JWST Just Found A Black Hole Inside A Star

A Door to Mysteries
791 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Look at this, this is one of the deepest images
of the universe ever taken and every one of these
beautiful smudges is a galaxy as it looked just
But look at this one, this tiny little red dot.
a few billion years after the big bang.
It takes up barely one pixel,
but when astronomers analysed the light coming from this dot,
they found something insane.
If it were a normal star like the sun, it would look like this.
As you move from red towards blue,
there's a little step down where the hydrogen
in the star's atmosphere soaks up some of the blue
light. Now this is what they actually saw.
It's nice and flat and then it suddenly falls off a cliff
No one had ever seen a drop in a spectrum like this before,
and everyone in the astronomy community was stunned.
Then they measured how bright it is.
This thing, whatever it is, is shining as bright as 100 billion suns.
The brightest star that we've ever found is a true monster,
and this thing is 11,000 times brighter than it.
It can't be a normal star.
Fusion, the process that is powering all
of the stars that you see in the night sky,
just can't make this much energy.
JWST is seeing it as it was just 660 million years
after the big bang, and a few months ago,
astronomers published a new paper saying
they think they've figured out what it is,
and it's wilder than anything you can imagine.
They think something is hiding deep inside this star,
something with no light of its own at all.
Oh, hey.
Black Hole. This really could
be the first Black Hole star we've ever found.
To understand what we're searching for,
we first need to go back to Christmas Day
2021, when the James Webb Space Telescope launched on top of an
Ariane 5 rocket. It embarked on its month-long journey out to L2,
a point in space 1.5 million kilometres from Earth.
It slowly unfurled itself piece by piece,
First, the sun shield, the size of a tennis court,
then its 18 golden mirror segments,
all locking into place, and then finally,
in July of 2022, it opened its eyes for the first
time.
This was the very first deep field image.
Every one of these dots is a galaxy,
and this whole image covers a patch of sky the size
of a grain of sand held out at arm's length.
Then they took these, the Carina Nebula,
Stefan's Quintet and the Southern Ring Nebula.
This telescope was unveiling the universe to us
in a way that we had never seen it before.
But less than a month later,
astronomers were looking through Webb's deep field images
and started to notice something weird.
Tiny red dots.
They were showing up in almost every single image that they looked at.
By early 2023, one team had picked out 6 of them
that looked like galaxies, and they found
that they were seeing them as they were just 500
to 700 million years after the big bang.
Each one of these little galaxies appeared
to hold more than 10 billion stars.
And that is a huge problem.
Using the standard model of cosmology,
basically the rulebook for modern astronomy,
the universe was just way too young to have built galaxies that big,
that fast. It should have been impossible
for them to exist that early. But here they were,
and so astronomers started calling them the universe breakers.
And their size made things
even more confusing, because they were extremely bright,
but physically pretty tiny
Imagine you have a cube of space,
one light year on each side, with our sun sitting right
there in the middle.
How many stars do you think are in it?
Well, just one.
Good.
Our nearest stellar neighbour, Proxima Centauri,
is all the way over here, four light years
away, far outside of the box.
Now let's take that same cube
and put it inside one of these red dot galaxies.
To make all of that light with stars,
you would need to cram several hundred thousand
1,000 stars into that one box.
For comparison, the most crowded place
in our entire Milky Way galaxy is right here
in the centre, around our own supermassive black hole.
And even that's still about a thousand times too empty
to match this insane red dot.
So surely this is a mistake, right?
Maybe JWST was faulty, so they checked everything multiple times,
different teams from various
universities joined in.
And they were right. This was real.
So something had to change. Either our understanding of galaxy
formation was just completely wrong, or these weren't galaxies at all.
A lot of the people
who have spent their lives studying these objects
are astronomers and mathematicians.
But those aren't the only jobs you can get in the space industry.
People ask me all the time, how do I get a career in space?
And honestly, you don't need to be a genius physicist or engineer.
I've traveled to places like NASA, CERN and ESA.
And along the way, I've met people
from all different kinds of backgrounds,
communication specialists, historians,
mathematicians and even marketers.
The right degree can open up a huge range of careers.
And that's why I've partnered with Southern New Hampshire University.
The sponsor of today's video. If you feel stuck in a career that just
doesn't fulfill you and you've told yourself
that going back to study just isn't an option,
I want you to hear this,
it's never too late to pursue something that you love.
