How To Make The Silkiest Mac And Cheese | Genevieve Ko | Cooking 101 | NYT Cooking

Food channel
95 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
I love this sound. It's so like, like Night of the Living Dead, like, brains.
Hi, I'm Jaina Vivko, a senior editor and columnist with NYT Cooking. This is Cooking 101.
Today we're making mac and cheese. So in the pantheon of mac and cheese, you have the baked
kind that are really sort of tight and stiff and end up even sliceable. And then you have the really
creamy stovetop kind that are almost close to soup. This is somewhere in that perfect middle
where you have a creamy, creamy sauce that is spoonable. But at the same time, we're going to
top this with crunchy crumbs at the end. So you really get the best of both worlds.
So mac and cheese is such a distinctly American dish, and its history is really deeply rooted
in the African American tradition. It really started in 1784 when Thomas Jefferson took
James Hemings with him to Paris. So James Hemings was an enslaved man at Monticello who had been
there since childhood. James Hemings ended up learning French cuisine and French cooking while
he was there. So when he came back to the U.S., he was cooking these really elaborate, beautiful
French dinners. And one of those dishes that's been recorded in history is macaroni pie. But that
has really evolved over the years. And again, throughout the soul food traditions, just really
so many iterations of the perfect mac and cheese. The best mac and cheese starts with choosing the
right cheese. So for any classic American macaroni and cheese, you really want it to be at least 50%
cheddar because cheddar is such a distinctive flavor. So cheddar has degrees of flavor from
mild, medium to sharp, extra sharp. And that's actually correlated with how long it ages. The
longer the cheese ages, the more liquid comes out of it. And that actually intensifies the flavor.
At the same time, when it has less liquid, it doesn't melt as well. An extra sharp cheddar is
going to give you a really lovely flavor. But this isn't the place for those extra, extra sharp
cheddars that have been aged for years. It's inevitably going to cause the sauce to be grainy.
So the other cheese that I love to throw into a mac and cheese, and I'm not the only one,
is Gruyere. So Gruyere is the cheese that you see on top of a bowl of French onion soup. It's also
the cheese that's often used for fondue. So you can imagine that sort of meltiness and
stretchiness, plus it has this additional flavor that's really lovely with mac and cheese.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, the cheeses that are super melty that will give you a
beautiful stretch, like mozzarella, and then a little further over Monterey Jack,
you're just going to have a mac and cheese that doesn't have a lot of oomph or a lot of punch.
The one thing though, no matter what kind of cheese you buy, you have to grade it yourself.
Tom Holland, I hear you and your love of pre-packaged shredded cheese.
When I came to America's First, I was like, that is so handy.
I get it. But for mac and cheese, you really have to do it on your own.
I'd rather grate my face.
And that's because the package shredded cheddar is actually coated with starches to keep those
strands separate. And that both can mess up the texture of your sauce, or make it too thick,
or possibly even clumpy. And it also diminishes the flavor of the cheese in there.
We're going to go ahead and use our extra sharp cheddar,
and I am going to cut these into smaller blocks to make them easier to grate.
And then with a gruyere, gruyere comes with a grind, sorry, gruyere comes with a rind.
So we're going to cut off these two sides of the rind.
But we're going to actually keep this last piece of rind intact, because as you're grating,
you can use that to make sure you don't cut your own fingers off.
And I'm also going to cut the gruyere into smaller pieces to make them easier to grate.
And if you've ever grated cheese before, you know that it is quite sticky.
And this mac and cheese uses a lot of cheese. That's what makes it so delicious.
So instead of just using a plate, or a bowl, or even a cutting board,
I actually like to grate my cheese onto a big sheet of parchment paper or wax paper.
Both because that gives you a lot of surface area. You don't have to
clean whatever it is that you're grating the cheese onto.
And also, it makes it way easier to ultimately add the cheese to the pot.
And this also gives me a chance to mix these two cheeses together.
So we're using the large holes of a box grater.
And to ensure that you don't grate your own fingers, you can, of course,
make sure that you hold the cheese with your palms and not having your knuckles face the grater.
But the other thing that you can do is that with each of these small blocks,
as you get closer to the end of them, just move a little more slowly.
And that will make sure that you don't cut yourself.
So this does take a minute, but this is really the key to really great mac and cheese.
So you can see when you are grating the cheese yourself,
these strands are really floppy and thin, and that's going to help them melt.
