Choosing the wrong material can have dire consequences. In this episode of our failure series, we discuss how the incorrect choice of epoxy led to a catastrophic failure and a tragic death. Discover the series of poor decisions that turned a new highway plan into one of the costliest public works projects ever. Join us as we uncover the lessons learned from this devastating event and the changes it inspired.
This Materialism Podcast is sponsored by Materials Today (https://www.materialstoday.com/) , an Elsevier community dedicated to the creation and sharing of materials science knowledge and experience through their peer-reviewed journals, academic conferences, educational webinars, and more
This episode of the Materialism Podcast is sponsored by Cal Nano (https://www.calnanocorp.com/) , leading experts in spark plasma sintering and cryomilling technologies. You can learn more about their work and services by visiting their website (https://www.calnanocorp.com/) .
Thanks to Kolobyte and Alphabot for letting us use their music in the show!
Materialism Team: Taylor Sparks , Andrew Falkowski and, Jared Duffy
Keywords: The Big dig Tunnel Failure Underground Highway Epoxy Creep Boston Massachusetts
I would like to describe a field in
which little has been done but in which
an enormous amount can be done this
field is not quite the same as the
others in that it will tell us little of
fundamental physics but it will tell us
much about the strange phenomena that
occurred just below our perception in
contrast to the Natural philosophers of
the past the scientists of this field
delve into the recesses of Nature and
show how she works in her hiding places
their Quest is to understand and create
the imperceptible after all there is
plenty of room at the
bottom hello and welcome to the
materialism podcast an exploration of
the past present and future of Material
Science and Engineering my name is
Taylor Sparks and I'm here at the
University of Utah and I am not joined
by my trusty co-host Andrew falowski
he's away in Maryland doing an awesome
internship this summer instead I'm here
with who else but Jared Jared how are
you man good but uh let's talk about the
elephant in the room you're now
Professor yeah man no longer associate
professor I joke myself sister her
chance her window for making ask
Professor jokes is now closed she had it
for 11 years and missed her window I'm
so pumped yeah I got 10 year back in
2019 you become an associate professor
and then five years later now promoted
so feels pretty great perfect well uh
we've got a very timely episode uh for
those who pay attention to sports the
Celtics just won and uh going yeah
there's going to be a lot of traffic a
lot of uh Kur fuffle going on in Boston
right now now we're going to talk about
the granddaddy of all Kuru I guess I
guess unless you go back to like the
Civil War era or the Revolutionary War
uh we're going to cover today another
entry in our series of episodes we've
done on engineering failures right if
you remember we did an episode on the
Titanic we did one on the campfire on
the deavin comet on the Challenger
shuttle and we have another one today on
The Big Dig so brace yourself for a
Taylor Jared special the only second
time ever doing this we're going to dive
into to The Big Dig okay Jared what is
the big dig so the big dig is
essentially this idea of getting rid of
the overground highways in Boston and
putting them underground and so what
happened is Boston when it was designed
it was not designed for cars obviously
it's a very old city for those who don't
know so they put this thing called the
central artery through Boston and it's
just it's a mess dude it was this
disgusting huge Highway and it was an
elevated uh six Lane highway I think
there was a joke somewhere I saw that
they called it uh the other green
monster in comparison to Fenway Park
which I thought was funny but uh it was
just ugly and people wanted to get rid
of it because when you got rid of it if
they went underground you'd free up more
land and also you could build a better
highway system that one of the big goals
was actually to connect I think where
the Waterfront was to where the airport
was to actually give more places to go
and this is back in the 80s so in other
words Boston was out musking musk before
he was even thinking about underground
freeways they were already thinking
about this and the whole process of
getting the money appropriated for it at
the time they thought this was going to
cost $2.8 billion which was an expensive
infrastructure project but they deemed
it was worth it and in the 80s they sort
of lined up the finances and they begin
the project in 1991 well it was and it
was really necessary there's a reason
they got that money they were saying
that I think by the '90s it was carrying
200,000 cars a day and they had
estimated that if they didn't fix it by
the 2010s it would be 16 hours of
traffic jam a day I mean Boston's
already I lived there right after the
big dig was done and it was still
traffic jam City so I can't even imagine
okay so I'm all for like big ambitious
projects that that make sense
financially um this one is actually you
know an example of what not to do in
