Flat Plate Strike Tests - for Arrows vs Armour 3

The Precision of Crossbowry
1 follower
1 Video View·May 20, 2026
Flat Plate Strike Tests - for Arrows vs Armour 3
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis research preliminary tests the penetration capabilities of three medieval arrowhead types (Type 9, 16, and 21B) against various armor. By comparing iron and steel constructions and varying shaft weights, the study analyzes how velocity, material hardness, and momentum influence the ability to pierce textile, mail, and plate armor.
Comments are disabled for this video.
So today in this film we're going to shoot three different arrows
at armour samples. So when we get into our main film tomorrow we have a better
understanding of what this guy is going to be facing.
But Joe you've never shot a type 16 or a 21b at plate?
Nope never.
Hi it's Todd here and we are back with Arrows vs Armour 3.
A series of films where we look in spectacular detail of what happens
when arrows strike armour. This first essential and valuable research film
is going to take place to do our homework before we carry on
with our main spectacular film. And with us today we have Warbow archer Joe Gibbs,
Master Fletcher, Will Sherman of Medieval Arrows, our Arms and Armour historian Dr
Toby Capwell and myself Todd from Todd's Workshop.
Before we're let loose onto a project like this
we need to do our homework because there has been a massive change
and we are now using a new arrowhead beloved by the English in the later
medieval period. The steel tips bladed and barbed type 16.
So in this film we're going to take our old arrow types and two new arrow types
and shoot them against armour samples and compare directly
how one penetrates relative to another. So when we get into our main film
tomorrow we have a better understanding of what this guy is going to be facing.
To find out more about the arrows I'm going to hand over to Toby and Will.
So we've done loads of testing with these
why are we changing arrowhead type now? So the reason we're looking at these two
new types fundamentally is because that's made of iron and these are made
of steel here. This is a type 9 that we tested in the
last two films. The type 9 is made of iron entirely. It's a one piece head,
iron socket, iron tip. We know how this reacts now with armour.
The tip often deflects and bends and the neck tends to break or bends and comes
off the arrow shaft. What they did to counter that was to
invent the type 16 arrowhead. The London Museum type 16 arrowhead has
still got an iron socket so it's still cheap to make
but they've now wrapped a piece of hardenable steel over the top. This means
that the piece interacting with the armour
is high carbon steel. You've also welded over the socket seam
so that can't open up and it can't fail on you. The downside to this
is that to make a type 16 by forge welding is quite difficult. Learning how
to forge weld is a skill on its own but what's easier than that is brazing.
So the type 21B, which is this one here, turns up in around 1450 and becomes
the arrowhead of choice. About 350 of these arrowheads were found on
the Toughton battlefield. They turned up at Tewkesbury as well. We've still got an
iron socket, we've still got steel barbs over the top
but this time it's brazed together in the fire and anybody can hold a piece of
metal in the fire, wait for the braze to melt and you've
got a functional arrowhead ready to go. So we need to find out what these two
different arrowheads do in our flat plate testing and compare
them to the type 9, which you already understand. So we've
discussed the arrowhead but the arrow itself has changed from the first two
tests as well. Previously we used an ash arrow which is quite heavy. There are
records of ash arrows being used but we know for a fact they were using
aspen. We've got records of them asking for aspen and for banning clog
makers from using aspen so they could keep the stocks of the wood for arrows.
So we've got an aspen or populous tremula arrow shaft here.
Same dimensions as the previous test but it's quite a lot lighter. Those arrows
were around 85, 87 grams. These are in the 50 gram area so they're
going to move a lot quicker. The problem with shooting at armour and
getting comparable results are the curves because if you shoot one
shot you can look at the damage, you can see
what's happened. If you want to go for a second shot to back up your data
you'll shoot, it'll go in a different place, different set curves,
different material thicknesses. Obviously shooting flat samples cannot give us a
definitive answer on how these arrows would perform against
real armour but because it's flat we can compare
exactly like for like, different arrows, different shots. So the first thing we
need to find out is how each of these three arrow types
perform leaving Joe's bow. All right Joe so this
one has the type 9 head on it and it's 80 grams.
Let's see how it goes. 54.8 meters per second.
So this one's type 16 and it's 58 grams. 62.5 that one. Okay now we've got the 21b
and this one's really light at 51 grams. 64.3 that one. That's moving.
Right now that we've got some velocity readings on the arrows
it's time to shoot stuff but we're not going to start
by shooting at the steel. Armour, protective garments,
were made out of a lot of other materials. Actually textile armour
was super common and I think we need to be shooting at this as well
just to get a better sense of the whole military situation that we're dealing
with. Military ordinances in France in the
say that you should make your jacks, your textile armour,
out of 25 layers of linen if it's got a stag skin facing
or 30 layers of linen if it doesn't and that's
this. It seems pretty tough but is this really going to protect our wearer
against arrows? Maybe? I don't know. Let's find out.
