How Flutes Work - Native American Flute

Make It Primitive
32 followers
14 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
This FluteCast is a bit different from usual.
Somebody asked me the question: How do flutes work?
and I did not have a good answer.
This video is about how Native American flutes produce sound.
You might this this is an arcane topic,
for physicists or flute makers.
But there is value for flute players.
There are some ornaments we will look at,
and we will look at the second register.
The first question is: What is Sound?
If you hit a drum head, it will vibrate for a while.
The drum head will push and pull on the air around it.
When the drum head pushes, it compresses the air,
makes the air more dense, gives it higher pressure.
When the drum head moves the other way,
it pulls on the air molecules next to it.
This reduces air pressure, rarefies it, makes it less dense.
To be clear, drum heads can produce very complex motions
and produce many different air pressure patterns.
But whatever pattern is produced from the sound source,
waves of air pressure compression and rarefaction
tend to propagate out from the source in all directions.
It is like waves on the surface of a pond,
when a droplet of water lands.
These waves move out through the air at high speed -
about 760 miles per hour - the speed of sound.
The sound waves of alternating higher and lower air pressure
move from the source to our ears,
where the high and low air pressures
push and pull on our eardrums.
Our ears convert that motion into tiny electrical signals
that travel along the nerves up to the brain.
The brain interprets these signals as sound.
Drum heads are great for describing how sounds works.
And it is obvious how the sound starts - you hit them.
But there are major differences between
the way drums produce sound and the way flutes produce sound.
You do not hit a flute to get the sound started,
and flutes produce a continuous sound.
Two big questions for flute are:
How do you get the sound started?
How do you make it continuous?
To answer the first question,
I would like you to get a dollar bill.
Pause the video, and go get a dollar bill.
Now hold the edge of the dollar bill
between your first two fingers on each side,
about half an inch apart
and bring it up to your lips
but do not touch your lips to the edge.
Make a small hole with your lips and blow across the edge
of the dollar bill.
The goal is to make a soft, high-pitched whistling sound.
That sound is called an "Edge Tone".
Some people call it a "Whistle Tone".
When air splits to go around an object
it tends to oscillate.
Native American flutes are designed to get that oscialltion
to happen in a very controlled way.
Our breath flows through the first cylinder and into the flue
the windway that sits under the block.
The air then exits the flue and crosses the sound hole.
See the air hitting the sharp splitting edge.
That will act like the edge of the dollar bill -
it will create an edge tone.
Here is a video of the edge tone at the sound hole of a flute.
Air comes out of the flue on the left, crosses the sound hole,
and hits the splitting edge.
The body of the flute is at the bottom
The important thing to notice is how the air is oscillating
as it hits the splitting edge.
This is where flute makers combine physics,
craftsmanship, and their own experience.
Their goal is to get just the right airflow and oscillation
at the sound hole.
Now back to the whole flute.
I am simulating what happens when we breathe into the flute.
It goes through the flue, across the sound hole,
and creates an edge tone.
That edge tone will affect the air inside the sound chamber.
With all finger holes closed,
we have a long column of air that is pushed and pulled
by the edge tone.
This is one way of looking at the inside of the sound chamber.
A pulse of alternating high and low pressure,
moving up and down the sound chamber.
High pressure in red and,
when it reflects off the end of the flute,
it becomes low pressure, shown in blue.
This is similar to a pulse travelling down a rope.
When the pulse hits the end point,
it flips and changes direction.
This is a simplification.
To get a better idea, we look at the whole sound chamber.
This simulation shows how the entire sound chamber behaves.
We see areas at the ends
where the air moves back and forth.
In the center, the air is not moving,
but it is changing pressure.
The red shows higher pressure
and the blue shows lower pressure.
We have a resonating colum of air that keeps going
because we keep providing breath input.
Here is a simulation of resonance in a recorder.
It shows low pressure in blue
and high pressure in red.
The movement of air in the sound chamber have
completely swamped the original edge tone.
The moving air from the sound chamber extends out the sound hole,
and also notice that it extends back up into the flue.
The edge tone got things started,
but the continued tone is maintained by our breath,
formed into a jet by the flue,
flowing into and out of the sound chamber.
All of these air vibrations
happen inside the body of the flute,
but how do we hear sound?
Both the sound hole and the end of the flute
are open to the outside air.
The moving air at both ends of the flute pushes and pulls
on the outside air and starts them vibrating back and forth.
That oscillating wave of sound moves towards our ears.
The air in the sound chamber vibrates
much faster than shown here -
about 300 to 800 times per second for
mid-range Native American flutes.
