How to Analyse Editing | Insiders Film School

Studio Solution
24 followers
#Education#filmmaker #teachnic filmmaker
Comments are disabled for this video.
Welcome back to the Insiders Film School where we master film analysis one concept at a time.
Today we're making sense of editing and how effective sequencing of shots can make meaning
without a single spoken word. What makes this one of the more challenging elements of film to
analyze is the fact that editors go to great lengths to make editing invisible. Except when
they don't. In this lesson you'll learn to spot and read every edit. Before we get started I always
like to take this opportunity to say a massive thank you to my patrons and members. They keep
this channel alive with their support and get exclusive access to the next episode in this
series and access to the community discord server so we can talk about films and stuff.
Right let's have a nice slow fade to black signalling the end of the intro
before we smash cut into something shocking to grab your attention in the next segment.
I told you that was coming. So when I'm introducing editing in film class I find it's helpful to
approach it from what preceded it. Welcome to the birth of cinema where there's no sound,
no colour and most importantly no editing. Films at the turn of the 20th century were single take
scenes capturing all the action within one shot like a theatre stage. The idea of interrupting
a shot to jump to another hadn't even been considered yet. Just capturing a moving scene
was enough to wow audiences. Soon though early film pioneers noticed by chance that when they
stopped cranking the camera in one location and then started it again in another they achieved
an effect that we now know as the cut. Believe it or not the many uses of this one simple device
the cut is all we're looking at today. At first filmmakers used it to extend the film world beyond
the confines of a single location and act as an ellipsis so we could skip time and space in a
heartbeat. But the real potential for editing became apparent when cutting began being used
within a scene. Look at this early short film by George Albert Smith. What if we cut from a full
shot of a boy looking through a looking glass to a close-up of an object. This pioneering use of an
eye line match cut expanded film language to include this is what the character can see. And
here in The Great Train Robbery Edwin S Porter used the cut to show two separate scenes happening
at the same time with a common technique we'll later know as cross-cutting. In each case meaning
isn't just being made by what we see in the shot but also by its juxtaposition with the one that
came before it. This is the result of a phenomenon called the Kuleshov effect named for Russian
filmmaker Lev Kuleshov who noticed that the meaning of the same shot in my example here the Union Jack
changes depending on what we cut to be it Winston Churchill, a skinhead or a Spice Girl.
Therefore and this is the real crux of today's lesson analyzing editing is a simple case of
identifying what we cut from and what we cut to and then when the cut happens. So the next logical
question is what do we cut from and to? Well there are broadly two approaches you'll find in film
continuity editing and expressive editing. Continuity editing as the name suggests favors
a linear easy to follow style. The goal here is to make every cut invisible for immersive viewing.
For example look at how Hitchcock shows a logical sequence of events almost like a picture book in
this scene. It's an incredibly intuitive style that developed in the days of silent cinema
where show don't tell was the only option until sound came along but the truth is it's
so effective that it's still the dominant style of editing in mainstream films today.
Now film wouldn't be an art form if its artists didn't start trying to break the rules that they
made for themselves so the second approach to editing expressive does just that and intentionally
draws attention to the cut. It emerged from avant-garde filmmakers like those of the French
New Wave, Soviet cinema and various indie directors. Perhaps a more intellectual form
of cutting the scope with expressive editing is huge but requires a bit more thinking on
the audience's part and can even be quite jarring. Now it's important to note here that neither
approach is correct or better than the other but as you'll see they produce very different effects
hence modern filmmakers tend to use them in tandem when a scene calls for a particular style.
So that's the history lesson over we now need to know the specific editing techniques you'll find
in each of these styles and what they typically mean. First up appropriately is the establishing
shot which confusingly sounds more like a shot type than an edit but the point here is the
placement of the shot at the very start of the scene. It's usually a wide shot of the location
and you can think of it as a visual version of a slug line or once upon a time in a creepy old
mansion or Gotham or the French countryside or whatever. The purpose of an establishing shot
is very simply to provide context. It tells us where we are before moving into the scene.
