It's Still Unknown If Anthony Richardson's Shoulder Will End His Rookie Season | Pat McAfee Reacts

The Pat McAfee Show
1 follower
Oct 17, 2023
I think it was you that tweeted that there's a chance that Anthony Richardson, they might
end up just shutting him down for the whole season.
I think he got like five different opinions on his situation.
What's the likelihood that that actually happens, especially given what happened Sunday in Jacksonville?
And when might we get an idea or like an actual decision on that?
I think we'll get one here in the next couple of days.
And Shane Steichen last week said that one of the options was season-ending surgery.
And so we'll see whether that is one of the options that they go forward with.
You know, what's interesting here, and I've gone back and forth with some medical specialists
on this, right?
Initially, it was reported to be a grade three sprain, but you wouldn't have to do surgery
on a grade three sprain.
So if they're going to do surgery, then why are they doing that?
Was there something wrong in the shoulder before?
So there's a lot of medical questions that, quite honestly, my background is not trained
in the expertise of what's wrong with the shoulder and the ligaments and grade threes
and grade twos.
So I can only speak on a layman's common person level to say that if it was a grade three
sprain, then he wouldn't ordinarily need shoulder surgery.
And they also keep saying that the tests came out better than they thought, that the shoulder
surgery wasn't as bad, that it might be just a grade two.
And if it was grade two, then why are they operating?
So the whole thing is a little bit, but here's what I will say also.
I think that the Colts are being intentionally very deliberate.
Is it the Colts?
Because I thought the way it was reported, it's like Anthony Richardson is potentially
choosing or opting to do the season-ending surgery.
It's the Colts?
I think they're doing this together.
And I think the Colts are being very deliberate because they're haunted by the memories of
another injured quarterback and making sure that everything went well there.
And sometimes with Andrew, I think maybe they felt like, okay, we rushed him back or we
didn't have the answers we wanted.
And I think whatever happened and transpired between them and their former quarterback,
I believe has influenced the very slow, methodical approach that they're using here to make sure
that they don't rush into judgment on anything and that they get everything as right as they
possibly can.
I can respect that.
I honestly can.
It does scare the hell out of me though, if he opts for the surgery.
Because the way it was reading is like Anthony was choosing to basically do a potential season-ending
surgery.
And it's like, damn, already?
Like, hey, I'm out of here.
I mean, Gardner Minshew goes and has his worst game he's had as an Indianapolis Colt, but
he was jacked up.
He was jacked up.
Playing his old team down there, that's okay.
So it's like, that is a big worry.
That was a big worry as I read it.
Like, he's choosing to end the season?
I think they're in this together and trying to figure out what the best course of action
is.
And he had a tough few beginnings here where four of the five games he didn't finish because
of injuries, various injuries.
Four or five.
So it was a tough start.
And I think they want to make sure he's right.
Whether that necessitates surgery or not, we'll see.
All the tests have come back negative though, after all of these things, four out of the
five.
Well, they say they came back better than they thought.
That's why it's a little odd to me.
Yeah, but the knee one, the first one was a knee, came back test negative, didn't miss
anything.
Then there was, I believe the concussion, but he played a series I think after that.
And then he went out and then now it's this, and it's like the tests were negative, came
back better than we thought.
It's like, damn, what the hell?
We hope.
Hey, AR, hope you're all right.
Good luck, AR.
Hope you're all right.
Hey, I'm scared to death though.
We're just choosing ends the season, week six, you know, the guy had like four touchdowns
in two weeks.
It got to be something.
I never, I can't even remember somebody getting a surgery for AC.
Sprain?
Sprain or.
That's what I'm saying.
It's weird.
It's so soft.
Yeah, I'd say.
Very, very weird.
I love this.
It tells you Pat, how heavily watched your show is because I'm getting a little medical
update on Anthony Richardson.
Grade three, grade three could warrant surgery.
Doesn't always need it.
Depends on what exactly the problem is.
Grade two is where it means the ligaments aren't totally torn and surgery is more puzzling.
But if he has some specific issues related to past history, his anatomy, something, he
might end up with a surgical procedure.
And of course you want to find out more at that point.
It's confusing, but hopefully we'll get some clarity.
So somebody's watching and somebody's texting me that.
Somebody smart is watching, which we could have never expected.
That's surprise of the year there.
Right about that.
But anyways, that sounds like a dog.
You know, we get, we get, we get medical updates and we get pronunciations of names as the
program unfolds in real time.
That's how this show works.
That's live TV.
Bye.
This is from Max Fletcher at Maximum Fletch.
Oh boy.
Hashtag I don't want to ever react, but Indianapolis is fucked.
Oh, we're in a worst case scenario.
AR is out the rest of the year, I'm missing reps.
MENUMANIA is dead and Stikine will drag this crappy team to 7A anyways.
Missed playoffs and get a crappy draft pick.
Hashtag tank from Marvin Harrison Jr.
Buddy, I agree with you, Max.
Marvin would be good there.
Huh?
It'd be cool.
See Marvin Jr. follow his dad.
Yeah, it would be really cool.