hindsight when it comes to building
these big things um it took way long it
took 16 years um it was massive over
budget it ended remember they predicted
it was going to be 2.8 billion I think
and it ended at what almost 15 billion
I've seen some different numbers but I
think 15 billion is the safe number I
believe that is what uh Massachusetts
sites it has so we'll stick with that in
other words this was one of the most
expensive infrastructure projects in
history at the time they consider this
to be the most expensive Highway project
ever dwarfed by only one and that was
the creation of all interstate
highways so absolutely absolutely nuts
um so anyways we're not here to talk
about the policies and the you know the
boond dog of how long it took and the
mismanagement of that project
necessarily what we are here to talk
about is a materials engineering failure
so help me understand what went wrong
Jared so when they had actually begun
building The Big Dig they realized that
they needed to suspend the ceiling to
actually get a ventilation system in
there because it's underground and under
a river so you need a lot of air flowing
through it so like in your home you
might have had you might have seen like
a dropped ceiling before right that way
you can hide your like your pipes and
your air vents you don't see them cuz
you've got this dropped down ceiling but
in your home you probably use like that
you know one of those ceiling tiles made
of it's like cardboard basically it's
this super thin stuff that's not what
they used in this tunnel what did they
use so they used
concrete sections just entire sections
of concrete and um these were 100 mm
thick they were 3 and 1/2 M by 2 and 1/2
M basically and they were somewhere
between 5 to 6,000 pound yeah so it's
basically like a truck like these are
very heavy panels overhead and so they
went to this Consulting agency and they
had actually designed this system of
adhesive anchors to support these huge 5
6,000lb panels and so they' used epoxy
and steel framework to do this actually
yes so they take these screws now
remember you're working overhead you're
drilling up into the concrete and you're
going to try and hang this extremely
heavy concrete panel and there's lots of
options you could do a Threaded Screw
you could do a an expansion bolt you
could do a um you could do an undercut
or you could do an epoxy right those are
sort of your four options they decided
to go with an epoxy anchor so if you're
like a rock climber there's been like a
big move away from expansion bolts
towards epoxy anchors in the rock
climbing world so maybe you're thinking
that's a great idea actually because
these were hanging upside down best
practice really would have been undercut
they decided to go with epoxy it is
worth noting that the Consulting agency
they did say that they undercut was the
best thing where an undercut anchor for
those who don't know it's just a hole
that's drilled wider at the base deeper
than the concrete and then the anchor
expands up in there that's right and
then the hole smaller at the top so that
was their idea but the managers on the
project they actually didn't like that
idea and they said no we want you guys
to use adhesive okay so now I I think
you can already see the problem you've
got these extremely heavy concrete
panels hanging from the ceiling and
they're basically glued in place yeah
and it's funny because we're going to
get to obviously a big failure but the
failure started early on when they had
first started opening portions of the
tunnel in the late 9s they had already
found that there was part sagging
because uh even though they were
designed to support like really heavy
loads it just wasn't working but they
couldn't figure out exactly what was the
issue so they just replaced the anchors
and try there were so many other
problems right there was they were
actually using this concrete this ready
mixed concrete for there was imagine
there's a lot of concrete they used here
and it was really subpar and actually a
company that was manufacturing ended up
getting indicted for fraudulent
practices there was actually there's a
there's there's since been many
investigations on this and they found
3,000 tunnel leaks that had to be
repaired um there's problems with I
you're digging a tunnel under an active
city right and there's water and there's
just this was an incredibly difficult
project um and they weren't monitoring
it very well uh I think even when they
figured issues out they just kind of
fixed it and let it be instead of you
know actively monitoring anything moving
or issues like that so there were a
number of warning designs that were
found before anything awful happened
here was one it said the ceiling panel
designer warned and this is back in 1997
right the project member finished in
about 2007 so this is way before it's
done the panel designer warned that this
epoxy might not be strong enough and
that it could fail due to the heat
coming from a fire if there was a fire
there um and then in 1999 the contractor
wrote the construction manager that five
ceiling bolts in the high occupancy
vehicle Lane right the um what do you
call that the car right they had pulled
out up to 50 millim in only two months
