LIVE: Senate Committee Holds Confirmation Hearing for National Counterterrorism Center Director Nominee

Live News Network
1.4K followers
4 Video Views·Nov 18, 2026
A Senate committee holds a confirmation hearing on Nov. 18 to examine the nominations of Joseph Weirsky of Virginia to serve as director of the National Counterterrorism Center and Gary Lawkowski of Virginia to serve as general counsel of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Call to today's hearing to consider the nominations
of Mr. Gary Lukowski to be General Counsel of the Office
of the Director of National Intelligence and Mr. Joseph Wierski.
To be the director of the National Counterterrorism Center,
I want to remind everyone that you are welcome to attend, but the Vice
Chairman and I agree that we will not allow any disruptions.
Audience members may not verbally
or physically distract from the hearing, including by shouting,
standing, raising sounds, or making gestures that block
the view of other members of the audience or the cameras.
The committee intends to hear from our nominees,
not disruptors seeking a few minutes of social media fame.
If anyone is removed from the chamber,
I will take further action to have them barred from committee.
The committee's future proceedings or the Capitol itself.
Our goal in conducting the hearing is to enable
the committee to consider the nominee's qualifications
and to allow our members thoughtful deliberation.
While both nominees have already provided
substantive written responses to dozens of
questions presented by the committee,
today members can ask any additional questions they
have and the nominees can share their thoughts.
Before we move on to the business hand, I'd like to repeat
in public today a few things I said yesterday at our closed hearing.
First off, I congratulate the vice chairman
on his reelection to the Senate.
I congratulate the Democrats on their victory last year.
We obviously have occasional policy differences.
Most of the agencies we oversee do not set policy.
However, we occasionally have differences on budget, authorities.
We've always worked together in a bipartisan spirit
that goes not just for my tenure in
this chair, but Senator Rubio and Senator Burr before us.
Well, Senator Warner has been there for all three of us,
and we look forward to that spirit continuing.
We will be losing two members of this committee
who aren't here, but we'll go ahead
and say nice things about them behind their backs in public.
Senator Collins and Senator Cornyn will be departing us.
They have been invaluable members of the Intelligence Committee
and the United States Senate.
We will miss them dearly.
They've been, again,
They've been incredible contributors to this committee.
They've been fierce advocates for our intelligence
officers who are risking their lives around
the world, and we wish them all the very best.
Speaking of which, I can now say it to his face,
Senator Cornyn, I was just saying that
you and Senator Collins have been invaluable members
of the committee, and we will regret
seeing you go at the end of this Congress,
but we appreciate your service here, just
like we know the men and women
of our intelligence agencies appreciate it as well.
Now, moving on to the business at hand.
First, Mr. Lukowski, who has been nominated to serve as the General
Counsel of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence,
currently serves as Deputy Assistant to the President
and Deputy Counsel to the President.
In this role, he has advised on national security-related issues
and represented the White House Counsel's Office
in deputy-level National Security Council meetings.
During the first Trump administration,
Mr. Lukowski also held various roles at the Department of the Interior,
including Counselor to the Deputy Secretary
and Counselor to the Solicitor.
Additionally, he is a graduate of the University of Virginia
and the University of Virginia
School of Law.
Next, we have Mr. Wierski, the nominee for director of.
to be the director of the National Counterterrorism Center.
Before joining the NCTC
and holding numerous senior-level positions there,
Mr. Wierski spent five years working in the private sector
and 26 years serving in the U.S. Marine Corps.
Mr. Wierski, let me say up front on behalf of the committee,
thank you for your nearly three decades
of distinguished military service.
After enlisting in the Marines in 1994,
Mr. Wierski went on to serve nearly a decade as a reconnaissance Marine
in 15 years.
With the U.S. Special Operations Command,
Mr. Wierski served at the height of the global war on terror,
completing multiple war zone deployments, graduating
from the operations course, and receiving three bronze stars,
two combat action ribbons, and the Legion of Merit.
In closing, I'd like to thank both the nominees
and their loved ones for being here today.
I look forward to hearing more about
the expertise they bring to the table,
how they plan to approach these leadership roles
at the Office of the Director of National
Intelligence and the National Counterterrorism Center,
and how they intend to keep our
our intelligence agencies focused
on the primary mission of stealing our enemy's secrets.
At this point, I would turn it over to the Vice Chairman,
but we have the distinguished Senator from Montana, Senator Daines,
who we also regret will be departing us in January,
but he is here for a brief introduction before he has
to get off to other pressing business.
After his remarks, I will recognize the Vice Chairman, Senator Daines.
Mr. Chairman, thank you.
I'm very pleased to introduce Joe Wierski, the President's nominee
for Director of the National Counterterrorism Center.
There is nobody more qualified
or more deserving to serve in this role so critical to our nation's
security.
Retired Master Gunnery Sergeant Joe Wierski enlisted
in the Marine Corps in 1994.
He joined the 2nd Recon Battalion in 1996,
and prior to the War on Terror, Joe served
abroad in Kosovo and stateside as Chief Instructor
at the Marines Amphibious Reconnaissance Course.
He was then assigned to Special Operations Command.
Where he spent the next 15 years conducting hundreds
of sensitive counterterrorism missions across the Middle East
as part of the Marine Corps
and intelligence community in support of operations Iraqi Freedom,
Enduring Freedom, New Dawn, and Inherent Resolve.
