🤔 On The SOUL vs. nihilism. Facts & Logic 🧐

Dualism
2 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 2, 2024
Hello there. Greetings. Salutations.
Let's talk about something that confuses countless, countless people on this whole.
I don't want to make a whole lot of references to original Buddhism, because it's not important.
And the term Buddhism didn't even exist until the 1600s.
I've had literally hundreds of people over the past 20 years say,
you know, these are their words, not mine.
As completely disgusted at how it represents itself as the soul denying nihilism,
like the ultimate attainment is like cosmic flushing of yourself down the toilet of oblivion.
The question is, and people, these people, they don't ask these questions.
It's like, who works for whose own good?
The only thing that they'll admit to is the psychophysical.
Rupa vedana sama sankara vinaya.
Forms, feelings, impulses.
Consciousness, perceptions.
Nibbana.
But what does nibbana mean?
I've talked about that endlessly.
The subjugation of becoming means nibbana.
Nibbana, depending on how you actually approach the term,
it's either nivritti or nisbandhu.
Nisbandhu means from bondage.
Okay, what's freed from bondage?
The question is, who works for whose own good?
That's the only thing you need to do to ask these people that.
The soul denying nihilists.
It's like, you know, subject precedes object of negation.
Nobody can actually deny a soul because it's a logical fallacy.
It's intellectual heresy, actually, is what it is, more apropos.
Who works for whose own good?
They talk about having a soul as if I, myself, or anybody else,
logically and intelligently speaking about the subject,
talks about something having a soul.
Having a soul implies one thing has another.
And that's not the case.
We can conventionally say that a radio has a signal,
but there's no signal in the radio.
Yes?
To say that there's no soul in the body is not a denial of the soul.
It's merely stating the fact that the soul is the consubstantiality,
the empirical soul, if you will.
And we're talking about the two cells.
All branches of monistic physics, monistic metaphysics,
speak about the two cells of the two souls.
The psychophysical one, like Bob, Sue, Larry, so on and so forth,
which has a beginning in time and an end in time,
and the transcendent self, just like the signal.
Yes?
What happens when you smash the radio?
Do you think you're doing anything to the signal?
I don't think there's a single intelligent person on this earth
with two brain cells that thinks,
you know, you get this radio here,
you get it tuned into a signal.
What happens to the signal when I smash it?
I smash the, you know, breakup of the radio.
It dies, disease, weak, whatever.
It's old, it doesn't work anymore.
That darn radio, you see people pounding on the radio.
It's an old radio, it just doesn't work anymore.
Does anybody intelligently think
that you've done anything to the signal?
Which, of course, the signal is modulated,
which means it's tunable to begin with.
Modulation is no different than the ancient Pali word vritti.
Vritti means perturbation.
We could say modulation.
Because the signal is modulated.
Frequency and wavelength, yes?
And there's no radio on earth
that can tune an unmodulated signal,
which really wouldn't be a signal by definition.
But there's no soul in the body,
and there's no signal in the radio.
These people lack the nuance and clarity
to understand things.
So, who works for whose own good?
I could quote you thousands of passages,
literally, pro-soul Atman passages
from the Vedic in Ikea, Mejima,
Samyutta in Ikea, Anguttara in Ikea,
Kodaka in Ikea.
The really, really old stuff that's original
to original Buddhism.
And I don't like to use the word Buddhism
because Buddhism was not anti-Vedantic,
which has been a claim of many of them.
But there's no basis in fact for that.
None whatsoever.
It was a neo-Saramonic movement.
Roughly 600 to 500 BCE,
i.e. the time of Gautama,
Upanishadic and Vedantic thought
had already become completely corrupted.
That's not my position.
That's the position of many countless scholars
of the fact that have no religious
dog in the race.
This is a fact.
Already completely old stuff,
teachings,
and it had already become completely corrupted.
People don't understand this.
How can something be completely corrupted
way back 2,600 years ago?
Because the stuff was way older than that.
It's already been completely corrupted.
This notion that Buddhism was anti-Vedantic
or anti-Upanishadic Atman
has no basis in fact,
no basis in logic,
and there's no doctrinal basis
Udana 81
There is, O followers, an unborn,
an unoriginated, an unmade,
and an unformed, i.e. the soul.
