On this episode of International Reporters Roundtable, UNICEF reports "human trafficking, modern slavery" is the second largest criminal industry in the world, raking in over $32 billion a year. Hundreds of thousands are coming through the open U.S.-Mexico border. Children are abandoned, used as drug mules, and trafficked. In China, religious minorities are jailed and tortured, used as forced labor, and robbed of their organs at a frightening pace. And in Africa, home of the original transatlantic slave trade, business is booming in child labor and organ harvesting, including babies.
It's Human Trafficking Prevention Month in the USA, a country that fought to abolish slavery. What are we doing now to stop it? Journalists Todd Bensman, Kay Rubacek, and Eric Caron join NTD host Steve Lance to discuss this widespread but rarely spotlighted issue: the human rights violations that occur in the modern slave trade.
If there’s a child you know who may be at risk, here’s a resource to help: The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children.
UNICEF reports human trafficking, modern slavery, is the second largest criminal industry in the
world, raking in over 32 billion a year. Hundreds of thousands coming through the open U.S.-Mexico
border. Children abandoned, used as drug mules and trafficked. In China, religious minorities jailed,
used as forced labor and robbed of their organs at a frightening pace. And in Africa, home of
the original transatlantic slave trade, business is booming in child labor and organ harvesting,
including babies. It's Human Trafficking Prevention Month in the United States,
a country that fought to abolish slavery. What are we doing now to stop it? Journalists Todd
Bensman, Kay Rubachek and Eric Caron join us to discuss this widespread but rarely spotlighted
issue, the human rights violations that occur in the modern slave trade.
Welcome to International Reporters Roundtable. I'm Steve Lance. Our conversations bring together
investigative journalists from around the world. They'll help to uncover hidden information and
details of conflicts, alliances and connections in a deep dive discussion. Joining us are journalists
who know the intimate details of human trafficking, the modern day slave trade.
In Africa, China and in our own backyard, Mexico, business is booming in bodies. Is our negligence
helping the second largest global criminal industry to grow? Time to meet our panel.
We have Eric Caron. He's a former U.S. special agent and diplomat who initiated and led worldwide
covert operations relating to transnational crimes and national security for over 25 years.
He held senior positions with the Department of Treasury, Homeland Security and Interpol.
Eric is currently an international security consultant in East Africa and a liaison for
Voices Against Trafficking. He writes for Blue Magazine, The Washington Times and The Epoch Times
and authored the book Switched On, The Heart and Mind of a Special Agent.
And next, Kay Rubachek, author of Who Are China's Walking Dead? She has 20 years experience producing
award-winning educational programming in print, digital and video formats. She's a producer and
a director for New York-based Swoop Films and directed their latest award-winning documentary,
Finding Courage. Kay's family members escaped communism in Russia, China and the former
Czechoslovakia from 1918 to 1986. She herself was arrested in China in 2001 in Tiananmen Square
while advocating for human rights. And next, Todd Bensman, an award-winning newspaper reporter and
magazine writer who transitioned to a career as a national security intelligence professional
for the Texas Department of Public Safety and then returned to writing and publishing.
He serves as senior national security fellow for the Center for Immigration Studies and has
testified before Congress as an expert witness. He reports on international and domestic terrorism
matters for major news outlets and is the author of two books, Overrun and America's Covert Border War.
For our first question, we'll go to you, Todd. We're happy to have you. I'll
ask you right now about the southern border, Todd. If you could give us the latest,
what's the current state of human trafficking on the border?
Well, the human trafficking part comes in the context of the human smuggling part, which is
that we are in completely untrammeled territory in terms of volume. We've had more people cross
that border than in the history of the United States. In the shortest span of time, it may
be one of the greatest mass migration crises in the world, in world history. Just millions and
millions, four and a half million that have been apprehended at the border, completely collapsing
our normal defense bulwarks, and also an additional million and a half people who just
got away, and that's on the conservative side. So the defenses that we normally have are collapsed,
and people are able to just pour in undetected, but also are being allowed in detected,
just being ushered into the country. And a key characteristic of this massive traffic
are families with young children and unaccompanied minors. That is a major characteristic of this
particular event. It's been going on for two years, and that has opened up the aperture
very, very wide to human trafficking and victimization of those children,
many of those children that are being brought in by adults, whether they're actual parents or not.
And then also the unaccompanied minors who are being sent for or sent from other places to cross
the border, those are the exemptions that the Biden administration opened up from its very first
day, and so those are the children that are coming across, hundreds and hundreds of thousands
breaking every record in the U.S. books. Kay, I'd like to go to you, moving over to Asia,
the continent of Asia, to China specifically. You've been arrested on Tiananmen Square yourself.