Joe is recipient of the Legion of Merit,
the Bronze Star with two gold stars,
the Defense Meritorious Service Medal with two gold stars.
Joint Service Commendation Medal,
the Navy Achievement Medal, the Combat Action Ribbon
with Gold Star, and the Joint Meritorious Unit Award with a Gold Star.
He retired from active duty in 2020 following 26 years of service.
Following his retirement,
he spent some time in the private sector, but I was very fortunate
that he spent a year in my office
as a defense fellow where he contributed to a wide range of
legislative efforts
and cemented himself as truly a very key member of my team.
Joe has been on the sharp end of America's spear for decades,
standing on the front lines
and taking on the most dangerous enemies since before 9-11.
He has planned,
organized, and led some
of our nation's most sensitive counterterrorism missions.
This counterterrorism mission for Joe is not a theoretical exercise.
He has seen it up close and personal.
His long record of selfless service, hunting down terrorists, combined
with his recent experience as deputy director and acting director
of the National Counterterrorism Center makes Joe uniquely qualified
to lead this critical agency at a time of incredible unrest,
danger, and high level of threats.
It is my honor, truly, to introduce Joe to you today as somebody
who I got to serve with for a year.
I urge the members of this committee to support his nomination
as director of the National Counterterrorism Center.
Mr. Chairman, thank you.
Thank you, Senator Daines.
I now recognize the Vice Chairman for his opening remarks.
Do we get to examine this with him?
Vice Chairman.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Let me add your comments to Steve Daines.
It's been great to work with you, and the Senate will miss you.
Let me acknowledge what you said at the outset.
We do work well together.
This is the most bipartisan committee I've ever served on.
And while this is generally classified,
and please, audience, don't take this with the wrong image,
most days we even like each other.
So, uh, um,
And we're going to continue that.
And I want.
Harder for you to say than me.
Thank you for having me.
And I want to echo what you said about John Cornyn and I
have worked on many projects.
There would not have been the investments in semiconductors
around the country without John Cornyn's work
on a host of other areas.
Including one of the things that we've still got
on our plate with section 702.
Let me get to the matter at hand as well.
And I want to welcome our witnesses
and congratulations on your nominations.
And thank you both for your willingness to serve.
As I said to both of your predecessors, the NCTC director
and the ODNI general counsel may not be cabinet level positions.
But they are nonetheless very important to national security.
Both positions were created in the wake of 9-11.
And with the fundamental mission of protecting the American people
and in helping to ensure that a tragedy like 9-11 never happens again,
to succeed, you will need to earn and maintain trust
not only with the American people, but also with allies and partners
and a workforce that you will lead and advise.
Unfortunately, I believe, over the last two years,
we've seen this administration repeatedly take actions
that I think has undermined that trust.
In many ways, weakened our national security.
And quite honestly, making the jobs
that you're both up for substantially more difficult.
Almost nine months ago to the day, the president and the secretary
of defense launched this ill-advised war against Iran.
It's come at extraordinary cost, not only of service members,
lack of munitions, deaths in the region,
but also $135 billion just in fuel costs for Americans alone.
And that's before accounting for all
the other rising costs as we get into Thanksgiving week.
We were told that this war was necessary to make Americans safer,
yet the DNI himself acknowledged in a memo to the White House
that the war has resulted in, quote,
substantially increased efforts to target U.S. personnel
and plotting against U.S. citizens has reached,
quote again, advanced stages.
In other words, the administration launched
a war without congressional authorization,
imposed enormous costs on American families,
stretched our military resources thin,
and by its own admission, increased the threats facing Americans.
Mr. Wierschke, sounds like you've got a distinguished career.
I applaud that in your service to our country.
Should you be confirmed,
that is the threat environment in which you'll be asked to serve.
As I mentioned, and the chairman did, your background
as a combat-deployed Marine I think will serve you well.
And I hope you will approach this job
with the seriousness that it deserves.
However, I continue to be troubled by a pattern of, I think,
recklessness in terms of this administration's handling
of many of our national security threats.
For example, while this would not be your responsibility,
this is what you're going
to inherit.
Director Patel at the FBI's decision to fire
or reassign literally hundreds of seasoned
agents working on counterterrorism and cyber,
and we're thinking all the things that have
happened just this week,
and many of them are actually working on the Iran threat team
for no apparent reason other than to go after
the president's obsession either on immigration
enforcement or against political enemies.
At exactly the same moment,
then we should be strengthening our counterterrorism capabilities
and foreign threats perpetrated not only by Iran,
but other nation states that wish us evil.
Mr. Lukowski, I want to turn to the importance of rule of law
and responsibility that you will
resume as the ODNI General Counsel.
As I said earlier, for you to succeed, it will be critical
for you to establish trust
and transparency within your organization, with Congress and
with the American people.
Nowhere is that more consequential than the job of the General Counsel.
Where your legal advice can literally affect Americans' constitutional
rights, civil liberties, in some cases, their very lives.
Again, I come back to what I believe
is this administration's troubling disregard for both law
and its obligations to explain its actions to the American people.
It took months for the administration to provide Congress
with the legal opinion justifying military strikes in the Caribbean.
And to this day, that opinion still remains restrained
or not available to the American public.
