Why did the Roman Empire fall? When did it fall? This is a question that has bedeviled historians and archaeologists for centuries, and arguably there isn't any end in sight for the search for that answer. Rome is an obsession of the modern world--if we can figure out why the Roman Empire fell, then we can save our own civilization.
Ben Shapiro, an American political commentator, recently put out a video exploring why the Roman Empire fell, and suggests that Rome and the present day United States resemble each other to a degree. Ben Shapiro lists the usual factors of degeneracy and licentiousness caused by wealth, a lack of civic virtue, and inflation as being among the prime causes for the collapse of Rome.
This video is a response to that and broadly outlines, economically, what actually happened, drawing on the scholarship of medievalists
SOURCES: Barbarian Migrations & the Roman West, 376 - 568, Guy Halsall The Fate of Rome: Climate, Disease, and the End of an Empire, Kyle Harper Imperial Rome AD 193 to 284: The Critical Century, Clifford Ando Imperial Rome AD 284 to 363, Jill Harries Exploring the Economy of Late Antiquity, Jairus Banaji The Inheritance of Rome, Chris Wickham Framing the Early Middle Ages, Chris Wickham
A number of weeks ago, Ben Shapiro released a short video on the fall of the Roman Empire.
Now, my channel is not involved in the political side of YouTube, but when it comes to late
antiquity, this is where I come into play. So, Ben notes at the end of that, that quote,
The Roman Empire teaches us that no civilization, regardless of its power and influence,
is immune to decline if it fails to uphold the principles of responsibility,
It's incumbent upon us to learn from history, to strengthen our institutions, and to foster a
society that values freedom, resilience, and relentless pursuit of truth. By doing so,
we can ensure that our legacy is not one of downfall, but perhaps of enduring greatness."
End quote. And that is an excellent point, and his video does raise legitimate problems
faced by the Roman state. It's just that those points either don't apply to the end of the Roman
Empire, or are actually wrong. Rome is usually a stand-in for the problems you think are present
in modern society, especially the fall of the Roman Empire, and modern society, in a western
context, usually means America. And that subtext bleeds through pretty heavily. So, taking that
quote as my cue, especially the relentless pursuit of truth, I want to examine why the Roman Empire
does indeed end. And essentially what that means is that we're talking about the breakup of the
Roman economy above and beyond anything else, and going along with that is the decay and
eventual destruction of the Roman imperial tax system. So, that video is broken into four sections,
economic, governmental, environmental, and social. And it contends that the economy of the Roman
Empire was a heavily centralized one, where some emperors initially were okay with permitting
aspects of the free market, but that later emperors clamped down on this, began exploiting
outlying areas for tax revenue while granting subsidies to the imperial center, and then the
debasement of the currency over centuries eventually forced the military to begin collecting taxes in
kind, further exacerbating economic problems. Taxes were raised on the wealthy, the economy was
increasingly reliant on slaves for labor, because wage labor would have required a free market,
and Diocletian's price edicts did not work, and then the barbarian invasions were a result of an
unhealthy economic state because it was unable to defend itself. He then quotes Bruce Bartlett as
saying that, quote, in the end, there was no money left to pay the army, build forts or ships, or
protect the frontier. And then to deal with these issues, Emperor Diocletian divided the empire into
two halves, West and East, but it backfired because it created a rivalry between the two
halves, and the Western Empire especially had a series of problems revolving around affluence,
laxity, and debt and credit problems, which gave it less room for error when dealing with the
barbarians and environmental problems owing to centuries of deforestation and soil depletion,
which led to a decrease in agricultural productivity. The end result is that, in 476,
the Western Empire collapsed. To get the easy thing out of the way first, Bruce Bartlett is
not a historian of ancient Rome. He specialized in modern American history, writing a master's
thesis on Pearl Harbor in the 1970s, and he has since worked for various Republican administrations
and politicians, and has written books about modern American diplomacy, politics, and
administration. So in other words, he's not a specialist on late antiquity. Victor Davis Hansen
is also quoted, but since 2004 or so, he hasn't really been involved in academic debates, and he's
turned toward political commentary. That is to say, the sources backing up the video are not
exactly cutting edge. With that in mind, if anyone wants to do further reading, the academic sources
I've used for this are listed, as always, in the video description. Now for the more difficult side
of things. There are, broadly, two positions on the Roman economy, especially in late antiquity,
that scholars take, and those are the primitivist and the modernist views. Dealing with this subject
is extremely difficult. It is true that the Roman state did not have a conception of economics as
its own field, and that the Roman administration did not fully appear to understand what inflation
was, but characterizing it as a system that was divorced from the free market, where taxes
increased on the wealthy, and which was characterized by a high degree of slavery, especially in late
antiquity, is basically wrong. And this is where the two views come into play. The primitivist
position really focuses on how the economy of ancient Rome was fundamentally different than
the economy of the globalized world today. Studies that take this position focus on the behavior of
Roman elites, in that they placed a great deal of emphasis on social status and basically rent-seeking
behavior, instead of something like venture capitalism. On the flip side, the modernist
position focuses on how the ancient and modern economies were fundamentally similar, hence the
name of this viewpoint, the modernist perspective. To a large degree, the economy of ancient Rome was
governed by basic economic rationalism, price-setting markets, and the easy movement of
goods within a unified commercial zone, connected by the Mediterranean Sea. The Roman state had a
complex system of banking, credit, and debt markets, which actually was the cause of a few market
crises over the course of Roman history, and a vast corpus of contract and commercial law.