after installation and had passed a
pullout test so that is crazy that only
two months in you're already losing
bolts uh they also found that when they
were drilling the hole into the concrete
to then place the bolt in it and epoxy
in place they were using a diamond
coring bit we've talked about Diamond
check out our previous episode on
diamond cutting tools I um but since
diamond is such a great cutting tool it
cut a very smooth smooth shaft and
because it was really smooth anybody
who's tried to glue things you typically
rough it up first right if you pat your
bike there's a reason you scuffed that
tube because you want it to stick better
this is leaving it super smooth and the
other problem is that they said that it
left a residue that wasn't cleaned for a
week after which time it was difficult
to remove and it resulted in 20% less
Bond so there's already sort of problems
coming up um good thing is that there
was some testing going on they did test
these bolts up to 125% of the design
load so if it was supposed to just hold
you know 5,000 lb they're loading up to
6,000 or whatever um and then after they
found a few bolts pull out it says that
the construction manager required that
the load during this testing be
increased to twice the design load so
now they're pulling it at Double what
what you'd expect which is good but
still where does that 2x come from if
you've taken my in Material Science
class you know that safety factors of
two that's not the way to go we should
be thinking in terms of probabilistic
failure what's the probability of
failure anyways so they had to do that
and after they did that the contractor
stated that since nearly all the ceiling
panels had been installed it was now
going to cost
$600,000 to remove or brace the panels
to test these bolts and since they
didn't want to test them all they did
what was a pretty big mistake they only
tested the bolts in the HOV lane and
their rationale was this they said if no
bolt fails here under these higher loads
then the other lanes would probably not
require testing so they made an
assumption that all lanes were sort of
not equal but rather that the HOV lane
was the most severe and so they only
needed needed to test it but what they
found is that over the next 8 months
only 8 months 187 bolts that were tested
had 19 pull out and then so it says but
since 17 we're in the so-called mockup
area where the workers were being
trained on how to do bolt installation
they just chocked it up to the fact that
these guys were inexperience with the
epoxy and that they would learn as they
were going and that the problem probably
no longer existed um pretty awful so
what did this all lead to Jared so it's
worth noting that when they did this
they were opening it in sections and one
of the sections they opened was called
the Fort Point Channel tunnel which
connected to the big Ted Williams Tunnel
and someone was driving there July 10th
2006 and a section measuring 20 by 40
just fell now very incredibly luckily
only one person was killed and one
person was injured a 38-year-old Melena
delal I believe her name is and her
husband they were in the car and it fell
on them and she passed away and he was
just injured uh it's very lucky when you
consider the size of the debris that
nothing else really happened but it it
launched a huge investigation into it
yeah so you said it was a really large
area that fell the way that these panels
they were big rectangles basically so
obviously at the corners is where they
came together and so at these
intersecting connection points this is
from the Wiki page talking about it
where several of these individual bolts
were all anchored to the roof slab uh
concrete there was the failure of a
group of of them and now you've lost
several bolts all at once so that caused
a chain reaction which caused several
other adjacent connection Corners to
fail and in short that's why you ended
up losing 26 short T So 52,000 pounds of
concrete ultimately falls down in the
road below so absolutely horrific that
this happened and that somebody died but
you can imagine after the fact people
there's this demand what happened what
went wrong this was a you know we took a
long time to build this it was extremely
expensive and we still had this
catastrophic failure so so so obviously
they want to know what's wrong and they
start demanding answers yeah so
immediately after a local Utah boy Mitt
Romney yeah he was governor at the time
out there he just ordered a like a full
audit by a engineering firm and they
went through it and then of course also
the national transport safety board
looked into it I think a few other
people all looked into it for different
reasons because this was a big concern
because while they had closed this
tunnel off obviously there was still a
lot of other things they had built so I
think there was just concern about the
entire project as a whole being safe
yeah in the aftermath they found that
there was
242 potentially dangerous bolt fixtures
that were still supporting tiles this is
after the collapse so in other words had
they not done anything there's a good
chance that this would have happened
anyways when the national transport