SNHU is one of the largest accredited universities in the US,
with some of the most affordable
online tuition rates in the country,
and they were voted one of the nation's most innovative
universities by US News and World Report.
If you started a degree years ago and never finished it,
you may be eligible to transfer
up to 90 credits, and there are no set class times,
so you can study when and where you
want.
If that's you, then maybe this is your sign.
Head to snhu.edu forward slash astro kobe
or click the link at the top of the description
to explore over 200 degree programs.
If these aren't galaxies, what else could they be?
In astronomy, when something in space looks red,
it's usually one of two things.
It's either full of dust, which soaks up all of the blue light,
or it's full of old stars.
Because as a galaxy gets older, the big blue stars burn out first,
and only the small, cool red ones are left behind.
The first suspect had both.
Monster galaxies packed with old stars,
made even redder by loads of dust.
To make all the light from this one little red dot,
you would need about 30 billion suns worth
of stars, crammed into just 130 light years of space.
They'd be packed so tightly that
stars would be smashing into each other roughly once per month.
Here in our part of the Milky Way, two stars basically never collide,
because there's just so much empty space between them.
There's a simple way to test this.
Dust that absorbs light gets warmed up
and that warm dust glows in infrared. So astronomers
pointed ALMA, an array of 66 radio dishes in Chile,
at the red dots to look for that glow.
Okay, so no dust, what's next?
In December 2022, astronomers found another clue.
When gas moves towards us,
its light gets squashed to be slightly bluer, and when it
moves away, it gets stretched redder.
So when a cloud of gas that is swirling around really fast,
one sharp line in its spectrum
gets smeared out like this.
The wider the smear, the faster the gas is moving,
and the faster it's moving, the heavier
the thing it's orbiting.
In a normal galaxy, gas moves around 100 to 300 kilometers per second.
This gas was moving at 2000 to 4000 kilometers per second.
There's only one thing in the universe
that can whip gas around that fast.
A black hole.
A few weeks later, this paper was published
with one of the best names in all of astronomy.
Hidden little monsters.
Maybe these red dots are all just supermassive black holes feeding
on gas while buried in
a cloud of dust that makes them look red.
We have found these before and they always come with other signs.
Normally, a feeding black hole looks like this.
Gas spirals in and forms a disc, glowing white hot.
Just above it sits the corona,
a cloud of gas heated to hundreds of millions of degrees
blasting
X-rays wrapped around all of that is a doughnut of dust,
heated to over a thousand degrees and glowing in
the infrared, and the whole thing flickers
because black holes are messy eaters.
As clumps of gas fall in,
the brightness jitters up and down unpredictably.
If these red dots were buried supermassive black holes,
we should find some of these
signs, so astronomers went searching.
First they used Chandra, NASA's X-ray space telescope.
They took its observations of 55 little red dots
and stacked them together,
giving about 400 million seconds of combined exposure time.
That's like staring at a single spot for 13 years looking for x-rays.
This is what it should have looked like, and this is what they found.
Nothing, just an empty patch of sky.
Next was the hot dust, Webb has its own instrument
for seeing in mid-infrared light, right where
that glowing donut should be shining, and again,
none of these little red dots appeared
to be glowing.
Finally, Webb photographed some of these red dots over
and over again, making a video of
them to look for that flickering, most of them just held steady.
This couldn't be a normal feeding black hole.
So if it's not an old galaxy completely filled
with dust, or a supermassive black hole devouring a gas cloud,
what else could it be?
And even if it was a black hole,
astronomers measured how fast the gas was moving and worked
out that the black hole would have to weigh 10
to 100 million times as much as our sun.
Today the black hole at the centre
of a galaxy usually weighs about a thousandth as much as the galaxy's stars
These would be
But way more than that, a few percent of their entire galaxy,
and for some of them, nearly
the entire galaxy's mass would be in the black hole.
By this point, people were starting to get desperate.
Papers started showing up suggesting
the dots could be black holes made in the Big Bang
itself, stars powered by dark matter,
or dark matter that crashes into itself.
There were nearly a thousand
thousand papers about these universe breakers
in just two or three years.
Things got so out of hand that someone published
an April Fool's paper joking that it's now a
requirement for every paper about galaxies
to mention these little red dots. Since we found
those first few, we've kept searching
and today we've counted around a thousand of them.