I want to talk to you about the issue of organ harvesting. What is the current status
of this crime taking place in China? I like to think that organ harvesting in China is really
perhaps the worst scenario of what can happen with human smuggling, because this is when
not only are people being killed for their organs, where their organs are being used for
transplantation, but in very many cases, their organs are being taken from innocent prisoners,
people who've been put into prison for either religious belief or political prisoners.
Often they have their organs removed while they're still alive, and it's the organ removal,
that organ trafficking process that kills them. So I think what we see with slavery in modern day
and human trafficking, we see the worst of it in China. It's been going on for quite some time now.
We first got reports in 2006, but it started much earlier than that, and it hasn't abated.
There has been some pressure internationally, but we know the practice still exists,
and it is supported by the state, the communist state of China.
Okay, we're going to come back to you in a moment on organ harvesting in China,
but first I want to go to Eric. Eric, if I could ask you, you've spent quite some time in Africa,
and what is the state of human slavery, trafficking, and even from what we're hearing now,
following in the CCP's footsteps, organ harvesting on the continent of Africa?
Thank you, Steve, for having me. Shockingly, as we speak, over two million people are being
trafficked around the world as we speak, and one out of three are people from Africa being
trafficked for various reasons, for labor purposes, for sexual exploitation, and yes,
shockingly, for organs. Like I said, one out of every three victims is from Africa,
and it's shocking. It's happening today, and right now in Uganda, 62 doctors are under
investigation. 62 doctors in Uganda are under investigation for working with transnational
crime groups for the purpose of organ harvesting. It's shocking. It's a $1 billion industry
every year, and the world has to do more. We all have to do more to identify and stop
this illegal harvesting of organs, as well as babies.
Todd, back to you. You touched upon it there with minors being involved in this trafficking.
If you could just let us know, how are children being used, to what extent,
and who's ultimately driving this?
Well, there are several things that are happening. One is that there is significant
labor trafficking. We're already starting to see it. This is indentured servitude, where
minors are being funneled into the staffing agencies that provide labor to meatpacking and
poultry industry, and also to the auto parts industry. The auto manufacturing industry
is starting to show up, with children as young as 12 and 13 being gang-pressed into terrible
conditions and awful jobs, the dirtiest of the dirtiest jobs in America.
We're catching them left and right now, major manufacturers like Hyundai
and poultry plants in Alabama and Georgia and elsewhere. But it's just the tip of the iceberg.
That is going to be expanding. We're going to be seeing this a lot as we go forward in the next
couple of years. And then there's prostitution and sexual slavery that works. It's not as a
direct line of sight as you would expect, like children being brought in for that purpose.
But what happens is that they come in without proper guardians, and they are moved through
very rapidly through a system, health and human services, the federal government,
that just wants to get them off the border and into foster families.
And it's the foster family system that is the big problem here. Many of the foster guardians are not
properly vetted. There's just too many kids coming through. They're in too big of a rush.
And we're starting to see the evidence of that where they are being abused by the foster parents
or they're running away and getting caught up in by gangs and by other nefarious characters.
That whole system is not properly overseen. There's no home visits. There's no home evaluations.
We're going to start seeing a huge amount, I predict, in the coming five years of sexual
slavery involving children because of this system. Kay, I want to ask you about your book,
China's Walking Dead. If you could just tell us, who are China's Walking Dead?
I interviewed quite a number of former Chinese Communist Party officials,
and that was largely because I've made a number of films about human rights abuses in China,
and one of them on specifically organ harvesting, forced organ harvesting in China.
That movie was called Hard to Believe. And it is hard to believe that officials or any human being
would put beyond slavery to actually kill someone for their organs and to be OK with that.
So I wanted to understand how people could do such a horrific crime and carry that out
on a large scale and indefinitely. So that led me to interview former Chinese Communist Party
officials, which led me to write this book, who are China's Walking Dead. And it was the officials
who told me that they had become the walking dead. I didn't like that term. But as I asked
more people and interviewed more officials and more people from who had escaped China and also
that was a term really that came about more than 50 years ago when academics saw they escaped
China, they fled and they looked back and one of them coined the term and said,
under this communist ideology, we will become the walking dead. And that's where the officials,
they're the hands, the feet of the regime. They carry out these criminal operations.
They themselves said that that's what they've been forced to become under this communist ideology.
Eric, I want to go back to you when it comes to human trafficking in Africa. Are there specific
countries where this happens more often and who's behind it? Is it the government? Is it a warlord?
