Codes and Copyright Protections: Johnson's Opening Remarks at Subcommittee Hearing

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Apr 21, 2026
TW: @HouseJudiciary | FB: HouseJudDems | IG: HouseJudDems | M: /HouseJudiciary
Thank you Mr. Chairman and thank you to the witnesses for your appearances today for this
very important hearing. When I get home to Georgia after a long week, I get off the plane,
take the airport rail to my car, pick up my car from the parking area, and once I get home I park
the car, walk into my house, cut the lights on. I might fix some hot tea after pouring some water
and heating it up in the microwave. And I really think about it, but all of these steps from the
airport to my house are governed by codes developed by Standards Developing Organizations or SDOs.
Standards governing everything from light rail and parking garages to home fire codes and water
piping touch each of us in our everyday lives. When a contractor works on your house or a
firefighter inspects your workplace for fire safety, they have to consult their respective
codes. While most of us know that these codes exist, we rarely consider where those codes
come from. An important part to you and me is that the standards in those codes work.
They keep us safe. They keep our lives running. With us, none the wiser. SDOs regularly get
together and come up with the state-of-the-art guidelines for their trades. These best practices
govern everything from consumer safety and household utility installation to home electrical
wiring and plumbing. SDOs make sure your house won't catch on fire, your plumbing is up to code,
your water boiler is installed correctly, and everything in between. If you live in an area
that might be affected by floods or by earthquakes, you want to ensure your house is
built to withstand natural disasters. You rely on your local contractor and your contractor relies
on their SDO standards. Now, so far as this sounds like a great hearing for the Transportation and
Infrastructure Committee, which I also serve on, the reason why this is in the Intellectual
Property Subcommittee of Judiciary is because this subcommittee cares about standards and is
because of a recent circuit court decision, actually recent court decisions that have made
harder for SDOs to assert their copyright when others post their codes online.
States and local governments frequently adopt SDO-developed codes by reference into law.
They do this for a few reasons, but primarily because the government doesn't have the funds
to employ experts to develop a unique building code and do not update the law often enough to
keep up with the changes of society and in best practices. So, Georgia, for example,
can refer to the National Fire Protection Association's most updated or up-to-date code
in their laws. That way, the law is always up-to-date and they don't have to pay experts
to develop something new. This is the point where intellectual property issues arise.
Some point to the Supreme Court's Georgia versus public resource.org decision and say,
quote, that no one owns the law. If you can't access the code, you don't know what the law says
and Americans have a reasonable interest in knowing they can access the laws that govern them.
Others point out that SDOs fund their work by selling their copyrighted material to
experts who use it to make necessary evaluations, repairs, and installations.
Without this rigorous development and dedication to constant improvement, they argue American
standards would fall behind. So, we find ourselves in a dilemma. Once the code is law,
it seems only reasonable that Americans should be able to figure out what the law says.
On the other hand, SDOs fund their work, which we rely on to keep us safe through the sale
of their copyrighted works. We also have an interest in ensuring these codes always reflect
the highest possible standards, and they can't do that without income or revenue.
Multiple circuit court decisions have found that publication of codes incorporated by
reference is fair use. So, if we want to ensure that SDOs retain their copyright,
legislation is necessary. The question is, what kind of legislation?
Last Congress, I voted in favor of the Pro Codes Act, but at the time I expressed concern
that we hadn't had a fact-finding hearing to listen to all the different sides to this issue.
I understand that there are quite a few different perspectives represented here,
and I commend my colleague Chairman Issa for working with me to put together a panel of
witnesses that can speak to the many facets of the copyright problems with incorporation by
reference. I look forward to hearing from the witnesses, and I yield back the remainder of my
time.