In the early universe,
around 3 or 4 out of every 100 galaxies looked like one,
and then by around 1.5 billion years after the big bang, they all just…
disappear. Something was out there in the early universe,
absolutely everywhere, and then it just
vanished. So whatever these things are,
they have to be red without dust, hide their x-rays from us,
and they have to have a really steady brightness.
There is no cosmic object that we know of that
could do all three. That was until
a new survey started looking at the strangest dots of all.
A new study was carried out called Mirage or Miracle,
because that's what everyone was
wondering. The team aimed JWST at these objects
to study them in even more detail. That same survey
actually found the most distant galaxy ever confirmed,
existing just 280 million years
after the big bang, way before it should have
been possible for galaxies to form.
But that's a story for another video.
In one patch of sky about a third of the size of the full moon,
this one little red dot stood out.
It has an awful name that I won't even try to read.
But Webb took pictures of it through different coloured filters
that reveal hidden details.
Through the redder filters you can
clearly see it shining nice and bright,
but in the bluer filters it just disappears.
They spent four and a half hours observing it
and that's when they found...
This cliff. Normal stars like Vega have a small step
in their spectrum where the light drops by
about 2.6 times.
This little red dot has a cliff where it drops by 7.7 times.
It's the deepest
cliff that astronomers have ever found for any object in the universe.
That drop in the spectrum
comes from hydrogen.
Think of a hydrogen atom like a multi-story building.
If its electron is sitting on the second floor,
any light that's bluer than a certain colour can
knock it clean out of the building, so that light gets absorbed.
Red light just doesn't have enough
energy to knock it out, so it slips right on past.
Stars do this too, and that's the small step that
we saw, but to make a cliff this deep you need
an absolutely enormous amount of hydrogen,
with electrons that are waiting on that second floor.
And this wasn't the only one,
Another team found a dot with a huge cliff of its own.
It was clear that normal stars
or galaxies could not explain these results,
so they tried something new.
They put a feeding black hole in the middle of all of that gas,
and it actually seemed to work.
This is the first black hole star astronomers have ever
found. This one is particularly special
because it completely outshines its own galaxy.
If you add the light of a small blue galaxy on top of its spectrum,
it looks basically the same as every other little red dot's spectrum.
Maybe all of these could
be black hole stars sitting inside young galaxies of their own.
So do you want to take a look inside one?
From the outside, it wouldn't actually look red at all.
Its surface glows at around 4,000 to 5,500 degrees,
a bit cooler than our sun,
so to your eyes it would look orange.
Underneath the surface of the star, you'd find a huge,
dense region of pure hydrogen.
All of that hydrogen hides the black hole deep inside.
Including all the x-rays it's shooting out.
The blanket of hydrogen soaks up all of the blue light,
creating that cliff in the spectrum,
and by the time the light from the inside works its way out,
all of that flickering
is gone.
Those three signs from earlier are perfectly explained
by this gas cloud surrounding a
black hole.
Okay, this might sound like a silly question,
but why isn't the black hole just sucking
up all of that gas and becoming even bigger?
It's actually light.
The light pouring out of the black hole in the centre pushes outwards
on the gas so hard that it holds the whole star up.
Normal gas pressure only does about 0.3% of the work.
This whole star is basically just floating on light.
If a beam of light is created in the middle,
it starts its journey as a blue-white beam that's insanely energetic.
On the way out, it gets absorbed and then re-emitted, bouncing
around aimlessly over a thousand times and losing energy as it goes.
Until it finally escapes as this warm orange light.
And this is what is powering all of it,
a disk of gas spiralling down into the black
hole and glowing white hot.
Gas falling into a black hole like
this releases about 10% of its mass as pure energy.
That's more than 10 times what normal
stellar fusion can get from hydrogen.
To shine this brightly,
the black hole would be consuming about an Earth's worth of gas
every half an hour.
And then right here at the centre is the black hole itself.
It's somewhere between about 100,000
and a few million times the mass of the sun.
And while that sounds impressive,
compared to the rest of the star, it's…
The craziest part is, this idea was predicted 20 years ago.
Back in 2006, a team of astronomers imagined something that they called
quasistars, black holes growing inside giant balls of gas.
In 2010, they even calculated how many
of these JWSTs should see when it comes online.
12 years before it launched.
So how big actually are these behemoths out there in space?
The thickest layer of gas stretches somewhere between 10
and 100 times the distance from
the Earth to the Sun.
Neptune's orbit sits at 30, Pluto's at around 40.
The core of this beast swallows most of our entire solar system.
