How Australians Get Ripped Off On Home Insurance- An Insider Explains.

Homeowners Insurance
7 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 28, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The reality for most insurers
is they'll charge you every dollar they can.
Why are you the most hated man by the insurance industry?
Well, I don't know if I am the most hated,
but maybe I'm about to be the most hated.
I mean, I worked for them for a decade.
I think I understand them reasonably well.
I think what I learned very quickly was that this insurance
claim process that could go on for years for people
was actually more traumatic sometimes than the flood itself.
The lobby group, the Insurance Council of Australia,
writes the guidelines for the industry.
Yes.
I mean, how does that even, how is that even allowed?
I mean, I laugh out of sheer terror.
Let's zero in on your hit list.
Okay.
Who does it badly?
Welcome to the show, everyone.
Well, there was a time when you paid your insurance and slept easy.
Storm, flood, fires, you were covered.
That was the deal.
Well, not anymore.
Take one case from just this month.
A federal court judge fined an insurer $2 million
for giving a family the runaround.
Their roof was damaged in a storm.
The claim was accepted, then ignored, then rejected 15 months later.
By then, the house was gone.
You know what? They're not alone.
Complaints about insurers to the financial ombudsman
hit a record last year, more than 34,000 of them.
And delays top the list. The hold music,
the assessors, the reports you can't read,
the fine print designed to wear you down until
you just give up. For a lot of people,
getting what they paid for is now harder
The disaster itself, think about that.
My guest today fights insurers for a living
and he's seen it from the other side.
If you've ever felt helpless fighting an insurance company,
this episode is for you. So Luke, first question,
why are you the most hated man by the insurance
industry? Well, I don't know if I am the most hated,
but maybe I'm about to be the most hated,
but I think it's about time that someone
is willing to speak out against
...insurers and call out their conduct because things need to change.
It seems like you're wearing it more as a badge of honour.
I think I am. I mean, I worked for them for a decade.
I think I understand them reasonably well
and every day I speak to people
who have gone through horrendous things and I just feel like
it's not being talked about enough.
Something or someone or a succession
of things made you want to cross the floor?
Well, I mean, look, I studied law,
graduated that and fell into insurance because no one
goes and wants to go into insurance, so to speak.
And I worked in the risk and compliance teams for insurers
and banks for about a decade.
For those who don't know risk and compliance,
it's kind of like the internal police.
And I climbed the corporate ladder
and I sort of got to a point where I just wasn't really
making a difference.
I sort of saw how consumers
were probably being taken advantage of and decided I wanted
to go back and help people.
And it was shortly after the 22 floods in Brisbane.
So friends and family were struggling with their home insurance claims.
By just knowing how, I guess, insurers work,
we were able to get in and get them significantly
better results.
But I just saw the sheer scale of people
who were being taken advantage of during that
time.
I covered those floods and I covered the floods in 2011
and it had a profound effect on me.
It was my hometown.
Yeah.
I saw all the regular places go under, but then the Brisbane River
swell to a point. I've never seen anything like it before
in Brisbane. I think it was
like since 74. And it had catastrophic impacts on families.
Then you add the stress of trying
to claim insurance. And there were all
these different definitions of a flood that came
through and people weren't covered and it turned into a scandal.
From your perspective
in 2022, how did it shake down?
Well, I think because there was the 2011 floods,
so everyone had sort of gone through that.
They'd rebuilt their properties,
and that was a one-in-100-year flood, and the fact
that this was the second one-in-100-year flood in basically a decade,
I think people went
into that rebuild exhausted,
because they'd just kind of just gone through that.
They're going to have to go through it again.
So I feel like it really tested Brisbane,
and as much as we're very good at getting
We're getting together and...
You know, the mud army and getting over that initial traumatic period.
I think what I learned very quickly
was that this insurance claim process that could go
on for years for people
was actually more traumatic sometimes than the flood itself.
And a lot of people, when that first happens,
you're not thinking about an insurance claim
because obviously that's where your family live.
It's where you keep your children safe.
It's near their school.
So everything is displaced immediately for those people.
I think for most Australians as well who are trusting of insurers,
Something like that happens, you hand it over to the insurer and go,
you're going to look after this.
And it's only six to 12 months later
that you realise that that might not have happened
and then you're re-traumatised
because of that through that claims process.
I've covered more disasters than I care to imagine
and nor do I want to cover another one, to be honest with you.
But it's when all the media goes home, it's when the clean-up is done
and when those claims are filed and the families are still displaced.
I've saw it all the way along the East Coast for 20 years.
Where do people go wrong with their insurance claims,
and even before that, when they take
out insurance?
Well, I think when people take out insurance,
we think all insurers are the same, all insurance
policies are the same, and we're probably misled
into that because people always tell
us to shop on price.
So that's kind of what we do.
I'm sure when you go to pick your insurer, you're not excited about it.
It's not a purchase that anyone really gets excited about.
It's sort of a grudge purchase.
So when you're actually taking out that policy,
you're not thinking that hard about what you
actually require if the worst was to happen.
So if a flood comes through and destroys your home
or if a fire burns your property down.
So it's only after a claim that you start
to realise that maybe you didn't have what
you thought you did.
And when I say that, I mean that a lot
of policies in Australia for domestic home, which
is a lot of the work we do.
They don't cover the same things.
So if you have a home and, say, for example, you have a pool
and that pool is really important to you,
well, a lot of insurance policies won't cover pools
or damage caused to pools.
So then when something happens and that becomes damage
and it costs a fortune to fix it,
people are often really shocked at claim time that,
well, I thought this would cover that damage,
but then it doesn't.
And I think that people need to...
Think about their property.
Think about what they want cover for when they're buying it
and make sure that the policy they buy actually has those things in it.
They don't make it easy, though.
I mean, these policies are like hundreds of pages long.
I don't think I've ever read one.
And I just assume that I'm going to be covered.
And that's the trap a lot of people fall into.
Well, 100% because they are.