The administration has provided
no adequate legal justification for its continued war
of choice with Iran,
despite having long exceeded the time limits established under the War
Powers Resolution, and despite votes
in both chambers of Congress opposing the conflict.
And what I'm particularly concerned about,
and this will come back to some of your actions
in the White House, I am troubled
by the president's abuse of pardon power.
We've seen a disturbing pattern of pardons
that reward political allies and individuals
with political and financial ties to the president and his family,
undermining the rule of law
and the whole principle that justice should
be administered without fear or favor.
We all know that shortly after taking office,
the president literally pardoned thousands
of individuals who participated
in the January 6th attack on the Capitol.
Since then, dozens of those individuals.
have since participated in additional criminal activities,
including child sexual abuse, rape, and domestic violence.
In another instance, the president pardoned the CEO of Binance,
a company that admitted to violating anti-money laundering laws
and facilitating transactions
with terrorist organizations in Iran and North Korea.
That pardon raises particularly serious questions,
given the reports that the CEO paid associates
of Donald Trump Jr. nearly a million dollars.
While Binance had entered
into a business arrangement supporting World Liberty Financial,
a cryptocurrency company owned predominantly
and controlled mostly by the president's family.
If that were the only such instance,
you might say, well, that's just a coincidence.
But consider Julio Herrera Velluti,
who received a pardon after his family's company
entered into a reported $50 million contract with Alina Haba,
the president's former personal authority.
Or Trevor Milton, convicted of defrauding investors
who received a pardon after he and his wife donated nearly $2 million
to support the president's re-election.
Or Paul Walchuk, convicted of tax crimes,
who was pardoned shortly after his mother attended
a million-dollar fundraiser for the president.
Unfortunately, that's all part of a broader pattern
of wealthy individuals securing pardons after making
enormous political contributions, paying millions.
To the people in the president's inner circle or entering
into business arrangements that benefit either he or his sons.
Meanwhile, these pardons have wiped out hundreds of millions
of dollars in restitution and financial penalties
that these criminals owed to their victims and the American people.
Mr. Lukowski, I know that you worked on some of those pardon cases
for the president while serving in your current role.
And you should expect that I will have plenty of questions
for you about the legal reasoning behind these decisions
and the process by which they were reached.
And how they serve the interests of justice and our national security.
Now, I know you're not going to talk about your direct work product,
but I'd like to get an understanding
of how you could rationalize those actions.
You're now being asked to step into the position
of general counsel at the ODNI.
Because ultimately, the common thread
running through all these issues is trust.
The intelligence community is vested with enormous powers.
But those powers are only going to last
as long as the American people trust us.
Most all of us on this panel thinks it's critically important
that Section 702 gets
reauthorized, but that, again, is based on trust.
So if people stop believing we deserve that trust,
those tools are going to be removed
and America is going to be made less safe.
So, Mr. Lukowski, Mr. Wierski,
I hope you're able to convince this committee and the American
people you're up to the task, and I look forward to our discussion.
Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
Thank you. Mr. Lukowski, Mr. Wierski,
before we move on to your statement, I will ask you both
to answer five standard questions the committee poses to each nominee
who appears before us. A simple yes or no for the record will do.
It doesn't need to be yes or no. The record does not reflect head nods
or shakes. One, do you agree to appear before the committee here
or in other venues when invited? Yes.
Two, if confirmed, do you agree to send officials
from your office to appear before the committee
and designated staff when invited?
Yes.
Three, do you agree to provide documents
or any other materials requested by the committee
in order for it to carry out its oversight
and legislative responsibilities?
Yes.
Four, will you ensure that your office
and your staff provide such material to the committee
when requested?
Yes.
And finally, do you agree to inform
and fully brief to the fullest extent possible all members
of this committee of intelligence activities
and covert actions rather than only the chairman and vice chairman?
Yes.
Thank you both for your answers.
I will note that after our hearing today, it is my intent
to move to convene a committee business meeting on December 1
to vote on the nominations and to report that to the Senate.
We will now proceed to your opening statements,
after which I'll recognize members by seniority
at the gavel for five minutes each. Mr. Lukowski, the floor is yours.
Chairman Cotton, Vice Chairman Warner,
and distinguished members of this committee,
it's an honor to appear before you today
as President Trump's nominee to be the General
Counsel of the Office of the Director
of National Intelligence. I'd like to begin
Let me begin with a few words of thanks.
Thank you to President Trump for his trust and confidence he has placed
in me by selecting me and nominating me for this position,
and to Director Clayton for supporting my nomination.
Thank you to my lovely wife, Heather,
who is here today for her support and patience.
Thank you to my mother, Helen,
who is also here today for all the work she did raising me
and putting up with an early interest in world affairs.
That couldn't have been easy dealing with a bunch
of questions from a five-year-old about that.
Thank you to all of my professional mentors,
many of whom are former colleagues,
without whom I would not be sitting before you today.
And finally, thank you to the team at ODNI.
Their dedication, professionalism,
and commitment to service is critical to the mission.
I remember when I was a young boy, my father would come into my room,
often before the day's first light,
to say goodbye before leaving for work.
He would not be home again until late in the evening.
He was a career federal civil servant,
spent most of his career with the Army.
From his example, I learned the value of hard work,
and that's a lesson that stuck with me throughout my career.