The other thing that helps is to actually mix all these together before they go into the pot.
And the nice thing, too, is that once you've grated this cheddar,
this is like the first thing you want to do.
You actually can just let it sit at room temperature.
So you're not adding it to the sauce cold later.
If you want to top your mac and cheese with toasted buttercrumbs,
one thing to do now is to go ahead and set aside a handful.
If you want to get technical about it, it's about half a cup to mix with those buttercrumbs.
So when the cheese boils with those buttercrumbs, you have the crunch of the crumbs,
and the cheese itself also gets even more savory and just adds another nice layer of texture.
Mac and cheese might seem like this super casual, kid-friendly dish, and it is for sure,
but it's actually built on a foundation of some classic French sauces.
And once you actually learn those sauces for mac and cheese,
you can apply the same techniques to a countless number of dishes that you already know and love.
So we're now going to start building our sauce, and we're going to start by making a roux,
which is a mix of flour and butter.
And then we're going to turn it into a bechamel by adding milk.
And then that is going to become a Mornay sauce by adding cheese.
We have equal volumes of butter and flour.
So this is a quarter cup of butter, a quarter cup of flour.
And we're going to start just by melting the butter over medium heat.
So for any roux, you really just need fat and flour,
but you can also flavor a roux.
And we're going to do that here today with mustard powder.
So mustard powder is a pretty common addition to mac and cheese
because the heat and the warmth of mustard
really accentuates the sharpness of the cheddar, which is so nice.
And in this case, with the Gruyere, it also brings out that nutty flavor.
I'm actually going to add the mustard powder before the flour
because you don't want it to clump in the sauce later.
You can see it's already a pretty clumpy powder,
but when you add it to the fat first, it dissolves right away.
And I can smell it and I can hear the tiniest, tiniest sizzle.
I don't know if you guys can hear that.
And then you just add the flour all at once.
But as soon as you add it, you want to start whisking.
So the goal with the roux is to get rid of the raw flour flavor.
So you can see it's starting to sizzle right away.
And I don't actually want my roux to take on any color.
So you can have a blonde roux, which is what we're going to do today,
and then you can have a darker golden roux, golden brown roux,
and then you can even have a very dark roux.
And that's just going to alter both the flavor of what you're ultimately cooking,
but technically it's all going to work as long as it's quite smooth.
And you have to whisk the roux constantly.
If you don't, it's just going to burn in spots and it's also going to create clumps.
So you're going to see, once you start adding the milk,
it's going to clump really quickly.
So you don't want to add too much at one time.
I just start by using a quarter cup at a time.
And you can see immediately how it separates.
The goal with this sauce is always to bring it all back together.
And in the beginning, you're going to be like,
what in the world just happened? I need a paste.
So once that paste is all incorporated, you can go ahead and go in with your next cup.
And again, you want to just be whisking the whole time.
And the reason I'm adding so little at a time is, again,
having too much milk not incorporated makes it really hard to get smooth later.
So you just want to do this in the beginning.
And it also is going to give you a really nice thick sauce later.
I'm still in this paste stage, you can see.
And I'm just going to keep going.
I would say it requires patience, but it actually goes really quickly.
So it actually doesn't require that much patience.
The rounded part of my whisk, I'm shoving it into the corners of the pan
where the roux mixture is going to want to cook.
All right, so now we're still in this beautiful, like, a looser paste stage.
So when you've added about half of the milk,
you can see that you've got this thinner sauce now, right?
This is like a thinner pancake batter.
And so now that I'm at this consistency,
I'm actually going to add the rest of the milk in a steady stream while whisking.
Okay, so I want this to bubble again just a little bit.
And you want that to happen both, again, to thicken the sauce,
but it'll also give you that guaranteed smoothness at the end.
You don't have to whisk as vigorously now,
because it's smooth and the milk is all added.
But you do want to whisk it every once in a while
just to make sure nothing burns on the bottom.
You don't want the milk to scorch and taste like burned milk.
All right, so this sauce is simmering a bit.
And we have made bechamel.
I'm just going to give it one last whisk to make sure there's nothing clumpy in there.
And I turned the heat off.
The reason I turned the heat off is because
you don't want the cheeses to hit this simmering sauce.
It's a little too much heat,
and it's going to cause the fat in those cheeses to bounce out of the cheeses right away.
I'm going to keep it on the stove, which is fine,
because I also don't want the sauce to get cold.
