How to Analyse Performance | Insiders Film School

Studio Solution
24 followers
#Education#filmmaker #teachnic filmmaker
Welcome back to the Insiders Film School where we master film analysis one concept at a time.
Today we're looking at analysing performance and oh listen Sir Ian McKellen is going to explain.
How do I act so well? What I do is I pretend to be the person I'm portraying in the film or play.
I think we're going to need a bit more than that. I'm starting this ongoing series with
a masterclass in each of the five key elements of film and having just looked at the aesthetic
of characters in the last video all about Mise en Scene, the natural next step is to look at
how actors add to this meaning with their performance and as you'll see there's more
to this than dissecting an actor's vocal and physical decisions. Everything I've ever done
in a film it requires this getting to some sort of emotional reality that that is contrary to
the actual setting that you're in. As always at the end of this video I'll give you a masterpiece
film assignment that I think is a perfect testing ground for you to practice your new film analysis
skills. Before we get started allow me to quickly shout out my insiders over on Patreon. They support
the channel and get exclusive access to the next video in this series so to stay completely up to
speed with your film studies head over to the link in the description. Okay let's dive in.
To truly appreciate the importance of performance in film form you only need to look at how
differently the same character can be portrayed by different actors. Let's take the Joker.
They're all familiar but so different aren't they? When you look beyond the slight variations to the
aesthetic of the characters what specifically is it that makes each performance unique? Well I have
three answers for you which will act as our three-step framework for analyzing performance.
The casting, the style of acting and the performance codes. Let's start with the casting. Now it might
surprise you to find out that the first step in analyzing performance actually happens before a
single line is spoken with the choice of casting in a film. It immediately communicates meaning and
sets expectations for audiences based on what we already know about the actor. For example when I
say Arnold Schwarzenegger you think I'll be back. You did not go to say that did you? When I say Hugh Grant
you think well I thought it might be a charitable thing to take his skirt out for dinner and try and
fatten it up a bit. And when I say Margot Robbie you think Naomi the Duchess of... uh not that one you think
I'm only your favorite woman of all time. Barbie! You get the idea. So when you're analyzing
performance in film first investigate the casting choices. Here are a few things that may come up in
your analysis. Genre and star quality. Is the actor synonymous with a genre or type of film? For example
Christopher Lee in horror or Julia Roberts in romantic comedies? By casting actors who've
previously starred in successful films within a similar genre filmmakers are often banking on that
association to bring both meaning and commercial appeal. This is referred to as the star system
where a-listers like Tom Cruise or Brad Pitt can draw huge audiences to the box office with their
own style of brand. Just look at any poster where the actor's name is as big as the title and you'll
see exactly what I mean. Cinematic legacy and intertextuality. Does the actor's previous work
bring extra meaning to their new role? Filmmakers will often intentionally cast actors with this in
mind. Take Jack Nicholson for example. By the time he was cast in Batman as the Joker he was already
known for iconic unhinged performances in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest and The Shining.
Have you ever thought for a single solitary moment about my responsibilities to my employers?
His inclusion added not only acting credibility but an intertextual connection to these similar
roles in Batman. Russell Crowe is another good example. His casting as Zeus in Thor Love and
Thunder nods to his legacy as Maximus in Gladiator. Casting against type. Sometimes filmmakers
intentionally go against an actor's established persona in order to surprise audiences. This is
known as casting against type or subversive casting. A great recent example is Hugh Grant
in Heretic. Ah good afternoon. We've already noted that we know him for charm and romance
which makes his turn in Heretic all the more unsettling. Or take Heath Ledger. Before playing
the Joker in The Dark Knight he was best known as a quiet brooding handsome teen heartthrob.
Arguably more suited to Bruce Wayne than the Joker. So his casting against type created audience
intrigue. See I'm not a monster. I'm just ahead of the curve. Metatextuality and real life persona.
In the age of social media audiences know more than ever about actors' personal lives
and this can influence how we interpret their roles. This is where we start thinking about
metatextuality. The idea that the actor's real world image feeds into the meaning of their
character. Take Jared Leto's version of the Joker. His public image as the heavily stylized
enigmatic frontman of 30 Seconds to Mars gives him a kind of rockstar mystique which aligns with
the flamboyant gangster inspired Joker we saw in Suicide Squad. Or what about Robert Downey Jr as
Tony Stark. The arc of self-destruction and redemption in Stark's story mirrors Downey's own
real life battles with addiction and his comeback in Hollywood making the performance even more
meaningful. And I saw that I had become part of a system that is comfortable with zero accountability.