My experiences both in and out
of government have prepared me well to lead the General Counsel's
Office. In my current role in the White House Counsel's Office,
I have the privilege of helping
to manage and lead a team of some of the brightest,
most motivated attorneys you could hope to meet
as we provide legal advice on tough questions,
often of first impression,
concerning weighty issues of constitutional authorities.
In my role in the Counsel's Office,
The White House Counsel and other top national
security lawyers have looked to me for advice
and judgment on a range of sensitive matters.
Before joining the White House,
I had the privilege of also directly advising and learning
from top agency officials, including the Secretary of the Interior,
the Solicitor of the Interior,
and three commissioners on the Federal Election Commission.
These experiences taught me a lot about how
to be an effective lawyer in a fast-paced,
high-stakes agency environment.
I learned the importance of providing clear,
accurate, and timely guidance to inform decisions
and the value of a robust
and open process for stress testing ideas and interpretations
against the best counterarguments.
Perhaps most importantly, they taught me
to recognize the distinction between providing
legal advice and acting as a manager.
Legal advice should be grounded in reasonable risk assessment
and give leaders information
they need to make their informed choices,
while management often involves setting the
office policies and directing operations.
My work in government and in the private sector
has emphasized the importance of servant
leadership, both at a personal level within the office
and at an institutional level.
After all, government officials are there to serve we the people,
not our own bureaucratic
convenience.
Thus, while we must be focused on the key mission
of keeping the American people safe
and secure, we also must not overlook the need
to safeguard our key constitutional rights
and make sure the American people have
the information necessary to make informed evaluations
of what their government is doing.
Thank you very much for your time this afternoon.
I appreciate the opportunity to be here today,
and I look forward to your questions.
Chairman Cotton.
Vice Chairman Warner and members of the committee,
thank you for the opportunity to appear before you as a nominee
to serve as a director of the National Counterterrorism Center.
I want to thank President Trump and Director Clayton for the trust
and confidence they have placed in me.
I am honored by the opportunity to continue serving our country and,
if confirmed, to lead NCTC in carrying out its vital mission
in support of the President's national security priorities.
I also want to acknowledge my family.
I want to say thank you to all of my family and friends
whose love and support have sustained me throughout my
years of military and public service.
My fiancee Jen, daughter Bree, son JC, and parents at home.
I am deeply thankful to each of them for standing with me
through every demanding moment.
As a father, I understand that the security of our nation
is about protecting our families, our communities,
and the future we leave for the next generation.
That sense of responsibility has guided my service,
and it would continue to guide me as director of NCTC.
My understanding of that responsibility was shaped
by 26 years of service in the United States Marine Corps,
enlisting just after high school.
Throughout that time, I conducted counterterrorism operations against
a diverse array of adversaries,
including hostile nations and non-state actors.
Across multiple deployments, including combat deployments,
I also learned how to gather
intelligence and clearly report it to inform our operational decisions.
After retiring from the Marine Corps
in 2020 as a Master Gunnery Sergeant,
I spent five years in the private sector
and most recently as a Chief Operating Officer supporting
national security missions. Leading teams,
managing personnel and budgets, and aligning resources with
mission priorities reinforce the importance
of disciplined execution and accountability.
Now I have brought my military and private sector skills together,
serving in NCTC senior
leadership, including as deputy director and acting director.
Over the past years, I have seen firsthand
the demands of leading the center in a complex
threat environment.
My experience taught me that effective counterterrorism
is rarely about a single operation.
It depends on sustained intelligence collection,
analysis, sound judgment, and partnerships
built on mutual trust.
These partnerships are not about convenience. They are critical.
They transform isolated information into actionable intelligence.
They make certain that overseas tips
and analytic leads reach law enforcement partners at home
and inform military and intelligence operations abroad.
And they ensure that
law enforcement and border security act
on the full picture rather than fragments of it.
In that same spirit, I commend President Trump's accomplishments
in strengthening our border security.
We must continue that important work to protect the American people
by remaining focused on the full range of terrorist threats
to our nation and its interests.
Iran and Iran-aligned terrorist groups pose serious challenges,
particularly as events in the Middle East continue
to shape the threat environment.
Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and their affiliates continue to seek to do us harm.
In the Western Hemisphere,
foreign terrorist organization cartels and transnational gangs
perpetuate destabilizing violence
and drug trafficking that kills Americans.
If confirmed as director,
I would welcome the opportunity to ensure NCTC remains focused
on what matters most,
protecting American people from terrorist threats.
We also have to ensure that NCTC is prepared for the challenges ahead.
We need talented people, clear mission priorities,
and all the tools and technology necessary
to operate with speed and precision.
Progress is often measured not in headlines,
but in better decisions, stronger partnerships,
more capable officers,
and threats identified early enough for our partners to act.
If confirmed, I would engage with this committee openly,
provide timely and accurate information,
And communicate directly about significant threats.
Thank
you, Mr.
Wierski.
Let's stick with you.
The Iran regime continues to pose
a grave threat to our national security.
Iran is terrorized.
mainly killed thousands of Americans over the last 47 years.
Recently, British law enforcement has
arrested multiple Iranian-linked terrorists
who were scheming to attack our troops at RAF Fairford,
and it has been publicly reported
that Iranians continue plotting to attack us at home.
How would you characterize the threat currently posed
by Iran's regime inside the United States?
