Heated Confrontation Between Hosts About Hamas Sympathizing, w/ Emily Jashinsky and Eliana Johnson

Megyn Kelly
51 followers
1 Video View·Oct 17, 2023
as I see people who I really previously respected,
or at least kind of respected,
take incredibly insane positions.
Now, this particular woman is on the left,
but I always thought was a voice of relative reason
on the left, Bernie Sanders supporter.
That's fine, I don't care.
Crystal Ball was a Bernie Sanders supporter too.
I've always liked her.
We have political differences,
but I think she's got sane views.
This woman is Breonna Joy Gray.
She's been on this program before.
And she tweeted out,
and then I'll play you,
in response to Anthony Blinken, the Secretary of State,
saying, what separates Israel, the US,
and other democracies
when it comes to difficult situations like this
is our respect for international law and the laws of war.
And adding that Hamas uses people as human shields.
That is all true, 100% true.
And you don't have to believe me.
I actually pulled it just for kicks.
NATO, 2019 NATO report,
the practice of using human shields is common
to most violent extremists operating in the Gaza Strip.
And they go on to provide the details,
including they've noted that even in this conflict,
Hamas has called for Gaza residents
to remain in the crossfire.
They like civilian casualties.
They want it.
They use them for propaganda.
They use the civilians as human shields
so that the Israelis won't bomb their military targets.
That's why they have their headquarters
underneath a hospital.
So just Anthony Blinken's correct.
That is what Hamas does.
And we are different.
We don't do that.
And neither does Israel.
Her response was the decapitated baby lie,
the lies about rape.
What lie is that, Brianna?
Because I've seen for myself,
at least one picture of a baby lying in its crib,
surrounded by blood, including around the neck.
So do we actually need to see the head
separated from the body?
What would satisfy you?
What would make you see that babies,
and do we really care?
Do we care if it had its head chopped off
or if it was burned or if it was shot?
Walk me through what would persuade you, Brianna,
that we've got a real problem on our hands
with these Hamas terrorists.
Is it, what do they need to do to the baby?
What kind of motion picture would you like to see
to make you actually believe
that these are actual terrorists?
But anyway, the decapitated baby lie,
the lies about rape.
I guess tablet has been completely wrong.
The women didn't get raped
next to the dead bodies of their friends.
Brianna knows better than the reporters who were there
talking to those who survived the massacre.
260 were dead, but on the ground reporters
went and actually asked the people what happened.
But Brianna sitting at her desk,
she knows better, you see,
because she went to Harvard Law School.
She's educated.
She's one of the elite.
So she sees through the nonsense, gals.
She sees the lie.
It was all to establish some moral distinction
between the piles of bodies killed by Israel
and the pile of bodies killed by Hamas.
Neither Hamas nor Israel respects international law,
but this is the shell game played
to justify continued US support of ethnic cleansing.
So the US is supporting Israel's ethnic cleansing
of Palestine, where the population has what?
I don't triple some huge number
over the past some 40 years,
nevermind when Israel turned over the entire region
to Gaza or to Hamas.
Ultimately, in any event,
the Palestinian numbers have gone up, not down.
So they're terrible ethnic cleansers.
The Israels, they suck at it, the Israelis.
This is her take.
Okay, it's all we wanna ethnically cleanse the Palestinians
and therefore we're making up lies
about the dead babies and the rapes, lies.
That Anderson Cooper video, lies.
He's in on it.
It's like Alex Jones with his Anderson Cooper
in front of the green screen.
I saw.
He made up Sandy Hook.
He was part of it.
Sure, yes, Brianna,
you are officially in Alex Jones territory.
Welcome to the insane, bizarre parade.
Here she is.
She hosts what used to be Crystal and Sagar Show on Rising.
Emily, you go, you're on this.
And she had this crazy exchange with Robbie Suave,
who's more, she's sort of,
she's been sort of left but reasonable
and he's been like right but,
like no one's extreme.
Not this day.
In a very, very heated exchange
that kind of stemmed off of similar allegations by her.
