One D & D: Are Dwarves a Problem?

Basically Dwarves
3 followers
Jul 28, 2024
Hello, this is Spicy Dungeoneer where we don't shy away from some big topics
And today we're going to be talking about dwarves. If you like this content, please subscribe to my channel click on the notifications
And you know if you want to comment, please comment below
just uh
Before we do start though. We are going to be talking about some
adult themes
uh, there's no bad language, but
Uh, there is going to be some extreme sarcasm. So just be warned
and uh
Look out for that. I just say this not because there's anything particularly shocking in this
video, but I just think that some of the
things that we're going to talk about
are not
really appropriate for small children
And that parents should be the ones that talk to their children about these topics
But let's continue
Uh, if you like this topic check out my previous video about orcs and i'll put the link in the subscription
Before we do go too far. Let's just talk about respect. We're just having a conversation here. We're just discussing this issue
Hopefully we all love role-playing and Dungeons and Dragons and we're all
Moving out of a space of that love for the game and enjoyment and having fun
So just respect each other
in the comments, please
I do believe that every table is its own little democracy
And that we all play the game that you want
each table has its own little rules and intricacies and things like that, so
It's an agreement between the DM and the players
so obviously the DM's got to want to run that world and
Be interested in that the players have got to be interested in the story and wanting to play in that world
so, you know like
I have played in many different tables and I have had
uh different
sort of things happen at these tables
and
uh, I normally don't go too dark
or
Things like that, but I can understand if some people do want to go
into those themes
It's up to you as long as it's all between consenting adults
I don't really care. It's a free world. Enjoy your freedom
So also i'd like to say, you know
Mike
Pape, I hope i'm saying that right. He produced these three videos and I don't want to
sort of criticize
The artist too much because I acknowledged that
Some of these drawings are much more intricate than I could do myself. So
You know, thank you for that and there is some really good positive feedback
online
About this person's work. I'm not sure of their pronouns. So I won't i'll just call them this person
uh
Do they play the game? I don't know
There's no negative
comments on his particular
Their particular feed, so I don't know
anyway
Let's talk about the most controversial
pictures of
dwarves
Now i'm not talking about this one
Or this one. Sorry something must have happened to my slides
Not this one either
or this one
One does wonder though with all of the talk about dwarves and
Species and things like that
nobody has addressed the
elephant in the room
which is that the relationship between dwarves
as a fantasy race and
dwarfism as a
condition that some people
are born with so
um
You know
If we're going to be politically correct
you know if we're going to
signal our political correctness by
Trying to be inclusive. There's something need to be done about that
I personally like the idea of calling dwarves
Dwarrows like Tolkien did but
Tolkien really liked that word
It didn't really catch on though
Or another one I like to use in my games is Dvergarth, but you know, that's a topic for another time
And the other controversial one is this one which many people believe
Was created by AI art, but of course
AI rumors have been denied
Anyway, let's continue
We're going to talk about
one of the greatest evils
of the modern world
I'm talking about carbohydrates, of course bakery food. Oh
My Achilles heel
Is it yours?
You know, it's not good for you
What is it about dwarves and bread, you know, Terry Pratchett had their
Famous fighting bread where they could be used as a weapon as well
Dwarves and bakeries have a long history
And I am reminded of the delicious and dungeon or dungeon meshy as well he was a good cook
so there's you know some
interesting connections between
dwarves and
Baking that is not really what we're talking about today
all jokes aside
and
A lot of people have been sort of asking questions about this picture in particular
What do you think about it?
I'd like to hear your comments
in particular
There is this
Couple I would say
they've got
tattoos of each other's beards on their arms
and
That means that they can
No longer change their beard fashion style
ever in their life
and therefore
Uh that has limited their fashion choices, which is a very big no-no in the dwarvish world apparently
Now, of course, that's not true. But these tattoos do make us wonder
Whether there's something else going on
Are they this like this?
picture would have been quite fine without that and then it could have had the same backstory and
You know, you could have all of their readings that we are already putting into them about
this
couple
Um, and it would have been no problem, you know
but I think it's the fact that these tattoos have sort of rubbed it in people's faces that
Maybe have caused some people to get upset
But that's not the only things that are
in this
Picture I mean, there's a lot of good things. I like the um, you know the actual feel of the place and all of this artwork
here
um
you know
Being a dwarf is one of the few places where you can also be
A red-headed person and feel safe these days
Um, i'm not so sure whether dwarves wear sandals. Would they be caught dead wearing sandals?
And these hipster dudes
I don't know the first hipster dwarves in mod media the bandana. I don't know
Look
I don't know
Like obviously they've got different
uh human
Races here. This person looks asian. This person looks
african
Same with this one
We've got a child but she's got red hair. Does that make?
Maybe she's the daughter of
This I don't know. Anyway
You uh get the idea, but um, they all live together. They all work together, which is fine
I get it. We're sort of trying to be
modern these days
but i'm just not sure whether
giving dwarves
this human like
evolutionary adaptions
is
useful
you know
uh
Skin color comes from
You know where you how close you are to the equator basically
and eye shape some
People say that it's the fatty deposit on the eyelid as an adaption to cold weather. I don't know
whether they're real that's real or whatever, but
You know, I just don't see how
Giving them human like qualities
um helps
Uh, if we look at the lore
Dwarves are described as blacker than pitch
Uh, well the dark elves are anyway, and some people relate dwarves to dark elves
We'll talk about dark elves again later in another video
Whether that refers to their beards or not is debatable
there's also uh
some
You know, there's a whole thing about female dwarves, which I think is quite unnecessary. Of course, there are female dwarves. They're just
uh
Weren't mentioned a lot, but they were mentioned sometimes
And I think ultimately it doesn't really matter
how
you know species
or fantasy species are
Presented in your game. I mean you could make all of them have um
Deer antlers, let's say let's say all elves have deer antlers in your game. That is fine
There's nothing wrong with it. You go for it. You do you if your table loves it go for it
Doesn't mean that we need it in a player's handbook. I'm not so sure about that
dwarves need to feel
Or seem like dwarves. That's one of the things I noticed with the orcs the orcs just
In the last video, they just didn't
Feel like orcs they felt like humans with bad teeth, you know
um, and so
What's going on here?
now
Do female dwarves have beards look if that's your thing go for it
um
I it's always been a funny thing. So like enjoy it, you know, and and some women do have beards
Um, you know, it's a hormonal thing. And so why not? I don't
Care about that topic. I I think you know
That's a up to each
table to decide that
Or, you know, perhaps each character even if you do have a beard you could always shave it
in a magical world
So much can happen anyway
But what do you think? Do you think there are problems?
with this
picture
Uh, have I addressed them all?
um
You know why?
like
if you're operating a
A smith is smith's forge. Should you be distracted like that? I don't know look
It's funny. It's a funny picture. I don't know why they felt the need to do this
There's no
What purpose does it serve?
What's it doing in a book that?
Children are going to be reading. I really um have questions
But it's is it really bad? Not really. I mean
It doesn't impact me at all like I could imagine this sort of um
Room happening in a big city somewhere in a dnd world. Why not?
anyway
Let me know what you think. Please like subscribe click on the notifications and i'll see you in the next one
Bye for now