Good afternoon, Senator. Thank you for that question.
Of course, a lot of the news that we've seen lately with regard
to Iranian threat-related plotting directed at the homeland
and our interests abroad, it is unsettling.
It's unsettling for the American people.
However, for the men and women of NCTC, it is not anything new.
You talked about that arc of terror from Iran
that started over four decades ago.
We saw it probably most recently before
this instance where epic fury began.
It's in 2020, post the Soleimani strike, where lethal plotting began.
And the threat inside of the United States?
Senator, that arc of terror has always
been directed at the United States.
There for sure is an intent by the Iranian regime
to direct terror inside the United States.
To talk to the specifics of that,
I would have to do that in a classified setting.
I understand.
Is Iran still trying to kill Donald Trump
or other members of this administration?
They continue to plot to kill senior members of our administration
and go at the very core
of our national power in the United States for over six years now.
What about members of Congress?
Is Iran plotting to kill members of Congress,
or would they aspire to do so?
Senator
They would aspire to inflict pain on the United States
however they could,
and they are directing that effort at senior officials.
Any aspect of the threat from Iran
that either you didn't discuss in your opening statement
or we have in our exchange here that you would like
to highlight for the American people?
Certainly, Senator.
As a young Marine,
I checked into my first operational unit in the mid-1990s,
2nd Reconnaissance Battalion.
There was 17 wooden paddles on the quarterdeck of the entryway.
Each one of those paddles wrapped with 550 cord and adorned.
It was a memorial.
For each of the 17 Marines that were killed
in the Marine barracks bombing October 23rd, 1983,
I knew at that moment that Iran was directing its terror at our nation.
And that conveyed across
my career throughout operational deployments into Iraq,
where the regime was trying to kill me
and my friends with explosively formed penetrators surveilling us,
and they still do to this day.
Thank you for that.
Iran has had changes in leadership over the last 47 years.
They had involuntary changes earlier this year,
thanks to American and Israeli airstrikes.
Is there any reason to think the current leaders
of Iran have turned over a new leaf?
Senator, yeah, there's no indication that there's any turning over,
I believe, with the results.
Thank you.
Mr. Lukowski, if confirmed to be the general counsel at the ODNI,
you'll be advising the director
on a multitude of national security issues,
including the surveillance of foreign spies
and terrorists within the United States.
Unfortunately, we have more than a few of those.
Thank you
for the question,
Senator.
I think generally, if you're looking at it
from the intelligence perspective or from the sort
of national security perspective, it's very few rights.
If you're looking to charge them under something like FARA
or another similar law, then obviously they have
the access to the American criminal justice system.
And if someone's an enemy combatant, they may have some habeas
rights under Kieran and Hamdan and some of the other line of cases.
Thank you.
Vice Chairman.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Mr. Olkowski, according to your own questionnaire.
You worked on some of the pardons in the administration.
One of those is finance co-founder Changpeng Zhao,
who pled guilty to both money laundering charges,
including illicit transactions tied to terrorist organizations
in Iran, North Korea, Cuba, and Russia.
Now, I understand you're not going to tell me
about the advice you gave the president,
but in your opening statement,
you were talking a lot about the role of a lawyer
to offer advice and counsel and respect for the law.
How do you square the circle that it's appropriate to pardon someone
who has literally helped finance terrorists,
including, as the chairman just pointed out,
Iran, which is one of our major enemies?
Thank you for the question, Senator.
In our system, it's not the White House Counsel's Office.
It's not the lawyers who decide who we're going to pardon.
The Constitution commits that power to the president in his discretion,
and he's able to kind of make that choice based
on whichever factors he chooses to look at.
So the fact.
that Mr. Zhao received his pardon after he paid
a friend of the president's son $800,000
and his company Binance created a deal with World Liberty Financial,
hugely enriched the president in a crypto deal.
Again, I know you're not going to get specific with me,
but it just seems like raising even
the concern about appearance of propriety.
If the...
Jay Clayton, a lot of respect.
We're going to ask you to.
Take an action where we're going to somehow take one of the crypto boys
and and start to do business with them as from the DNI's perspective.
And if that was somebody who had been involved
in financing of terrorist organizations or had received or it was,
in effect, appearance wise,
at least paying the president's family for getting a pardon.
What would you advise? I know it's a hypothetical,
but what would you would you say?
This doesn't look right. This doesn't smell right.
How would you how would you advise Mr. Clayton?
So I think I'd have to look at the specific facts of the situation.
With respect to Mr. Zhao and Binance,
my participation in his pardon was very limited.
It's mostly limited to receiving information
and talking about how we're going to respond
to different press inquiries, so I'm not
familiar with all of the facts surrounding
that particular instance.
With respect to your hypothetical, though,
I mean, well, if we consider the facts, I'd
advise appropriately under the law.
I missed the last part.
Sorry, I would consider the facts and circumstances
surrounding whatever the question that was posed
and then apply and advise appropriately under the law.
Again, I just feel, and this keeps coming back to trust here,
I think the American public's trust has been fractured a little bit
by not just Mr. Zhao, but a number of these other individuals,
the $25 million contract for one of those pardons
to the president's personal lawyer.
And particularly when we're dealing
with extraordinary powers like Section 702, it's a huge concern for me.
