Number One Student Loan Question: What Happens With SAVE?

Loan Solutions
2 followers
May 25, 2025
The SAVE student loan repayment plan is paused, and the number one question we get is: when will SAVE borrowers have to make payments? Here are the three most likely scenarios for borrowers waiting in SAVE Limbo.
The number one student loan question that we have been getting over the last six months is for the
seven to eight million borrowers that are in save, what is going to happen? When are my payments
going to resume? And what do I need to know? And the hard part is, is we don't know, but there are
three main scenarios. And I want to spend a minute to break down the three scenarios, because with
the passage of the Republican budget bill, it's a lot more likely that scenario two here in my
list could happen than it was just a week ago. So here are the three scenarios that you need to know
if you're in save. You want to have the seven to eight million borrowers. Number one is that the
court voids the save plan. And this is the number one expected scenario. We think the court's going
to avoid it. It's highly likely that saves going away. And what that would mean is if the court
voids it now, and either Congress hasn't passed the new law yet, or Congress never passes the new
law, well, the Department of Education is going to have to make rules, they're going to have to decide
what are we going to do with these seven to eight million people? What payment plan are we going to
force them into? When are we going to force them into doing it? And what is the consequence if they
don't decide and how that looks? So in most likely scenarios, if court voids save and there is no
other new repayment plans or Congress doesn't act, this is going to be like a nine to 18 month long
process because the court's going to rule the Department of Education is going to have to
understand what that means. They're going to send out communication, they're going to have to start
a rulemaking process, they're going to have to tell borrowers that you are going to either have to
choose a new repayment plan, or we're going to move you into like the standard 10 year plan, and then
we're going to give you a grace period, and then maybe by like the middle of next year, like the
first payments will be due for those borrowers. That is the longest timeline. It is also, you know,
the most like complex because it's going to require rulemaking. Number two, which is significantly
increased in probability, is that Congress acts first or Congress passes the, you know, repayment
assistance plan, even if like the court voids save. Like once this repayment assistance plan passes,
the very first clause in it is that all borrowers in a administrative forbearance or an income to
contingent repayment plan or one of these has to move into amended IBR within six months.
That's what's in there. However, the rule is a little vague that they have to start the process
within six months. I think logistically, it might take a little longer before the first payments
actually come about. But this one is really increasing in the odds. So let's just say they
do pass the budget by June 30. Well, six months is the end of the year, they'll likely start the
process and you know, start moving borrowers into this new thing by the end of the year. And then of
course, the first payments under the amended IBR plan would likely come in the beginning of 2026
or the middle of 2026. Finally, there is the very rare scenario that the court upholds save entirely.
Very rare. But if that happens, they could literally just turn payments back on now granted,
it would still take about 60 to 90 days like you can't flip it on a dime. However, if rap does pass,
even if the court upholds save and rap passes, well, the rap rules start applying, the six-month
period starts. So even if save is upheld, if rap passes, save is still going to die because all
those other plans die except for the amended IBR plan. So these are the three biggest scenarios
that we expect to happen. With that said, you'll notice that in basically all the scenarios,
2026 is when your first payments are going to be due. Whether that's going to be like January 2026,
mid 2026, late 2026. All signs point to that. Could it happen earlier? Yes, of course. They
could try to do some expedited things. But my guess is that they'll pass the law, there might
be some lawsuits, there's going to be some logistical headaches. Like logistically, the
odds of it going before 2026 are pretty rare if you're in the same plan. If you're in one of the
other plans like IBR, ICR, pay, you could theoretically have the amended IBR coming into
your life this fall or by Christmas time. But again, I doubt it. I think your first payments
under amended IBR would still likely be in early 2026 regardless. So this is our estimates. This is
not anything concrete, but based on what we know today, what's happening with the WRAP plan, what's
happening with the court cases, and just the sheer logistics of migrating seven to eight million
people and dealing with loan servicers and processes and bureaucracy, this is what we think.
Early to mid 2026, probably more mid 2026 would be like if I was betting in Vegas, that's when we
expect SAVE plan borrowers to start having to resume payments depending on which of these
courses of action happen. So with that being said, let me know in your comments. If you want the full
breakdown, you want the full article, of course, you can find this on the collegeinvestor.com.
You can hit the link in bio, the description. We are here to bring you this information. These are
our estimates, not anybody else's, not official, but based on what we know and what we think,
this is when the SAVE plan borrowers should start expecting to make things happen.
