Lead Poisoning as a factor in Rome's fall | Examining what we know of the theory and evidence

Cycle Nomad
1 follower
2 Video Views·Dec 8, 2024
SOURCES:
The Myth of Lead Poisoning among the Romans: An Essay Review, Scarborough
Lead & Lead Poisoning in Antiquity, Nriagu
Lead Poisoning & Rome, The University of Chicago (https://penelope.uchicago.edu/encyclopaedia_romana/wine/leadpoisoning.html)
the Roman Empire existed as an Empire
more or less from the time of octavian's
Triumph at the Battle of actium in 31 BC
to some point in the fifth or 6th
Century ad different positions taken
require different dates but much of the
discussion is broadly moving to the 6th
Century due to widespread long-term
disruptions like the wars of Justinian
and the ravages of bubanic plague but no
matter how you conceive of it what
you're ultimately looking at is a
complex civilization that exists for
over half a millennium and then it
collapses and Fades away Roman
civilization does survive in the Eastern
provinces although those quickly come
under attack from numerous different
threats and the archaeological evidence
for the rest of the empire in Europe and
the Mediterranean tells us that for
maybe a century or so things get really
bad in terms of quality of life Rome is
the great standin for modern concerns
and it's not unusual to try and search
for monocausal reasons for the end of
that Civilization because if we can
figure that out then perhaps we can stop
our own civilization from ending in a
similar fashion since the 18th century
when Edward Gibbon published The Decline
and fall of the Roman Empire people have
been searching for that cause and in the
1980s Alexander deont a German historian
published a book on Roman history
toriography in which he outlines the
major and minor suggestions for what
happened to Rome and it gets categorized
into what has since become informally
known as the list it's about 210
different reasons people have suggested
for the fall of the Roman Empire and it
goes from things that are fairly
straightforward like military defeat to
things that are a bit more out there and
probably difficult to prove like lack of
moral fiber to some fairly outlandish
ideas like overheating from too much
bathing so in this video I want to
explore one of these reasons the idea
that Rome declined and fell due to
Chronic lead poisoning now there are two
ways we can do this the first is that we
can ask the question do historians of
the Roman Empire take this as a serious
argument for what happened to the Roman
Empire to which the answer would be no
they don't because there isn't really
evidence for it with an exception that
we're going to come to at the end of
this video but past a certain point that
answer isn't really useful because this
idea still does pop up from time to time
this shows up in the reboot of Cosmos
for instance so for the rest of this
video I want to focus on the second way
that we can approach this topic where
did this idea come from how did the
Romans come into contact with lead were
they aware of any problems associated
with lead and ultimately why isn't this
idea really all that viable as an
explanation so the earliest take we have
on this idea comes from a paper
published by Rudolph Cobert chronic Leed
poisoning in classical Antiquity in
1909 but it sort of just seems to have
been an idea that was put forth which
did not make a huge Splash among
classicists and ancient historians it's
sort of laid dormant for several decades
until
1965 when cury gilfillan a sociologist
published an article in the Journal of
Occupational Medicine and then later
after his death a book was published
Rome's ruined by lead poisoning these
Publications sort of resurrect the
debate around this question but really
it takes off in its modern form and in
popular culture due to the last major
publication and restatement of this
Theory Jerome nagu's LED and led
poisoning in Antiquity which came out in
1983 the basic argument of all of these
works but especially in rago's book is
that the Romans came into contact with
enough lead to cause chronic serious
exposure to the substance and thus
poisoning in two major forms the first
is through the piping used in Plumbing
in the aqueduct systems and the second
is through wine production generally
speaking this is thought to have
impacted the Roman population as a whole
because cities and even Towns at
Aqueduct and bathouses and fountains but
more specifically the argument really
tries to focus on the Roman aristocracy
because they drank a lot of wine so
where would the Romans have obtained
lead in the first place well the answer
to this is that the Romans primarily
would have obtained lead as a b
byproduct of the silver mining most
notably in Iberia and in the British
Isles especially in Cornwall and in
Wales this ore was smelted and refined
and eventually it was separated from the
lead and once it was separated the lead
was soft enough that the Romans could
work with it and one of the ways that
lead was used in the Roman Empire was
for plumbing sheets of lead were either
rolled into pipes or the sheets were
placed in the channels of aqueducts to
line them so lead certainly was present
in the Roman W system but did it lead to
Chronic lead poisoning well they
certainly understood that lead could
potentially be dangerous one of our
major sources on Roman architecture is
the writing of betrus who lived in the
first century and concerning lead
poisoning he makes it very clear that
the workers probably slaves in all
honesty who were involved in the
smelting and processing of lead were
often extremely pale these specifics of
lead poisoning in the sense of what you
would see if you went to a hospital in
the 21st century and you looked at the
blood work in the vitals chart of
someone suffering L poisoning do not
appear to have been known to the Romans
but they were aware that exposer did
something to the body Vitruvius tells us
that quote for ENC casting lead the
fumes from it fixing on the different
members and daily burning them destroy
the Vigor of the blood water should
therefore on no account be conducted in
lead in pipes if we are desirous that it
should be wholesome this is just one
example and the earliest reference to
something that sounds like lead
poisoning appears to come from the poet
nander in the 2 Century BC but the
Romans were aware that exposure to lead
was not a good thing especially in water
which then leads us to two questions why
would they use lead pipes and if lead
pipes were not desirable what did they
use
instead well because the lead was a
byproduct of silver mining the Romans
had quite a lot of it and due to the
softness and the low melting point it is
quite malleable so essentially it was
cheap to use lead piping but where
possible multiple surviving sources like
the Truvia tell us that the Romans
prefer to use terracotta pipes that
being said lead was used extensively so
could there have been a danger to the