I mean, I know you'll probably answer the same, but I can tell you
for all of us who were up here on January 6th a few years back,
it was one of the things I'll remember for the rest of my life,
not unlike 9-11, not unlike where the man landed on the moon,
Kennedy's assassination.
Hundreds and hundreds of these individuals pardoned.
Do you realize there are 97 of those individuals
that were pardoned have gone on to commit
other serious crimes?
I haven't kept track of all those individuals. However, obviously,
if they have committed other crimes
that are not covered by the pardon, they should be
charged and prosecuted appropriately.
Those crimes have included rape, murder,
child sexual abuse. Again, we're looking for judgment here.
And again, I understand you were
just the lawyer, but so many times I was just
the lawyer kind of becomes the default answer.
And I'm, I'm continue this, um, one last question.
Uh, one of the things that we've been trying to,
to get to is, um, on the question of Caribbean
raids.
And I'm like anyone else feel very strongly.
We need to do everything we can to eliminate these,
these drug traffickers.
Uh, there was a legal opinion.
Um, we debate the merits of it, uh, but.
If you're confirmed with this, will you work,
and this is a very important issue to a number
of the members on my committee,
to work with us to try to make sure that legal opinion
is released to the American public?
Thank you.
So transparency is something that's incredibly important to me.
That's certainly a question I'm happy to look
into if I'm fortunate enough to be confirmed.
I want to be careful committing to release something
because I haven't been involved
in the discussions about why it hasn't been released yet.
So it's sort of...
In some ways, it's a Chesterton's fence situation where I see
the fence I up, but I don't necessarily see why it's there.
And I want to understand that before I make that commitment.
Well, should you be confirmed, I will want to follow up with you
and would love to get a legal justification why
this would not be released to the American public.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator King.
14th
Street.
If the Metropolitan Police had suspicion
that an individual walking down 14th Street was carrying drugs.
Could they shoot him?
No, Senator.
Okay, so if that's clearly the case,
and you answered that without any qualification,
why are these drug strikes on these boats in Latin America,
and what are people who
are couriers, legal?
What's the legal justification for that action?
I believe the legal justification
for that is still classified at this time as Senator.
I want to follow up on that.
I've never heard of a legal opinion being classified.
What is the basis of the classification of a legal opinion?
How can the people of the United States know
that the administration is acting lawfully
if they say, we have a legal opinion that says it's lawful,
but we're not going to let you see it?
I've read that opinion, by the way.
There's not a word in it that needs to be classified.
I haven't been involved in the decision about whether
or not to classify that or keep it classified.
If I'm fortunate enough to be confirmed,
I'm certainly happy to look into that question.
Well, again, the vice chairman is talking about trust and transparency.
It's ironic to talk about transparency when the legal basis
of a significant federal action is not available to the public.
Are there, I mean, I'm curious about the pardon.
You talked about that.
At one point, you said it's entirely the president's decision.
What I wrote in my notes is, so why do we need a pardon council?
What was your job?
So we've had a couple different, throughout
the way the government's been organized,
we've had a couple different ways pardons have come up.
Obviously, the president is one individual.
He can't possibly know every situation.
So there's been a pardon office in the Department
of Justice that sometimes makes recommendations.
Also, for us, the White House Council.
Does that department, the Department of Justice, still exist?
I believe it does still exist.
But also with, so what, tell me again, what was your,
what was your job? You went to work in the
White House. What did you do?
My main focus was litigation and policy. As pardoned? I thought
your job was as part as pardon counsel in the White House.
I'm actually not our primary pardon
counsel. I've worked on some pardon issues
and I understand the New York Times has suggested that
I might've been, but my main issues have been litigation
and policy matters. Do you believe
there are any ethical
or legal limits whatsoever on the president's pardon power?
As set forth in the Constitution, it is one of the broader
and one of the more unconstrained authorities the president has.
It pretty much commits the authority to his unilateral discretion.
So could a person walk into the Oval Office and say,
Mr. President, I'd like a pardon.
Here's a million dollars for that pardon,
and the president could grant it, and that's okay?
Well, bribery itself would be a separate statutory crime.
How that would interact with presidential immunity,
I think, would be a complicated legal question
that the court kind of reserved in that case.
Let's move on to another legal question,
which is the legality of the Iran war.
We know that it wasn't declared by Congress.
We know that there was no finding under the War Powers Resolution.
What is the legal basis of the current conflict in Iran?
I wasn't involved in the formulation on that legal basis.
I'm not able to speak to that question at this time.
As an attorney practicing at the highest level
of the federal government, you have no opinion
or thoughts on...
What should be the legal basis of this country entering into a war?
I mean, I might have lots of thoughts about what should
be a legal basis or what I think
the legal basis is, or I could speculate
on the legal basis, but I wasn't involved and
cannot represent what the legal basis the president's relying upon is.
So you just said your job in the White House was litigation.
What could you describe the litigations you were involved in?
So most, a lot of the cases,
so overseeing our team as we kind of help manage litigation that
touches upon the White House, touches upon White House equities,
touches upon executive orders or
kind of priorities of the president.
Can you give us a case that you were involved in that we would
be familiar with? The slaughter case, for example,
or some of the removal cases that kind of led to
the Supreme Court's decision in slaughter would be one example.
Were you involved in the decisions
Any conclusions involving Mr. Garcia and his attempted removal?
Yes, I've been involved in some of those matters.