Sometimes a director may intentionally forego the establishing shot to leave us feeling as
lost and discombobulated as the characters. Next we'll be needing to cut within a scene as action
unfolds and the best way to do this for continuity is with match on action. This is when a physical
action such as opening a door or drawing a weapon even something as simple as a head turn disguises
the cut. Here it is used in Doctor No. Just look at how seamless each cut is. Because we're so
focused on the action we barely notice the cut. Match on action doesn't necessarily make a great
deal of meaning in itself but it can help direct the spectator's eye towards a particular character
or action that we aren't meant to miss. Next to show a character's perspective we may use an
eyeline match where we have a shot of a character looking at something off screen and the cut to
what they can see either as a point of view or over the shoulder. No different to the looking
glass example from over 100 years ago this seamlessly communicates what they can see
and when we cut back we'll often see their reaction to what they've seen. This cut really
demonstrates how each shot is a response to the one that came before it and it's a common tool
filmmakers use to offer us a more subjective view of the world and position us with a specific
character. Next we're likely to have some conversations between characters and for this
we'll probably use the shot reverse shot. This is when we cut from shot one to shot two and repeat.
Oh looks like this beach was a little too much beach for you Ken. If I wasn't severely injured
I would beat you off right now Ken. I'll beach off with you any day Ken. Hold my ice cream Ken.
While this may at first appear to be the most straightforward cut in all of cinema there are a
few ways that it can make meaning. Firstly how are each of the subjects in the shot reverse shot
framed? This links very closely with cinematography but remember we're interested in juxtaposition.
Take a look at this shot reverse shot from taxi driver. Notice that Travis is always isolated in
a single but the person he's speaking to is either over the shoulder or surrounded by people. He
lacks the social connections that everyone else seems to enjoy. It's also interesting to note
who has more screen time be it the speaker or the listener which can alter our perspective
on the exchange. Closer please. Closer. In moments of intimidation we may linger on the listener to
see their reaction.
We may linger on the speaker to prioritize their perspective.
Most of the time though it's simply used to show the back and forth of a conversation.
Finally consider how and when the framing changes within shot reverse shots to reflect the narrative
of the conversation. Like when a long exchange between characters suddenly switches to close-ups.
Is it because something significant has been said? Does it mark a turning point or a power
shift in the conversation? I know you remember it. Your name is on the memorial wall of the
very building you attacked. Now this is a good time to mention the 180 degree rule.
When cutting within a scene such as with dialogue continuity editing states that you shouldn't cross
the invisible line of action. Crossing the line changes the perspective and quickly disorientates
the audience. When this rule is broken it's usually for good reason like in Parasite when
Jessica crosses the line between her and Mrs Park. And finally we have cross-cutting which we've
already encountered in The Great Train Robbery. This is when two separate scenes are intercut to
show parallel action in different locations. Sometimes it's used to leave the audience
hanging on a pivotal moment in one scene while the fix or repair is delayed in another like this
tense scene in The Ring. Other times we may cross-cut across scenes to offer further juxtaposition
like the image of Mark Coleman brutally fighting in The Ring cross-cut with Mark Kerr receiving
stitching after a similar beating in his match. Now when it comes to expressive editing the jump
cut is a great place to start because of how jarring it is. This is when a segment of a shot
is removed making the action appear to skip or jump. Brought to the mainstream by the French
New Wave director Jean-Luc Godard this cut may be used to skip a long passage of time,
a fractured memory or more broadly to feel more meta-realist. When we see the cut right in front
of us the illusion of the film world is shattered and we are reminded this is just a film made by
real people. Next you'll remember from the start of this video the smash cut.
This also draws attention to the cut but by using sharply contrasting imagery.
Whereas continuity editing tries to soften the cut with match on action within the same space
a smash cut deliberately smashes our current continuity with an opposite be it colour,
shot distance or even sound. The effect here is often alarming, disarming or shocking.
And finally we come to perhaps the most expressive form of editing the montage.
