LIVE: Florida Attorney General, Orlando Police Chief Announce Arrest, Charges in 2013 Cold Case

Live News Network
1.4K followers
1 Video View·Nov 19, 2026
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier joins Orlando Police Chief Smith on Nov. 19 to announce an arrest and charges in connection with a 2013 cold case.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good morning, everybody.
It's good to be here in Orlando this rainy morning.
We're here to announce the arrest and charges facing four individuals,
including first-degree
murder, related to a case that goes back almost 13 years.
These killers that will now face justice
in our court of law, they thought they could get away with it.
Over 13 years as a case went cold,
They got comfortable.
They thought they could get away with it.
But here in Florida, there's no expiration when it comes to justice.
We will always keep searching, keep working, keep fighting and
gathering evidence to hold violent offenders accountable.
Joining me here this morning is Orlando Police Chief Eric Smith,
a special counsel in our Office of Statewide Prosecution, Rich Mantai,
who oversees our cold case unit we launched about a year ago.
Ryan Backman with Project Cold Case.
I'd also like to recognize
and thank Detective Michael Fields with the Orlando Police Department
who did the bulk of the work
on this and really did tie together evidence and bring home a big case,
as well as Detective David Netting
in our Office of Statewide Prosecution Unit.
This case goes back to December 6, 2013.
When Jim Johnson Jr. went to get a haircut, and upon leaving
the barber shop, was encountered and taken by four individuals.
The evidence suggests that he provided an address
in this dangerous environment to a family home,
where they then relocated in an attempt to steal valuable goods.
They would encounter a friend of his there
who was held at gunpoint, ultimately shot.
Thanks be to God, did get away to get treatment
and talk about what had happened.
But these four individuals stole a vehicle,
stole items, and ultimately fled the scene.
It would be five days before Jim's body would
be found over in the Daytona area.
This case went cold for about a decade.
Leads were lost, attention distracted.
The evidence was not there to support continued investigation
and potential prosecutions.
But today we have more tools, more technologies,
more opportunities to work together across
jurisdictions to share information
and ultimately track down leads that can bring accountability
years later.
We don't stop.
13 years is a long time for justice. I understand that.
I know we have a lot of family members here this morning.
My heart goes out to you that you had to endure this pain.
You had this uncertainty for so long.
It's good that we get some closure here today. Ultimately, we have to.
Prove this case in the court of law, but the evidence is there.
The arrests have been made.
We will bring the heat in the courtroom,
which is the best in the business.
We will ultimately get the justice you deserve for the loss of Jim.
We obviously cannot bring him back, but we will
do everything we can to ensure that the people who took his life,
who engaged in this heinous crime, are held accountable.
So this case sat cold for over a decade
when our cold case initiative brought these great leaders together.
Our detectives, our law enforcement agencies here
in Florida were blessed. Our agencies all work together.
We're not territorial. We all have the same mission.
We want to put bad guys away. We want to protect.
Florida families are victims
and ensure that dangerous people are taken off the streets.
The four individuals that have been arrested,
several of them are tied or convicted in other very heinous crimes.
These were not good guys.
They've been running out on the streets for a long time.
That's not going to happen again.
We will be prosecuting to the fullest.
So the detectives, they got together,
working with Rich and our prosecution team.
As I said, we were able to use some new techniques
and technologies to do some DNA tracing, to look at cell phone usage.
We could see who was communicating together, when and where.
And ultimately, some of these cell phone records tied the connection
as somebody moved over to the Daytona area where the body was found.
These guys, they work night and day kind of recreating.
That day of events and those that would subsequently follow
to connect these dangerous offenders
to the crime, to the body, to the facts surrounding the case.
So I'll conclude and turn it over to these guys and just say again,
you know, 13 years is a long time. It's a long time.
Long enough for a case to go cold,
long enough for killers to get comfortable, but here in Florida,
it's not long enough for them to get away with it.
It's not long enough to evade justice.
We will always pursue the facts and the evidence.
We will work relentlessly to hold wrongdoers accountable.
There is no expiration date on justice here in the state of Florida,
and we will prove that in the court of law as we ultimately...
Seek accountability and justice for those that took Jim from this earth.
God bless you for being here this morning.
Thanks to all the investigators
and law enforcement officers who were involved in this.
With that, I'll turn it over to Chief Smith.
I want to thank you all for being here.
I want to thank the Attorney General
for being here today for this announcement.
I also want to thank the statewide prosecutor's offices
for their partnership.
Today marks a significant development
in the homicide investigation that began nearly 13 years ago.
On December 6, 2013, Jim Johnson Jr. was kidnapped
from Gooley's Barbershop on South Orange Blossom Trail here in Orlando.
