The ability to avoid detection is one of the most useful tricks of modern day combat aviation. In this episode we dive into some of the history of various stealth endeavors ranging from painting ships with fun stripes to creating radioactive fuel additives. All culminating in a discussion of the materials that make a plane stealthy.
This episode is sponsored by Materials Today (https://www.materialstoday.com/) , an Elsevier community dedicated to the creation and sharing of materials science knowledge and experience through their peer-reviewed journals, academic conferences, educational webinars, and more.
Thanks to Kolobyte and Alphabot for letting us use their music in the show!
Materialism Team: Taylor Sparks (co-creator,editing assistance), Andrew Falkowski (co-host, co-creator), Jared Duffy (co-host, production, marketing, and editing).
I would like to describe a field in
which little has been done but in which
an enormous amount can be done this
field is not quite the same as the
others in that it will tell us little of
fundamental physics but it will tell us
much about the strange phenomena that
occurred just below our perception in
contrast to the Natural philosophers of
the past the scientists of this field
delve into the recesses of Nature and
show how she works in her hiding places
their Quest is to understand and create
the imperceptible after all there is
plenty of room at the
[Music]
bottom hello and welcome to the
materialism podcast an exploration of
the past present and future of Material
Science and Engineering my name is
Andrew falowski and I am not joined by
Taylor Sparks instead I am joined by
Jared Duffy Jared how are you oh you
know I'm good uh Christmas is over now
so it's less fun you know I'm just kind
of right back to work and back to the
sludge of life no holidays for a while
yeah I feel you I I started my PhD this
semester and I I've reached a level of
busy that I never thought was possible
but uh that's how life goes I am
learning a lot so it is fun in that
respect oh that's good obviously I I
like my job a lot so there's benefits
but there's something about you know
when you're busy five days a week and
you just get those two off you think man
I miss Christmas break yeah no it's nice
sometimes I think about the number of
holidays that medieval peasants had and
um I'm a little jealous oh yeah if only
we could have that many huh yeah maybe
one day but um we were talking uh during
christas break you were doing a little
bit of reading and you had an
interesting idea for an
episode yeah so the thing that really
kicked this episode off for me was I
received a book for Christmas called
skunkworks by Ben Rich so for those who
don't know skunkworks is the informal
name given to Lockheed Martin's Advanced
development program Ben Richard was the
second director of Skunk Works from 1975
to 1991 and he was following up Kelly
Johnson and I'm sure a lot of you people
out there who listen to this who rant
Aviation you're going to know who Kelly
Johnson is Kelly Johnson is probably
arguably like one of the most important
uh Aviation Engineers aeronautical
Engineers of all time uh I would say
he's probably most known for Designing
the SR71 Blackbird and kind of overseen
that entire program but he made the P38
Lightning U2 spy plane he was over a
bunch of planes during his time at locki
so how does Ben Rich follow up this
impressive Legacy well he oversees the
Advent of stealth technology as we know
it today and it's a very interesting
story kind of talking about the
different things that go into stealth
but of course the thing that captured my
interest also was the materials that go
into it and so I pitched this to Andrew
and he was game to do it and so we
started researching and I got to admit
we didn't know just how complicated this
was going to get but I think we sorted
through it really well and I think we
have a great episode for you guys and
I'm really excited for you to hear
it yeah definitely it was sort of one of
these rabbit holes where the complex
ities of it just kind of continued to
unravel as we learned more and it it
wasn't so much an episode where it was
okay you know where can we dive deeper
where can we learn a little bit more and
make this more interesting it was okay
where do we need to stop um we've maybe
gone a little bit too deep and we're
starting to lose our audience and our
own sanity and so I think we did
actually a good job of finding the right
balance here but when Jared was
initially talking to me about this and
tell me some of the stories and the
antidotes of what inspired you know the
development of these stealth
Technologies and you know examples of
how effective they were it really
brought back the story of um when I was
in Boy Scouts we played this game called
army tag and the idea was that you had
an attacking team and a defending team
and the defending team was defending
something like a bench for instance or
maybe it was like the deck of like a um
an Eddie rondak or something and the
goal of the attacking team is to
basically touch that or to get on the
bench or something like that right and
so what we do is we do this at night so
it was you know pitch dark we'd be
camping right so there's there's no
light pollution and the Defenders would
have flashlights and the attacker goal
was to you know they'd start on the
opposite end of a field or some sort of
forested area and they'd move through