safety board had finally concluded they
had decided that the root cause was the
epoxy yeah so the company that made it
this was Powers Fasteners Incorporated
they were charged with involuntary
Slaughter they ended up paying $16
million to dismiss the charges and also
paid 6 million to the family of the the
lady who was killed absolutely horrific
and then this one statistic I think was
really interesting the total amount of
the cost of the epoxy used on this D
Street portal that epoxy from a buying
it as a supplier was only 1,200 bucks
basically and yet it led to the redesign
inspection and repair of all these
tunnels and that was over $54 million
all in choosing the wrong material yeah
the the company that actually made the
uh epoxy I think later had to up all of
the safety factors like we talked about
just because it wasn't enough absolutely
so we're going to get into what went
wrong but before we do that we got to
talk about epoxy I don't think we've
done an episode on epoxy Jared so let's
do the basics of epoxy really quick and
you know it's one of these things where
there's a lot of oam there's a lot of
reactions so it's there's some visuals I
wish I could show you but we'll just
talk through the big picture stuff for a
moment um first off what are epoxies if
you haven't used them before you
probably have and you just didn't even
realize it if you've ever taken an an
adhesive where it came in two tubes and
you had to mix them together either you
squo it and they mixed automatically in
the tip or you had to you know paint you
to sort of mix it with a Q-tip or
something that was an epoxy probably
most people probably used the JB Weld
that clear yeah so all epoxies have some
things in common they all have a
molecule and there's different types of
molecules but at the end of that
molecule is the epoxide group so an
epoxide group what is that it's a little
triangle right it's two carbons bonded
to an oxygen in a triangular shape now
obviously you have to do the electron
counting you realize that it's not just
carbons and oxygen because you have to
make things count up you'll realize
quickly that the carbons each have two
other bonds right so on one carbon is
going to have two hydrogen the other
one's going to have one hydrogen and
then it's bonded to some functional
group and that functional group has a
huge amount of variety um there's loads
of different epoxies out there but they
all have this sort of triangular carbon
carbon o Little Triangle sticking off
the end and that's going to be important
because that epoxide group is what we're
going to uh use to make a Theros set
polymer so remember if you've taken an
intro to MC course thermoplastics are
the ones that you heat them up and they
melt so like your GI Jo's right you heat
those up hopefully you're
not but uh thermosets don't do that
these things form strong bonds all the
way through they are three-dimensionally
bonded there's not just like bander
Wall's bonds holding them together that
you can melt easily these things form
strong bonds um so that we call them
thermos sets okay now I said that the
functional group off the side that
there's lots of different ones so there
are bisphenol a epoxy resins there's cyc
aliphatic epoxy resins trifunctional on
and on and on there's so many different
types of epoxies um and they all kind of
have their different pros and cons that
that side group on the side can be
really big it can be hundreds of atoms
or thousands right and so now you have
this idea that you can tune the
molecular weight so if you want a an
epoxy that's really thin like water so
has really good flowable characteristics
you might choose a low molecular weight
you want one that has a really high
molecular weight right then that might
make it more like a viscous liquid or
even a solid um there's some that have
double bonds which can be broken later
on and cause problems with stability and
there's some that are fully saturated
like only single bonds so that's like
your cyc aliphatic because there's no
double bonds that can be broken these
ones tend to have really good UV
stability they weather really well they
have good thermal properties um there's
these so-called triun fun or Tetra
functional epoxies which is basically
saying like how many different
directions do they have to connect three
or four or what um what makes it fastet
that would be a good thing to mention
yeah so let's talk about curing there's
lots of different bases right including
by the way biological polymers which is
really cool you can actually stick these
epoxies on the end of like fatty groups
um you can put them on the ends of uh
let's see glycerol and fatty acids to
make biodegradable epoxies if you want
them to break down over time but you're
asking about whether or not they set
right so and how they set is it a fast
set or a slow set does it require
temperature or not yeah so the the big
reason that's important is when they had
designed this uh for some reason they'
chosen a fast set epoxy by power
Fasteners which is not the typical
choice for doing this obviously because
you know as we all know materials when
you gain a property you tend to have to
compromise somewhere else yeah so if so
we started with our base monomer of