Watch.
There is still this embellishment
and I believe it is rooted in a desire
to strip humanity from the people of Palestine
and justify doing what Max Miller
and a number of other officials
in the Israeli government have said.
Max Miller is an obscure Republican official.
It does not matter what he says.
So every leftist, wait a minute, Robbie.
Every leftist in America was asked to apologize
for some random protest.
They should apologize.
They should apologize for their endorsement
of terrorist attacks on innocent Israeli civilians
just as I am outraged by the retaliatory actions
that are killing innocent Palestinian children everywhere.
I care about both of these things
and have said I care about both of these things
over and over again.
It is you and the idiotic leftist,
terrorist sympathizing people
who do not care about the dead Israelis.
They don't.
So I'm a terrorist.
And they've said it over and over again.
Black Lives Matter has said it.
The Harvard students have said it.
The DSA in various locations have said it.
The left endorses what Hamas did.
They do, they endorse it.
The Harvard newspaper said exactly
what the editorial page of Israel's major newspaper said.
I don't give a fuck, Brianna.
Okay, well, that's clear that that's your opinion,
but the Israeli voices in Israel who are getting killed
because their fascist right-wing government
decides to keep 2.3 million people-
The Israelis are getting killed
because a terrorist group targeted them.
Emily, you used to work there.
Now you help Crystal and Sagar on their independent venture,
but they're not normally quite that fiery.
This issue has really divided people.
And I have to say,
what she's saying is absolutely outrageous to me.
I mean, it's absolutely outrageous to me.
What sane person questions,
oh, the decapitated baby lie, the rape lie?
What the hell does she know?
She's suggesting women, how does she know anything?
That's just absolute, that's holocaust denialism.
That's what that is.
I like Brianna.
And if that exchange, if I were involved in that exchange,
how I would have responded is actually that Haaretz,
is what she was referring to, the Israeli newspaper
that allegedly said the same thing as the Harvard statement.
I think that there was a huge distinction
between those two statements.
One, first of all, is coming from an Israeli paper
that obviously has been covering
at the time of that editorial, all kinds of stuff.
And it kind of goes without saying
that they condemn the slaughter of Jews.
On the other hand also, the Harvard statement said
that Israel was entirely to blame.
We saw that in a lot of the statements, entirely to blame.
And so I think,
and I have actually been thinking about this a lot
as I've listened to some of these arguments
over the last week,
there's this very visceral anger, frustration, rage
among some people on the left
about the way Western media oftentimes,
and Western media has a whole lot of problems.
And I think we all agree with that.
We'll take like that I-24 report,
which I believe said that there were 40 beheaded babies
at Kfar Azzah.
And because that number might not be exactly accurate,
we saw this sort of eruption of that visceral frustration
a lot of people on the American left have
with Western media,
because they just think all of the Palestinians
get ignored and they're the ones that are suffering
under the oppression of colonialism, et cetera, et cetera.
I completely disagree with the history there.
I think that's where it comes from.
And I think it was really, really, really unfortunate
to see a lot of that on display last week
in the aftermath of the slaughter of innocents.
To do that within a few days.
I mean, I get that there are serious concerns,
but Hamas is bragging
about using civilians as human shields.
They are right now telling people not to evacuate,
saying things like you have two options,
or we have two options as the Palestinian people
to fight or to die in our homes.
That is the kind of language
that treats civilians as martyrs,
not as people who should be trying to find safe passage
to Egypt or other ways to evacuate,
which the community is,
the global community is actually working on,
but to tell people to die in their homes,
that is using civilians as human shields.
That is not evacuating civilians
in a way that ensures they will be muddled together
with the military population in Gaza,
knowing that Israel is going to retaliate
because hundreds, more than a thousand of their people
were slaughtered in cold blood,
ambushed at their homes at a music festival.
These two things are not the same
and they're not justified,
even if you believe that there were decades
of colonial oppression.
So I think to do anything,
but to blame Hamas for the situation
that it's putting its own civilians in,
in the context of this last week is really, really wrong.