They're like 100,000 words or something.
All legal, though.
All legal.
With every little trick in there sometimes.
Like what?
Yeah, well, there's a lot of tricks around keeping
your home in good condition.
And when we hear that, most of us would go,
yeah, my home's in good condition.
But certain policies will define that to mean no rust,
no wear and tear, no damage.
And that becomes really problematic
when you have a claim and you might want the insurer
to repair it because
They'll then try to cash settle you and say,
well, we can't repair it because your house
isn't in good condition.
Or even worse, there's plenty of examples where
the insurer will go, oh, actually, had
we have known the condition of your home
when you took it out, we wouldn't have actually
gave you a policy.
So they'll cancel the policy and try and decline the claim.
And we've seen that on all sorts of very large insurance claims.
It's a highly traumatic thing to happen to you.
So it's also that a lot of the time people, you know, you buy a policy.
And you think you're buying a policy with a certain brand
because it's prominent, but the insurer that is behind
that policy might be someone completely different.
Explain that.
Yeah.
And with examples, if you don't mind.
Yeah, sure.
So there's only maybe six or seven big domestic insurers
in Australia, but you might be a Qantas customer
and decide, oh, look, Qantas insurance I can purchase
and I get some Qantas points with that.
What that's actually called is white labelling.
So Qantas themselves do not have their own insurance company
and they don't have their own insurance policy.
They're actually selling that on behalf of another insurer.
In that case, it's an insurer called Auto & General.
And by selling that product, they get paid essentially a commission
to sell that product on behalf of that insurer.
The reason that's important is because when it comes to claim time
and maybe that insurer lets you down, people feel a little bit misled
Most of the big brands will do this,
but I was buying Qantas Insurance and I bought
that because I'm a loyal Qantas customer,
only to find out that once you actually make
a claim, that's not the person who's managing your claim
or your policy for that matter.
And also, because you're shopping on price,
you might not realize that, for example, that
Qantas Insurance product, flood doesn't come as standard.
So you just have to be really careful
when you're making those decisions that you're
You're not doing it just because maybe you get Qantas
points, you're actually making sure that you're getting
the policy that's right for you because the way you use your
House or the way you use
your car can really impact whether you'll have any cover at all
when a claim happens.
Well, guys, insurance isn't the only thing
in this country buried in fine print.
If you run a business, award rates, rosters,
and fair work rules can trip you up just as
fast.
That's why I have partnered with Tanda.
They're Australian-owned, based in Brisbane,
and their software handles rostering, timesheets,
Payroll and HR.
For more than 10,000 businesses.
So you pay your people right without needing a law degree.
And how good is that?
Check them out at tanda.com.au.
They're great guys.
You mentioned some of these claims and nothing aggravates me more.
People are underpaid
and otherwise they're forced into this agonizing wait.
Um, and they're basically trying, you know,
for you to settle early and get sick of it,
get tired of it and go, hang on, I'll just take whatever you've got.
Does that happen a lot?
All the time.
And by the time people call us,
which might be six to 12 months later, and you say to
them on the phone, I understand what you're going through.
They'll just burst into tears
because not only is there a delay, it's also that they
know their home best and they're raising
these issues as the insurers coming in and
Making certain conclusions or findings about their property,
they're saying to them, well, that's not true.
Like, I know my property and they're being gaslit through that process.
And that delay just wears people down.
I think when I first started Claims Hero
and was working in this home space, it kind of shocked me.
how often that was happening
and people were left in these really horrendous situations where their
home might be full of mold for example
and they're having to live in that property so the longer it
goes on that pressure just keeps building
and building on homeowners to the point where a lot
of them will just take what they're being offered
which is not enough and then they'll go and try
or you have the other extreme where after a flood
The insurers offer to rebuild your home quickly
and you don't really think about it and you go,
yes, thank you so much. That's very kind of you.
Only when you receive your premium the following
year and it's five times as much and you can't afford it
and suddenly your home's uninsurable
that consumers start to realise that potentially they've
been taken advantage of in that process.
Is part of that because insurers tend
to rebuild in harm's way?
100% and I always talk about this,
that there's a real irony in the insurance industry lobbying
so hard for governments to invest in resilience because no one
has rebuilt more homes in harm's way than the insurance industry.
Look, whether they'd agree with this or not,
they have very big contracts with their builders.
They promise, you know, certain volumes into that network
to get the rates that they can get, which normal consumers can't.
So there is a real incentive to rebuild those properties for people.
And people don't want to move from the place where they live, right?
100%.
And the government will, you know, after the 2022 floods,
they'll come in and say, we can lift and raise your home.
Like Lismore.
Yeah, exactly right. But often that can take some time
and there's delays in that. So the
pressure to rebuild is always there for a consumer,
but I feel like that can leave them in a really
bad spot. If it's uninsurable, 100%,
the value of their property can decline quite significantly
because people don't want to buy a property that is in a flood area.
And it's compounded by the
the fact that insurers price your individual property now.
So.
Previously, it used to be sort of like
a community-based pricing where a certain postcode
would get a risk rating
and then everyone would share the risk of the homes in that area.
Well, nowadays, the insurers have such granular data
on individual properties that your premium
is based on the risks at your property,
which means the most vulnerable people
are getting the highest premiums
and they're sort of being priced out, which is really
a challenge for consumers
because your mortgage often requires that you have insurance on your
property. So I really feel for people,
they're finding themselves in some really horrendous
situations. I mean, my mom lives in Yorkies, not in Cairns.
And I mean, she's made very few claims
over 40 years.
But the cyclone risk there has meant that her premiums have gone up to,
I think it's 8,000 bucks, which is a lot for a pensioner.
But that's considered this risk zone now.
I mean, there are other better examples further south
where councils have allowed buildings to go ahead
in areas that are flood-prone.
Yeah, and it's a big problem.
Where they're allowing people to build homes,
not thinking through that future risk,
or even when someone's purchasing a home,
they're not necessarily thinking about,
well, because that is in a high-risk area,
that insurance premiums are going to be $8,000.