If there were not, O followers,
this unborn, unoriginated, and unformed,
there would be no way out
for the born, the originated, the made, and the formed.
People will actually make reference
to these soul-denying nihilists
saying,
all these teachings of no self in the text.
But there's no such thing as a teaching
of no self in the text.
Ultimately, conventionally, there is.
This is not the soul. That's not the soul.
That via negativa methodology
is something completely foreign to their minds.
They don't understand negative theology.
They don't understand apophoticism.
Nery nery.
Very, very common to Upanishadic
and Advaita Vedanta
vis-a-vis Sri Sankaracharya's teachings
of Upadisthahasuri and the Vivecchara Muni
is the same thing
in original Buddhism.
The word is
anatta. In the Pali,
the word in Sanskrit is anatman.
The word anatman is found in the Upanishads
and the word anatman is used
by Sri Sankaracharya.
There's not a single person alive who ever lived
that has ever said
the words
that Advaita Vedanta teaches
that there's no soul.
But the very word anatman
in Sanskrit, same word by the way,
is used by
Advaita Vedanta.
What makes them think that Buddhism
contextually uses this term
in any different way?
Because there's no doctrinal substantiation for it.
I'm literally the world's foremost expert
on that topic. I know all 576
occurrences.
The term anatta is never used in a pejorative fashion
against the soul.
It is used in a pejorative fashion in reference
to the foul, the evil,
the temporal,
mara, it's called maradama,
the principle of
mara or of evil.
Attachment to materialism.
Form is not the soul.
Feelings are not the soul.
It's common via negativa.
If there were no soul in doctrine,
it would say, followers, there's no soul.
We don't care, we don't care. What's not the soul?
That's not the soul. We don't care about that.
There's just no soul. Period.
There's no such passage.
If there were no soul,
nobody would ask them the question
which they could never answer.
Who works for who's ungood?
If there were no soul and only phenomena,
therefore the refuge is evil
and phenomena.
Passage and all
translations are the same except for one
by Bhikkhu Bodhi who
glosses the translation.
He's a Theravadan.
He purposely mistranslates it.
He translates maradama as subject
to mara. Mara means great evil.
You cannot translate
dhamma as subject to.
He hides that because
the passage in Samyukta Nikaya 3.196
is so glaringly obvious.
The passage goes,
Lord Gautama, what does the word anara
anara here, what does this word anara mean?
Just this, radha.
Form is not the soul. Feelings are not the soul.
It is never used in a pejorative
fashion. The soul
nowhere in doctrine, in
any translation mind you, is
ever used in a pejorative fashion.
The soul is never disparaged
or pooed, you know,
poo-pooed the soul, you know, eh, that's soul stuff.
It's not.
False or heretical views
on the soul are, and the
Pali passage word for that is called
atanuditi.
Nu is prefictual meaning heretical
or foul or incorrect, atanuditi.
Diti is views
or speculations, crazy
speculations and nonsense
about the soul. That is
waylaid. It is.
And that's no different than
Upanishadic thought. It's no different
than Advaita Vedanta. Nobody
with a halfway sharp mind
that has researched the text for themselves
and themselves by themselves would ever
come to any other conclusion because it's completely
untenable, it's impossible, and there's
no doctrinal substantiation for the soul
denying cosmic oblivion
nonsense.
It has no basis in doctrine.
None whatsoever.
The soul
term, which in Pali is ata
or atman in Sanskrit,
is never ever in any
translation used in a pejorative fashion.
Ever. No translation.
You see, that's really telling to somebody
with a halfway sharp mind,
which apparently nobody has anymore.
It's a radical
fallacy that original Buddhism
is somehow unique or apart
from Upanishadic
metaphysics, has no basis in fact
whatsoever and none
whatsoever in doctrine.
As I said, Buddhism as a term didn't even exist
until the 1600s. When asked
what his teachings were, he said,
my teachings are brahmayana,
which translates as
path to the absolute, brahmayana.
So,
what is currently called
Buddhism, the
founder of saying,
Gautama, he called it
brahmayana, so it should accurately be called
brahmayana, path to
the absolute.
Also, there's this
other notion that Westerners who
are interested in this cosmic oblivionism,
oblivionism, I know
that's not really a word, and I'll give a
passage here I read, someone sent me a link to
this radical
article, he's talking about
people talking about
relative to the soul, an Abrahamic hangup.
