Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw play Agree to Disagree, and things get heated over voice notes, cups of tea and whether Die Hard is a Christmas film.
The Black Doves co-stars react to a series of statements, and it gets brutal from the start. Keira’s solution to voice notes is to “kill them all”. She’s open to a sweet 10-second one, but she draws the line at the 10-minute monologue a friend once sent her. Then they argue over when the milk goes in your tea. Keira says you can’t know how much milk you need until you’ve seen how strong the tea is.
Keira strongly disagrees that Die Hard is a Christmas movie, even though she’s never seen it, while Ben backs The Muppet Christmas Carol as a top-three festive film. The pair also discuss Love Actually, which Keira hasn’t watched since the premiere over 20 years ago. They argue over which of them would make the better real-life spy, which leads to Ben calling Keira “treacherous” and both of them wondering how they’d do on The Traitors.
Plus, should you tell someone they have bad breath? Is the book always better than the film? And what’s the right way to eat cold roast potatoes the morning after?
Do you agree with Keira and Ben? Let us know in the comments.
BLACK DOVES SEASON 2 IS OUT NOW ON NETFLIX.
Chapters: 0:00 Intro 0:16 Milk goes in tea before hot water 1:04 Voice notes should be limited to three minutes 2:44 Die Hard is the best Christmas Film 4:07 I would be a better real spy than the person opposite me 5:34 You should tell someone if they have bad breath 7:00 The book is always better than the film 7:35 I loved working with the person opposite
Three-minute voice note?
Kill them, kill them now, kill them all.
If I left you one that was a minute and a half,
would you listen?
I'd never speak to you again.
I'm starting to speak now.
Milk goes in tea before hot water.
God, I strongly disagree.
That's wild.
Milk goes in tea before hot water, what would be the point?
When does the teabag go in?
I strongly think that you must adjust milk levels.
I strongly agree.
As the tea brews.
I strongly agree, otherwise how do you know how strong the tea
is and therefore the milk level that you require in the tea?
The only way that you can do this is by knowing how strong
the tea is and then adding the milk.
Just wild, you're a wild human being.
You're just insane.
You're insane, yeah, great.
So we strongly agree in our disagreement.
We strongly agree about disagreement.
That was great.
Perfect, I think that solves it for the rest of the country.
Yeah.
Voice notes should be limited to three minutes.
I hate voice notes.
Where's the, wait, should be limited, should they just die?
They should just die a death.
Okay, agree, strongly agree.
Limited to three minutes?
A three minute voice note?
What would your rule be, Kiera?
Kill them, kill them now, kill them all.
I'm strongly agreeing that they should definitely
be limited to three minutes,
but that would be like interminable.
Do you ever leave them?
Nope.
I don't like, I on principle don't listen to them.
If I left you one that was a minute and a half,
would you listen?
I'd never speak to you again.
What if it was 25 seconds?
Would you not?
We're getting like.
We'd just ignore it.
Well then I'd just be like,
what the , what was the point in that?
Why are you sending 25 second voice notes?
Text me. What if it was 10 seconds?
What are you going to say in ten seconds?
I'm thinking of you.
Oh, that's quite sweet.
Yeah, right, you can leave me a ten-second voice note.
I got one from a friend that was ten minutes.
And I really love this friend, but I was like,
I just don't think I can find ten minutes right now.
No, also, like, that's a monologue.
Somebody is monologuing at you.
And I'm not going to hold what you've said
at the beginning of the ten minutes in mind
till the end of the ten minutes.
And then I've got to answer all the things?
Have I got to respond to all of the things?
Well, and then you've got to remember all of the things.
All of the things.
Now, that's a stream of consciousness.
It's a stream of consciousness.
I have to say I think it's unacceptable.
Like, at least do it.
I've been off show since I was a boy.
But, you know, like, do it face to face
and then I can interrupt at some point.
Exactly.
And we can pretend that we're having a conversation.
But if you're just sending me a monologue.
Neither of us really like them.
We strongly disagree.
We strongly agree.
Yeah.
Die Hard is the best Christmas film.
I...
No, wait, I've got to go up here
because I feel like I've said this before.
You got a head start because you've at least seen it.
I've never seen that film.
You've never seen Die Hard?
I've never seen that film.
Oh wow. So how can you strongly disagree with that statement then?
Because I just have no relationship to it.
You could disagree, but strongly disagreeing
when you haven't seen the film is a bit much.
I just think I've got an instinct.
Okay, fine. It's not a Christmas movie.
No.