Arguably, the major difference between the Roman economy and ours is that it was not industrial,
although it did have large centers of manufacturing, especially for goods like pottery,
and the Roman economy was undercapitalized. But, the Roman economy was also one that, for an
agrarian economy, was extraordinarily complex. Farming was an extraordinarily profitable
industry that was well integrated into the broader economy as a whole, and the archaeological
evidence tells us that agriculture and its associated industries, like viticulture, were
market-oriented. When it comes to slavery, well, in the period we're talking about, slavery appears
to have been falling by the wayside as the basis of the economy. Now, this isn't to say that the
system was abolished and that slaves were not ever used in late antiquity, far from it. Slaves were
still used, and they were used heavily, but the heyday of Roman slavery was between about 200 BC
and about 200 AD, because this was the era of massive estates, or latifundia, which depended
on slave labor. In late antiquity, by contrast, estates began to shift away from slave labor
and towards the use of the colony, free or semi-free peasants, who legally became tied to
the land. You could look at this as the beginning of what becomes serfdom in the medieval period,
and Roman landlords became increasingly interested in taking rents from their laborers, either in
actual taxes or in kind. In other words, the slavery argument isn't really accurate, and we'll
talk more about that in a moment. When it comes to the inflation and the debasement of the Roman
coinage, though, this is a bit harder to deal with. For about 200 years, the Roman state had
a bimetallic currency, the silver denarius and the gold aureus. The ratio between silver to gold was
about 25 to 1. Now in 64 AD, the denarius was debased by 10% by Nero, and then Trajan debased
the denarius in about 100 AD by 5 more percent, reducing the overall silver content to about 85%
on average, but this doesn't really alter the standing ratio of 25 to 1. When Marcus Aurelius
came to power, it was debased to 75%. Under Septimius Severus, it gradually became debased
even more to about 50%, and then Caracalla came along and he did two things. The first thing he
did is that he reduced the gold in the aureus, which had not been debased by that point, but he
does so only slightly. He also introduced a new coin, the Antoninianus, about two-thirds the size
of the denarius. So why does he do this? What was going on? Unfortunately, we don't have as many
records surviving from the Roman world as we would like, but the best estimates for the imperial
budget in the 2nd century AD is something like a billion sesterces. It's a smaller Roman coin,
basically the ratio is four sesterces to one denarii, and in the 2nd century, something like
70% of that budget went to the military. This budget was not balanced, and expenditure routinely
exceeded tax revenue, although extra money did come into the state coffers through plunder and
war, and through massive silver mining in places like Iberia. But there seems to have been a problem
with those mines, and the silver deposits began to be exhausted in the 2nd century. The solution
then was to debase the silver and not the gold, because the denarius was the basis of the economy,
while the aureus was used for more specialized transactions. The Marcomannic Wars fought
between 166 and 180 AD almost bankrupted the state, so with the supply of silver drying up,
the currency was debased basically to about 50%, and this is probably what explains Caracalla's
actions as emperor when he comes into power in 198. He introduced a new gold coin, and he expanded
the citizenship drastically in order for the state to have thousands, if not hundreds of thousands,
of new citizens who would owe taxes. It's not entirely clear, but out of all the emperors prior
to the crisis of the 3rd century, he appears to be the one who best understood what was happening,
and actively tried to fix it. The Roman economy was a fundamentally monetized one. They didn't
just utilize coins as some sort of abstract representation of value, they actively thought
in terms of profitability, labor, and productivity in monetary terms. The state and the economy
almost broke up in the 3rd century, and in some ways it's a miracle that it didn't,
but the situation did stabilize, and it's due to two factors. The first is that the composition of