Like every other edit we've seen this is all about the juxtaposition between shots
but in this case we may well cut to imagery that evokes the same feeling or tone as the
The most famous example is battleship Potemkin, particularly the Odessa step sequence. Here
Einstein cuts between multiple fragments of the chaos, the fleeing crowd, the marching soldiers,
the falling pram, the close-ups of terrified faces, not to follow a single character but to
build an overwhelming emotional impression. In more extreme examples montage may include cuts
Here's one of my favourite examples from 2001 when early man discovers that they can use tools,
in this case weapons, we cut from him smashing bones with his new power to a shot of other
members of the animal kingdom falling, suggesting this one discovery kick-started man's dominance
of the planet. So these are the edits that you need to look out for and just how meaning is
made through juxtaposition. But one final area that we need to talk about is the tempo of the
cutting. Without worrying about what we cut from and to or what type of cut we use, pay attention
to when we cut in these examples. Clearly the rhythm or tempo of cutting is able to convey
meaning as well. At its most simple fast-paced cutting can increase the intensity of action
sequences and slow cutting can focus our attention more on subtleties of the performance. But
this definitely is not one size fits all idea. Sometimes fast cutting can be passionate or
exciting. Sometimes minimal cutting can make us feel helpless when an attack is unfolding lifelike
in front of us. Simply put as well as paying attention to what we cut from and to you also
need to think about how long it is between cuts. In short what energy does this give us?
Special mention here has to go to the option that overwrites every single idea we've discussed so
Directors use this sparingly and always with intent. A continuous shot can trap us in the moment
refusing to let us look away or mentally reset. It can heighten tension by denying us the relief
of a cut or it can pull us deeper into a character's experience by making the scene feel
real-time and unbroken. Sometimes it's a technical showcase but at its best it's a storytelling
choice placing us right in the space with no escape, no manipulation and no chance to breathe.
So we're nearly at the end of this lesson. Now we understand how editing makes meaning through
juxtaposition, cut types and tempo. But how do we practically use this to analyze film?
Well here's a model based on three T's that you might find useful when you're new to analyzing
editing. Tone, tempo, technique. First up what's the emotional tone or narrative purpose of the
scene? As we've said in other lessons the various elements of film form are used to establish this
tone. So starting with the outcome and working backwards is often really helpful. If the scene
is meant to be intimidating we need to look at how the editing contributes to this tone.
Next consider the tempo. Are the cuts generally fast, steady, slow or non-existent? Is it consistent
throughout the scene or does it speed up or slow down? How does this help achieve the tone?
Finally look at the technical cutting within the scene. Broadly speaking are they establishing
continuity or are they expressive? What specific cuts are being used and how does the juxtaposition
between shot one and shot two make meaning? Does it favor a particular character positioning us
with them? Does it answer or build upon the information in the previous shot? Another
technique you may find useful is to break down a scene into a storyboard allowing you to visualize
every single cut in one. This really helps to see editing as a big picture and you'll be amazed at
the little details you'll notice when doing this. I'll be posting a separate video outlining how to
use this technique exclusively for members and patrons so be sure to check that one out too.
There we have it. As always I like to finish off by recommending a master class example of the topic
in action and it would be remiss of me to not suggest a Hitchcock film. This time I'm going with Psycho.
Hitchcock is the perfect filmmaker to study here because he believed the film should still make
complete sense even if the sound were turned off. Meaning for him editing and visual sequencing
were the true language of cinema. Psycho is a brilliant case study in how that philosophy
plays out across the entire film. From the early motel sequences that build unease through precise
pacing and rhythm to the shocking fragmentation of the shower scene. Every cut controls what we know,
when we know it and how we feel. Even the quieter scenes are meticulously structured
to guide our perspective and sustain tension. Psycho proves that great editing isn't just about
hiding cuts or drawing attention to them it's about shaping meaning purely through image and rhythm.
So that's it for this lesson guys. I hope you found it useful. If you've made it this far please
do me a favor and press the like button. It tells YouTube that this is a video that film fans like
you may find helpful and it tells me that this is the kind of content you want to see more of.
If you can't wait for the next lesson on how to analyze sound remember you can access that
right now if you're a member or patron and I'll look forward to seeing you in the next one.
Bye for now. Hasta la vista baby.
