How Different Directors Create Different Looks: Pachinko

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
This video is sponsored by Squarespace, the all-in-one platform you can use to build a
website for your business. The job of a director is to take the bunch of words written in the
screenplay and transform it into an audio and visual work. As you can imagine, there are a
number of ways this can be done. Some lean into stylization, others side with naturalism. Some
like to let the performances of actors stand alone, others still like to push the looseness
of the camera language. Just like how different artists can produce portraits which look and feel
totally different, different directors, DPs and creative crew members with their different points
of view produce films which are unique to them. With this in mind, let's take a look at how
different episodes of Pachinko, which used the same technical crew and locations, each took a
unique creative approach based on having a different director and cinematographer team.
Multi-part series have a shooting structure which differs from regular feature-length filmmaking.
Almost all movies will be led by a singular director and photographed by one cinematographer.
However, due to the extended workload and high shooting volume that comes with long-form series,
these shows are usually broken into a few different blocks, which are each directed by
and photographed by different creative teams. To maintain consistency, typically the creative team
who shoots the first block of episodes will create what is called a bible, which dictates the look
and feel of the series and how it should be creatively produced going forward. In the case
of Pachinko, this first block of shooting was done by director Koganada and DP Florian Hoffmeister.
The structure is that the first block, which was my block and which includes the pilot,
will actually set the look. A lot of creative exploration and a lot of creative development
will actually happen in prep for the first block. And then the second or third or whatever comes
after basically works along those guidelines established by the creative team of the first block.
These guidelines will usually be bound by both technical choices as well as creative ones.
For example, the camera selection, lenses, rigging of lighting fixtures at regular locations
and the LUT which interprets the look of the colour grade will remain consistent.
While similarly visual decisions like the aspect ratio, frame composition and camera movement will
try to conform to what has been done before. You can see this across the various seasons in shows
like Breaking Bad, which was filmed in 35mm with Kodak Vision 2 stocks, a 16 by 9 aspect ratio
with a warm colour palette with sickly greens and consistent handheld camera movement.
Or The Bear which uses quite a contrast heavy saturated LUT, lots of long lenses,
tight close ups and a cooler palette. Or Yellowstone's use of natural light,
sharp lenses and stable frames which are shot with telephoto focal lengths that compress the
background of landscapes and bring them closer to the characters.
What made Pachinko a bit different from your average series was that when it came to shooting
block 2 with the new creative team of director Justin Chon and DP Anthe Cheng, instead of
conforming to a bible, they were given the freedom to depart from the established look
and creatively approach their episodes with the look they felt was best suited to the story.
So what made the approaches of these two different directors different from each other?
Koganado who shot the first block is a director to whom form is everything. If you look at his
other work, each frame feels carefully considered, deliberately crafted and photographed with a
subtle feeling of objectivity. All aspects of his storytelling feel structured and based around form,
both narratively, in terms of blocking and performance and visually.
Justin Chon on the other hand who directed the second block is a filmmaker with an acting
background whose work is very much bound up in performance and emotion. Again this directorial
tone also creeps into the look with much of his other work having a level of looseness,
energy, emotion, texture and far more subjectivity and closeness to his characters.
Each block was given the same resources, locations and crew to shoot with,
but was led by a different vision from two different directors.
So what were some of the things that each block did differently to create their unique tones?
Firstly, each director worked with a different DOP, Anthe Cheng and Florian Hoffmeister,
both of whom I could look up on their websites, something that you too can achieve thanks to
today's sponsor Squarespace. If you want to be a cinematographer or filmmaker of any kind,
you need a website. This is a freelancer's modern equivalent to a business card that collaborators
or clients can use to get in contact and view a portfolio of your work. Squarespace makes setting
up your website easy and intuitive with their design intelligence system. This uses AI technology
to personalize your site and create a unique digital identity across your online presence.
Then use Squarespace's other tools like SEO to get your site seen, or their payment and
invoicing systems to simplify your workflow. Check out squarespace.com for a free trial
and when you're ready to launch your site go to squarespace.com slash in-depth cine
to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Pachinko is an historical epic drama with a storyline which jumps around between the 1920s
and the 80s, showing how significantly the past experiences of people inform their present
situation. This connection between the past and present is so strong that on a philosophical level
it's almost as if the story is taking place in one time.