the civil service actually changed. Prior to the crisis of the 3rd century, the Roman system
functioned by co-opting local elites into the power structure. After the 3rd century, this was
no longer the case. The aristocracy changed from one of birth to one of service, and it drastically
expanded. It effectively made it easier for the emperors to govern by reducing the burden on their
shoulders and spreading it out. With the result that long term, the bureaucracy had a vested
interest in keeping the Roman state going because they now got something out of it. Prestige, power,
and most importantly, money. Which leads us to the other thing that changed. The economic historian
Jairus Banaji once remarked that quote, in the late empire, gold came to circulate at a floating
rate. This essentially means that the whole monetary system in the late 200s and the early
300s fundamentally changed. There basically was not any sort of attempt to tie the bronze, silver,
and gold coinage that was circulating together. It allowed for further credit expansion, and it
allowed for the monetization of the Roman economy to expand drastically, and this is what we see in
the late 4th century. The economy, and thus the state, was far more integrated than it was
previously, and the state began to recover. We have plenty of archaeological evidence that informs us
of new towns being built, urban construction picking up again, and the future of the Roman
state looked fairly bright. It really would not appear to a citizen of the late 4th century
that anything was really that wrong. Indeed, there's little indication that anything bad at
all was going to happen. That is to say, there's no indication that the Roman empire was going to
disappear. The basis of wealth shifted from land to money, and land became profitable so long as
it generated money. Hence the attempt at market rationalization of estates in the Roman world,
and the desire for taxes and revenue produced in colony, as opposed to slaves. There was a
massive expansion of agriculture and industry, for example in North Africa, because olive oil,
which you can grow in North Africa, made lots of money. So this is the major challenge. Things
seem to be picking up, and the state recovered from the problems of the 3rd century. So then
how, about a century or so later, did the Western empire essentially disintegrate,
while the Eastern empire continued to prosper? Well, on the one hand, you have environmental
and climate change, the Roman warm period. A series of centuries which had unusually warm
temperatures came to an end in the 4th century, and as a result, the climate shifted. It's not
that soil was overused or forests were chopped down. That did happen, but it tended to be
localized, with the Romans actively practicing forestry conservation and burning olive oil
waste as a substitute fuel, so much as temperature shifts stopped allowing for excessive crop yields,
which formed the basis of Roman prosperity. Beyond the climate problems, the best answer
to this question, why does the Roman empire fall, comes from the work of Chris Wickham,
and to paraphrase a section of his book, Framing the Early Middle Ages,
the Roman empire was indeed a state, which stands in contrast to the territories which took its
place, especially in the fact that the Roman empire was a complex state, unified geographically
by its proximity to the Mediterranean sea, and fiscally and territorially united by its tax
system. Upper level officials calculated the revenue needed for the fiscal year, and sent
out the numbers to the governors in the provinces and cities. To move that money, as well as the
taxes in kind for the army and grain and olive oil and other resources for the Anona, the city
of Rome's grain distribution system and Italy's system more broadly, as well as for the military,
which was arguably the major driver of the economy, ship owners were contracted, the holds
were filled, and they left their home ports, and after discharging their tax cargo, they could go
anywhere else and essentially get a tax write-off. While these things don't survive archaeologically,
what does survive are thousands, probably millions of pieces of pottery. In some places, like Britain,
it was locally produced, but it still spread through the whole province. But in many places,
it was produced in one area and shipped across the empire, much like many of the goods we have today.