Do you know, it just occurred to me too,
I mean, I always think,
Oh, thank God I've got insurance.
They're there for me.
But are they really?
I mean, this is a $150 billion industry in Australia
or something like that, or it's going to be.
Yeah.
Are they really on your side?
I don't think so.
But they will spend, and we know they spend,
tens of millions of dollars to try and convince you
that in that moment you need us, we're there for you.
But I think for most people who...
We've all seen those ads.
100%.
And I think for most people who have a claim,
That's not what turns up at their door to fix it or repair it.
When you say most, it gives me the shivers.
Well, I think that you're...
What's the percentages of payouts?
Well, I think that there are a lot of people
in the industry will say, you know, that they
have a great success rate and most customers
are happy with the repairs.
But I think that you have to view it in light
of the fact that most people don't understand
insurance and they don't understand claims.
So they might not even realize
that they're being taken advantage of when, you know, they'll
have water come through their roof and the
insurer comes and says, hey, we'll paint your
ceiling.
And you're like, oh, thank you.
But the reality is they shouldn't have done that.
And then they leave it.
It gets full of mold and then you try
and tell them six months later and then you're in for a
really big fight at that point.
I mean, ultimately insurers are there to make money. If they've got
shareholders, it's there to return capital to shareholders,
which is why I always find it quite
interesting where the industry will, you know,
they'll talk about claims costs and rising claims
costs as a reason for why premiums are going up,
but they overlook the fact that
When they have a record profit year,
that money is paid out to shareholders as dividends.
And don't get me wrong, we all benefit.
We probably all part own it as part of our superannuation.
I shouldn't.
But the reality for a lot of consumers
that some of the savings that are then paid out
as dividends should have been paid to them with their claim.
Or they're left to pick up the pieces for an insurer
that didn't turn up when they needed them.
And ultimately, if an insurer is doing that, someone pays.
So the insurer might get out of paying a claim
that they should have paid.
But if it's not the individuals, it's governments.
So the industry has a lot to answer for, I think,
in terms of how they're sort of pushing the cost
of either under-insurance or not insuring
to other parties that isn't themselves.
But again, millions and millions of dollars spent
to convince consumers otherwise.
But I thought, again, ignorance is not always bliss.
Yeah.
We've had several inquiries into the industry.
There's a bunch of watchdogs closely monitoring.
How do they get away with it?
I have to be honest, I'm not sure.
And I was working internally when the Royal Commission was on.
And that was really great in terms of highlighting
the issues that are happening on these claims.
And CEOs were dragged into that Royal Commission.
And they had to front up an answer
to what's occurring within their businesses on these
individual claims that had fallen through the cracks
and at times had ruined people's
lives.
And I was really hopeful after that there
was going to be some real change.
Because if you read the recommendations
and you look at the findings, things should have
changed.
But as we're almost a decade on, the same things are still happening.
We had a parliamentary inquiry after
the 2022 floods looking at how the insurers responded.
It's the same issues that they're dealing with,
which is delays, you know, issues with
their suppliers, the impact that they're having on consumers,
destroying lives.
And I think what happens is it gets a little bit of attention.
And then people forget about it.
It goes away.
And they go back to spending lots of money
to convince the right people that, you know,
they're trying their best.
But I think that there needs to be more sustained attention
on these failures that are happening
on claims.
Where would you say those biggest failures are then?
And really zero into the granular on that if you can,
because I think...
If you've gone through it, you know,
but you've still got to get insured and the number of
people who have gone through it multiple times.
So explain to us some of those issues.
Well, I think the one that comes to mind,
which has been a recurring issue, is that
the insurers, they don't own the builders that do the work
or any of the trades that
do the work.
So when you have a claim and you lodge that and they say,
let us rebuild your property,
they're not talking about them.
They're talking about the suppliers that they have contracts with.
Which, you know, one of the frustrations
when I worked internally is like all we ever focused
on was like, how do we get those costs down,
down, down for these suppliers?
The problem that you have with that is the unintended
consequences, which is that if
you're paying them very little,
then when they turn up to someone's house, they're probably
not doing a thorough job.
So for someone to go out and do a leak detection,
sometimes they're getting paid $150.
Which nowadays, by the time you've turned up
on site, you're already losing money.
So everything is just rushed.
It's done really, really quickly.
And because of that, issues start to arise naturally.
And then they'll sometimes
also not want to necessarily do the work because if it's complex
in any way and you're getting paid next to nothing,
you don't want to do those repairs.
And then the insurers start to push cash settlements.
And they'll be cash settling a lot of the time
on what it costs them to get the works done.
Well, anyone who's had someone turn up to their house recently
to do anything, it costs a fortune.
And the rates that insurers get paid,
people just couldn't possibly get that work done themselves.
So a lot of the issues start to arise in that
where you've had a claim, they're trying to cash settle you,
you don't think you're getting paid enough.
Or alternatively, you think you
are and you're taking it going, oh, great, I've got this
money.
But the reality is if you don't do those repairs
and you don't do it properly, you won't be
able to get insurance the next time that that happens.
So I think that that is a big problem.
The other thing for insurers is that people are overworked.
You know, I don't sit here and say everyone
who works in the insurance industry is evil.
That's not true.
I worked with so many amazing people,
but I think that executives have a lot to answer for
in terms of how they control costs and how when
You know, big events happen.
People can be managing hundreds of claims.
And the reality is you can't do it properly.
And that's that recurring theme that we see
in those inquiries is that the same thing
keeps happening.
And then from there, you start to get
into this whole idea around independent experts.
And it's a really hot topic because-
They're not independent.
Look, I don't think they're independent.
If I have a secret contract with you that you're
not allowed a copy of, I don't think
I'm necessarily independent.
And then they can get into that whole cost control mode
and consumers then get caught
up in that where, you know,
you might have a supplier that they send out who's done a
bad job.