Earlier, we grated our lovely mountain of cheese onto the sheet of parchment.
One of the best things about doing this,
aside from not having to wash extra dishes,
is now to add all of this cheese to the pot,
you can just gather up the sides and then drop it in.
Smush it into the sauce.
And then I'm just going to start stirring it with the whisk.
Once your cheese is pretty much melted,
if you want to make it even smoother,
and you want to keep this sauce super hot,
you can turn the heat back up to a very low temp.
Basically, the lowest your stove will go.
And as you're heating it up again,
you don't actually want to whisk too vigorously.
You just want to keep it moving to make it super smooth.
All right, so our cheese has melted into this gorgeous cheese sauce,
so we have made a mornay.
So even if the star of mac and cheese is the cheese sauce,
the macaroni actually makes a big difference, too.
The main thing you want in a noodle
is you want it to capture as much sauce as possible.
So you're looking for some sort of spiral,
you're looking for some ridges,
and you're looking for, ideally, a hole in the center to capture that sauce.
This is your typical elbow macaroni.
The reason I don't like to use these is because they're teeny tiny.
They're so small, and the hole is so small,
that the cheese sauce can't really get into that hole,
even after the pasta is cooked.
So just to show you by comparison,
this here is a large elbow.
It's not necessarily bigger in length,
but you can see that the hole is much bigger,
and it has like a wider ground.
Large elbows work great.
I really love them because they evoke the nostalgia,
the sort of childhood nostalgia of macaroni.
Another option is cavatappi,
which is both ridged and spiraled,
so you can get the best of both worlds,
plus a bigger mouthful of pasta.
You can see that both of these pastas are ridged,
and the ridges are great
because they're another way that the sauce sticks to the pasta
instead of having the sauce just slide right off.
This mac and cheese calls for a pound of pasta,
and instead of cooking it to al dente,
as you would for different pasta dishes,
you actually wanna cook this pasta
all the way until it's tender.
And that's because it's not gonna keep cooking
for much longer in the sauce.
It's just being stirred into the sauce to coat
and to warm through,
but it's not actually cooking any further.
And again, for that really cozy,
comforting, nostalgic mac and cheese,
you want it to be a tender mouthful of pasta.
So cooking it through all the way means
that if you take a piece of cooked pasta
and you cut it in half or you bite it,
you won't see a ring of white
around the middle of the pasta.
It should just be translucent all the way through,
but it should still actually hold its shape
and be a little bouncy and springy.
If it goes too far, that's okay too.
What you wanna do, just drain it right away,
and instead of rinsing it under hot water,
rinse it under cold water,
and that's gonna help both rinse off the starch
and stop the cooking.
Save some pasta water before you drain the pasta.
You may not need it, but if you don't save it,
you won't have it.
All right, so I'm just gonna go ahead and drain this.
And I'm actually gonna give this a quick rinse
under hot water.
And all I'm doing is rinsing off the starch
on the surface of the pasta.
Oftentimes with pasta dishes,
you want that starch
because it helps the sauce soak into the noodles.
But in the case of mac and cheese,
I actually don't want the sauce to soak into the noodles
because it makes the sauce both too thick
and the whole dish a little bit too bland.
So this is actually a technique
that I borrow from a lot of Chinese noodle dishes.
So in Chinese noodles,
you often will cook the noodles quickly
until they're just done,
and then you rinse them
before you toss them into any sauces.
So that makes the noodles still give them
that nice bounce and chew,
but also keeps the flavor of the sauce intact.
And now you just wanna go ahead
and make sure all of the noodles are really well coated.
I love that sound.
That's like floop, floop, floop sound
because that's the sound of the cheese sauce
going into the tubes.
So you know that every single bite,
you're gonna get cheese on the outside of the noodle
and on the inside.
So this looks, I know, super soupy,
but that's actually what you want
because as it sits, even like five minutes, 10 minutes,
it is just gonna thicken and thicken and thicken
as the sauce sits.
I actually don't season the mac and cheese
until the very end,
until after the pasta has been added
because you don't always know exactly how salty
it's gonna taste in terms of the saltiness of your cheeses
as well as how salted your pasta was.
So, mm, so this already has great flavor,
but salt never hurt.
But we're also gonna amplify, again,
the flavors that are already in here.
And one of the best ways to do that
is freshly grated nutmeg.
I love this combination.
If you don't have it or if you don't like it,
you totally don't have to add any.