Five days later, on December 11,
Johnson's body was discovered in a wooded area in Daytona Beach.
From the beginning, detectives believed multiple individuals
were involved in these crimes.
However, figuring out how those suspects worked together
and piecing together the evidence required a lot of investigative work.
For nearly 13 years, detectives continued to work in this case,
pursuing leads and searching for answers.
Through a comprehensive review of the original investigation
and additional analysis of evidence,
detectives were able to establish a timeline of the crimes connected
to suspects involved before, during, and after the kidnapping.
That work showed this was not a random or spontaneous crime.
It was a coordinated operation in which those suspects worked together
to kidnap Johnson and rob him of his money and property.
Detectives developed probable cause to charge four individuals,
Carlton Williams, Derek Dean, Sean Davis, and Nathaniel Webster.
Charges including first-degree felony murder, kidnapping,
armed robbery, racketeering-related offenses.
Three of those suspects were arrested
by the Orlando Police Department's fugitive unit and SWAT team.
One suspect turned himself in.
The Orlando Police Department is proud to have a dedicated cold case
unit that continues to pursue answers for victims and their families.
No matter how much time has passed,
we are still out there investigating the crimes.
I want to recognize Detective Mike Fields, along with the detectives
from various agencies who worked this case over the years.
Cold cases require persistence, attention to detail,
and a willingness to revisit evidence.
Their work helped bring us to this point.
I also want to thank the Florida Attorney General's Office,
the Office of Statewide Prosecution,
the Daytona Police Police Department, and all our law
enforcement partners for their work and commitment to this case.
Most importantly,
I want to acknowledge Jim Johnson Jr.'s family.
Nearly 13 years is a long time to wait for answers and justice.
While nothing can bring Jim back,
I hope today's announcement brings
his family one step closer to justice
and provides some measure of closure after years of uncertainty.
Yeah, as I mentioned, it's been about
a year since we launched the initiative.
Obviously, Rich has been working big,
complex cases for a long time, cold cases.
But we wanted our office to understand that this is now important.
It's going to be one of the key parts of our platform.
No case is too old to be forgotten.
We will not forget.
We will continue to go through the files.
Thank you, Miles, and today...
With our cross-jurisdictional partnerships
with new technological advancements,
we might be able to go
and break something open that they couldn't 10, 15, 20-plus years ago.
So Rich leads that effort for us.
We've already had several successes, including cracking this case.
And so long as I'm Attorney General, that's not going to stop.
So thanks, Rich, for being here.
Thank you, General.
Ladies and gentlemen,
that is an example of the work that got put into this case.
That's the arrest warrant in this case for one of the four individuals.
So this one's prepared.
I want to thank the general for making this unit possible,
continuing to support its full personnel and financially.
We have partnerships with DNA companies.
We have partnerships with other agencies,
all because of that commitment.
I do want to thank Detective Fields, Detective Nutting,
Daytona Beach Partnership, and the great work that the Orlando PD
has been doing in relationship to these cases.
We are going to continue this prosecution.
Individuals will be going to see the grand jury in a couple weeks.
We'll prosecute this case as long as it takes.
The counts in this case are serious,
the events in this case were serious, and I want to thank
their patience and perseverance.
I want to thank Ryan Backman for Project Cold Case for his continued
advocacy in this. We take Mars' Law very seriously in this office,
and this is a plug for
that. There's a little deck of cards that Mr. Backman
and his association publish that has
other cold cases on it. Every one of these people has a family.
Every one of these people was a
victim. Every one of these people deserves justice
in the best that we can do. So I want to thank
I want to thank my bosses. I want to thank my partners.
I want to thank the detectives who put all their effort
into this case for making an event like this possible,
and we're going to continue doing it. Thank you.
Ryan, thanks for your help, and we've got more of these.
We've got to go and crack open.
I look forward to the next one, but please come share with me.
Jim was featured in our second edition
of Cold Case Playing Cards. You can see there.
This is the third edition that we have just recently published.
Good morning. Thank you for being here.
Thank you to the Attorney General.
The theme that I keep hearing is partnerships,
and I can't express how important those partnerships are.
I have known Rich Manti, Dave Nutting,
and Mike Fields for years and years and years,
and being able to all come together for a common cause and common good
and answering 13 years of questions
and forcing accountability warms my heart and means the world to me
and so many other families that have loved ones
that have been victims of unsolved homicides.
I work, I run Project Cold Case.
We're a nonprofit organization that provides advocacy,
awareness and support to families of unsolved homicides.
We are not investigators.
We focus strictly on that awareness and advocacy side of it.
But those things can run parallel to an investigation.
While Detective Fields and Nutting were working
and while Rich Manti was figuring out what charges could be brought,
we were sharing Cold Case playing cards with Jim's face on them.