You don't know, but in the contract,
it's saying, well, we'll recover from you if you
do a bad job on our consumers' properties.
So then when they send that supplier back out
to review their own work to see if something's
gone wrong.
It wouldn't surprise you to know
that they often don't find that something's gone wrong
and that's where we can find these claims get really,
really complicated because simple
issues aren't addressed quickly
and therefore they can blow out in costs.
Why are they able to seemingly handle a big event?
Is it because of the focus of the media is on it
and because they're gun shy about it?
Why can they seemingly get to those issues
as opposed to someone's deck going down and
that taking years to fix?
Well, I think that they sort of plan for those events
and they have processes in place.
The other thing is a lot of people don't realize
that the insurers are often reinsured.
for losses. So when you take out an insurance policy,
often part of what you're paying for is
going to the insurer's reinsurer.
So it's basically the insurer's insurer. So for those
big events, sometimes it might be that a reinsurer might
be picking up part of that cost. So you can
sometimes find that they'll respond better
to those natural disasters because they're more
willing to move quickly, pay what they need to, to get things done.
And you'll see that with some
some insurers, like they'll pay their suppliers more after an event.
But when it comes to, you know,
these ordinary things that happen in your house, maybe you
don't get that same level of attention.
Can you give me more detail on what a reinsurer is?
Well, there's some really big players that sit in the background.
A lot of them are overseas,
so a lot of people would probably know of like Munich Re or Berkshire
Hathaway.
These guys sort of provide reinsurance for the world.
Cover.
Cover, that's right.
So the insurers don't get enough premiums that obviously
if a massive flood happens, you can imagine the cost of that.
So they basically take out insurance to cover when certain losses
happen to them the same way you do.
But it's just on a far bigger scale.
And those reinsurers are obviously doing
that for insurers around the world.
And that's what the insurers will talk about,
the cost of that and how that's going up.
And Australia's seen...
You know, Australia is a pretty risky place.
So there is an element of justification
in those costs going up overseas.
But I didn't even know this whole thing existed.
I just presumed they had money and then they paid it out,
but they're covering themselves overseas.
So if we're seen as a riskier country,
then the money that they lend us or our insurers gets more expensive.
Absolutely.
Is that the base in a nutshell?
To a certain extent.
I mean, I think what goes into making up your premium and what you pay,
I do think there's a bit of smoke and mirrors with the industry
about where the cost truly lies there.
So it is definitely one part of it.
There's no doubt about it.
Explain that to me then.
What is in a premium?
We're all looking at them now going up.
Yes.
I don't know that there's any that are going down,
and I don't know how that gets fixed.
Yeah.
But despite all these inquiries, I don't know of any bill
that I've got actually across the board that's coming down.
But what...
Makes up a premium.
And there's different categories, obviously, in insurance.
Yeah, exactly right.
So, I mean, at a high level,
the insurer is determining the risk that you're taking out.
So it means if you've got a home,
they're trying to work out, well, what risks exist there?
And then they're pricing it.
Now, all of that is commercially sensitive
and insurers don't share that.
So what you tend to just see is the number.
You don't quite know what's going on in the background
and I think the industry wants you
to believe that there's this precise science
and that it's made up of the reinsurance costs and
the risks at your property.
The reality for most insurers is they'll charge you every dollar they
can and you can see that when your renewal comes
and it goes up significantly and if you just call
up they'll then lower it immediately. So it's not this exact science.
Truthfully, I believe that the main thing
that probably keeps insurance more affordable is
competition. So the less competition you have,
the less these insurers have to compete with one
another. And that's where the white labelling
that we spoke about earlier can really confuse
people because you might think
that you're comparing multiple insurers, but it's just
one. Or you have comparison websites out there.
Compare the market is probably
a good one where you go on there to compare your home
insurance, but the reality is you're often only comparing
a couple of insurers across
multiple different brands.
So how many, explain that again, sorry,
I find this quite fascinating and also very
disturbing.
How many white label insurers are there then?
In terms of just brands putting their names on policies, countless.
Really?
Really?
There's so many, like all your.
Banking ones like Westpac Insurance, Commonwealth Bank Insurance,
all of those are just white-labeled to underlying insurers.
So who's the underlying insurer of all those?
Well, some of the main ones
that people would know are Allianz, Suncorp,
IAG, which are brands like NRMA, or there's auto in general,
which are ones like Budget Direct, Qantas Insurance, Coles Insurance.
So those big players actually then have way more brands
that often they're selling policies through.
So you might think that you're comparing two,
but really, and some of them, the wording
of the policy is almost identical,
but you'll be being quoted different prices.
Why would they do that?
Is that just a retail strategy?
Well, they do it because they make a fortune out of it.
I think if you look at the financial services guide
for Qantas, it says that they can get
paid up to 24% of the premium for selling it to you as the customer.
And I think that this is the awkward part
for the industry is it's like, well, if there's
There's a cost-of-living crisis, and you're saying...
Home insurance is unaffordable.
Why are we giving away up to 24% of the premium to these brands?
I agree.
Because arguably, you could lower that and just sell it directly.
Is it 24% less if you go to one of those bigger companies?
Not necessarily.
So, and I think this is the,
what I always say is that if they're giving a lot of the
premium away, they sort of have to make back,
arguably, that cost somewhere.
And what you can potentially see is that some of those companies
then have to obviously
be a bit tougher on claims and things to make it work.
What you're seeing from some insurers,
which I think is a good thing, they're sort of cutting
back how much they're willing to give away
because they're not making a lot of money.
So that range and the percentage they give away varies.
But the industry is also, you know, insurance broking in general.
They're taking part of that premium when it's sold.
So we're talking billions of dollars is being paid
to different people to sell these insurance policies.
So I think it's just important context
when the industry is out there talking about.
resilience and the government needs to spend more money
to protect consumers that they also
probably just need to be a bit transparent about
how much money they give away. Or is it only a
problem when you're not making money out of it?