epoxy if you want to turn that into a
three-dimensional strong mechanically
rigid structure you have to start
bonding these little monomers together
if you've seen the basics of like a
chain you know reaction polymerization
this is going to look like one of those
except that what we have to do is we
have to take that little triangle of
carbon carbon oxygen we have to split it
open so now it's going to create a free
radical in the end of it that can go and
attack another epoxy ring and split it
open so what do you do to split that
open right um that's the curing process
and there's a bunch of different ways to
do that the most common way to do it or
the the most basic way is with an amine
group an amine is just a nitrogen bonded
to two hydrogens so you got your little
carbon carbon oxygen ring on one sand
now if that gets in proximity of this
nh2 group what's going to happen is you
have due to what's called nucleophilic
addition right basically the nitrogen
wants to bond with one of those carbons
but they each have one Bond too many as
it is so what they do is they each kick
off a hydrogen right or well the
nitrogen kicks off a hydrogen the amine
group but the carbon kicks off the
oxygen so now the hydrogen and oxygen
they got kicked off are bummed but they
find one another and so they form this
hydroxide group and then you are able to
form the bond now that kicks off a free
radical another end which can just keep
this reaction going so that is amine
curing and that happens sort of as a
catalyst it's very easy for that to
happen but it's not something that you
can control like once you put those two
things together they're going to react
which is why if you've ever worked with
JB Weld or whatever else you have a
window of time before you can like get
that done because it's going to set up
as soon as you mix the the amine with
the well it's probably an amine or
something with an amine group on it with
your whatever your base epoxy is you
have a limited amount of time survey
Against Time yeah so there's other ways
to go about it right you don't have to
use an amine you can do alkal groups
that will cure it there's anhydride
curing agents where you basically
provide a catalyst and then it goes
forward there's catalytic curing agents
and these have different pros and cons
one of the big advantages though is uh
longer pot life so if you're selling
this you know epoxy and it's going to
sit on the shelf for 2 3 years you need
to make sure that 2 years later when
somebody buys it that it's not going to
be completely you know solid and then
there's this question about time which
you asked um one of the big things that
you'd like is obviously you want it to
cure uniformly all the way through and
as quickly as possible if you could help
it um if you just take an amine group
and you put those two things together
they're pretty fast so for example if
you take like one of the most basic
epoxy resins um dgeba that stands for d
glycal ethery fenyl a it's one of the
classic epoxies and you expose this to
UV light they find that it is 90% cured
so all the bonds that are going to be
made you've got 90% of them made in
about 40 seconds so that is pretty
fantastic to be able to very quickly
create these bonds um and it doesn't
have to be UV light it can also be
temperature if you heat the thing up
that could be enough to get the to
catalyze those reactions going
forward um but this is a choice that you
have in in which epoxy you use whether
you choose a room temperature setting
slow one which is going to set very
slowly or a fast set which is tends to
be more controllable um but the the
ultimate properties of the final epoxy
will be different as
well yeah so this difference in
properties is actually what really
caused this whole issue so the fast set
epoxy that they were using was more
susceptible to creep and really not good
for this application but before we get
into that background let's actually talk
about what creep is yeah I know we've
covered it before in the show but just a
reminder creep is time dependent plastic
deformation yeah in other words if you
pull on something with a load it might
strench or bend or compress or whatever
right immediately or maybe that
deformation is going to happen really
slowly and we just call that creep right
yeah so we already read for example when
they tested after just two months they
found that uh a bunch of these bolts had
stretched out they pulled out 50
millimeters right so they had been
creeping already yeah so what obviously
that's only two months you can imagine
over a long periods of time it could
creep to the point where it just comes
out and fails entirely so there is a
difference on whether do a fast set
epoxy or a slow set epoxy and they knew
this right they they knew that fast set
epoxies where you UV light curate or
something like that they should only be
used in cases where it's not going to be
applied for long terms because then you
don't have a lot of time for creep to
accumulate a lot of overall strain and
so there's cases you know if there's
wind or earthquake loading stuff like
that where you'd use it but for a tunnel
that's just not what you should have
done especially for this this is such a
