From Crafters to Warriors: How Dwarves Have Changed in Myth & Fantasy

Myths and magic
3 followers
Dwarves are considered fearsome warriors across fiction these days, but originally they were small and not warlike, and were simple crafters of magic powers.As always, a great thanks to the online artists whose visual works made this video possible! If you are one of the artists, please let me know and I will post your name and a link to your work in this description!
#Dwarves#Norse#Tolkien
From crafters to warriors, how did dwarves transform from these simple craftsmen,
but crafters who protect their creations too? Hey everyone, Yoisten here and I hope you all
are doing well wherever you are in Midgard. Today we're going to be talking about dwarves in
mythology, fiction, stories, and how they have transformed from kind of what we know
them in Norse mythology as craftsmen with magical abilities to warriors and fighters.
Granted, they do have these magical qualities about them. They're not simple craftsmen,
but they're not really warriors and those legends. But then we look at the dwarves of
J.R.R. Tolkien's world, right, and how they are tremendous warriors. So if you follow me from
Men of the West, obviously, right, my main channel, I talk a lot about Tolkien's works and so forth,
and I'm going to talk a lot about Tolkien today. So get ready for that for sure. And like I said
last year and in recent posts here on this channel, I definitely want to make videos for
this channel when I find the time and inspiration. It's been a while since my last video, but thanks
for your patience in this video coming. I want to just keep going with this channel when I have time.
It's a fun side project for sure. So my friends, thank you all so much for joining me today. Let's
dive into it. In Norse mythology, which honestly is pretty much a lot of the origins that we get
of the dwarves as a concept, they weren't necessarily warriors as we see them in the
Lord of the Rings. They are more like craftsmen, forge masters, and arms dealers for the gods.
So in Norse mythology, they were born from the flesh of the giant Ymir or the earth,
and they were master craftsmen, making things like Mjolnir or Gungnir, which is Odin's spear,
right? They created tools, weapons, magic items that became larger parts of the mythology.
Now, sometimes being these magic kind of craftsmen, they were also stealthy and clever,
greedy. They were transactional. They were just these small presents that might be a bit tricky,
right? Their battles were usually those of wits, or when we think about how the dwarves,
when they were forging Mjolnir, had to put up with Loki, they were kind of fighting just small
battles of their own because Loki was a fly who kept stinging them during their, or biting them
during their operations. And so they weren't fighting these massive giant legendary battles,
but were kind of doing these smaller moments as they created their pieces of art. Now, J.R.R.
Tolkien and his legendarium, they were really the pivot for the archetype of the dwarf,
and that archetype is honestly more popular now than the old mythic version, or at least the two
blended together are typically what we see nowadays in all manners of fiction regarding
the dwarves. He definitely kept the idea that they're craftsmen, that they're related to the
foundations of the earth and stone and all of that. But on top of that, they are warriors that
protect their creations, not just creators themselves. So we see this in the Silmarillion.
We see this with the Nauglamir and their great strongholds and so forth, the things that they
create. It's not just that they make them and make them for someone stronger like the gods,
but they make them for themselves, right? Maybe they'll have some allies that they'll
work with to combine the Silmaril with the necklace, the Nauglamir, to make into something
more beautiful. But then those same dwarves in that story, at least became ferocious and greedy
and killed elves in taking that Nauglamir for themselves, right? They fought to protect their
craft and giving into that greed, they became violent over such things. Now, that is also not
a general part of the archetype. Those dwarves, I should say, don't represent the general dwarf
in Tolkien's works or the fiction and mythology since then. Because loyalty tends to also be a
big part of what it means to be a dwarf, right? And so Tolkien definitely established this idea
that they themselves are also hard as stone and that they make naturally great warriors and
infantry especially. That they have their own styles of fighting and because of their height
and strength, Tolkien and fiction since have shifted them towards shields, heavy mail, axes.
They're not no longer these stealthy beings like they were in mythology, but that is one change
since the myth. I mean, that's why they needed the burglar Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit, is because
dwarves are not naturally stealthy in The Lord of the Rings and most of the mediums since then.
That's why you have the halflings or even elves and so forth. And so, honestly, they turn the
disadvantage of being short and stocky into an advantage. Almost like a small moving tank,
right? Behind heavy layers of armor and with sharpened weapons and so forth. Also, honestly,
one thing that's not really a part of this archetype, but I could see being really good
for dwarves, are spears. Sometimes you'll see dwarves with spears and these guardsmen and so
forth who wield them, but again, axes tend to be the most popular thing for dwarves. Even though,
honestly, to make up for their reach and so forth, I think spears would be great for them.
Now, part of the archetype has held on because, again, they continue to be great craftsmen. So,
when we look at works since The Lord of the Rings, right, in the last 70, 80 years or so,
when we get more into the modern fiction and all of that concerning dwarves, so we're looking at
Warhammer, D&D, Warcraft, that crafter identity became a bit more of an artificer and an engineer
kind of idea as well to where you get siege works, but also a lot to do with gunpowder and
more futuristic kinds of weapons. Also, they tend to kind of use their own magic, their runes
and enchantments in different sorts of ways. So, this could compete with elven sorcery on
the battlefield. And again, you see kind of the roots of all of this way back even in Norse
mythology, when in many stories, dwarves and elves aren't always very different and sometimes
they are. But yeah, I mean, you definitely see where it began and where it kind of ended up
with these modern pieces of fiction. Now, sometimes they still are these berserking,
shirtless barbarians, or even in the Elder Scrolls, they are kind of wise beyond belief. So,
they are, there is a lot of differences between them and the old versions of them in so many
pieces of fiction today, but they're certainly different. And so, they're not just jewelry
makers or magic craftsmen anymore, but they themselves have interesting senses of warfare
and of creating weapons of war and so forth, right? They became the defenders of the very
things that they create, their own senses of militia and army and all of that. But they're
still rather unique when compared to how the archetypal human or elf or halfling or whoever
else orc tend to fight. So, there you go. Their tools, such as a hammer that they might use for
blacksmithing, became one of their also main weapons, right? Or an axe that could be used for
crafting and cutting wood and so forth became repurposed for combat in that archetype as well.
And the psychology, the symbolism of the mountains that they tend to live in became
really a symbol for how strong they themselves are. Short, sturdy warriors from the mines
and the creatures encountered therein, all the way to the battlefields where they're helping
out men and elves or fighting against them. Now, again, they keep these aspects of greed and so
forth as well, but they also are loyal beyond all belief, right? Loyal to the death. And then,
even then, as they die, they'll continue to fight for what they believe in. So,
many of them have a sense of greed and a sense of stubborn honor. And yeah, I mean, that translates
into the dwarven warrior tank archetype that we have today. From Norse mythology to the transition
that Tolkien gave in Middle-earth, The Lord of the Rings, The Silmarillion, and so forth,
into what they tend to be in modern fiction and fantasy today. From this tale of how the dwarves
evolved, we see that we too must be ready to evolve and become stronger, just as the dwarves
from mythology through fiction and fantasy have themselves. My friends, thank you all so much for
watching. I hope you enjoyed this video. Please hit that like button. Let me know your thoughts
on the evolution of the dwarves. Is there anything that I missed? Let me know in the comments below.
It's good to be back making another Masters of Mythology video. Again, it's not necessarily my
top priority or anything like that, but I like doing it when I can. So, thank you guys for
watching. Let me know what else you would like to see and what you would like to see in our next
video. Check out our main channel, Men of the West, as well as our Patreon and YouTube memberships
over there for the best way to support me and the work that I'm doing here. My friends, thank you
all so much for joining me on this adventure. Until the next one.