If you're making money and selling it, then
it's not a problem. I would imagine,
just listening to you, that that is an area,
just one of the many that needs to be cleaned up.
I think so. Streamlined. And more information
to the consumer.
Yeah, absolutely.
How many times does an industry need to be cleaned up
before they get their ---- together?
Well, I get frustrated because the regulators
will give them a slap on the wrist every now and again.
But if you're a sole provider financial advisor,
if you did even a fraction of what these insurers would do,
you'd lose your license straight away.
But it seems like for these insurers,
I don't know where that line would be where we start going,
give us back your license.
I mean, you had the...
The federal court this week handed down a $2 million fine
to Hollard Insurance over the handling of a single claim.
Which was a storm claim, reasonably simple.
I mean, I see this every day.
Water comes through the roof.
They don't deal with it.
18 months later, the house is full of mold.
It's condemned, basically going to be knocked down and start again.
And they were found to have breached their obligation
of utmost good faith to that customer.
But that one claim and the facts, I mean,
I would have 10 of those on my desk any given
day of people calling up and telling me that exact same.
story but again it's the two million dollars
is just a drop in the ocean compared to the money
they make so there are some really great regulators
out there ASIC you know from working internally
they're really scared of ASIC because they have teeth
but I think until we start actually
threatening to take the license off some of these providers.
I don't think they're going to take it seriously.
It's a difficult thing to prove.
Is that the whole thing?
It's costly to do an inquiry into some of these providers or,
you know, how would you
do it?
How would you clean it up?
Well, how I would clean it up, particularly
if we're thinking about home insurance space,
is I think you need actual legislation
and regulation on how they manage claims.
At the moment, and to be honest,
I don't even know how this started, but the Insurance Council
of Australia, which is a lobby group for the insurers,
have self-regulation.
So they have a code of practice, which they develop for their members.
And this sort of just becomes the go-to thing
that everyone refers to of how they need to act.
And I was thinking of, you know,
if you and I had to self-regulate our own behaviour,
you're naturally going to make sure that you don't
do anything that's going to get you
into actual trouble.
And I think historically in Australia,
these codes of practice have just miserably failed
and they're rewriting it.
At the moment, and they're going for the first time,
we're going to make it enforceable
through your policy.
But they've just rewritten it currently,
the current draft, in a way that no consumer would
ever be able to enforce it.
That is shocking that it's onerous on a consumer.
I don't know how it even works.
And just to reiterate,
so that I've got this clear and this thick head of mine, that the
lobby group, the Insurance Council of Australia,
writes the guidelines for the industry.
Yes.
I mean, how is that even allowed?
Well, I don't know.
I
Good on them for convincing someone that that, you know.
I mean, I laugh out of sheer terror.
don't
I know.
Imagine if we did that.
Imagine if, you know, instead of,
you know, take criminals, for example,
not to say insurers are criminals, but if we just said to them,
actually, you know what, you can start writing your own laws
about how you should act.
know.
It would just be a complete disaster.
But now it has just suddenly occurred to me why, you know,
they've been allowed to get away with it because those lobbyists
are going to the government to pitch for money.
100%.
And you see that their access to ministers is unprecedented.
Or you see politicians going on, they talk about their delegations
overseas where they'll go to the US or they'll go to Europe
and they'll go meet with...
Uh, re-insurers and other parties.
So I think that that relationship that they have is too close.
And I think that that can potentially result
in some conflicts there and consumers are
the ones that are paying the price for that, but it, it might start to.
Make you question, is that why some
of the meaningful changes aren't occurring in that
industry?
Because we can keep holding them accountable
on individual claims, but it's just a matter
of time until the next big disaster happens
and then consumers are left in horrible situations.
But this is making complete sense to me now.
You say we can hold them accountable.
That's you, like your company, which I think you do an amazing job.
But you're one company up against a Goliath.
And the industry is worth so much money.
If the coverage of their inadequacies isn't being highlighted,
then how on earth is it supposed to be changed?
I think mainstream media have gone really soft on insurers.
Obviously, they're big advertisers.
And we know that they're under pressure at the moment.
But I just do not see the stories like we used to about these insurers.
And then when they do do a story, it...
I always say, you know, a current affair will chase
a painter down the road and give them
way more of a hard time than what they
do a big insurance company who is often being
made aware that a claim is off track
and yet they'll still leave at six to 12 months.
But as soon as the media get involved, they'll pay the claim.
The media plays such an important role
and that's why I think it's so important that
these stories are being told because insurers,
I know internally, nothing would get us to
work quicker than knowing that a story was going to air.
So part of the reason why I
want you on is because whilst
mainstream media might have
dropped off bagging insurance companies, it is right up my alley.
Alright, so I want everyone to, if you can, send us a note on our email
or just in the system below or go to your, give us your Facebook site
and they can give us the story there and we'll follow it up and we're
going to get you back on in a couple of weeks to talk about it, right?
Yeah, so, I mean, look, Claims Hero,
you can Google it across all social media or claimshero.au.
So, yeah, if you have a story, you're welcome to reach out to us.
Obviously, you can do inquiries with us.
But we're just so happy that someone like you is willing to help out
because there's so many consumers in bad situations
who need people like yourself with a platform to tell their stories
and to raise awareness of, you know,
some of these issues that are occurring.
Well, quite frankly, highlighting some
of the insurers that maybe people really need
to think about if they're with them.
We're going to do that right now, too.
So that is one thing that we want your feedback.
We want your stories.
And we will highlight that.
We'll come back to that in a couple of weeks' time.
I'm just so sick of people getting ripped off
and sick of stories going over and over
and over.
But they're on a constant treadmill.
And nothing gets done year after year after year.
Parliamentary inquiries, yada, yada, yada.
Let's zero in.
On your hit list, okay, who does it badly?
Who does it badly?
In my experience, obviously, with the claims we see,
and we mainly obviously see when claims are off track
and they come to us, the ones that would be on my list,
I think auto in general, so Budget Direct,
Qantas Insurance, Coles Insurance, those are the brands.