So Joe, type 9 short bodkin against 30 layer cloth jack
backed by archery foam. Okay. Well that's pretty obvious what happened.
Second one, type 9 again. Could you get it more central next time?
I'll try. Type 16. I do. Well and again
so another type 16. Lighter than the old type 9s.
Nice. So 21B and again this is lighter still.
So this is the last of the 21Bs. So these are the ones with the brazed on
heads and sharpened up like a blade. Right.
Wow. Yeah that's a thing to see. Wow. Do you got some readings?
Yep. Okay so we'll do the type 9s first shall we? So we've got 18
and we've got 23 there. Type 16s, these are the barbed welded ones, we've got 18
there and we've got 17 there and Joe do you
want to do the 21Bs? That one's 24 and that one
that one's off the chart that one. So 25 plus. Okay so we'll have to measure that
one afterwards so we actually get definitive.
I'd like to start and the first thing I'd say is
didn't really work did it? He's died isn't he?
The suggestion is that whatever this textile armour is for
it isn't for stopping arrows. What we can see from this
is these are our two type 9 bodkins, aren't they short bodkins? So they've
gone in not massively dissimilar to the type
16s which are bladed, a lot lighter, a lot faster, less momentum.
The only really notable one is that these two here which are
21Bs, again they're bladed, seven, eight centimetres, two and a half,
three inches deeper. But when you're talking about going in this deep
in a way the guy's already dead so what's two inches between friends? They
did behave a little bit differently just for the future. They are bladed,
they look more like a cutting tool than the diamond section heads don't
they? But next up we're going to be talking about male
so we're going to do the same three arrowheads again
shooting a male. Okay let's do it. Male is still used extensively on the
battlefield in 1450 so what we've got over there is a
commercially made sample of eight millimetre flat link male over an
arming doublet sample so that's much thinner than the padded jack before
it's about three layers of hemp canvas and linen.
So Joe again we're going to shoot the three arrow types, take it away.
Type 9 there you go, thank you. But again that's
quite clearly in isn't it? I mean there's no doubt. In fairness to
mailmakers, if you go into a mailmakers workshop and
you say I need a collar that is arrow proof, he can
do that. If you said I just need light mail to
cover the gaps in my armour for general use in case blades get in
there whatever, that's a different thing. All right Joe
another type 9 bodkin. Thank you. Yeah they're going in aren't they?
One prediction I'll make, if we're going to see
a difference between those two, the type 9s,
I think those are probably just breaking through the links at the rivet
or just stretching the links out of the way. The type 16s maybe but
certainly the 21s, those blades are just going to shear through the main body of
the link. It'll look like someone got in there
with clippers. All right Joe, welded, barbed, hardened type 16. Thank you.
There's a massive difference in momentum between the arrows though.
Because of the weight. Because of the weight and energy is one thing
and we know that the type 9s have got more energy anyway, they're heavier,
but they're going to have a lot more momentum and that's going to make a
difference to penetration, it always does.
All right here's your second hardened type 16.
Went in at a slightly funny angle didn't it? Yeah. All right so now we can try these
brazed, hardened again, Tauton type heads.
Oh!
Amazing. Okay last of your Tauton type heads. Thank you.
Yeah very good. Thank you. Let's go have a look then.
Oh look at that. Yeah. It's cool. This one's a shame isn't it? But we have to almost
discount that because of the angle it went in at and you can see now as well
that it's much less. However the others are actually all
fairly comparable. Yeah this is a 9 isn't it? These are the
type 9 vodkans here. If I can see around. Oh okay so that one's gone in beyond
our mark. Okay that one's on 21. So then we've got. That one's type 16
there. Type 16 and type 16, these two. So this one
is 21 centimeters in. This one is 14 but it was
kind of a weird shot. And you've got these two here. So that one's 23.
It's gone in beyond the mark as well? Yeah.
Well let's just remember that we didn't really doubt
that these would go through this male. We're mainly interested
in do any of the heads perform differently?
Is there an appreciable difference in the way they're getting through?
So obviously like the previous test that we've done everything's going through
but the bladed barbed ones and the winged ones aren't making a massive
difference compared to the the bodkin type heads. So my big
takeaway from this is that there's not a significant
difference in performance between any of the arrows when they're hitting this
male. The guy wearing it is going to be in deep trouble
and if he's using it for protecting his vulnerable areas that may well be
protected against sword cut they're not going to be protected
by arrow impact. Do you say that's fair enough? Definitely.