But freshly grated nutmeg has a really unique scent.
Ground nutmeg is way more intense.
So if you only have ground nutmeg, add less.
Black pepper also accentuates the heat
that you originally added in the mustard.
And you just want that little bit of heat
to cut through the richness, right?
This is a super rich dish.
I'm just gonna add a tiny touch more salt.
So it was already super tasty from that first bite
before I added any salt.
But with each addition,
you're just amping up the flavors.
The salt isn't here to make this salty.
It's here to bring out the cheesiness.
It's here to bring out that rude, toasty, fat flavor.
It's here to just, yeah, tie everything together.
Here you have super creamy, delicious
stovetop mac and cheese.
And you can go ahead and just eat it at this stage.
But we're gonna go a step further
because one of the things I love about mac and cheese
is that crunchy, crunchy top.
Having a crunchy top is optional, but it's pretty great.
The first thing you wanna do
is you just wanna get your casserole dish nicely buttered.
You know, that just makes it easier
to scoop out the mac and cheese later,
to clean the whole pan later.
And of course, it actually just doesn't ever hurt
to have more butter flavor.
We also have the broiler on,
and we have the rack six inches from the heat source.
So you don't want it too close
because those crumbs are gonna burn pretty quickly.
And here we're gonna make our crumbs.
I am using panko breadcrumbs,
which are just a great shortcut to a crunchy crust
because they have this nice, bigger texture
and they're so crunchy.
And I'm gonna go ahead and add some melted butter to that
and some salt and pepper.
So I just wanna mix this up
to evenly moisten the crumbs with the butter.
And what the butter's gonna do
is not only give the pankos flavor,
but just help it toast into a really delicious toasty layer.
And you can see, I'm not just stirring,
I'm sort of mashing a bit
because the butter causes the crumbs to clump.
So this just helps redistribute the fat
evenly among the crumbs.
If you know that you wanna add this crunchy top,
make sure you save some of that cheese too.
We're adding the cheese after we mix in the butter
because we don't need to add any more fat to the cheese.
We just want all that butter to go into the crumbs.
And then I'm going to, in a feat of strength,
tip, hold on.
Okay, so here's a tip.
Dutch oven is super heavy, right?
To pour it easily at this stage,
I'm actually just gonna start by scraping the far side
so that it's all ready to go into my pot.
There we go.
I wish I was strong enough to do this one-handed,
but I like 100% can't.
All right, so I'm gonna just do this by hand
to get the nicest coating.
And you want it to just be a super thin layer
to give you that crunch.
You don't wanna have like untoasted crumbs
beneath the top layer.
So this is all crumbed up
and then we're gonna go in the broiler.
Slide this under the broiler
and if your broiler has a low setting,
that is what you want.
Just cause the crumbs can go
from brown to black pretty quickly.
It can take anywhere from two to five minutes.
If you know that you have a really gentle broiler,
you know, you can walk away.
If you know that you have a really intense broiler
and it only has one setting,
that setting is hot.
Ooh, it's looking beautiful.
I'm actually gonna rotate this pan
cause I can see the right side
is getting more brown than the left side,
which means that the broiler is just stronger there.
Look at this beauty.
So you now have a super creamy mac and cheese
with a really crunchy top.
So the best part is tasting it.
Right when you bite down,
get the crunch of the topping,
you get the cheese sauce all on the outside of the pasta
and it's just so flavorful.
It's so delicious.
You can definitely taste the cheddar and the gruyere
and all the seasonings.
It's just amazing.
This is such an awesome party dish
because as you can see,
it makes a lot and it's so rich
that you can actually serve a lot of people with it.
If you wanna make this ahead of time on the same day,
you can turn off the heat
depending on how far ahead you're making it.
And then when you're ready to serve it,
go ahead and turn it back on low heat
and all that saved pasta water is gonna come in handy
because you can just reheat it with that pasta water
to thin it back out
because it will have stiffened
and wait until it's steaming
so you know it's really nice and hot.
And then just before serving,
you spread it in the dish,
top it with the crumbs
and as you can see,
it just broils for a few minutes
and you can bring it to the table hot.
Thank you guys so much for joining me
for cooking 101 mac and cheese.
I hope you feel like you now know
everything you need to know
about making the perfect mac and cheese
and you also have the foundations
for making other amazing dishes and sauces.
You can find this recipe on nytcooking.com.
Happy cooking, happy mac and cheese.