Identity politics and cultural meaning. Finally with casting it's worth acknowledging that it can
also be a political or cultural act. For example gender blind or color conscious casting brings new
layers of meaning to familiar stories. These decisions can challenge gender or racial stereotypes
or reflect changing social values and they very often prompt us to think more deeply
about whose stories are being told and by whom. I would only ask that you consider that this plane
we call life is one of many. So whether actors are cast for their type against it or in ironic
reflection of their real lives casting is never neutral. It's one of the film's first major
storytelling decisions and it should be our first port of call in analyzing performance.
You either follow my rules or follow my rules. Thank you. Thanks. Step two is to identify the
This refers to the overall approach or philosophy behind a performance. There are countless styles
of acting from classical to method to absurdist to postmodern but all of them can be broadly
categorized into either naturalistic or formalist styles. Let's return to our Joker example. This
time Cesar Romero's Joker and Heath Ledger's. How would you describe their overall vocal and
physical expression? You're crazy. Make those messages clear. Romero's performance is theatrical,
exaggerated and clearly performed whereas Ledger's feels raw, unpredictable and grounded in emotion.
Can you see the difference? Romero is demonstrating formalist acting and Ledger is naturalistic.
Let's define those terms in a bit more detail. Formalist performances tend to be more rehearsed
whereby a performer constructs their performance based on the director's vision
and external technique like posture, voice control and gesture. Formalist styles of acting would
include melodramatic and Brechtian styles but the most common formalist style you'll encounter in
cinema is classical acting. This approach to acting is grounded in theater and favors very specific
almost clinical decisions by the actor to translate the words in a script into a performance.
The performance might evolve over the course of countless rehearsals with the director
where every movement and word is analyzed. For this reason it's synonymous with Shakespeare
and the multitude of ways his work has been interpreted by actors. Don't lose focus. To be
or not to be that is the question. This was the primary approach to acting in the early to mid
20th century and you'll recognize it in some of the great actors who graduated to cinema from
theater such as Sir Ian McKellen and Patrick Stewart. Naturalistic acting on the other hand
is characterized by interpretive often spontaneous performance where actors seek authentic connection
to the character. Method acting is perhaps the most common form of naturalistic performance
where performers draw on their own emotional memory and sometimes undergo immersive preparation to
inhibit the character. While it might seem unstructured some naturalistic performances
involve just as much rehearsal. The goal is to make it feel lived in. Method acting and improv
are two examples of naturalistic styles. It's probably fair to say that naturalistic performance
is the dominant approach in modern cinema but it really does depend on the film and what the
director wants. It's also worth noting that it's inaccurate to define an actor by a style.
They may employ different approaches for different roles as Tom Hardy beautifully summarizes in this
clip. In a nutshell there's two types of acting. Convincing and not convincing and the move away
between the two is any method necessary including fake it to make it. I could be saying something
and thinking what's for lunch and that could work and translate. So why is this step important
identifying the approach to acting? Well first and foremost it'll inform the technical aspects
of the performance which we'll look at in step three but it will also shed light on where the
Is it a constructed collaboration between the actor and the director like we see in a classical
approach? Or does it reflect the experience of the actor offering a far more personal
interpretation of the script? The answer has implications for the role of the auteur of a film.
Identifying acting styles may also reflect genre with certain performance styles synonymous with
specific films. Method acting is far more synonymous with psychological thrillers such
as Black Swan and Melancholia than classical acting which is more likely found in historical
epics. So in this step do a bit of research and find out how the actors you're analyzing
approach their performance. This brings us to the third and final step where we finally get to talk
about the specifics of acting by analyzing performance codes. Now that you've considered
the casting and the acting style it's time to look at what the actor is literally doing on screen
in minute detail and ask how does this create meaning? Our body is a wonderful instrument.
We can express so much with the body, the body language, the face expressions. It's no different
to how we broke down the details in Mise en Scene in the last video but this time we're talking about
the body, the face, the voice and the way the character interacts. Take a look at these auditions
by Emilia Clarke and Claire Foy reading the exact same script but with completely different outcomes.
Dido you stop it won't you? You know no more of love than I myself do you? Dido you stop it won't
you? You have more of an idea of what love is than I do. This stage of analysis sees us scrutinizing
what each actor is doing with their eyes, their tone of voice, their hands, everything. These are
just a few of the things that we refer to when we say performance codes. All we need to do is
identify them and consider their meaning. So here are all the things that you should look out for
when you're analyzing performance helpfully put into four categories. One, voice and vocal delivery.