There is a broken rivet here. Oh it's stretched that ring you can actually see
the ring is visibly thinner. There we go. Yeah. Is it that link there?
Yeah yeah it's bent that one out of the way.
I think on that one it opened and split a link.
There you go Toby. This is the link that failed against one
of the type 21s and notice that the rivet is intact
and it's sheared right through like someone took a pair of clippers to it.
This one's interesting as well it's ultimately it's cut it
but it's stretched a lot before it did it. You would have thought the join is the
weakest point but it's cut through the body of the
link. Right well I think the next test has to be our plate steel. It doesn't
need a lot of introduction really but it is
one and a half millimeter mild steel plate. Slightly heavier arrow
with a type 9. Thank you. And still it amazes me every time.
Well done good shot Joe. Thanks. Okay here's your second type 9.
Thank you. Lovely good shot. So this is where it's all going to
change isn't it? Yeah this now hasn't been tested so.
But Joe you've never shot a type 16 or a 21b
plate? Nope never. Will? No never. Toby? No obviously not.
Don't know though there's a little wobble at the end. A bit of a waggle.
Which suggests to me broken head or very shallow.
Type 16 take two. I so want to know. Oh they're not bouncing out are they?
Last round these are the the lighter faster type 21s with the blades.
Did you catch that other one? I think the annoying thing about that shot is I
think we have to do another because it's so
close. This is the second lighter type 21 braised head.
Is that the broken one falling out? That is. They're not going as deep are they?
They're not. Both of them. I think I can see the head but even if I can't
it's not going deeply in. Okay because the first shot with the 21
kind of skipped in and may have glanced off of one of the other arrows
we're just going to shoot one more 21 just to be safe.
Did you hit the same one again? Good shooting but
we're gonna have to go again aren't we? Let's maybe we should
let's go and evaluate the record. Yeah let's go and have a look and see what's
going on. I just made it a lot worse. Unbelievable.
That's a bit of a mess isn't it's trying to work out what's going on. Oh wow yeah.
However our friend Joe here has just done
a Robin Hood. Hey look at that. Is that a head inside the socket of another?
Yes. Look there's all this empty space up here. The perfectly good test space.
Right anyway we'll celebrate that one afterwards. Goodness Joe
I knew you were good. So what have we got? That one.
Do we even know what was left of that? That was a 16. That's the one that fell out.
That's the one yeah that was that one. Yeah that's that one. Well we've got our
two heavy iron type 9 bodkins here. Penetrated
what looks like about. To the neck really isn't it? Yeah
about seven centimetres. We've got our type 16s here.
Penetrating maybe 30 millimetres inch and a quarter.
Then we have our 21b here which again is penetrated
20 millimetres 25 maybe around an inch. The other one we can't tell because of
Joe. Being too accurate. By putting another 21b straight down the
back of the first one and driving it in further but assuming
that it's much like that. Good shooting by the way Joe.
It really is a day for the type 9s. Yeah. They're significantly better against
this one and a half millimetre sheet than the lighter faster barbed and
bladed arrowheads. So what's the virtue
of the 16s and the 21s which. Well maybe it's an angle thing.
That's what I'm thinking if we go out on a limb for a second
the virtue in them might be that they bite better against curved shaped
surfaces. Well Toby you're in the right place at
the right time because this is all well and good
getting a good data table together and seeing what it does
so we can compare them. But we all want to see some real world results as well.
So we've got our chap there he's set up with our breastplate from Arrows versus
Armour 2 which is two and a half millimetres
thick in the middle. Joe you up for shooting three arrows at
that see how they bite. I mean I think we all know they're not
going to go through but how they interact with it
how they do bite how they engage that armour is going to be really interesting
so you up for it? I'm definitely up for it. It's going to
be interesting. Just above the stop rib I think but
first notable point didn't go through. Didn't go through. But it'll be nice to
see what that impact is like because all of the
energy of that arrow was expended into the target. Yep. Whereas
yeah it's expended in other things. It didn't blow up.
Didn't blow up. Also a good point. That's one shot as small a data set as we can
have so far but it does seem already to be
distinguishing itself from the type nines that we already are more familiar
with. It'd be interesting to see sort of a
glancing blow on the edge where it picks up at maybe 40-50 degrees
how it bites in then. Right Joe so you got another shot there.
Now we could do more but we're trying to preserve our arrows so
make this an interesting shot and then we'll give you some more otherwise we'll
call it a day. Make it count. Make it count.
Well that got him. It did get him. So I think we need some more arrows don't we?
Right well all right all right Joe keep going. Let's do the
next one. Yeah.
