Is EMDR a Genuine Alternative to the "Gold Standard" CBT for OCD? Let’s Look at the Science! 🧠🔬 When it comes to treating Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is usually the unavoidable path. But what about EMDR, a method that actually originates from trauma therapy? An exciting study by Marsden et al. (2018) pitted these two methods against each other. The results are surprising—and contain an important statistical detail we need to look at closely.
What is the "Gold Standard"? (ERP Explained) The most well-researched and recommended method worldwide is CBT with Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP). The principle sounds simple, but it is hard work: patients deliberately expose themselves to situations that trigger their obsession (e.g., touching door handles) but consciously refrain from the usual compulsive behavior (e.g., washing hands). The goal is to learn that anxiety subsides on its own without performing the ritual.
The Study: EMDR vs. ERP In this randomized controlled trial, 55 participants with OCD were randomly divided into two groups:
- The EMDR Group: These patients received a specific adaptation of the EMDR protocol for OCD. Using rapid eye movements, they processed current triggers (obsessive thoughts), future scenarios, and potential traumatic events from the past.
- The CBT (ERP) Group: These patients created a "fear hierarchy" and systematically practiced facing their fears (both in vivo and in imagination) without performing the compulsive behaviors.
The Results: A Statistical Dilemma? At first glance, the researchers' conclusion was: Both methods work! There was no statistically significant difference between the groups—both showed improvements.
BUT – A Look at the Numbers (Numerical Trend) Here is where it gets interesting. When you look at the raw numbers, CBT (ERP) had the edge:
The effect of symptom reduction was slightly stronger in CBT (Cohen’s d = -0.24 in favor of CBT).
More patients in the CBT group achieved "clinically significant improvement" (40.0% for CBT vs. 21.4% for EMDR).
Why was the result "not significant" then? The problem was likely statistical power. With only 55 participants, the sample size was too small to prove this smaller advantage of CBT beyond a statistical doubt. It is reasonable to assume that if they had tested 500 people instead of 55, CBT would likely have been statistically confirmed as the superior method.
Conclusion EMDR proved to be a viable alternative, especially for people who cannot or do not want to do ERP. However, numerically—and based on the broad body of research—ERP (CBT) remains the undisputed champion.
Study: Marsden, Z., Lovell, K., Blore, D., Ali, S., & Delgadillo, J. (2018). A randomized controlled trial comparing EMDR and CBT for obsessive-compulsive disorder. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 25, e10–e18. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2120
About the Author: Eskil Burck is a psychological advisor and textbook author. He teaches psychology for Kalaidos University of Applied Sciences (Zurich). His psychology podcast "psychologie-lernen.de" consistently ranked #1 on iTunes in the "Education" category. His books "Angst - was hilft wirklich ...?", "Das manipulierte Gehirn" and "Neue Psychologie der Beeinflussung" became Amazon bestsellers. Even in his spare time, he enjoys reading studies...😅🙈 For more information, visit: www.learningpsychology.net
Does EMDR therapy, eye movement desensitization and reprocessing therapy help with OCD?
I really wish there was more research on this question, but there is one pilot study, even
though the authors of the study probably won't like it that I call it the pilot study, but
what I like about this pilot study from Marston and colleagues published in 2018 is that they
compared EMDR not with a weightless control group, but with the gold standard therapy,
which is ERP, exposure and response prevention, which means if you are, for example, suffering
from contamination OCD, you are helped by a therapist that you expose yourself to your
feared situation, like for example, touching a doorknob and then your usual response, for
example, washing your hands gets prevented.
And in this way you learn that you don't have to wash your hands and you learn that it's
absolutely okay, you don't get a deadly disease just by touching a doorknob and your brain
learns that all this OCD behavior was just a waste of so much energy.
So ERP really works great and this is what they did with the control group in this study.
The other group received EMDR and you might know it, it is this strange therapy, somehow
strange therapy and many scientists in the beginning said, well, this is all bullshit,
but many studies could show that especially with people suffering from post-traumatic
stress disorder, PTSD, it is very effective.
It is this strange therapy with these fast eye movements, which you do in order to weaken
your traumatic memories.
And in case of OCD, there are also sometimes traumatic memories, like for example, the
memory of somebody in your family getting a really severe illness or somebody dying
from an illness.
And sometimes this is the starting point for some people to avoid all kinds of bacteria
or viruses and to keep everything clean.
And for example, cleaning their hands like 10, 20, 50, 100 times per day.
And therefore the goal in this EMDR therapy was to weaken those traumatic memories of
for example, the death of a loved one or the illness of a loved one many years ago.
So the participants had to think back to this traumatic memory and while having this traumatic
memory, they were asked to do these typical eye movements.
And one hypothesis why all this works, why it's possible to weaken your memories this
way is memory reconsolidation, which means that whenever we remind ourselves of something
in the past, this memory gets into a malleable state.
It's not something that is unchangeable.
It's something that we can change whenever we reactivate it.
And during this malleable state, this state in which it can be updated, when we then do
these eye movements, we integrate some new visual input into this old memory.
And therefore this old memory gets changed and it's no longer as vivid as before and
it's no longer as distressing as before.
And of course, now you might say, well, but sometimes with OCD, there is not one specific
event, there is not one specific memory that we can target.
So what do we do in this situation?
Well, what the scientists did in those cases is to say, well, remind yourself of one situation
in which your OCD was really strong, which is also some kind of traumatic memory, because
for many people, this creates the fear of the fear.
And therefore, if we weaken those situations, we also can take a lot of tension out of the system.
At least this is the theory.
But did it really work?
Well, in comparison to the gold standard therapy, the ERP therapy, from a numerical point of
view, the effects of EMDR were not that strong.
So after therapy in the ERP group, 40% had a reliable and significant improvement, whereas
in the EMDR group, it were just 21.4%.
But those differences were not significant, which is probably because the sample size
was quite small.
And in a follow-up testing six months later, these differences had become much smaller.
So what can we learn from those results?
First of all, we need bigger studies.
Second, EMDR seems to be promising, but there is a tendency that it is not as effective as ERP.
So third, I think at this point in time, I would not recommend EMDR as first-line treatment.
Instead, of course, ERP, which has been tested in so many studies, and also in comparison
to this study, there have been studies with much bigger success rates.
So ERP still is the gold standard.
But, and maybe this is point number four, especially for people who can name a specific
event in the past, a specific memory that was the beginning of their OCD.
I think for those, EMDR, eye movement desensitization and reprocessing could be very helpful.
And as usually, probably a combination of both therapies might be the best solution.
That's it for today.
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
And if you want to learn more about therapy methods in psychology, of course, feel free
to take a look at the website or maybe take a look at the books.
Thank you very much for watching.
And if you should be suffering from OCD, there are effective therapies out there.
And it's definitely possible to overcome OCD.