Probably no coincidence, they spend probably the most money,
I'd say, on advertising.
just are not an insurer that I personally would want
to be with if I found myself in that
situation. And the conduct that we see on some
of the claims that we manage is that they have
reports and information
and they just refuse to provide it to a consumer or will be requesting.
Well, they'll get a scope of works for,
I have one at the moment, they'll get a scope of works
for restoration, which is probably about fixing mold
at the property. We only identify it two
years later that they actually had that quote and scope,
which is telling them likely that
There was mold in the property and they needed to deal with it.
They just refused to provide it.
We'll request it under the code or we'll request it on the Privacy Act.
And they'll say, no, we're not giving you that.
And even as you go up the ranks,
they just maintain that decision that there's no good
reason to give that information to a consumer.
We don't experience that with other insurers.
They give the information.
I used to work in personal injury, highly regulated.
You had to give the information.
And for me, withholding information
from a consumer is just unconscionable
because the power imbalance is massive.
Well, that should be against the law.
It should be, 100%.
And that's what I think where they're doing a code review,
but I think it needs to be legislated
that you have to disclose the information
that you have to a consumer,
not the current code says if we relied upon it,
which just gives them an out—that we didn't rely upon it
so we're not giving that information.
So...
To me, it's conduct like that that's really poor.
We've seen a tendency of that insurer
to want to cash settle quite quickly.
And the good condition term that I mentioned earlier, in my opinion,
is just far broader than other insurers
which say you've got to have your home
that's well-maintained and watertight.
That good condition terminology,
which we've actually referred them to ASIC over this.
It's so broad, it just gives them basically the ability
to not repair homes if they don't want to.
But then they leave consumers with this long list of things
that they need to do to repair their home or, you know,
because they're saying it's not in good condition.
But often the list that we have from consumers,
and we just see these letters being sent every single time,
could be tens of thousands of dollars on maintenance items
that probably aren't required or don't need to be done.
You know, we had one example where they're asking them
to comply with codes that didn't
apply when the home was built, and then you say to them,
it's like, oh, well, that code
didn't apply, why would you ask them to do that?
That's so much money, and they're like, well,
it's their obligation for the home to be in
good condition.
So they're just not reasonable, in my opinion,
and I think for consumers who are taking out
those policies, which are often cheaper than others.
That they just need to really look at the policy wording
and why they might be cheaper.
The other one that's probably on my hit list is QBE,
very big brand, but they rely heavily
on loss adjusters.
So loss adjusters are people that an insurer might appoint
to manage your claim, but they
are also there to often minimise the cost for the insurer.
So we just see with insurers
that rely heavily on loss adjusters that...
You know, they're sort of trying to reduce those costs.
And I've seen it in reports where they'll go,
a loss adjuster will take $7,000 out of a quote for a builder
or just go, could you remove that $7,000?
And then they'll write to the insurance,
say, I saved you $7,000.
And I'm like, no, you didn't.
You just ripped off that consumer $7,000
because they should have been paid that.
Or you'll have QBE where...
Honestly, some of these insurers think that their obligations, well,
no, their policy terms gives them rights more than the police, where
if they have what they think is a suspicion of fraud or an inkling,
they'll make you, you have to go to a recorded interview that's filmed.
You can have a support person that can't say anything.
You've got to give your bank records, your phone records.
And if you say no to any of it, they're
just going to decline your claim.
What?
It's wild.
Yeah.
And they will aggressively pursue that.
And then these investigators that work for the insurers,
you know, they come in and they try and act like the police as well,
where they go, you know,
we don't need to tell you why we're investigating it.
We don't need to tell you what our reasonable suspicion is,
but you have to do all these recorded interviews.
Highly stressful for people.
And we've seen in notes from these insurers, from these teams,
which are called fraud teams,
Which naturally, it's like when you've
been pulled over by the police, right?
And you haven't done anything wrong, but you immediately feel guilty.
A lot of consumers feel the same way
when you start getting emails from the fraud team
wanting a recorded interview.
People naturally get nervous and want to walk away from that.
Well, you become a problem.
100%.
And you're just trying to alleviate your problem.
Yeah, and it just angers me so much
because it often causes delay and extreme stress.
And it would just be over something simple like...
Well, the water didn't quite touch the electronics,
so we don't know why you wanted to claim those,
even though when you also look at the notes,
their own people had told the customer that you can dispose of those
because it was in that room.
But so often they're doing these sorts of processes
because it often does result in more withdrawn claims.
But I just think it speaks to a culture and an insurer
that treating customers that way is acceptable.
And that's not to say that if it's a fraudulent claim, fair enough.
But often what the suspicion they have does not justify that behaviour.
And the police can't even do that.
You know, imagine if they could just go, oh,
I've got a reasonable suspicion that Carl's got something to hide
and then haul you in and put cameras.
Actually, yeah, while we're here, bring the cops in.
I'm uninsurable.
Yeah, exactly.
So it's just those behaviours that.
They're really not good enough.
And even though Hollard was the one
that ASIC took to court for $2 million,
my view is it's not really fair on them because, yes,
that was a poorly managed claim, but all the insurers are doing it.
And if they had to pay $2 million every time,
all these insurers would be having to do that.
But it's a shame that that money goes to the government that fine.
It probably should go to that poor consumer who,
God knows what they had to live through.
While that claim was being managed.
Agree.
So when you come into it,
and would you say that you've had reasonable success?
Yes.
And why do you have success?
When someone comes to you,
explain that process and why you're able to do what no one else can.
Well, it's not to say that no one else could
do it to a certain extent, but I think a lot
of insurers take advantage of the fact
that this is just one insurance claim that you
might have in your lifetime
and you don't understand the processes and what's going
on.
So once we get involved, they'll often see,
they know that we've seen this a hundred times
and they're less likely to try
and argue something that they might be arguing with a consumer.
Like what?