And does the president have the obligation to follow
the orders of a United States District Court?
Generally, there's an obligation to follow court orders.
There are limited exceptions for if, for example,
you're trying to challenge a prior court order,
you're trying to establish a basis for appeal.
But your position is that...
The administration, any president,
should follow the orders of a duly constituted Article III court.
Is that correct?
And I believe this president has.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator Wyden.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Mr. Lukowski is Deputy White House Counsel.
You were involved in conversations related
to the investigations and prosecutions
of Trump-perceived political enemies.
Which of the cases were you involved in and who did you talk to about?
Can you ask a little more specifically
which individuals you're referring to?
Particularly, which of the cases were you involved in?
I'm not quite sure
who you're referring to as the president's political enemies.
Well, why don't we move on?
Do you understand why it's so inappropriate for the White House
to be involved in any criminal investigations,
much less of the president's political enemies?
I agree that criminal law should not be used for partisan purposes.
I don't necessarily think that's what's happening here.
I don't agree that the president has no role in the criminal process.
I mean, that's a core executive power
that's vested within the presidency.
You know, what has troubled me about all this is your inability
to appreciate the importance of the Justice Department independence.
Justice, you're going to have the same attitude about
the independence of the intelligence agencies.
Make some progress on independence issues here going forward.
As deputy White House counsel,
you were involved in two executive orders designed to help Donald
Trump persecute Americans designated as domestic terrorists.
So I was very troubled by this and by your legal analysis.
There's no basis in law to designate a domestic terrorist organization,
but you claim the president can just do it anyway based
on some magical constitutional authority.
Once he's operating outside the law,
are there any limits to how Donald Trump can persecute Americans?
I don't agree with the premise
that the president's acting outside the law.
And of course, the president is constrained
by the limits of the Constitution.
So in 2023, you responded to public reports
of abuse of Section 702 of FISA with this tweet.
If only there were some process to get a neutral third party
to sign off before conducting a search.
That sounds to me like endorsement
of a judicial warrant for searches of Americans.
Is that still your position?
I support 702 reauthorization and the involvement of the FISA court
so that there is an independent judicial body
that is reviewing kind of how this process is going on.
Can you confirm that the president doesn't have legal
or constitutional authority to
direct the intelligence community
to conduct warrantless surveillance of Americans?
The president's bound to follow the Fourth Amendment.
I think it kind of depends what
you're referring to as a warrantless search of Americans.
You don't need a warrant for all
sorts of activities. And so there
are certain times where you wouldn't need a warrant. There
are certain times, even under FISA,
where a probable cause finding is sufficient.
Senator Ossoff.
Mr. Lukowski, you just stated your personal opinion.
That criminal law should not be used for partisan purposes, correct?
Yes, Senator.
And you stated further your view, I infer,
based on your experience in the White House,
that that hasn't been the practice of the administration.
Is that correct?
Yes, Senator.
Is it appropriate for the president to direct
or encourage the Department of Justice,
privately or publicly, to investigate,
indict, or charge persons for reasons of
personal animus or personal grievance?
The president has broad authority to oversee the Department of Justice.
My question is not about presidential authority.
You stated earlier your private view that it's
not appropriate to use the criminal law for partisan ends.
My question is, is it appropriate for the president or administration
to apply criminal law for the purpose of pursuing the president's
grievances or for reasons of the president's personal animus?
If what you're referring to is grievances
or reasons of personal animus overlap with violations of the law, yes.
Is it appropriate for the President to direct
or encourage the Department of Justice to
apply prosecutorial discretion to pursue alleged violations
of criminal law because the President
wants to target certain individuals for reasons
of personal grievance or personal animus?
Again, I mean, if the reasons the President
is citing are violations of the law, then
of course it's appropriate for the Department of Justice to pursue.
So you think it's appropriate for a president
to direct the Department of Justice?
Apply prosecutorial discretion according to the president's
personal grievances or personal animus against defendants?
I certainly think the president,
as part of his oversight of the Department of Justice
and his duty to ensure the law is faithfully executed,
has a key role in advising...
Not my question. My question is, is it appropriate for the president
to ask prosecutors to investigate, indict, or charge people
because the president has a personal grievance
or personal animus against those defendants? Yes or no?
Is it appropriate? You stated what's proper earlier.
Is that appropriate? Yes or no?
It's appropriate to work with the Department
of Justice to bring charges where there's a
valid basis under the law to bring charges.
Earlier, you stated your view that this White
House has not applied the criminal law
for partisan reasons. In your opinion,
has this White House or this administration applied
the criminal law in order to pursue
the President's personal grievances,
personal animus, or personal vendettas?
I believe the president has sought to apply
the criminal law where it is appropriate,
where there are violations of law.
Yes or no, do you believe that this president
has asked prosecutors of the Department of
Justice to investigate, indict,
or charge on the basis of his personal grievances or
personal animus?
Yes or no, Mr. Lukowski?
I believe it's based on whether or not there's a violation of law.
Did you recuse yourself in the Kelsey matter?
I did not materially participate in that matter.
Did you recuse?
Yes.
You did recuse?
On Kelsey, yes.
Will you provide the committee with a memorandum
or letter substantiating that claim?
If I can, there's an email, but I need to see it.
I'd have to check if I can release that.
We'll look for that.