I mean, the fact, like,
it's so just dishonest, Eliana,
to say these are lies told by the media.
You know, they're trying to tell,
they're trying to suggest Hamas did evil things
to draw a moral distinction
between the evil Hamas and Israel.
That's what she's saying.
In this tweet, she says,
these lies were to establish a moral distinction
between the pile of bodies from Israel and those from Hamas.
There is a moral distinction.
There is a moral distinction between Hamas and Israel,
whether she wants to see it or not.
And she can delude herself all she wants
based on how many babies were decapitated.
Was it 40?
Was it four?
Was it one?
Versus, and ignore all the evidence.
Did you see the picture from Netanyahu of the burned babies?
Are you one of the loonies, Brianna,
who decided to do a little AI investigation on the picture,
like Tim Pool, only to later find out,
oh, whoops, I embarrassed myself.
It's real.
How about the one of the dead stabbed shot?
Couldn't tell because they blurred it.
Baby in its crib.
How about the bloody other crib that they tweeted out?
How about the many bloody playrooms that they tweeted out?
How about the Anderson Cooper?
Like to run with it's a lie, right?
And it's meant to like manipulate you
into thinking Hamas is evil unfairly, Eliana.
It truly is Alex Jones territory.
Like you really are, you've gone off the deep end.
You need to be reeled in.
And I don't know in her case what the motivation is,
whether it's an anti-Semitism thing, what it is,
but it's disgusting because the evidence is overwhelming
that Hamas is murdering children
and the elderly and the disabled.
And if you don't believe that,
why don't you believe Hamas' own videos
where they have little babies hostage right now?
What is that?
Is that okay?
Do the Israelis do that, Brianna?
Is that cool with the international rules of war?
It's a no.
Show me the international rules of war
that Israel has broken.
They try not to kill civilians.
They attack military targets.
They drop a warning bomb let on the buildings
that they're about to bomb to let the people know
the real bomb is coming, get out.
They send text messages to the Palestinians
saying a bomb is coming, evacuate now.
My God, she's right.
She's wrong to say that there's no moral distinction
between these two.
There's a world of moral distinction between the two.
Well, I actually think this is a really sinister
mode of argumentation that you're seeing,
not just from her,
but there was a Los Angeles Times reporter
who also seized on this fact on Twitter.
And it is to seize on a detail
and saying this hasn't been proven.
And the effect or the intended effect
is to make others question the reality in front of them.
Well, if babies weren't bedded,
how can we know if all of these other things are true?
The intended effect is to say,
did these events really happen?
Question what you're being told from the press.
Question the pictures that you're seeing.
Question the videos that are being put out.
Question the reality.
Unfortunately, Hamas intentionally broadcast footage
and I'd be happy to get in an argument
about were the babies beheaded
or were they merely shot in their cribs?
Were there 11 bloody handprints or were there 20?
Because that's the path they're going to go down.
This show is supported by Grand Canyon University.
Founded in 1949, GCU is a private Christian university
that's dedicated to delivering an affordable
and transformative higher education.
Their vibrant campus is located
in beautiful Phoenix, Arizona.
And according to niche.com,
it's ranked a top 25 best campus in the country.
As of June, 2023, GCU offers 330 academic programs
with over 270 of them online,
allowing you the freedom to earn your degree on your time
from wherever you are.
Their programs are also designed to challenge
and inspire you.
At GCU, your degree,
whether it's a bachelor's, master's or doctorate,
integrates the free market system
and a welcoming Christian worldview.
And they believe that higher education
should be accessible to all.
Learn more about GCU's programs,
competitive tuition rates,
and scholarship offers from your university counselor.
They're part of the supportive graduation team
that's going to take a personalized approach
to helping you achieve your academic goals,
walking next to you every step of the way.
GCU is a private Christian, affordable.
For more info or to enroll, visit gcu.edu.
Hey, thanks so much for watching.
If you like what you just saw,
hit the subscribe button for more clips and full episodes.
