ONE OF A KIND! SpaceX Genius New Stage Separation System Mechanism!

Tech Swell
39 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 16, 2022
With SpaceX planning to fly the full Starship prototype for its first orbital flight in a few
weeks, many are left wondering what separation mechanism it is going to use and how it will
function. Will it work better than a multi-stage separation system and set Starship as the rocket
of the future? Join us as we explore what SpaceX plans to achieve with their new stage separation
system and their determination to boldly go where no man has gone before. Starship Stage
Separation System The Starship is a reusable vehicle regarded as one of the most advanced
and largest in the world. It is made up of two main stages, the upper stage called Starship
and the Super Heavy Booster. This two-stage setup will separate on its launch and typically there
are two launch vehicle separation strategies to achieve this, all requiring some frangible
bolts or actuating latch to attach and detach the upper and lower stages. With the commonly
used strategy, the vehicle's upper stages are jettisoned from the lower stage before igniting
its engines, either vernier thrusters or small solid rocket motors, and heading to the Earth's
orbit. The second method uses hot staging, where the separating upper stage ignites its engines
before or at the same time as its release, blasting the lower stage in the process.
Attempting to do away with decades of precedents and experiments, SpaceX has decided to remove
any recognizable separation system using spring-like mechanisms that can be tested on the
ground and reused. This was decided at some point during the design and testing process, with Elon
Musk calling the use of existing separation mechanisms superfluous since the same effect
can be achieved by using the existing systems on Super Heavy. So what are they going to do?
Instead of the pushing separation system, Starship will rely on conservation of angular momentum to
Before the main engine cutoff, the Super Heavy booster will use its gimbling engines to cause
the vehicle to rotate. The latches connecting the Starship to Super Heavy will release,
causing the two stages to gradually float apart, similar to how SpaceX deploys its Starlink
satellites from Falcon by spinning the upper stage and leaving the spacecraft to rely on
centripetal forces. Since Starship is five times heavier than Super Heavy during separation,
it will move away from the booster in a straight line. The cold gas thruster on the ship will settle
its propellant, and its six Raptor engines will be ignited as it heads towards orbit.
The separation process will also initiate the booster's flip,
necessary for conducting the boost backburn. This approach is largely possible due to the
six Raptor engines tucked away in the skirt of the Starship, as there is no chance of nozzle
damage by impacting the booster's interstage. If this unorthodox deployment system is successful,
SpaceX can effectively preclude the development of a spring system with the ability to push a
1,300-ton ship away from the Super Heavy booster. To aid its safe return to Earth,
SpaceX will replace the hot gas thruster on the booster with eulogic gas tanks. The eulogic gas
will help to increase altitude control of the booster during the flip by having four vents
spaced 90 degrees apart. The Super Heavy booster will be outfitted with four flaps called grid fins
to exact a form of aerodynamic control on the booster and bear the stress of landing.
This addition has long been expected since 2016, when the original form of Starship was released.
Unlike the cast titanium grid fins of Falcon booster, the fins are built with welded steel,
a cheaper but heavier material. They are not spaced 90 degrees apart like the design of the Falcon 9,
because the weight of the Super Heavy means that it requires more pitch control than a Falcon Heavy.
Each of the car-sized grid fins weighs roughly three tons, but the mass of each grid will be
cut in half as the vehicle becomes more optimized and more mass needs to be cut off. The grid fins
are electrically powered, using a modified Tesla Model 3 motor to drive them. Unlike what we see
in the Falcon 9, there is no sophisticated retraction system for the fins cutting off mass,
unnecessary complexity, and failure modes. Additionally, the constant deployment of the
fins doesn't have a significant effect, as there is still enough strength to push and drag the
rocket at hypersonic speeds, assuming that they are not at a high angle of attack.
