Your support is very much appreciated. Thanks, guys!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker argues that many Linux distributions waste excessive effort on aesthetic desktop customizations and branding rather than focusing on core system stability. He suggests that \"ricing\" the UI often disrupts intended workflows and provides little real value, as most experienced users prefer to customize their own environments.
In recent years, I've started thinking
that most Linux distributions waste a lot of time.
I think a lot of development
into all of our Linux distributions,
I think much of that development is wasted
on things that don't really matter.
One of the things that I've come to realize,
especially as somebody that has played around
with the idea of creating my own Linux distribution
in the past, I've created ISOs
and my own repos of software.
I had to learn how to package things
and go through all the trouble creating ISOs
and creating custom installation programs.
And now it's a lot of work.
And there's a lot of work that goes into building
and maintaining, especially a Linux distribution.
It's not something I enjoy.
I've done it a little bit in the past,
mainly just for content purposes.
People want to know how to create a Linux distribution.
So that's why I've done a lot of that work in the past.
It's not something I enjoy at all.
I certainly don't want to maintain a Linux distribution.
Right, it's way, way, way too much work.
It would take away from all the other things
that I have going on in life.
But I know a lot of people do enjoy that work
and you never want to tell people, you know,
where they should spend their time and effort
when it comes to free and open source software.
But I do think a lot of these Linux distributions,
they need to reconsider some of the work that they're doing.
I think, you know, there's really two main areas,
two main, you know, categories of a Linux distribution.
There's all the under the hood stuff,
you know, your core system components.
So the kernel, the drivers, the shell,
your shell utilities, you know, that sort of stuff.
And then there's the desktop that sits on top of it,
right, your graphical user interface.
And I think way too many Linux distributions
focus on that graphical user interface part,
the desktop part.
I don't think these days,
I don't think it makes much sense
for all these Linux distributions
to spend all their time or most of their time
customizing the desktop.
There's no reason to customize these desktop environments.
Just ship them vanilla out of the box.
There is no reason to spend all your time
trying to make GNOME or make KDE
or whatever desktop you're using
to make it look some weird, fancy way
with a workflow that maybe wasn't even intended
by that organization.
That's the other thing.
Some of these desktop environments like a GNOME or a KDE,
they've spent thousands of hours
trying to decide what their user experience should be,
what the user interface should look like,
what the user experience should be,
the intended workflow.
And these distributions,
sometimes when they do radical customizations
of these desktop environments,
they're changing the intended workflow.
And that may or may not be a good thing.
And it's subjective too.
Not every user wants to use the same desktop environment
or the desktop environment you ship with.
Even if they wanna use that desktop environment,
not everybody uses that desktop environment the same way.
Everybody's going to tweak it to their needs anyway.
So I think a lot of these distributions,
they waste way too much time on the looks, right?
Just make the thing rock solid under the hood, right?
Worry about kernel optimizations and drivers
and things that really matter.
Make sure I can get it installed on my hardware.
I really don't care about the desktop that gets shipped.
Ship whatever desktop you wanna ship with,
because I'm going to install whatever I want anyway.
And I think most Linux users,
especially longtime Linux users,
they're gonna install the desktop environment they want.
And then they're gonna customize it however they want,
whatever extensions they want,
if they want any extensions,
strip things out that they don't want,
install things that they do want.
So I don't think these distributions
really should be so hyper-focused
on that desktop experience.
I don't think that matters
as much as what many of them think.
Too many of them get in the mindset of,
it's all about ricing the desktop.
That's the distro, right?
The rice, right?
The customization, the wallpaper, the icon set,
where the taskbar sits on the panel,
where the panel's oriented on the screen,
things like that.
Should we have some cool widgets on the desktop,
like a clock widget or a weather widget,
and yada, yada, yada.
And again, I think all of that
is more superfluous kind of stuff.
That's not the stuff that really matters
at the end of the day.
And furthermore, I think most people
that develop and maintain Linux distributions,
if you've ever created a Linux distribution,
you know that it's not really about the desktop, right?
It's all about the under the hood stuff
that truly matters, right?
It's that kernel.
It's your software repos, right?
It's the repos and the packages within the repos.
It's your release cadence,
static release versus rolling release.
The drivers, that's the stuff that truly matters.
But here's the thing.
If you only focus on that stuff,
then every Linux distribution,
they start to be hard to differentiate themselves
from one another.
To really differentiate yourself
from one distribution to the next,
I think a lot of these distributions,
they think that it's all about the branding.
You have to come up with a fancy look,
fancy wallpaper, a logo, a unique design.
Yeah, we know that this desktop environment
wanted the panel to sit at the top of the screen,
but we're gonna put it at the bottom
just to make ourselves look a little different.
And put it on the right-hand side of the screen,
the left-hand side, whatever side of the screen.
We're gonna put it over there
because we'll be the only ones to do that.
And that'll just make us stand out a little bit.
So that's, it's all about branding too.
A lot of this wasted desktop customization effort
is really more about branding
than does it actually provide anything to the user.
And that's partly why I have a problem with it.
I mean, if you really think about it,
if you stripped the desktop away
or you just made these Linux distributions
ship vanilla desktops.
So for example, if Ubuntu, Linux Mint,
and Pop! OS, MX Linux, and Debian
all shipped vanilla GNOME out of the box,
and that was the desktop they all went with,
they'd essentially all be the same Linux distribution.
That's why a lot of these distributions, I think,
feel like they have to customize their desktop
because some of them would feel like,
hey, we're kind of irrelevant
if we don't customize the desktop.
And I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing.
I do think some of these distributions,
I won't say that they're pointless,
but I do think they're not serving a real need
that's out there in the community.
I think a lot of them,
it's more about the maintainer of that distribution
wants to be seen as the maintainer of a Linux distribution,
wants that distribution to be popular,
whether that popularity is actually warranted or not,
whether that distribution is actually needed or not.
Of course, there's some ego involved
and that's just natural human behavior.
But I really wish a lot of these distributions
really focus more on, again, that under the hood stuff
rather than the paint job that's sitting on top of it.
Anyway, food for thought.
Peace, guys.