general population if there was any risk
of lead contaminated water in general it
probably was very very small the Romans
did not have filtration systems in the
manner that we do today so because the
water flowing through the aqueducts and
the pipes came from Rivers streams and
natural springs what that means is that
as the water moved through the system
two things occurred the first thing that
happened was that although the Romans
did have Taps for fountains and things
of that nature more often than not they
were left on meaning that there wasn't
really an extended period for the water
to sit and become contaminated by lead
the second thing that happened was that
because of the sources being tapped the
water was often fairly hard so there was
builtup on the lead over time mainly of
calcium carbonates and the Romans had to
send in workers every year to scrape off
the deposits on the aqueduct lining and
routinely replace pipes because they
were becoming clogged this is why texts
on aqueducts usually specify the channel
has to be wide enough for a man to fit
in it what this did over time was
effectively lineing the lead and prevent
the water from becoming contaminated so
that's it for the piping now let's talk
about the wine if you were to read the
literature which argues for lead
poisoning this is really the major
argument it's more about lead poisoning
from contaminated wine then contaminated
water but for whatever reason the pipe
seem to stick out in popular imagination
so with that in mind how would the
Romans have come into contact with lead
contaminated wine well it's not
necessarily through the wine itself
instead it probably would have been
through Sapa a syrup made from grapes
was mixed in during wine production to
act as a preservative and to sweeten the
drink Sapa was made by taking the must
that is the unfermented grape juice that
also contains the grapes skins and Pulp
and boiling it to either 1 half of its
original volume or one thir depending on
how sweet the sapper needed to be during
the boiling process there were
potentially three types of cauldrons the
Romans could have used the first was
made of brass which wasn't preferred
because during the boiling process C
apparently some flakes would come off
and get mixed in and it created a bitter
taste the second type was made of bronze
which potentially had a 10% mix of lead
in the alloy and the third type which
seems to have been preferred if they
could get it was made of lead we have to
be very careful here because although
lead cauldrons appear to be preferred
since they did not make the sa a bitter
which would sort of ruin the point of
trying to create a sweetener lead was
not always used so we need to keep in
mind that not all sappa would have been
contaminated that being said there was a
study done that suggested that even if
you had a cauldron simply lined with
lead or having lead as part of the alloy
of The Cauldron creating Sapa that was
reduced to 1/3 of its original volume
would contain something like a gram of
lead per liter of Sapa and another much
earlier study suggested it maybe would
have been 250 mg per liter and the
resulting mixture of sappa and wine
Accord according to surviving Roman
recipes would result in a concentration
of anywhere from 5 to 21 mg of lead per
liter depending on which particular
study you were taking the figures from
it is possible then that the Romans
consumed wine that was contaminated with
lead but this idea has been questioned
because the sources are not exactly all
that clear on this we don't know if Sapa
actually was reduced in cauldrons made
of or containing lead in Greater
proportions than and cauldrons without
Le and we're also talking about a period
of time spanning hundreds of years the
specific ratio of Sapa to Wine done in
these studies comes from a recipe
recorded by colel in the first century
but it's not the only ratio that we know
of being used and we should keep in mind
that the Romans typically cut their wine
with water on top of that it's difficult
to really quantify how much of something
people ate or drank so there is that
caveat additionally this probably would
have been the major way that led enter
the wine process critics of the idea
have noted that wine empera were often
lined with pitch or resin so the wine
likely would not have absorbed lead from
that and sappa wasn't always added so
with that in mind if it's difficult to
gauge how much wine a Roman drank on
average and we don't really know how
contaminated the wine or the water from
the plumbing was is there even a way
that we can determine how much lead was
present in an average Roman from any
period
well sort of one of the major fields of
interest for both classical and early
medieval Archaeology is the archaeology
of cemeteries and as a result of about
200 years of digging we have a lot of
Bones and with advantage in osteology
and the associated
Technologies archaeologist are starting
and starting is the key word here to
analyze chemical levels in Bones such as
overall lead content there was some some
work of this kind being done in the
1980s but it's only now starting to pick
up the problem though is that as of
right now the studies are kind of all
over the place and the results we have
don't necessarily indicate anything
major we do know that when comparing a
Roman skeleton basically for the
entirety of classical Antiquity to a
skeleton from bronze or copper AE Europe
or the Mediterranean the Roman Skeleton
on average has a higher concentration of
lead beyond that however the data is not
clear the Romans appear to have had less
lead concentrations than people from the
19th century during industrialization
and the British Empire and the French
Republic for example did not collapse
due to lead poisoning but those sample
sizes are not exactly overflowing so as
more testing is done we will be able to
learn more about the total lead levels
in the Roman population but currently it
doesn't seem to be a high enough level
that exposure would have been
debilitating this is the sort of thing
you'd really need to try and do to
quantify something like lead levels in
the population we have textural sources
and those are very useful but we are
also talking about an Empire of millions
of people and after a certain point
texts simply are not going to capture
that we need the archaeology something
else you maybe should keep in mind here
is that if lend poisoning was that much
of an issue it doesn't seem to have
affected rmes rise to power so did
chronic lead poisoning lead to the
decline and fall of the the Roman Empire
not really or at least we don't seem to
have much evidence indicating that but
the Roman population appears to have had
higher levels of lead than previous
societies what long-term effects those
levels may or may not have had is
difficult to really determined at least
as of now and probably will only be
answerable with a greater volume of
skeletal analysis