huge sustained load yeah and they knew
that so test had already gone back to
1995 and six that showed that the faster
setting epoxy did not meet the criteria
for creep like the normal setting one
that did and I've got the the data here
showing the creep compliance so think of
this is like the modulus it's it's
related to the modulus right it's
showing you how much it's resisting
deoration as a function of time and by
the time that you're out 25 years the
fast set epoxy is creeping at 10 times
the rate it is dramatically faster close
which is and it's interesting that that
all this data is there because
when I was reading through there's
actually a very good PowerPoint by NASA
covering this and they even mentioned
that uh from their stuff at least the
installation team claimed to be unaware
of these properties which is interesting
when you also look in and you see they
have all this data available and I get
it like there's a lot of different
people lot moving Parts like maybe
there's it was a problem about
communication but whatever the problem
it led to this collapse and so obviously
after the fact they're checking things
and they found you know they actually
found this before the clops in 1999 they
were actually pulling out bolts and real
realizing that big sections of the bolt
were bare they weren't covered with the
epoxy everywhere and that makes sense
right you're doing this overhead who's
ever done like dry wall over your head
it sucks it's not fun this is kind of
like that you're hanging things above
your head and they're hoping that they
can squirt the epoxy in there and I get
why a fast setting would be appealing so
it's not going to be leaking out on you
or anything um but the problem is that
there was significant fraction of the
epoxy that just wasn't in the hole they
they found that you know a bunch of
these holes and as they did the study
they that that because there existed
holes in the epoxy it led to a reduction
in the pullout capacity of about 38%
which makes sense why they were so much
weaker you didn't have the epoxy there
the epoxy that was there was more prone
to creep and so this was really just not
the right way to do it um they did when
they investigated the anchors themselves
they found the following that said you
know the use of adhesive anchors was
really subpar to other anchor types like
undercut for example they used the wrong
epoxy they Ed the fast Setter instead of
the
slow um they did the diamond coring
which left a really smooth surface and
they didn't clean it right away and
because they didn't clean it right away
they didn't get that residue off and so
they didn't have a chance to properly
clean it to get it to stick well because
you've got this dust in there which
prevents good adhesion yeah it was
delayed for up to a week which made it
difficult to remove that res that
residue and that there was insufficient
amount of epoxy which led to voids in
the bolts and lower performance and
obviously that they weren't inspecting
it like they needed to so the national
Transportation safety board in their
study after the accident concluded these
four points they said overhead
installation of these adhesive anchors
is very likely to introduce voids right
they said that design and construction
engineers and Builders they have to know
the complexities of epoxies and Polymer
Products this is why civil engineers
mechanical engineers I know you guys
hate Material Science as a course but it
is so important to understand the
differences
different ways of curing a polymer for
example thermoset polymer can give you
totally different properties they found
that product Testing Laboratories should
better assess long-term safety factors
of anchors turns out that safety factor
of two was not sufficient that was not a
way of being probabilistic in
understanding the failure rates and
finally that national standards were
needed to come up with basically when
you do tunnel finishes including
suspended ceilings we need policy that
that dictates that yeah and really just
boils down to obviously a a a genuine I
think communication issue when we look
through a lot of things because it's
very clear that there was a lot of
issues I mean they talk about that
documentation provided by the supplier
wasn't clear about the differences the
contractors really never questioned it
the design people never questioned it
there was an independent verification
there was a whole bunch of issues but
this is just why it's really important
to have that interdisciplinary stuff you
know you need mechanical engineers you
need civil engineers you need materials
they all need to be working together on
a project you can't do a project with
just one type of engineer it's just not
going to work yeah and I think it's kind
of exciting too because it points to I
it's it's tragic when something like
this happens but it prompts additional
research it led people to say like man
creep and epoxy is an issue and how can
we fix it and there's you know since
that accident there's been a bunch of
cool papers for example I'm looking at
one where they're actually introducing
um carbon nanop particles and graphine
as a way to adhere to it and they find
