration has also revoked the press credentials of journalists whose coverage
it basically didn't like.
It targeted law firms, universities, and former government officials because it didn't like
their protected speech, and is trying to use federal grants now to force organizations
to adopt the president's political ideology with federal money.
Could you talk about Congress's role in addressing the scale of the Trump administration's systemic
violations, particularly of the First Amendment right now?
Yeah.
I mean, it seems like there are a couple of different things that Congress could do and
that prior Congresses have done.
I mean, I think the first is more robust oversight, using, for example, nominations hearings,
using oversight hearings, using budget hearings as opportunities to ask the administration
what exactly it's doing and why.
I think there are ways in which Congress could condition funding for some of these agencies
on not engaging in those behaviors.
It is not unconstitutional for Congress to condition federal funds on the administration
refusing to retaliate.
But also, Senator, I think Congress could make it easier for those who are having their
speech chilled in these contexts to sue directly, because I don't think it's possible, even
for a well-meaning Congress, to actually enforce every single flashpoint between the
government and its citizens.
That's why I think the absence of a meaningful remedy, even for ephemeral constitutional
violations, is something that has been exposed over and over again as a structural flaw of
our current moment.
Professor, you also noted in your testimony the Constitution grants Congress, not the
president, the power to decide how the government spends taxpayer money.
This power of the purse allows us to basically serve as a check on abuses by the executive
branch.
After two American citizens were shot and killed by DHS officers as a result of the
administration's tactics, many of us tried to use Congress's spending power to ensure
reform as well as accountability.
But when the president decides to ignore Congress and claims the spending power for himself,
not Congress, it leaves Congress basically with no leverage and the American people with
basically no accountability.
So my question for you, sir, is are you aware of other instances in history where the president
has violated Congress's power to appropriate funds and Congress basically did absolutely
nothing?
And what are the consequences when the administration ignores Congress's appropriations power as
granted in Article I of the Constitution?
Senator, I'm not aware of another example where we saw this degree of appropriations
misbehavior by the executive branch and no congressional reaction.
I think, as you know, the Empowerment Control Act itself was Congress's response to not
comparable, but at least loosely analogous behavior by the Nixon administration.
And Congress responded by, I think, quite powerfully reclaiming its power and indeed
authorizing, Senator, some of the behavior President Nixon had engaged in while prohibiting
the rest of it.
And it seems to me that that is the point I would have liked to have made to Senator
Johnson, which is you can think the president having this power is a good thing or not.
The point is that Congress has to provide it.
And so it seems like what is missing from this conversation is the idea that if we like
what the president is doing, we shouldn't worry about the separation of powers.
Just to quote the Supreme Court for a second, it would be ironic if in the name of national
defense we would sanction the subversion of one of our civil liberties that makes defense
of the nation worthwhile.