Is it a cartel? Help us understand. Well, yes, Steve, thank you for that question. It's an
important question. You know, let me just say for W.H.O. estimates 10,000 kidneys are illegally
harvested every year, 10,000. And on your question relating to Africa, Steve, there's 54,
give or take, countries in Africa. I think there's only one that meets minimum standards set by the
U.S. State Department. And so human trafficking, organ trafficking, baby factories set up in
involved in these horrendous activities. We have terror groups as well involved in human
trafficking, in organ harvesting. We're talking ISIS and we're talking Boko Haram,
who are both engaged in the trafficking of humans for their soldiers, if you will,
for profit making of organs. So this is a huge problem globally. And the United States and other
countries, quite frankly, need to do more to address it, to identify and address and stop
this hideous crime. Eric, I just want to follow up quickly. Is the U.S. proactive in Africa,
the military, either overtly or covertly? Well, yeah, I mean, right now, as we speak,
there's some 20 some odd shadow wars going on in Africa from AFRICOM is at the tip of the iceberg
at the tip of the spear, if I may say, relating to those wars going on throughout Africa,
20 some odd shadow wars going on in Africa today, targeting the Muslim extremists
in those countries who, quite frankly, are destroying those countries and massacring
Christians. So, yes, because of these conflicts, because of poverty, because of corruption,
human trafficking is at an epidemic and organ harvesting and baby harvesting is at an epidemic
right now in Africa. Todd, could you just try to help us understand the difference between
trafficking and smuggling? Sure, it's pretty simple. Smuggling is voluntary.
The participants are paying for the service. Trafficking is involuntary,
people being brought in against their will and being held under various kinds of coercive threat
and usually for a profit with a profit motive behind it.
So, Todd, let me ask you, a lot of these folks that are that are coming from various countries
around the world, how are their governments looking at them fleeing the country, obviously
not helping to make their country better? Are they looked at as disposable?
Well, there are more than 150 countries that are sending immigrants to us right now.
Some of them are grateful for this because they're going to get remittance cash back in return.
It's a remittance. A lot of these are poor countries. They're going to be looking for
remittance cash. It might be their only or a major source of cash back into their countries.
We're seeing population transfers out of places like Guatemala. They're losing
their populations. Cuba is practically emptying out right now.
Kay, I want to go back to you on the issue of organ harvesting in China. How to break
this cycle, how to break the influence that the Chinese Communist Party seems to have
on foreign countries, specifically the United States?
I think first off, we as a people, we have to recognize that these crimes exist because
it's too easy to want to just put our heads in the sand and say that such horrific crimes
couldn't be happening because we don't see them on the streets every day. But every day in China,
people are being killed for a heart, a liver, a kidney, and people around the world are purchasing
those organs without knowing where they're coming from. So we really first have to recognize that
the Chinese Communist Party is capable of doing such evil crimes, and they are still doing it
every single day. Once we really get that clearly into our heads, then corporations will also
realize that by doing business with China, they are doing business with a criminal state. The
Chinese Communist Party is a one-party monopoly, and they are allowing these crimes to continue.
And on that note, Eric, I have to ask you, when it comes to the crimes that you've
brought to light that are taking place in Africa, how aware is the U.S. and the United Nations for
that matter? Well, you know, they're aware of it. The U.N. has done dozens of reports,
as well as the U.S., on human trafficking and organ harvesting. They're very much aware of
these activities, but we need to do more. Like Kay said, this is not just going to be
a government solution, if you will, to these issues. It's each and every one of us.
We have to make sure that the products we buy are not being made by human slaves today.
We have to make sure the supply chain in the world is safe from human trafficking.
And so corporations, including transportation organizations such as airlines and shipping
companies, all need to do more, as well as corporations, in making sure that their products
are not being made by human slaves. Todd Bensman, I want to get your final thoughts
and just say, you know, where does everything go from here,
and what are the consequences if this is not addressed?
Well, the policies of the Biden administration that enticed hundreds of thousands and millions
of children over the border are going to hurt those children. It is an inhumane policy,
not a humane policy like they put it out to be. We are already seeing children being hurt,
who are being trafficked, and we're going to see a lot more in the coming years.
Kay Rubachek?
Looking at China, the crime of forced organ harvesting started in the 80s.
It started with prisoners. It then grew exponentially with the Falun Gong spiritual
group that was targeted. Because we didn't stop that, the persecution of them and the
organ harvesting from that group, it has expanded to the Uyghur Muslim group.
Where does it go from here? It will continue, group by group, if we don't stop it,
when we allow such an ideology to really dehumanize ourselves, humanity, to such a point.
That's where I see it could potentially go.
Eric Caron?
Thanks, Steve. Globalization is a wonderful thing, but unfortunately, transnational crime groups and
terror groups involved in human trafficking will exploit trade, travel and telecommunications
for their criminal evil purposes. That's why we need a border security program in place here in
America, and really throughout the world, because we're only as strong as our weakest link.
And that's why we need security, not just here in America, but throughout the world, to keep
our cities and country safe from criminals and transnational crime groups around the world,
including terror groups.
Thank you to our guest reporters today, Eric Caron, Kay Rubachek, Todd Bensman.
And to all you brave journalists out there, seek the truth and report it.
On behalf of International Reporters Roundtable, I'm Steve Lance.
Thank you for joining us. We'll see you next time.