That made a hole. Yeah. And it didn't blow up. That made a hole.
And it didn't glance at all. At all. Again it was the same as before that all
of the energy went. Do it again. Do it again. Do it again.
So Joe right right here on the edge of the rest
plate please. I'll try.
Didn't blow up. It didn't. It was kind of like a non-event.
Yeah. What happened? Well let's go and have a look. Yeah. That is going to be
interesting. Well this is interesting isn't it
already? Well let's begin with the obvious one.
No great surprise here. Through the male. Through the arming doublet.
Well there we go. This one. That was the last shot.
Okay. Can I just say about this what's interesting for me
is it's collapsed the shaft. It hasn't snapped it like we saw a lot.
Yeah. On Arrows Vs Armour 2. This now matches the Westminster Aviaro perfectly.
Because the tip's broken off that one. In that way. And the tip is
embedded in there. In there. That bottom one there yeah. Yeah.
And then is there is there any material stuck in that one too? Is that part of
the head? And there's metal stuck right in there.
Yeah. So there's the head. Whether it would go through the Aventail I don't
know. But it was long enough and pointy enough that it went through the Aventail
and the padding and into the steel. Yeah. Whether it would
have actually passed through the Aventail is a different thing. And this
one. One of our previous Type 9 hits to the
same breastplate. There's this huge area of denting around
it. So that Type 9 is hitting and then it's
just pushing the metal in. And a lot of energy is going into
denting it. Yep. Because of the shape of the head. Not into piercing.
There's no there's hardly any denting around these at all.
They're everything's going into cutting into the steel. There's a bit of a tiny
bit of a dent. But nothing like that. And that was the
third shot we did. Yeah. Which is that head there. Which looks like it's brand
new. You could shoot that back. There is
there's not a chip. Not a mark. Not a scrape. Nope. It's hard steel. So it is
absolutely biting in a way that the old Iron Type 9s didn't.
So once you get a purchase you can then keep driving the energy that you've got
into. It's not being wasted that way is it? Yeah. However there is less energy
available than the Type 9s. Yep. Because they're lighter. It made a
hole. But not a significant injuring hole in any way at all.
But that breastplate is probably 2, 2.2 millimeters thick at that point.
It's the thickest part of the armor. So there's no great surprise.
Everything about this is really interesting and it's also
intriguing. So although this original helmet from Arrows Vs Armour 2
resisted our arrows well. It'll be interesting to see how our new helmet
resists. Because it's a different beast and these
are very different arrowheads. This is the thickest heaviest part of the
armor of any armor just about. You would never expect any arrow to get
through that. But you can't wear that on your whole body.
And I wonder whether this this capacity to really
bite is going to matter a lot more when one of these hits
anywhere else. Well Joe I mean what would your estimation be?
These arrows are now coming in maybe 25, 28 grams lighter than the Type 9s.
What kind of distance improvement is that going to give you? A huge amount.
You should you know these will be getting on near on 300 yards.
So that's a huge. So 50, 60 meters more maybe? Yeah I'd say so. You probably do.
You might do 240 with the other one. So yeah a good
60 yards on. That is a huge advantage for a projectile weapon.
I mean we have always said and I stand by it that longbows are predominantly
used at short range. But it doesn't mean that every
single day, every single encounter that's what you want. There will be moments when
you do want to harass a target at 300 meters
that previously you couldn't, today you can. So the thing is if you have an arrow
that doesn't go through that armor anyway, the
advantages of having a heavier arrow are gone.
So you may as well have a lighter arrow which still does the mail,
still does perhaps the light armor maybe,
will do fabric armor, but it also has a greater range on it.
I think the fact that I only shot four arrows at it and put a hole in it
whereas last time I shot tens of arrows at it
and didn't put any holes. That is very true actually because this has run
through the whole of the Arrows vs Armour 2
testing series of all of the assorted films and there is one
previous hole in it. So what I am thinking
is bring on the main film because when we get our
soldier from 1450, brigandine, arms, helmet, mail, this is going to be
absolutely fascinating. Yeah I think the fact that we're going to have seven
archers will make a huge difference as well.
So you know seven times the arrows. Seven times the arrows,
seven times the weird chance lucky shots, seven times the possibility of getting
through an isolate which is the holy grail of shooting
helmets isn't it. So this has been fantastically useful for us today
giving us insights in how these arrows are going to work when we do our main
film about this fellow here and like I said
shooting hardened type 16 arrowheads at our soldier here. But before we go I've
just got to thank, we've all got to thank the people who contributed to this
project. So thank you so much for allowing this
to happen and just watch out for the next film
because it is going to be fabulous. Bye.