Fine. It is set at Christmas.
I know, but I just don't want to watch it.
No, that's fine. At Christmas.
No.
Fine. Or ever. But fine.
Particularly not at Christmas.
Okay, fine.
What is the best Christmas film?
The Muppets Christmas Carol.
Good one.
I mean it's become, a few years ago
that was like a bit of a, from left field,
but now everyone sort of agrees
that's up in the top three or something.
I like Elf.
I don't really know that one either.
I always watch Elf.
And there's of course Love Actually.
There is of course Love Actually, which again, I've only seen once,
so I can't rate that one either.
And that was, I only actually saw it last year.
Did you?
Yes.
I saw it at the premiere.
A long time ago.
Over 20 years ago, and I have not seen it since, so I feel like...
You couldn't really get behind it as a favourite Christmas...
I just can't comment on its Christmas standing,
although I do believe it's quite big at Christmas.
I would be a better real spy than
the person opposite me.
Would he ever be a better real spy than you?
I don't think so.
No, I think you'd be quite a good spy, actually.
Why?
I don't know, that little shifty eye move you did right there.
No, I don't know, I think you would, I think you'd be quite...
You think I'm unreliable in some way.
Yeah, I think you're treacherous in some way.
Um...
I think you're very good at, um, at, at...
Appearing like something I'm not.
Maybe, yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I think you'd be quite good at traitors as well.
I think I'd quite like to see you in traitors.
But I think that you'd be quite good for the same reason.
Really? That we're not saying,
but that we both kind of understand what we mean?
Thank you.
We might be both quite good at giving
a general wash of being quite nice.
Yeah, sure.
But actually it's not true.
And it may not be true.
But I'm not saying you're not.
No, thanks. You've just basically said I'm a...
But it's fine. I love you too and it's okay.
There's no way of answering this question without seeing the person.
I think actually we'd both be terrible.
Yes, that's the truth.
It's the truth.
It's the act.
It's like the...
If we actually had to pick this apart.
But for the sake of laughs.
You'd be a good spier and I'd be a good spier.
That's fine. Yeah, fine.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You should tell people if they have bad breath.
I mean, I'm not going to tell people.
It depends how close I am with them.
I think...
Are you going to tell people?
Like, if you don't know them very well,
are you actually going to go like,
dude, your breath f***ing stinks.
I'd love it if you did.
I just don't think this is a hard and fast rule, guys.
I just think I'm staying on the line.
You've got to go with agree or disagree.
You're staying in the middle?
Like, I'm floating around on this one.
Have you ever done it?
Okay, with some...
Right, so...
I think it's a sensitive issue because sometimes people have issues,
real issues around it.
There's like, you know, it's sort of a kind
of congenital thing that they just can't,
they've just got some issue with their stomach.
And you've gone up to them and said, you stink!
I think saying to someone you stink is generally...
Not great.
Not great.
No.
I think you have to find a...
Nice way of doing it.
Yeah, I would. But then look,
sometimes it is just best to go, darling, I'm so sorry.
So you're agreeing. You're going there.
I'm going to boldly go there.
You boldly did go there.
I'm sticking with disagree unless I know the person unbelievably well.
It's a tricky one.
It's a really tricky one.
Because I would be worried that maybe something
was very wrong and I just don't know.
I'd maybe offer a bit of gum.
Yeah.
Thank
The book is always better than the film.
A little bit.
No, wait, the book is always better than the film.
you
Well, we can strongly disagree with the wording of the question.
We have to, we have to.
Yeah.
Because we've been in too many adaptations.
very
A, we've been in too many adaptations so we can't go the other way,
because that would be wild.
And B, always, you can't put an always in there.
You can't put an always, because sometimes, sometimes it is improved.
much.
Sometimes, depending on the book.
Depending on the book, it's improved.
But let's maybe not name anything.
No, no, let's just talk abstractly.
Yes.
I loved working with the person opposite.
Ah.
Yay.
That's a very easy one.
That's a very easy one, but wouldn't it have been embarrassing?
It's a bit embarrassing, and I feel we're being a bit cute now.
Yeah, there we are.
But it is actually true.
Should we just put it like, strongly disagree,
just so that we don't vomit in our own mouths?
Yeah, exactly.
Hate him, hate him.
Thank you.
Roast potatoes?
F*** that.
Cooking it in butter.
Frying the f*** out of it in butter.
It's a um.
Cold roasties in the morning.
No one's looking out in the fridge.
Do some cold roasties.
Dunk it in the cold gravy.