As if the soul
is somehow Judeo-Christian
or Abrahamic, and that's completely
not true. There's a definitive book
on that, and it's a free download, at least it used
to be, it's called Resurrection or
Immortality. It's the definitive
work with nothing but,
nothing but, book and
citation to the Old
New Testament and other
Judeo-Christian sources. There's no
mention anywhere within
the Old or New Testament, I'm not going
after the Old or New Testament, of an
immortal soul. None.
Not a single mention
of a permanent immortal
soul, anywhere within the Old
or New Testament. And there are, I believe
there's 12. I could
be wrong and it could be 10. This
book you can download, it gives you the book and verse
where a soul is destroyed, like
an evil soul is destroyed by God,
wiped out, period.
That's a fact.
So these people, they'll say, well you're talking about a soul
in original Buddhism, well that's just like
Abrahamic, you know,
stuff. It's like, excuse me sir,
let's stick to facts, logic,
reason, and what is
doctrinally substantiable.
It can be doctrinally substantiated.
There is no immortal soul within the Old or New
Testament. That's not my feeling
or belief, it's a fact.
So, here's the
paraphrasable core of the original,
and this passage repeats itself many times,
1 Jimenike 1.436, whatever forms,
feelings, perceptions, experiences, or consciousness,
i.e. the psychophysical,
i.e. the five aggregates,
i.e. the psychophysical,
i.e. namarupa. These
he sees to be without permanence, as suffering,
as ill, a plague, a boil,
a sting, a pain, an affliction,
as foreign, as other,
as empty,
as selfless,
because that's
the only way this word is ever used.
This is not the soul,
that's not the soul. Is that pejorative?
I ask you a question. Be an intelligent
person for once in your life
and answer me this question. Is that a pejorative
of the soul? This is not the soul.
That's not the soul. All these
things are foul and they are not the
soul. That's the only
stuff that's ever mentioned in doctrine.
This is not the soul, that's not it. This stuff
is foul, evil, otherness,
not the soul. Is that a pejorative
of the soul? Of course it's not.
There's not a single halfway intelligent
person on this earth that can
say that. It's ridiculous, it's absurd,
it's illogical, it's nonsensical.
You can't say that.
You can't even
breathe and walk
and think something that ridiculous.
It's impossible. And yet
these people, and they're just saying
it's a permanent soul in Buddhism, that's like
Abrahamic stuff.
It's ridiculous.
So he turns
his mind, continue with that passage,
so he turns, we say noose,
or chitta,
he turns his mind, in this Pali word,
chitta, which is a non-aggregate,
turns his chitta away from these,
i.e. the psychophysical. Therein he
gathers the chitta, or the mind,
whatever word you use, noose is fine also,
within the realm
of immortality.
Pali for that is amataya, dattaya.
Amataya
is immortality.
In any translation,
mata is death, amata is immortality.
Dattaya is realm,
yeah,
realm of immortality.
This is tranquility, this is that which is
most excellent, this is meaning,
means nirvana.
Suvimutta chittasana
bhanam. The thoroughly
liberated chitta, or noose, or mind,
or spirit of sanctum, don't care what word
you use, means nirvana.
Suvimutta chittasana
bhanam. Been translating
ancient Pali now for 23 plus years.
I tell you right now,
all these people they do is they throw spit wads in the
dark, and they tell
all these people, and I don't really care what they say,
but all these people that
are interested, and this is the same
stuff you find on Wikipedia,
completely ludicrous,
non-doctrinal, no substantiation,
no facts, no logic, nothing.
Yeah, Buddhism is just, they
make it out, and this is why people
that have a half a mind
are disgusted by it, because it's presented
this is Buddhism, it's a soul
denying nihilism. It's like, you know,
the ultimate attainment is just like fleshing
yourself down a cosmic toilet of oblivion.
Turn that...
There is no soul!
Well, who works for whose own good?
If there were no soul, then there would be
no reason to do anything with it. You just do whatever.
Well, who cares, you know?
There's another
word. There's a million ways
to defeat this
illogical
ridiculousness,
and the other way is to
talk about other things relational to the soul.
They believe in instant
transmigration. Reincarnation
is an incorrect word, by the way, transmigration.
And the word
that completely ruins or wrecks
their day is antarabhava,
which means in-between existence. In other words, after
this life has petered
out, you know, before
transmigration occurs, they don't believe
in an intermediate.
