After 24 hours of nonstop debate, House Democrats bypassed the state constitution and passed a state income tax, paving the way for a Washington IRS.
Supporters claim the bill’s aim is to tax the rich. Yet Democrats rejected numerous Republican amendments that would have guaranteed low- and middle-income earners never pay it. Democrats also insist the tax is popular – but blocked every effort to let the people decide the issue directly.
In the hours and days that followed, several local businesses and entrepreneurs announced plans to leave Washington, citing the cumulative impact of taxes and regulations.
My first mission today, Madam Speaker, was to stop this tax.
I spent 24 hours doing it.
My second mission today was really clear.
If I couldn't stop it, then I was going to do everything I could to provide real relief to Washington State residents.
That didn't happen either.
We turned down helping small businesses.
We turned down helping farmers.
We turned down helping seniors.
We turned down helping veterans.
And worst of all, we turned down helping working families.
Every binding amendment that would have limited this tax to high earners was rejected.
This tax will soon hit regular working Washingtonians, all of them, Madam Speaker.
These taxes start small and grow.
The federal income tax in 1913 applied to 1% of the population.
Now almost every working American pays.
Two years ago, two years ago in one week, 76 in this body voted to ban an income tax.
And, you know, I always remember my wife when I first had my daughter and she said,
never make a promise to your daughter that you can't keep.
And I've always thought about that and tried to expend that to the rest of my life and say, you know,
don't look someone in the eye and overpromise something that you can't keep that promise.
And I think about that today.
Once you give the government the power to tax income, it rarely, if ever, gives that power back.
I believe this income tax bill and the standard deduction that is currently at a million dollars will continue to go down.
And I believe it will be an income tax on everyone.
And not only that, but I don't believe the sales tax will go away or the B&O tax.
I think this is a disrespect to the job creators in this state and a disrespect ultimately to the voters.
The voters needed to get to decide this.
There were several different amendments that addressed a vote of the people.
But the people that have been opposed to this not only don't feel like their voice was heard,
they see the joy about new taxes and they see no objective benefits.
This state is so full of taxes.
Capital gains tax, B&O tax, sales tax, death tax, high property taxes, gas taxes.
And yes, the Climate Commitment Act.
Farmers in District 14 are already operating in razor thin margins due to fuel, fertilizer, labor and water costs.
An income tax adds another layer of financial pressure.
When farms close, we don't just lose business, we lose generational livelihoods and the backbone of our rural economy.
I just in the last few weeks have people in my office telling me that they are moving their, not only their business, but their family to Idaho to avoid the tax.
It's really heartbreaking and I know other people have said this, but it's true because I love this state as well.
It's a beautiful state. It's a great place to live.
I chose to live here and I chose to represent businesses here.
And I see them struggling.
They're struggling under the pressure not only of our sales tax, property tax, B&O tax, but also all the regulations that we keep putting in place.
This bill barely makes a dent in the lives of the folks who need our help the most.
Our constituents are facing among the highest prices in the country in terms of gas, groceries, childcare, housing.
This bill gives them virtually nothing.
Instead it provides a series of pie crust promises.
A promise that, trust us, we'll fund school lunches in the budget, but not in this bill.
Trust us, we'll cut taxes for working families maybe sometime next session.
Trust us, we'll never lower the exemption of $1 million to apply to ordinary people.
I'm sorry Madam Speaker, I don't trust us.
We sat here on this floor two years ago, you and I, we both voted in favor of initiative 2111 that would abandon income tax in Washington state.
So I don't blame my constituents when they don't trust us either.
Instead of following the clear instruction of the state Supreme Court, instead of listening to voters, instead of making life more affordable for those in need,
we're going to send our economy into a spiral and we're going to no longer be able to fund things that make Washington great.
I've said before, Washington is blessed beyond what we deserve.
We took over 100 years to build what we have, but this bill is set to destroy it in one fell swoop.
This bill is a signal to companies that if you're hiring, don't look to hire here in Washington.
If you're an entrepreneur, don't look to build your idea here in Washington.
If you want to build affordable housing or start a new company, don't do that here in Washington.
Mr. Speaker, we talk about the businesses, well the businesses are people.
Not only just the owners of those businesses, but the people who work for those businesses.
So if a Starbucks or a Boeing or other people start to diminish their presence here in Washington state, guess what happens Mr. Speaker?
Those high paying jobs of people that are affected by this tax and the ones that will be affected when the tax changes at some point in time, as we've been discussing, are going to leave.
We have some of the star companies in the world, so many other states would be jealous of us, and we're shunning them away.
And it's not just the income tax, it's the sum accumulation of everything, the taxes, the regulation.
The people that are going to be paying this tax are working hard, they are running businesses, they are benefiting us in ways.
What happens, all I have is questions, what happens when they don't have the disposable income?
What happens when they can't continue to grow their existing business?
What happens when they can't invest in a new business?
What happens when they can't afford R&D?
What happens when they can't afford to hire new employees?
What happens when they stop their charitable giving?
If they don't produce, then what happens?
And that's when you see that sliding scale.
Madam Speaker, I don't think that this income tax solves the problem.
Because the problem is that we have continuing to overspend our revenues, and yet continuing to get more and more and more revenue.
And so we haven't satisfied our insatiable desire for extra cash.
We're just passing another bill that will give us more revenue, but we're not fixing the underlying problem.
Madam Speaker, the fact of the matter is, if expenses rise faster than revenue, there is no amount of revenue that can keep up.
This past budget started with $2.5 billion, added $4.3 billion in new taxes, and is still negative one year later.
The problem is not with revenue, it is with spending.
And this bill does not solve the underlying problem.
This tax is not going to help.
You add it all up, Madam Speaker, and it's like killing the golden goose.
We needed to stay within our means, and we didn't.
We're not going to get out of this by taxing our way out of it.
We get out of this by reducing spending, being smart, making tough decisions,
making decisions so that we can take care of everyday Washingtonians, because they're the ones that are being hurt.
This income tax is a failure of duty.
It fails our people, it fails to preserve and protect our Constitution,
and we could have done a lot better than this by just curbing reckless spending and making government live within its means.
Vote no.