Roof tiles and other ceramic building materials too were mass-produced, and they were used in
construction all across the Roman world, which, whether we think about it or not, led to healthier
homes because it kept decay and insects out. The economy was unified by large estates and a web of
complex markets, in many ways not unlike our own interconnected economy, and in the 4th century,
it appears to have been a very healthy one. But by the middle of the 6th century, the former
territories of the Western Empire began to undergo what medievalists termed radical material simplification.
Red slipware, a distinctive type of pottery made in North Africa, often serves as a proxy for
In the 6th century, its distribution shrinks drastically, and essentially, the economy
unraveled. More than anything else, what did in the Roman Empire was the seizure of North Africa
by the Vandals in 429. From the province of North Africa came much of the grain and oil which fed
Italy, especially Rome, and which also supplied much of the Western Roman military, and this
province was also the wealthiest one in the West. It was also one end of the tax spine in the Western
Mediterranean, the other one being Italy. The Vandals were one of many groups of barbarians who
entered the Roman Empire in this period, and really, there are three views on them and the
destruction they caused. The first is that there was mass migration in a short period of time.
The second view is something more along the lines of an elite transfer, and the last is that there
really wasn't any movement at all, just a gradual diffusion along the frontiers spanning decades.
Now, all three views are correct depending on the situation and on the group being examined.
The seizure of Africa was a violent affair, and although the archaeology does not show the Vandals
as a materially distinguished population, the written sources we have describe mass incidents
of molestation, especially of nuns, the wanton killing of priests, and the torture of civilians
to uncover hidden loot, such as stuffing feces down throats, twisting cords around foreheads
until they snapped, and of course, flaying. By 442, though, the Vandals had married into the imperial line,
and at least for a time, they supported the Romans, attempting to join the system,
something that most of the barbarians of late antiquity wanted. In 455, though, due to the murder
of Emperor Valentinian III, the Vandals sailed to Italy, and they burned and sacked Rome.
The extent of this event is not fully understood, and we have differing accounts of the severity of
it. What matters, though, is that with the loss of Africa, Rome was starting to feel the pinch
of a weakened economy, and the crucial tax spine between Spain, North Africa, and Italy, which
unified the Western Empire, effectively broke. This is the key difference. The tax spine for
the Eastern Empire, which connected Egypt to Anatolia and then to Constantinople, remained
intact, not in the West, and with rapidly decreasing tax revenues, the formal structure
of the Western Empire was split up into smaller semi-barbarian kingdoms. A spiral had started,
which, with the failure to militarily reconquer North Africa after the defeat at the Battle of
Cape Bon in 468, essentially proved impossible to stop. The state ran out of money because it
could no longer collect taxes to ensure its healthy functioning. Now, the empire did not
end in 476, there's actually a large push among historians to move the end of this state to the
530s and the 540s due to a series of massive wars undertaken by the Eastern Emperor Justinian
in an attempt to reconquer the lost Roman provinces of the Western Empire.
If you are looking for a major breaking point, the point of no return as it were, where you can
clearly see a Roman world on one side and a distinctively medieval world on the other, the
6th century, not the 5th, that is to say not 476, is where you should look. So, when did the Romans
think that the Roman Empire fell? The same with the barbarians, when did they think that this was
gone? Well, essentially when they said it fell. We have very little evidence to suggest that states
like the Ostrogothic Kingdom, which was based in Italy, or the Visigothic Kingdom in Iberia,
did not see themselves as Roman. Their law codes did make a distinction between Romans and Goths,
that is true, but the people living there still saw themselves as living in a fundamentally Roman
world and in a fundamentally Roman context. Indeed, King Theoderic of the Ostrogoths appears
to have actively styled himself as a Roman Emperor, and many of the Roman aristocrats
supported that move. Justinian, however, needed a pretext for conquering what were still understood
to be Roman lands and Roman people, and the basis for that justification became the ousting
of Romulus Augustulus by Ordovaca in 476, and the removal of the last Emperor of the Western Empire.
The Western Empire, then, in Justinian's framing, had indeed fallen, and the Romans were coming to
take it back. This created a mental break in how people living in the territory of the former
Western Empire understood their place in the world. A Roman Emperor, the only one,
had dispatched an army to conquer them, labeling them as barbarians and not Romans. The failure
of these conquests and the devastation that they wrought broke the mental and ideological framework
of the time, and the failure of Justinian's wars created the conditions under which the idea of
Rome, and with it the Empire, was truly gone.