that you know normally when you add
secondary phases in thermoplastics you
get this dramatic Improvement in
properties the strength and the
ductility can simultaneously be
increased because when you add the
additional filler material it actually
modifies the Matrix so normally think of
a typical composite your your filler and
your Matrix have the properties they
have and they don't really change it's
just that you're leveraging the best of
both worlds and how they're distributed
but in thermoplastics adding this filler
changes the Matrix properties in a Ben
icial way unfortunately it hasn't been
shown to have as big of a benefit in
Theros sets which is like our epoxies um
but they have shown that when you change
the cross-linking density perhaps by
being Modified by nanofillers then you
can change the macroscopic properties so
in this paper they add graphine and they
show that they can actually see
significant creep rate reduction in
these Nano composits as they tune the
amount and the dispersion of those
graphine particles and that's always one
of the challenges is if you add graphine
it has to actually be distributed nicely
it can't just cluster together or
doesn't do what you think it's doing so
there's ways of doing it there's
ultrasonic mixing there's High Shear
rate mixing there there's things that
sort of work but it's been it's been
nice to see that in the the the wake of
this devastating accident that smart
engineering minds are trying to address
that with new and Advanced
Materials yeah and and obviously even
the company that sold the epoxy was
prompted to improve their formulations
and make it safer and do other things so
it's not you know and and I got to say
when when it was all said and done it's
very it's a very sad tragedy but the um
big dig tunnel actually did succeed yeah
I mean I moved there in 2009 and this
was a few years just two years after the
big dig was completed and we used that
all the time it was a fantastic way to
get to the airport congestion was way
lower I'm told in the city so I
appreciate it being there um and it also
is pretty iconic for example like that
Leonard zakim Bunker Hill Memorial
Bridge if You' been to Boston you've
seen it that giant white one with the
suspension cables it is a beautiful
iconic Bridge so it's nice that they've
done it um from a from a a use
standpoint yeah it it opened up almost
300 acres of open land I don't know what
all these different from the old uh
Highway that cut through the from
destroying that old um Highway the
expressway is what it's called and also
I think they had said that the big thing
it did was it also removed all of the
truck traffic from downtown Boston
because they didn't have to use that
anymore there was no to noise and
everything
yeah yeah it was um certainly we can
learn from this mistake and do similar
projects that will make life better but
in a safe way yeah and it's a good
example of I think the idea of Going
Underground and kind of supports how you
can really free up more land by doing
that good examples trains or other
things like that but yeah right it has
to be done in a way that's safe and
smart or else you also suffered the
downsides like we had here because cost
overrun a lot of it was probably with
just how poorly planned it was yeah well
we hope you enjoyed this episode we
really enjoyed learning about ourselves
doing some reading and getting ready for
it um and we hope you're having a
wonderful summer we wanted to do a quick
shout out to our sponsors they are the
ones who make the show possible we are
very grateful so Props to materials
today you know that we've been sponsored
by them for quite a while we hope that
you'll check out materials today.com you
can stay up to date on all the things
happening Material Science uh they
obviously OB have some great articles
we've got a few that we drew from this
this week that were from the ele catalog
um so we we're going to put those in the
show notes you can take a look at them
but we think that they're a great
partner and we appreciate what they do
to make the show possible our other
sponsor is C Nano uh if you've listened
to the podcast you've heard us talk
about Cano before yes they can do some
crazy spark plasma centering on scales
that you probably don't think is
possible billing yeah they do everything
and they're they've been a really big
supporter and we really love working
with them so thanks to them as well you
can check them out at calanoc corp.com
and obviously we are also grateful to
the people that made the music for this
show that is alphabot and kabit so
special thanks to them and we are always
looking for suggestions for episodes and
reviews so materialism. podcast
gmail.com shoot us an email talk and we
you can interact with us on social media
we're on Instagram we're on Twitter X
yeah to find LinkedIn we would love to
connect give us your ideas for episodes
hey we will see you guys next time
thanks for listening The Adventures of
fire electricity
magnetism iron lead glass silk cotton
the makers of tools the captors of
lightning the architect the engineer the
musician are all beneficiaries of the
materials of this world and are bound
only by their imaginations in
manipulating those materials