Koganada's approach stressed that the spaces in the film are more important than time,
and in doing so stylistically disregarded the different periods and treated them almost as
if they were taking place at one time. What this meant in terms of camera language was that they
chose not to visually differentiate the different time periods, not using any different language
of cinematography to portray different timelines like aspect ratios, the colour grade or different
lenses. Koganada and Hoffmeister made the decision to maintain the same visual look
in both the 20s and 80s. They let the production design, costume and makeup work differentiate the
time periods rather than the camera. This look leaned on their preference for structured,
formal, objective, stable visuals. They almost exclusively shot off a tripod or dolly,
carefully composing each frame and barely moving the camera much. If the camera did move
it mostly tracked along with the motion and speed of the characters with a high degree of stability
from something like a steadicam or dolly. Or they used some linear push-ins or pull-outs on
stationary characters. However these were handled almost exclusively with very subtle, barely
perceptible creeping motion done with a dolly and tracks. In other words the camera never did
stylistic moves for the sake of movement and was rather motivated by the movement of characters
or an emotion. When it came to their shot selection they often covered scenes with a
medium-wide master shot, taken from the waist up, before jumping into medium shots,
medium close-ups or close-ups, which very rarely were framed tightly on characters.
They saved using these more intimate close-ups for key moments where they really wanted to
emotionally elevate a feeling and get inside the character's head. Framing scenes from this
mid to wide range distance created a little more emotional separation and a greater feeling of
objectivity. The DP and director often balanced these shots with a symmetrical care, lining up
centrally framed compositions of characters, especially during wides which gave a hint of
Yasujiro Ozu. In terms of their camera and lens selection they favoured quite a clean,
sharp, large format look with a shallow depth of field. The first block was shot on a Sony Venice
with Panavision Panaspeed spherical prime lenses. These come with a very fast stop of T1.4 which
was used by Hofmeister to separate characters from their background, especially during close-ups
by shooting them with a wide stop with lots of bokeh. Shooting with a wider field of view of a
full frame sensor and large format lenses meant that Hofmeister could choose longer focal lengths
and still be able to frame with enough width for wide shots. Using these more medium or telephoto
focal lengths again created a shallow depth of field which better isolated the characters in the
frame by blurring the background. Hofmeister worked with colourist Tom Poole in creating a
photo-chemical looking LUT for the digital camera which was based on the colour work produced by
magnum photographer Bert Glinn in Japan. Overall the stylistic approach of this first block relied
on creating one consistent clean look across the different time periods, which didn't try to be too
nostalgic or emotional, maintaining more objective traditionally cinematic composed frames, never
trying to make the audience aware of the presence of the camera. Block 2's approach countered this
idea of a clean, objective, formal structured tone, instead leaning into emotion and subjectivity.
This was done by largely foregoing the smooth or locked camera moves in favour of a hand-held
camera, deliberately operated with much more looseness and less precision. Although like in
the first block they would often hold on static frames, Chon and Cheng decided to do this with a
hand-held camera rather than off a tripod head, giving the image a subtle looseness.
Sometimes these hand-operated compositions would even have a bit of a Dutch tilt to them,
with a slightly off-kilter horizon, or go in and out of focus a little in an organic way
as the focus puller reacted to the more improvised camera motion.
When they wanted a bit more energy they also incorporated some hand-held camera moves
to give the footage a bit more dynamism.
When it came to portraying the different time periods, the Block 2 team took a different
approach. Rather than maintaining the same look for everything, they subtly gave the
20s period footage a different feel by shooting it on anamorphic lenses, then used the same
spherical panoramic speeds for the 80s scenes. When shooting anamorphic they kept the same
2.20 aspect ratio as the rest of the show by chopping off the sides of the wider 2.40
native frame which they extracted from the anamorphic lenses.
These anamorphic lenses provided a greater focus fall-off around the edges of the frame.
In other words, the sweet spot in the middle would stay sharp,
while the borders of the shot progressively fell out of focus.
These lenses also create an oval bokeh shape which is different from the regular rounded
bokeh of spherical glass. Anamorphics also tend to flare a bit easier, with a lateral flare.
These flares were another inclusion which differentiated Block 2 from Block 1 and made
Chon's images feel a bit more textural and a bit rougher than Koganada's clean frames.
The DP and director also messed up the image in other ways. They added haze when shooting
interior scenes, especially those in the 20s, to give an additional layer of texture.
Also, their images have a higher degree of halation or bloom to the highlights than Block 1,
which looks a bit cleaner. I'm not sure whether this came from the anamorphic glass,
the use of haze, effects in post or by using a stronger diffusion filter in front of the lens.
However, it too added a smoky texture.
Like in some of their other work together, they also implemented much more colourful
lighting than in the first Block, pushing in blue or red tones. Or sometimes using a very
cool colour balance to push tones into an exaggerated dawn blue look.
I think what this case study shows is that there's not necessarily a right or wrong approach
when it comes to making creative decisions. Different directors, DPs and crew members
will bring different sensibilities and interpretations to the screenplay.
Like in art it's these nuanced differences in how the subject matter is portrayed,
which are the little signature at the bottom of the painting, which show the authorship of each film.
Hope you enjoyed another video. If you'd like to support the channel,
you can do so by signing up to Patreon to get this content ad free.
Otherwise, until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