This intermediate
in Pali is called antarabhava,
you know, disembodied being.
They literally believe in instantaneous.
It's not my position, this is theirs.
Instantaneous transmigration.
Immediately, as soon as somebody kicks
the bucket here, they're
transmigrated here. Instantaneous,
because if there's an in-between,
then you must posit
a soul.
And we can't have that if you're
a nihilist. If you're a nihilist
Buddhist, and by Buddhist
I mean a nihilist, not an actual Buddhist.
You can't
have something in-between. The croaking
of this one and the birth of this one
has to be instant. In their words
they say, and this is not non-doctrinal,
it's in their own commentary,
which is not original
Buddhism at all. It's like one
candle lighting another. These are their
words. One, like you took one candle and you
lit another one. Instantaneous.
But that's not what doctrine
actually says. It says antarabhava,
which means in-between
existence, a disembodied being.
And man, oh man, they don't
like that! Because when you talk
about a disembodied being,
like the body is croaked here,
and the spirit hasn't picked up another body
over here, well that means
a soul! Whatever word you use,
spirit, soul, don't care. Can't have that.
They don't like the fact that
that's in doctrine. No!
They don't like that at all!
I know, and you
can see I'm saying this egotistically, I know
all the dirty little stuff
that they don't want you to know.
Every little passage,
every one of them,
all 576 occurrences
of the Thermanada, and all
its 32 compounds, the soul
is never used or mentioned in a pejorative
fashion anywhere in doctrine.
Heretical views about the soul,
regarding the soul, which of course
Upanishads teach the same thing.
Don't have crazy views about the soul,
that's not helpful to liberation and wisdom.
No different.
To think that Buddhism is somehow,
well that's that Hinduism stuff.
Hindu is referred to a people,
not a religion by the way.
It's ridiculous.
Buddhism is some sort of autonomous thing
that's spawned up.
It's the holy new teachings.
It's completely removed from Upanishadic
and it is in no way, shape,
and form. It is nothing other than
a neo-sermonic movement and
condensation of Upanishadic thought.
Just as Plotinus
is not something different
than the teachings of Plato and Pythagoras.
I mean that would be
ludicrous if someone were to stupidly
say that, right? Well Plotinus was different.
He didn't agree with that Plato and Pythagorean
stuff.
Neo-Platonism is nothing
other than a condensation
of Pythagorean and Platonic thought.
No different. Nothing is known
except in the modality of the knower.
Same thing.
It's ridiculous to think that Plotinus is
totally removed from Pythagoras and
Platonic thought
and metaphysics.
As it is to think that Buddhism,
there's Buddhism over here and here's all that other Hinduist
Upanishadic and Vedic thought
over here. Ridiculous.
Illogical. Unwise.
Non-doctrinal.
No substantiation. None
whatsoever.
Every expert Sanskrit
metaphysician, be it Dr.
A.K. Kumaraswamy,
Sarvapati Radhakrishnan,
countless others said the
same thing. And of course they were all right.
We're talking about people that have
translated many countless tens of thousands
of pages from the principle of Upanishads,
the Vedas and whatnot. They all said the same things.
The majority
of the people that espouse
this stuff are Westerners.
It's a type of
spiritual nihilism.
There's other words I'd like to use
but I'm not going to use them.
Who works for whose own good?
I can quote you a thousand passages
of which you'd never pay attention to.
But who works for whose own good?
If there were no soul, then liberation is not possible.
Liberation of what, by what
and due to what?
They'll say, well, it's true.
The psychophysical is mara.
It's called maradama.
So what is it that is freed
from the psychophysical?
They say, well, there's nirvana.
Nirvana of what?
Nirvana means the thoroughly liberated
citta. Citta is just
a Pali word for
the word nus or
spiritus sancta.
Same thing. Yoga, citta,
vritti, nirodha, same thing in Sanskrit.
The culmination of yoga
is citta vritti nirodha, citta perturbation,
the subjugation of
citta perturbations, i.e. modulation.
I hope I made this simple.
The soul denying nihilism has no
place in original doctrine.
It's illogical. It's untenable.
Great word! Untenable!
Untenable.
I hope this was mildly entertaining.
It might not have been. Thank you so much for watching.
Lux Everitas!