As the Super Heavy returns to Earth, the original plan was to execute a vertical landing,
initiating a landing sequence to slow the rocket on the descent. The landing burn will begin before
touchdown and provide the booster with a soft descent before landing back on Earth. This is
something SpaceX has done a couple of times with Falcon 9, but the Starship is a horse of a
different color, and to handle it properly, all you have to do is hit the like button if you've
been enjoying the video and subscribe to the channel. Once stacked, the Starship is almost
twice the size of a Falcon Heavy, and getting them to land directly on the ground will be much harder
and more complicated than one might expect. So for the Super Heavy to land without significant
damage, Elon Musk has developed a means of catching the booster right before it hits the ground.
As it performs its descent, the booster will aim to fall in between two building-sized arms fixed
to SpaceX's rocket-catching launch tower. This is the same tower responsible for attaching the
upper and lower stages of the Starship as it prepares for takeoff. The final speed reduction
and shock forces will be transferred to the launch tower and its robotic arms, marking the descent
complete. SpaceX began a series of proof tests in January for its robotic launch tower, closing and
opening the arms to see how well they function. Tests were also performed on the third fueling
arm higher up on the tower, slowly lowering the arm to where the Starship will be standing.
Much like what Elon Musk designs, this system, or chopsticks as they are called, is unlike anything
that we have seen in the aerospace industry and will be useful as the company works towards
designing a lighter and more efficient spacecraft. The Risks
There are a lot of risks involved with the separation system and descent of the Super Heavy.
Each separation of a multi-stage spacecraft adds another layer of risk to the successful flight of
the rocket, but this system is necessary due to the laws of physics that place a limitation on
maximum velocity achievable by a rocket based on its wet-to-dry mass ratio. The velocity of a heavy
suborbital payload needs to reach low Earth orbit and significantly higher than what a single-stage
spacecraft can achieve. Reaching such velocity requires a high wet-to-dry mass ratio, and a
multi-stage rocket sidesteps the limits by splitting the velocity into fractions depending
on the number of stages it has. As the lower stage is separated, the succeeding stage is ignited,
pushing the vehicle forward with the burnout speed remaining constant for the rest of the craft.
Since the lower stages of the multi-stage rocket require more structure due to the weight it bears,
the upper stage can use engines that are suited to vacuum conditions, making it easier to reach
low Earth orbit. It seems SpaceX is trying to significantly optimize Starship before its orbital
launch. While this can be considered a step in the right direction, some argue that SpaceX cannot
make any substantive changes without gathering flight experience, which can only happen when the
vehicle has been put to the test. Once the Starship has flown to orbit and made several successful or
unsuccessful attempts, SpaceX will finally be able to make modification by increasing its payload,
reducing its mass, and removing suboptimal systems. The proposed landing of the super-heavy
rocket is another cause for concern, as it is not possible to accurately predict what will happen
because the Starship has never been flown. The booster will be landing on a small patch of steel
rather than a concrete path, and if the timing and control of the rocket are not accurate,
it can result in failure. The booster must execute a cautious descent and a ridiculously slow
touchdown to be able to land on a pair of hard points with little room for error.
The slightest lateral deviation from the arms would cause Super Heavy to fall off,
hit the concrete, and explode. But the slow descent means that the booster's landing
might cost more than the Falcon's suicide burn, as it may need to burn 5-10 tons of
propellant for it to land safely on the chopstick. If SpaceX decides to take the Falcon route by
attaching simple legs to the rocket, it will increase the rocket's dry mass by 20 tons,
and reduce its payload to orbit by up to 5 tons. Although landing on the launch tower will increase
the speed of reuse of the boosters, it is hard to predict if it is actually going to work or make
much difference than if it was landed on the concrete path. Perfecting the booster's landing
is something SpaceX will have to figure out if they really want to make the rockets reusable.
SpaceX's new separation system sounds incredulous, but it may be feasible given the ability of Elon
Musk and his team to push the limits of just about anything. How successful do you think
the SpaceX separation system will be? Leave your comments down below!
In case you want to watch more fascinating videos, click the videos on the screen now.
If you enjoyed the video, don't forget to subscribe with all notifications turned on.