Um, I believe in Gartner though.
You believe in Gartner?
Yeah, I put a tweet out yesterday, actually.
He said this morning when I woke up, I kissed my baby, said hello to my wife, took a dump,
and then I looked in the mirror and I said, you know what, I'm pumped we got fucking Gartner
Minshew.
Going back down to Jacksonville, going to be a little extra juice.
He had four turnovers.
You know what I mean?
Had his worst game as a professional.
That's just one of those things going to happen, but yeah, I trust Gartner is going to get
us some wins.
And I trust that he's going to bounce back after having his worst game because he's Gartner
Minshew, a big brain, nose ball.
Shane Steichen's going to set him up for success.
I agree with a lot of the things he said there.
My biggest worry, and I don't know Anthony Richardson well enough, but it was being reported
as if he was the one saying, nah, need surgery, take me out for the rest of the season.
That scares the shit out of me.
That scares the shit out of me because of what we've heard has been happening in the
building last year and then obviously Jonathan Taylor's situation where he's opting out of
playing with the new culture.
He gets a new deal.
Then if Anthony Richardson's opting out, it's like, what the fuck?
This doesn't happen at the Chiefs.
This doesn't happen at anywhere else, you know?
So now that we're learning that the Colts are also telling Anthony Richardson, let's
figure it out.
That takes a big weight off of my scared ass shoulders about the Colts.
But yesterday for a while, there was a lot of like, we're dead forever, like type of
conversation happening.
Like, how do you change what's going on behind closed doors?
And then now we're hearing it is a little, which is good, which is good news.
But yeah, the Anthony Richardson thing really scares me because four out of five games.
That's tough.
He was hurt.
Yeah.
All lines playing.
And I saw somebody who had a real big brain who we appreciate, Strad, Rick Strad down
there and say like, look at the play where he got hurt on.
The coach needs to take care of him.
It's like, yo, that's why he got drafted four overall because he's the fastest quarterback
to ever come through the combine.
Like that's a part of who he's, that's who he's going to be.
That's like, that's why Shane Steichen's here.
So like some of those tackles he has taken have not seemed to be, you know, like abnormal.
And then he gets hurt from it's like, Oh no, is this guy getting figured out?
He's going to figure out how to get down, how to avoid those.
He's going to figure it out.
Yeah.
But some of those, he has to like some of those, there weren't like crazy routine.
Yeah.
It's not like avoiding those shots.
It was like just standard.
That's a standard tackle right there.
Like that's good.
I couldn't take it.
Okay.
That's why I was punter.
I could, my body couldn't handle it.
But his, it's like, is he getting incredibly unlucky here or what is the, what is the,
was he hurt coming in?
Maybe that's what they're thinking.
Maybe with the shoulder.
It's like, hopefully it gets figured out because he is fucking awesome when he's playing football,
but we haven't seen a lot of them.
I have not got to see a lot of them.
And when you watch like Lamar in London and granted they're two completely different players
and Anthony Richardson is much stronger, heftier, it seems like than Lamar Jackson.
But Lamar is so good at like running up to guys and then just falling at their feet.
Like he's not sliding and that he's not taking big shots, but like he gets down.
Do you think that's really what it comes down to for AR?
If he can just learn how to get down or, or no, I, I don't know.
He's a bruising.
He's like a bruising back when he runs.
Like he's a physical back and none of the shots, like the Darius's point, they're very
routine tackles.
Like the knee one, he got hit and I think his knees like hit together and then he was
off and it was like, he's got a knee.
It's like, Oh no.
Like was he just unlucky there?
And then the other one was just like a standard hit.
It's like, is he just unlucky there?
Hopefully we get the curse lifted from Anthony.
So he's healthy a little bit more, but I didn't like to hear that he was the one choosing
because then it's like, Oh, this guy's like, he thinks he's got no shot of staying healthy
this year.
Yeah.
Well, and like you said, that stuff's on like the hits he's taken where he's getting hurt.
It's unavoidable.
It's not like he's like, you know, how does it has a 20 yard gain and instead of just
getting out of bounds, he tries to get like an extra three yards and put his head down
and that's how he's getting hurt.
Like this is the shit that he's gotten hurt on or like unavoidable hits, like stuff that's
going to happen when you play his style of football in the NFL.
He's in hopefully one day, you know, like Calvin and I talked about how much Lamar has
progressed as a pocket quarterback.
I think the same thing will happen for Anthony because Anthony, like at some point he will
only be a pocket guy with running like as a last resort, but that time's not now, you
know, it's like how many years does it take to get to that point?
And it's like a long time.
It's like, what are you, you know, you, you got to play, like you got to play, like you
got to get a lot of reps.
Like it takes a lot of time to get that feel.
So not playing is obviously tough.
And I don't even talk to Cam Newton, sorry, D, but maybe she talked to Cam Newton.
How did Cam stay somewhat healthy being such a big physical guy when he first came in the
big thing with Cam was they weren't calling the same penalties on hits on Cam because
Cam is so damn big.
Like Anthony, he was punishing defenders.
That's the problem.
Like exactly.
Yeah.