What happends if we open the bottom finger hole?
First, the sound has a new opening to exit.
The sound will come out of any hole in the body of the flute
that is open to the outside air.
Also, we have made the sound chamber shorter.
The air column has a shorter distance to vibrate
and so each vibration cycle takes less time.
That gives us more vibration cycles every second,
a higher frequency to those vibrations,
and our brain interprets that as a higher pitch.
Here is another simulation of a recorder
showing it emitting sound.
In this simulation, all finger holes are open
so the sound comes out many openings in the sound chamber.
Notice that each new pressure wave comes out
all of the openings: the sound hole,
the finger holes, then end of the flute
at almost exactly the same time.
Back to the resonating flute with all finger holes closed.
The way it is shown is great for demonstration,
but it is not quite accurate.
We have shown the location of greatest air pressure
in the middle of the sound chamber,
under the fourth finger hole.
Here I have added a graph of that air pressure.
It is not accurate because there is an acoustic effect
that happens at each end of the sound chamber.
It is called the "end effect".
When the ends of the sound chamber are open to the outside air,
as they are with Native flutes,
the sound chamber gets acoustically lengthened.
The reflections of the sound wave
actually occur beyond the physical ends of the sound chamber.
And that end effect is not symmetric.
The sound chamber is acoustically lengthened at both ends,
but because the two ends of the sound chamber
have different shapes,
the sound chamber is lengthened
much more at the upper end,
the end with the sound hole,
than it is at the foot end of the flute.
So the sound chamber is longer acoustically
than it is physically,
and it is also skewed toward the head end of the flute.
That means that the center of pressure,
the point at which there is maximum change in air pressure,
is more toward the head end.
It is typically very near the top-most finger hole,
the finger hole closest to your breath.
Here is an improves graph of that air pressure.
The sound chamber is acoustically longer
than the physical length
and the point of greatest change in air pressure
is under the first finger hole.
What happens if you do not get that hole completely
sealed with your finger?
It is shown here as the finger lifting up,
but even a tiny leak on a finger hole has
a dramatic effect on the way the flute behaves.
The reason? Right at the place where the air pressure has
the biggest swings, we are cancelling out those
swings by letting the outside air in and out.
This causes the resonance to immediately change.
The length of the sound chamber is cut in half,
and the frequency of the sound doubles.
I have slowed it down on this simulation
to make it easier to see.
This is often called the "second register",
or the "second harmonic".
You might hear it as a squeak or a mistake -
"Oops, I did not cover all the finger holes" -
but this can be useful for flute players.
Try this:
play your lowest note - all holes closed -
and then intentionally leak the top finger hole
just a little bit.
The diagram shows a little crack on the top finger hole.
Here it is on an E minor flute:
[Playing]
You might think that is a squeak,
but it is really a note.
Compare it against this note, the top octave note:
[Playing]
They should be pretty close together.
Now try this fingering: top hole open and all others closed.
[Playing]
On most that will produce a note that is
one semitone above the octave note.
[Playing]
That is a wonderful note.
It works on a lot of flutes, and it is a high-tension note.
You can add it to a song, maybe only once in a song,
maybe only once in an evening.
It is a very high tension note.
[Playing]
There is actually a whole set of notes in the
upper register of the flute - this second register,
when the flute is resonating in a different way.
But like the drum heads that have a lot of different ways
to vibrate, flutes are the same.
Every flute will produce different results
up in this second register.
This flute can play a few notes.
Most flutes can play at least one or two notes.
Most flutes will play this note.
And then - try some other notes. You will find some ornaments
up there, you will find some real notes up there.
Notes in the second register that happen to work on this flute
All flutes are different!
[Playing]
Or as an ornament ...
[Playing]
And we have another very useful technique we learned:
Edge Tones.
If you breathe very very softly into your flute,
before you get the sound chamber resonating,
you create an edge tone.
These are high whistling sounds.
Give it a try ... get close to the microphone,
and crank up the reverb or echo,
and if you have a loop pedal you can loop these sounds,
you can create some great sounds.
[Playing]
The sounds of the whales ... birds ... have fun with it.
There is a reason we put this out on YouTube.
Some people really want to know how a flute works,
but it is not the kind of information we get into in workshops.
We feel that when you come to a flute circle
or music workshop, or retreat,
you do not want to be cluttered up with "head space" information.
At our workshops, we really try as much as possible to
play from the heart and make music in the moment.
If you would like to sign up for our newsletter,
or see our schedule of upcoming flutes schools and retreats,
go to NativeFluteSchool.com
And, as always, we hope you can join us at a workshop!
