The Evoking Freedom Technique is one of the simplest and at the same time most effective influencing techniques that have been investigated by psychologists in studies so far. In most cases it is enough to add one of the following sentences to a request:
"..., but you are free to accept or to refuse." "..., but don't feel obliged." "..., feel free to say no."
The technique probably works so well because we usually react to other people's requests with reactance. That is, we initially have the impulse to say "no" because we don't want to be restricted in our freedom (e.g. freedom of what we do with our time or money). However, as soon as someone assures us that we are completely free to decide, our sense of freedom is restored (evoking freedom), reactance is reduced and compliance increases. It is also interesting that the effectiveness of this technique varies according to culture (individualistic and freedom-loving versus collectivistic)... __________________
Studien und Bücher (nur kleine Auswahl):
Burck, E. (2019). Das manipulierte Gehirn: Psychologie der unbewussten Beeinflussung. BoD–Books on Demand.
Burck, E. (2016). Neue Psychologie der Beeinflussung: Die Erforschung der Manipulation. BoD–Books on Demand.
Carpenter, C. J. (2013). A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of the “but you are free” compliance-gaining technique. Communication Studies, 64(1), 6-17.
Carpenter, C. J., & Pascual, A. (2016). Testing the reactance vs. the reciprocity of politeness explanations for the effectiveness of the “but you are free” compliance-gaining technique. Social influence, 11(2), 101-110.
Farley, S. D., Kelly, J., Singh, S., Thornton Jr, C., & Young, T. (2019). “Free to Say No”: Evoking freedom increased compliance in two field experiments. The Journal of social psychology, 159(4), 482-489.
Samson-Secrieru, L., & Carpenter, C. J. (2017). Examining mindlessness and friendliness in the evoking-freedom compliance-gaining technique. Communication Research Reports, 34(4), 368-375.
About the Author: Eskil Burck, a psychology graduate, is a psychological consultant and textbook author. He teaches psychology for Kalaidos University of Applied Sciences (Zurich). His psychology podcast "psychologie-lernen.de" consistently ranked #1 on iTunes in the "Education" category. His books "Angst - was hilft wirklich ...?", "Das manipulierte Gehirn" and "Neue Psychologie der Beeinflussung" became Amazon bestsellers. Even in his spare time, he enjoys reading studies...😅🙈 For more information, visit: www.psychologie-lernen.de
Before we start today's video, I only have one request for you,
which is, if you like the video, if you like psychology in general,
feel free to subscribe to the channel and feel free to give the video a thumbs up.
But of course, do not feel obliged, of course, feel free to do so if you want or not.
And at this point, I have influenced you with three different phrases.
Of course, now that I tell you that I influenced you, probably it doesn't work that well.
But the first technique was to say, I only have one request for you,
which proved to be very effective in a study by social psychologists from Poland,
in which they asked passers-by if they were willing to spend money for a children's hospice.
And in one condition, they finished their request with, this is my only request.
And in comparison to a control condition, this phrase, this is my only request,
raised compliance to spend some money more than three times.
So 55% were willing to spend the money in comparison to a control condition
in which only 16% were willing to spend the money.
But I did not only use the, this is my only request technique,
I much more used the so-called evoking freedom technique by saying,
feel free to subscribe, or by saying, do not feel obliged,
or by saying, of course, you are free to do so or not.
In this way, and this could be shown in many studies,
in this way, it seems like that you are able to counteract the reactants,
the other people experiences, if he or she gets told what she should do.
So it's something that is deeply rooted in ourselves,
that we don't like it if we are told what we should do.
It's like when your mother tells you, tidy up your room,
or your dad tells you, do your homework, or somebody tells you,
please subscribe, please give a thumbs up.
We don't want to be told what we have to do,
because we want our freedom, we want to decide for ourselves.
And of course, now that I told you that I tried to influence you in the beginning,
now your reactants might be even stronger,
because now you know that I tried to take away your freedom to decide on your own.
But usually, if this technique gets used,
the other person doesn't know that she is getting influenced,
and maybe you already used this technique on your own,
because maybe you already told somebody,
of course, you can decide for your own if you want to do that,
or maybe you told somebody, feel free to do so or not.
And science tells us that this probably improved your chances.
So take a look, for example, at a study that was conducted in the United States,
which is very important, because up to now,
almost all studies have been conducted by French scientists
and have been conducted in France.
And therefore, it's very important from a scientific point of view
that these results are replicated by other scientists and in other countries.
But also in this study, the technique worked very fine,
because in one experiment, for example, they asked students at the campus,
hello, sorry, my phone is dead, can I use yours?
And in the control condition, only 45% of the participants agreed to do so.
They were giving away their phone to a stranger.
But when they added the phrase, but feel free to say no,
so they said, hello, sorry, my phone is dead, can I use yours?
But feel free to say no.
In this condition, 95%, so almost all participants
were willing to give away their smartphone to the stranger,
which is remarkable, because at that time,
the criminal rates in Baltimore were quite high.
And to give your phone away to a stranger is always a little bit critical,
and maybe you would also hesitate to do so.
But as I said, this technique has been used in numerous studies.
Up to now, there have been studies with more than 18,000 participants,
and they used phrases like feel free to say no, do not feel obliged,
but you are free to accept or to refuse.
This actually is the original name of the technique,
which was later on when they found out that also other phrases work
was renamed into the evoking freedom technique.
After showing that the technique works,
of course, scientists try to figure out why it works.
So what is the working mechanism behind this evoking freedom technique?
The first one we already discussed.
It's about giving the other person their freedom back.
It's ensuring the other person that,
no, I don't want to pressurize you into a decision.
I even make it absolutely clear.
Feel free to say no, but you are free to accept or to refuse.
Do not feel obliged.
And in this way, the other person gets the feeling,
well, he is not pushing me into one direction.
I still can decide for my own, and therefore I will agree on his request.
Another explanation is about sympathy and empathy,
because if somebody tells you, but feel free to accept or to refuse,
or do not feel obliged,
he shows that he knows that you don't want to be pressurized,
and therefore he probably seems more empathic and sympathetic.
So which explanation is more plausible?
At the moment, most scientists favor the explanation
that the technique really counteracts reactance
and that it really creates this feeling of freedom for the other person.
And what speaks for that is that it could be shown
that in more collectivistic societies, like, for example, in China,
the technique does not work that well
in comparison to more individualistic societies,
like, for example, the United States or France.
And because of the fact that in these more individualistic societies,
it's more important for people to strive for freedom,
to be independent and not to be told what to do.
Because the technique works better in these societies,
it really makes sense that it's about evoking freedom.
What makes the technique work that well?
So that's it for today.
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
And if you want, we will see you next time.