Voyager 1 has been flying away from us for almost 50 years
and it's about 170 AU away.
It would still be well inside the black hole star's gas.
This beast is 390 billion kilometres wide,
that's about 280 thousand times wider than
the sun, or about 100 times wider than
the biggest star that we've ever found.
If you lived on a planet inside of its galaxy,
say around 1000 light years away, it would
hang high in your sky,
about 10 times brighter than the full moon, a permanent
Orange second moon. The habitable zone for this beast is about four
and a half light years away,
that is roughly the distance from us to Alpha Centauri,
our nearest star system.
So that's it, right? I mean, we've found one, but not quite.
When this paper was first posted
online in 2025, it was called,
A Black Hole Star Reveals the Remarkable Gas-Enshrouded Hearts of
the Little Red Dots. Pretty damn cool.
But by the time it finally made it all the way through peer
review and was published in Nature,
it had been given a new title, A Gas-Enshrouded and
Gas-Reddened Black Hole at Cosmic Dawn.
The words Black Hole Star were missing.
So why? It's because astronomers still can't agree
and the biggest problem is actually how
heavy these black holes are. Remember how we weighed them?
The wider the smear in the light,
the faster the gas and the heavier the black hole.
But inside a black hole star, light keeps
bouncing off electrons in the cocoon
and every bounce smears the light out a little bit more.
It makes the gas look like it's moving much faster than it really is.
In January 2026, a team of astronomers corrected for that effect
and the black holes came out to be
about 100 times lighter.
That would fix the problem of them being so insanely heavy.
But there was another twist.
In May 2026, another team of astronomers studied a little red dot
called QSO1. There's a giant galaxy cluster sitting
in front of it that gravitationally lenses it.
acting like a big magnifying glass
and splitting that little red dot into three images. For the
first time, they could watch the gas orbiting in a little red dot
and weigh the black hole
directly by measuring the gas's speed.
The answer was about 50 million suns.
It's insanely heavy, just like the old estimates said.
It makes up about two thirds of the entire system's mass.
Maybe it formed before its own galaxy did.
Lots of astronomers still aren't convinced
that these are black hole stars at all.
Some believe that they're just ordinary
feeding black holes, surrounded by that dusty
donut, and that we're just seeing them side on.
So when it blurs out, it kind of just looks like a big red ball of gas.
And then, when astronomers held a conference back
in April to discuss all of this,
apparently the group just erupted into arguments,
and no one could get past the first bullet point on the agenda.
If even a few of these really are black hole stars,
it could completely change our understanding
of the life cycle of black holes in the universe.
It's possible this is so common that every
massive black hole, like the one in our Milky Way,
went through this phase too. Sagittarius
A star, the black hole at the centre of our galaxy,
weighs about 4 million suns.
Right in the range of black hole stars,
it's possible that our own black hole spent its
early years hidden inside a giant orange star,
bigger than our entire solar system.
And then, over time, that gas got consumed,
leaving the black hole all on its own.
This could explain why they all
of a sudden just vanish around 1.5 billion years after
the Big Bang.
We might have even caught one hatching.
Chandra found an object that looks just like a little red dot,
except it's glowing in
x-rays.
It had been sitting in Chandra's survey data
for over 10 years before anyone realised
what it might be.
Some astronomers think its cocoon is just thinning out.
Letting the x-rays punch through,
others think it's an ordinary dusty black hole.
But my favourite is this one.
Behind a giant galaxy cluster,
the light from one little red dot had been bent into four
separate images, called an Einstein Cross.
Each image's light took a different path to reach us,
with delays of up to about 130 years.
So in a single photo we are seeing the same object
at different moments across more than a century.
And it's changing. It brightens and dims,
getting bluer as it gets brighter, like a pulsing star,
Except this one is around 2000 times the Earth's sun distance across.
We are going to know more very soon.
Astronomers have secured more time on JWST
to study this red dot and the cliff,
and NASA's new Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope, which just launched,
will help to search for more of them too.
The lead researchers on this project think
that black hole stars could have controlled
when galaxies were able to make their very first stars,
shaping everything that came after.
Planets, life, and eventually even us.
Every one of these beautiful red dots could be a baby
supermassive black hole,
hiding inside a star that is much bigger than our entire solar system.
The survey that found it asked one simple question,
mirage or miracle? The answer
might be both. A mirage of a star,
powered by the miracle of a black hole.