Well, we had some recently where there's a roof claim hail damage.
The insurer's got two reports.
One report says...
80% of it's damaged and the roof should be replaced.
Then they go and get a second report, which says it's less damaged.
And then they rely on the report
that says there's less damage to the roof.
And then once we get involved, we're like,
well, why did you even go get a second report?
Your first one said it should have been paid.
And just bearing in mind our earlier conversation about
these assessors and who they work for.
A hundred percent.
And, you know, why are they even requesting a second one?
They'll look at that and go, oh.
Yeah, we're in a bit of trouble here and they'll overturn that.
And sometimes that can happen in a week or two days.
I think our record's like a day that that can change.
And, you know, for consumers, that doesn't,
they don't necessarily feel like a win.
They're happy that we were able to get that result for them,
but it's quite frustrating when they were arguing that point.
And I think that...
Unfortunately, that's the reality is that you can have
a well-written argument and AI is going a
long way to help people argue things.
But for these insurers, you know, sometimes they're
looking at it more broadly or thinking,
can we potentially get away with that? Or do we think
it's justified? There is the Australian Financial Complaints Authority,
which is free for consumers
And you can lodge a complaint, they're impartial.
And, you know, consumers can get good results through there.
But then there's also, you know, a long list of people who have
also felt like that process hasn't necessarily been done fairly.
You don't pay for it.
So it's funded by the industry.
The insurers are the one paying for that service.
Service, end.
Yeah, it can leave consumers in a tricky spot
when it can take six to 12 months to go through that process.
I don't want you to take offense at this.
Oh, actually, I don't care if you do.
But the fact that you have a successful business
out of business that's been done poorly
says a lot about an industry.
It does, and I think also the way they behave.
Not to diminish your expertise.
No, 100%, and I think that you do kind of need to know
how they work internally to be able to position things
to try and get things paid.
All
And truthfully, you need some pretty thick skin
because I've been accused of all sorts of things by these insurers,
and when we first started, every claim was a real big fight.
right.
But over time, they obviously start
to learn that we don't back down either.
So tell me about that.
Tell me how they greeted you.
We started this interview by saying that you are hated in the industry.
That's for sure how you were at the start.
Yeah.
And it wouldn't have diminished that much, would it?
It's probably got worse, to be fair.
Worse?
Well, you know, we do a lot of work to educate consumers.
On what they need to do, how they go about it.
You know, we put a lot of content out as well
to help consumers fight this on their own.
I always say to insurers, if I was just out to make money,
why would I go around trying to teach people?
Like at my core, I'm a consumer advocate.
That's why I started this company.
That's why when insurers go hard at me, right?
They really love when I talk about them.
They like to threaten me and stuff.
I'm like, it's the opposite.
I started this company to help consumers
and to stand up to that behavior.
So the more you do that to me,
the more I'm just going to keep digging in 100%.
I think that that is sort of what insurers have learned over time.
And when we first started, we were raising a lot of issues.
And they'd be going, Luke, you don't know what you're talking about.
That's not an issue.
I later found out they were sort of starting remediation programs.
Get out.
So the smart insurers have probably realised over time
that it's not that smart to fight that hard
when you probably have a few skeletons in your closet.
And, you know, sometimes we joke that we know where they're buried
because we buried them when we were there.
So we know that those issues exist.
So it's a pain point for a reason.
Unfortunately for consumers a lot of the time, they don't know that.
As I said, it's only when something's gone off track
and then they're living in their car or something
because the insurer's not funding alternate accommodation,
their home's destroyed,
that the realities of not knowing that system
become very problematic.
I have to confess too at this point
that we were recommended you because we had a mould problem
and we just thought on the surface it looked bad,
but then we spoke to you
Thank
You said something that really rocked me.
It was, if I get the quote right,
mold is the new asbestos.
Yeah.
And that kind of rocked me to my core.
And because it's not what you,
you're not going to see the stuff that's really bad,
but explain to me why mold is such a terrible issue right now.
you.
I think there's a growing understanding of mold
and the impacts that mold can
have on people.
That was actually an executive that said that to me,
that mold is the new asbestos.
And you just took it as your own, which I like,
which I've now taken as my own.
It sounded good when I said it as well, didn't it?
But the reality of it is that if you don't deal
with water in a property,
so a lot of claims involve water, right?
Flood, storms, burst pipes.
If you don't get in and dry that out really quickly, mold develops.
The problem with that is that if you leave it
for a long time it just gets worse and worse
and worse and what we found after 2022 floods
was there was this group of providers that
had very limited qualifications
because there's no required qualification to assess
mould in Australia and they were going around
and basically just doing a sniff
test and looking around and going this one's good to go,
no mould here you can rebuild.
But what we realised was there's
a scientific test you can do to actually work out whether
there's mould or not, so we don't need to just sniff it.
And what we were finding is when we were going
into those homes after they were giving it
the all clear, that they really had quite
a lot of toxic mould in them, which makes
sense, right?
Because...
Flood water or water that comes through your roof,
it also then travels through lots of
contaminants.
So it's contaminated water and mould needs moisture,
a food source, and then it can grow.
And then sometimes we also then just lock these properties up.
And if it's in Brisbane or Cairns, you know, it's very humid.
These properties then become full of mould.
But what we were finding was that there
were people living in these and then you can actually
do a blood test and you can find mould in your blood.
So it was very concerning for some people to actually,
sometimes they'd find the mold in
their blood and then you'd find it
in their property. And this is a really big-
Health issues?
Health issues, 100%. And I've met a number of people who have lived in
mold-infested properties for a couple of years,
and they share a similar cognitive decline.
And if you look online or if you look at the research,
it's really, really bad for you.
And I think for the industry, and this is one
of the things that we're sort of blowing the
the whistle on to a certain extent is that
They need to do more to deal with this
because too many properties are left in that state of yours
where you're going, oh, there's a little bit of mould there.
That's bad.
It releases spores into the air and you're breathing that in.