Julio Martin Herrera Velutini had been charged with conspiracy,
wire fraud, and bribery,
and later struck a, quote, unusually lenient plea deal
for a campaign finance violation.
Are you familiar with the Velutini case?
No, Senator.
You're not familiar at all with the Velutini case?
This is Julio Martin Herrera Velutini.
You're not familiar with the case?
No, Senator.
This is the matter in which
the president granted Mr. Velutini a pardon
shortly after his daughter hired Alina Habba.
You're not familiar with the case?
I don't recall the case, no.
Mr. Lukowski.
Strains credulity, this has been a very high profile case involving
a very high profile pardon, very high profile payments made
to a DOJ official and the president's former personal attorney,
Ms. Haba, with whom I have no doubt you're intimately familiar.
Your testimony today is you're not familiar with that case.
It's not ringing a bell. I could certainly
email and try to find something on it.
A follow-up on that. Juan Orlando Hernandez,
the former president of Honduras, was convicted
of conspiracy to import cocaine in the United States
and sentenced to 45 years in prison.
Are you familiar with that case?
Generally, I'm familiar with the headline.
Did you work on the matter? No.
Are you aware that the president granted him
a full pardon two days before the Honduran
presidential election? I think I saw press reports about that.
You don't recall any discussion of it in the White House?
There may have been some discussion,
but I wasn't involved in the pardon.
Mr. Trevor Milton had been convicted
in 2023 of securities and wire fraud.
Are you familiar with the Milton matter? Not in any depth, no.
Are you aware that President Trump granted Mr. Milton
a full pardon in March of 2025,
shortly after he and his wife contributed nearly $2.5 million
to pro-Trump political committees?
I believe it's been referenced in this hearing, but otherwise, no.
This is the first time you've heard of it?
Again, I'm not our principal pardon person,
so I don't necessarily track all the pardons.
Is this the first time you've heard of it?
I don't recall it before.
I may have heard of it before, but I don't recall.
Mr. Paul Wachter, are you familiar with the case?
Wachter, are you familiar with the case?
No, I don't recall it.
You've never heard of Mr. Paul Walzak?
I don't recall it.
He was convicted in 2025 of tax crimes.
You're not familiar?
Again, I'm not our pardon person.
I'm not intimately familiar with all of our pardons.
His mother then attended a one million per person
Mar-a-Lago fundraising dinner for MAGA Inc.
in April, three weeks before the president
granted him a full pardon.
Are you familiar with that?
Again, I believe it's been referenced earlier in this hearing.
This is the first time you've ever heard about it?
I don't recall it before.
I could search my email to see if there's some sort of reference to it.
Are you familiar with Mr. Adam Kyden?
No.
Contributed hundreds of thousands of dollars
to Trump-aligned political committees.
And was then granted a full pardon.
You're familiar with the case?
No.
Never heard of it?
I don't think so.
Did you ever advise the president
that he could undertake acts that would be criminal
violations for a private individual,
but that he was protected by the immunity granted by
the Supreme Court for such acts?
I mean, I couldn't discuss what I've advised the president,
however, but that does not
sound like something I would say.
Thank you.
The vice chairman.
Mr. Lukowski, I'm not going to go down the same line,
but I find it hard that you didn't
even hear about the $50 million contract with Alina Habba.
It was on all of the front pages of every newspaper,
and it's just strange credibility
that it wouldn't be a discussion matter,
at least amongst the staff at the White House,
so maybe you can correct that at some point.
Mr. Lukowski, I've just got one question,
because we have real concerns about this administration
using the powers you're granted inappropriately,
and I appreciate your answers to me on NCTC's
domestic activities,
but there has been a long history way before this administration
of
Political dissidents, civil rights leaders,
journalists being taken advantage of.
So I just want to make sure, for the record,
what assurances can you provide this committee and the American public
that NCTC will not use its considerable powers to target
those presidents' perceived political adversaries,
you.
such as by labeling those adversaries simply domestic terrorists?
Thank you for the question, Senator.
So NCTC requires a foreign nexus.
We do not do an evaluation on purely domestic terror individuals.
No.
You're saying you will not use this enormous power that you've got
to target the president's political adversaries,
even should he call them, without proof, domestic terrorists?
Senator, if there is no foreign nexus,
we do not pursue action on any of those domestic-based individuals.
Even if the president directs you to?
So you won't take an illegal action in your role?
I would not.
But we never have to come to that point.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Mr. Wierski, for that answer.
This has been an issue that the committee has both Republicans
and Democrats have had with NCTC over the years.
There's a lot of bad guys out there in America
that deserve to be arrested and locked up for a long time.
That doesn't mean that the NCTC
is the right agency to tackle every bad guy.
That's why we have the FBI and the Secret Service
and the Marshals and Homeland Security Investigations
and U.S. attorneys and so on and so forth.
Okay, as I mentioned earlier,
it's my plan to hold a committee vote on your nominations as soon
as possible. For planning purposes,
any member who wishes to submit questions for the record
after today's hearing, please do so by 5 p.m. tomorrow.
That's Thursday, November 19.
We will ask for both of your responses to those questions
by noon next Wednesday, November 25th.
I trust that you will be able to get
those responses to us in a timely fashion so we can
To a committee vote the week after Thanksgiving.
Thank you all for your attendance.
We are adjourned.