This is where you explore how the actor uses their tone, pitch, pace, rhythm, accent and just as
importantly sometimes silence. In other words, does their voice tremble? I think there's an
entire spectrum that your game is neglecting. Boom. Romamu I've come to bargain. Whisper. There was
once a dream that was Rome. You could only whisper it. How does this make the audience feel? Do they
speak quickly with nervous energy? Because I'm going up the machine I thought maybe you know I
get somebody something because I've had all these sweets and I think I'm going to get something
or slowly with menace. You're going to help us Mr. Henderson whether you want to or not.
Are they using an accent that changes how we perceive the background or status of the character?
How does one come by front row aisle seats for a first night at the opera Toscana with one day's
notice? Consider the differences in Leonardo DiCaprio's voice in The Wolf of Wall Street,
ranging from manic, coked up confidence in times of success. Are you behind on your credit card
bills? Go and pick up the phone and start dialing. To desperate, fragile and whiny in times of
stress. Oh my god you had to deal with the golf course people too. What is he literally doing to
his voice to communicate these feelings? Next and arguably the most powerful tool in screen
performance is facial expression. Look at this incredible scene full of tension from There Will
Be Blood where Daniel Day Lewis' face communicates meaning. So when looking at facial codes consider
what emotion the character is expressing in the scene, be it anger, despair, passion and how they
are using each part of their face to communicate this. Compare the deadpan expression commonly
found on Bill Murray's face with the raw vulnerability of Adam Driver's breakdown in
Marriage Story. Next up consider the body. Look at posture, gesture, movement, the physical
vocabulary of the character. How do they sit, stand, move? Does this convey confidence,
awkwardness, aggression? Is their general posture strong or weak? Joaquin Phoenix in Joker is a
great case study. His physical transformation over the course of the film is stunning,
shifting from hunched and broken to upright and dangerous. The body tells its own story.
Finally consider interactions. Performance doesn't happen in a vacuum, it's all about
relationships. So here you're analysing how the actor responds to other actors,
props and how they move through the environment. Look out for the following. Do they dominate the
frame or defer to others? I'm not referring to the size of the character but rather how their
presence potentially dominates. Look at how Tyrion Lannister commands the room in Game of Thrones
I'm guilty of a far more monstrous crime. I'm guilty of being a dwarf. Is there a binary
opposition between characters and their performance? Look at how differently Batman
and the Joker move and fight. How do a character's vocal, facial and bodily codes change around
others? Do they sit close, do they hold eye contact or shy away from it? Think of Before
Sunrise where Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy constantly shift in response to each other,
listening, reacting, matching each other's rhythms. The beauty of performance codes is that
they reward close observation and I'd argue they reflect your ability to read people in real life.
I promise you the last thing I wanted to do was find the one true religion
but unfortunately I did. The more you notice the subtle non-verbal cues in film the better you'll
become at understanding how meaning is communicated beyond words, through breath, silence, stillness
or movement. So the time has come to apply this knowledge straight away and this time I'm going
to suggest The Godfather as your masterpiece film assignment. But first, since you've made it all the
way to the end of this lesson, do me a favour and like this video. If you want to be notified
whenever a new lesson drops, you might want to subscribe as well. So, no doubt you've already
seen The Godfather, the greatest film of all time in my recent top 30 meta list. It's a masterclass
in almost every respect, direction, cinematography, set design but today you're going to watch it or
re-watch it solely focusing on the performances.
We've known each other many years but this is the first time you ever came to me for counsel, for help.
First, consider the legendary casting of Marlon Brando and Al Pacino. Brando had become known in
the public eye as brilliant but unpredictable, even defiant. He'd also previously appeared in
legendary films like A Streetcar Named Desire and On The Waterfront. How do you think this
You can act like a man! What's the matter with you?
Pacino, on the other hand, was a relative unknown actor at the time. How does this change how we
feel about him in the role of a younger sibling who is to take over the family?
Yes, Enzo. You better get out of here Enzo, there's going to be trouble.
Next, look at acting styles. Brando and Pacino were early adopters of method acting and are now
whereas Robert Duvall demonstrates a more restrained, measured approach that resembles
classical acting. How does this present in their performances and how much ownership do you think
this gives them of their performance? And finally, look into the performance
codes of characters including voice, face, body and interaction.
I've often used the Italian restaurant scene in my videos as an example of masterful filmmaking
and here, look at how Pacino communicates stress, panic and resolve in his performance codes.
He doesn't say a word but his face and body language say everything.
So, that's how we approach performance in film analysis. Pick a character,
consider the casting, research their style of acting and how this impacts their performance
before deep diving into an analysis of individual performance codes.
Next time, we'll be stepping behind the camera looking at how to analyse cinematography.
Remember, my latest video is always exclusively on Patreon until the next one comes out,
so head over there if you want to keep up to speed with the Insiders Film School.
Good luck and let me know what you thought of The Godfather in the comments below. Bye for now.