So if you can smell mould, that's pretty bad.
But I've been in plenty of properties
that have really high mould levels
and you can't see it.
Okay, so, I mean, people will be panicking a little bit now
because how dangerous is it?
If it's at a certain part of the house, if it's on the roof,
where are the danger levels there?
Where is it okay to have it in your house?
And also, what if you've got no recourse for insurance?
What if it's just an old house and it's in the winter
and it's been raining a lot?
Well, look, I'm no expert in mould, to be clear,
so a disclaimer there.
But there are certain types of mould that are particularly toxic.
So when something has stayed wet for a...
An extended period, you can get certain moulds
that are quite toxic to humans and the spores
they release can cause significant health impacts,
particularly to people who are immunocompromised.
But again, it just seemed to us that the industry
were just not taking this seriously and they
were sending these providers in and they'd say, yeah, this is all good.
And when we say to them, it's like,
they're not occupational hygienists with a four-year
university degree.
They sometimes had as little as like a few-day course
and an online certification from the
US.
And we're going, like, to me, I'm like,
this is wild that you're just relying upon that
and rebuilding these homes.
I would hate to think,
and this is probably for anyone who had their home rebuilt after
the floods, if they didn't give you scientific test results
to show the mould was low, you're
probably still living in a home
that's got really high mould levels in it.
But for consumers, that is a problem
because there's plenty of things that can contribute
to mould in properties and anyone who rents a property.
Has experienced this where you'll raise
that some water's come in and someone might come
in and just wipe it off.
But the reality is you've got to deal
with what's causing the issue, which there's usually
a moisture source.
Is it a hole in your roof?
Is there some waterproofing issue with your shower?
You've got to get to the bottom of what
that is and you've got to deal with that properly.
And it's like, the frustration for me
is the amount of time I saw insurers arguing for
months over who should fix the roof tile on the roof.
And the whole time it's letting water come in.
I'm like, for God's sake, could you just put a tarp on the roof?
How's there an argument there?
Well, you know, this is the thing
that the consumer sitting in their home going, water's
coming in every time it rains.
That didn't happen before the event.
And insurers going, no, that's a pre-existing damage.
You can see why customers start
to think they're going crazy where it's like, well, I know
my property, but this is everyday occurrence for people.
And the insurers just send this expert out.
And often blindly follow it.
And that's where we're sort of saying, no, you need to do better.
And we've seen an improvement around mould,
but a very small claim that could be worth $2,000
could then be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Really? Out of mould?
Out of mould, because mould gets into furniture and porous items
and you can't get that mould out necessarily.
So it's a really big problem for the industry in terms of costs
and they're concerned about it.
The other reality for policies is that they don't cover mould.
Like, mould is excluded.
Mould just, you know, arises naturally, as you say.
It's excluded.
But if it's linked to an insured event, so water's got in from a storm
and mould is then throughout the property,
then it's covered at that point.
But the reality is that a lot of the time it's the insurer's failures
to do what they should do.
And Australians, it's great we're laid back.
But then we go, yes, we trust the insurer, they're going to do it.
But they're not cutting out the walls
and they're not removing the kitchen
that they should because, you know,
they're probably investigating or...
Doing a fraud investigation behind
the scenes that you don't know about.
Meanwhile,
no one's telling you that you should be drying out your property
because you might find later on that it's full of mold
and now you're responsible for trying to fix it.
And for people who do have quite an adverse reaction to it
I've been fine.
If I go into a really moldy property, you'll get headaches.
Once you start to understand it, you get a lot more concerned about it.
But they'll know that this is happening to them
and then their home's not habitable
and they're in alternative accommodation and that's being cut off.
You can see how they end up in these situations where they're
in a really, really bad spot.
Gee, that's a growing problem then.
It's been a problem for years, but we're just more aware of it.
Yeah, I think it's an awareness piece.
And I think for the industry, they also appreciate that.
The sniff test after the floods probably wasn't great.
And I think in 2011, who knows,
they probably didn't even do the sniff test.
But there's still some insurers who rely on that.
And I think that there needs to be a better understanding
of what's required in Australian standards
to make sure that, particularly when it comes to claims
and where they're relying on insurers,
That you're actually doing the right thing,
because lots of people would be getting sick
as a result of those failures.
Look, this is much broader than I thought it was going to be,
and there's a lot to talk
about.
So I'd love to get you back.
I mean, we just barely touched the surface,
but I think that's a great crossover on the
areas where people can take a look in their own backyard.
Also, more importantly, take a look at their policies.
We didn't get to the better ones.
We'd better be a balanced podcast.
Just give us a couple of the good ones.
I think Australian owned and run, so Suncorp and IAG,
with Australian shareholders, you better bet.
They don't always get it right.
Don't get me wrong.
They also make big mistakes.
But when things go wrong, at least in our experience,
they're quicker to address the issues.
How are we going to keep those premiums down?
Well, I think we spoke about a couple of those issues
that the industry can control,
and I think for those ministers that like to go to ICA events
or overseas, I think you probably should sit down with consumers
or people who are willing to call out the industry
because there aren't that many.
The industry is very powerful.
They pay a lot of people.
So that's probably why I'm the most hated,
but I think that these conversations are important
because it's not just as simple as...
You know, it's getting riskier to have a property in Australia.
There's a whole lot of things that can be done
to reduce those costs and we need to have
a balanced discussion to get there.
We are devoted to it on this show, you know,
standing up for those who don't really have
a voice.
It's one of the priorities.
This is one area that I think we're going to get a lot of feedback on.
So it'd be awesome to get you back on.
Yeah.
And if we can go through some examples,
I think people get a lot out of it.
So I appreciate your time.
Great to talk with you, Luke, and we'll see you again soon.
Thanks, Carl.
And I think for all those consumers,
just so grateful that you're willing to help them.
They want to tell their stories
and we're willing to help in any way we can as well
to support them and get those claims back on track.
Good on you.
Stay strong.
Good on you.
Appreciate it.