We did a spotlight article.
Recently, with a partnership with the University of North Florida,
a journalism student that
called and interviewed the family.
Those things are really important to me,
and I believe they're important to the family,
and that's why we do them, again, parallel to that investigation.
So I want to acknowledge the family of Jim Johnson,
Jr., sitting here, 10 of them, particularly
Melody, his sister.
For nearly 13 years, Melody has fought
for answers about her brother's murder.
In our conversations with Melody,
she described Jim as more than her brother.
He was a protector, a role model, and her superhero.
And when Jim was murdered, she lost someone
who had always been there for her,
but she never stopped being there for him.
She continued advocating, asking questions,
and searching for anyone who could move the case forward.
Her determination is a powerful reminder
that behind every unsolved homicide
is a family whose lives have been forever changed
and whose need for answers does not diminish with time.
Through our work with Melody and her family,
Project Cold Case featured Jim on our second
edition of Cold Case Playing Cards
and published a spotlight article to bring renewed attention
to his murder.
We also helped refer this case to the Attorney General's office.
Today, we recognize the dedicated investigators
and prosecutors whose work resulted in these
arrests.
The case demonstrates what happens when family advocacy,
sustained public awareness, and
law enforcement partnerships work together.
And while today's arrest represents a significant step toward justice,
we recognize that the judicial process is just beginning.
Nothing can return Jim to his family
or erase the years spent waiting for answers.
To Melody and the entire Johnson family,
thank you for trusting us to stand alongside you.
And to the Attorney General, his investigators and prosecutors,
the Orlando Police Department,
Daytona Police, and all who continued pursuing this case,
thank you for demonstrating that the
passage of time does not diminish the importance of justice. Thank you.
So to conclude,
thank you all for not giving up.
Thank you for staying on this.
Thanks to our detectives back there.
I hope you guys have somebody that loves you
and takes you out for a nice dinner tonight.
You deserve it.
Job well done.
Excellent work.
Thank you to the prosecutors and law enforcement officials
that put their lives on the line to keep our streets safe.
Chief, you do a great job here.
Thanks for hosting us.
Crime's at an all-time low in Florida,
including in a lot of our busier cities
and more populated areas,
and it's because we get it.
Catch bad guys, we do the job.
It's not political, it's not partisan.
It is the job.
We prosecute, we keep our streets safe.
Thanks, everybody, for being here,
and hopefully we can go through this deck
and crack a few more cases
so that other people out there
can get the closure that they certainly deserve.
I'll say the weather here has been challenging
for the state the last month.
I know we're seeing heavy rainfall levels in much of central Florida,
including significant flooding.
We will be monitoring this at the state level.
It will be responding as necessary, but be safe out there.
Any questions?
Yeah, the questions about price gouging.
We do activate a price gouging hotline in a team
when you have extreme weather and disaster situations.
Sadly, there's people out there that want to scam
and take advantage and overcharge,
take advantage of people in need during these tough times.
Yeah, we're working with the state
and a division of emergency management. Obviously,
we take their lead on a lot of the declarations that need to be made.
But we'll be working, and we'll certainly go after any scammers
and gougers that are out there.
Yes, sir.
We'll talk to you afterwards.
We can do that one-on-one.
Yes, sir.
Sure.
So what happens in these cases is you've got agencies
that have their own case files.
A lot of these have been out there for many years.
We've got cold cases ranging back decades.
Today, you know,
we've got easier opportunity using computerized technology, using.
Um e file software systems where we can better coordinate
with one another and maybe there's
some evidence in one jurisdiction that's helpful.
You know, when you have cases that span across
jurisdictional lines, when bodies are found
on a different place than where a crime might be
committed, another agency might have another investigative file
that's helpful. So the big
thing is really enabling us all to work together to share information.
A lot of times you'll have
Various DNA, you know,
opportunities that weren't known back in the 80s and 90s
and today we can cross-check things in a database to see
matches. Cell phone technology, we can go back,
we can recreate a case to look at
calls being made in a certain location
between individuals. That certainly
occurred here. Ultimately we were able
to trace the telephone communications to
To the location where the body was found.
Yes, sir.
No, I mean, I've heard rumblings that there's some localities
that are looking at their 287g obligations here in Florida.
I don't write the law. I enforce it.
We are always going to be a rule of law state.
We will always enforce the law. Local governments around the state
do have Florida law statutory obligations to engage in best efforts
to support the federal government in its mission. And there
are penalties where they choose to do so without justification.
So I haven't seen any further updates on that.
We've been pretty busy, but we certainly monitor,
and our executive branch up
in Tallahassee has made it clear we enforce the law.
Okay, thanks, everybody.
Appreciate it.