and try to get it and I remember when I
first started I was you know I was
pretty naive I was like okay if I'm just
the fast enough if I just run right at
it um you know I'm going to be able to
sneak around them I'm going to be able
to get to that and I quickly realized
that that's not the way to go because
with those flashlights they would always
just see me coming from while you know
see be coming from a long way away and
then they'd be able to just you know be
ready for me yeah exactly like it didn't
matter how fast I was because they could
prepare for me in advance of course and
so as I got older I started realizing
you know you have to sneak you want to
get as close as you can without being
detected because your chances go up of
being successful and I think a lot of
these examples you telling me are a lot
like that and that's generally the
strategy we go for yeah I mean a great
example of what you're talking about uh
it's mentioned about the raid on Saddam
Hussein's nuclear research facility so
the first time they attempted this they
used conventional Brute Force methods 72
aircraft in total went after it 14 of
those were just fighter planes and all
of the compliments you would need to
give it the best chance of succeeding
and when it was over they did not score
one successful hit on the entire
facility so what they did was they took
our stealth plane at the time which was
called the F-117 Nighthawk and they sent
eight of those in with two tankers just
to refuel and that was it and using
stealth planes which like you said you
know you get a lot closer to your target
before you get seen Maybe visually in
another way they were actually able to
destroy three of those four reactors and
the fourth one they damaged very heavily
they said that actually in the entire
time that they flew these during Desert
Storm they flew 1271 missions Which is
less than about 1% but that aircraft
accounted for 40% of all damage Targets
in fact the Secretary of Defense under
President Clinton referred to them as
the enablers because they could go in
and take out these defenses and then
you'd send in the actual aircraft that
maybe you know had a little more
Firepower but could be detected easily
yeah and it really is a number of key
technological advancements that allowed
this to happen right like it's both the
shape the really unique shape of these
aircraft but also the Coatings the
materials of these aircraft as well um
but before we get into what those are
and why they're so important as well as
the complexities of these materials we
should probably start at the beginning
and look at how stealth has evolved over
time yeah so I mean like you said you
know for you you were worried about
being spotted and so the first thing
that we had back in World War I when
airplanes and other things started going
for that more stealth look was visual
inspection and to this day visual
inspection is incredibly important which
is why we paint planes that are military
based usually these dark Grays and
blacks CU that way against a night sky
or a darker Sky you won't see the
aircraft I think that was something that
really helped the Nighthawk was that it
was full black underneath so you
couldn't see
anything but this doesn't just apply to
ples
so in World War I they had taken boats
and they had covered them in these zebra
prints basically going all around
different directions and blocked out so
it wasn't just one long zebra stripe and
the idea was is that now when you're
looking at the boat you can't tell
entirely which direction it's going
which makes your cannon fire and your
torpedo fire much more difficult because
you don't have an exact heading right
this was before any sort of guidance so
you're basically trying to like compute
maybe the trajectory and hope that it up
and that's sort of not necessarily like
that's more or less disguising your
movement not necessarily disguising the
thing itself yeah um which you know at
the time if if visual inspection is the
method and with a you know a ship that's
so large you know that might be the the
method you have to use because you're
not going to hide that yeah I think that
you know they call this Dazzle
camouflage and I think it's probably
because it really overloads your senses
with so many things that you have to
sort of discern what's happening yeah I
mean the you should look it up the
Dazzle camouflage it looks like a herd
of zebras in fact um other words for
groups of zebras are are called dazzles
or um or Zeals which is kind of
interesting maybe a little more poetic
yeah I mean it definitely does look like
that it's a great example yeah will
definitely post a a photo of this but
going back to aircraft and really the
heart of stealth is the idea of being
invisible now how do you make an
aircraft invisible the Germans thought
they had a way in World War I and so
they said okay here's our plane and a
plane back then you know it's got Fab
fac and the fabric goes over between
these ribs they said what if we take out
the fabric and we use cellulose acetate
it's somewhat similar to film it kind
looks like San wrap to me a little bit
in some of the photos but uh basically
they stretch this over and they get the
aircraft in the air and from a few
hundred feet up where it sits down below
you can barely see it and they think
they got a hit on their hands they did
not take two things into account the
first thing is that underneath hard to
see from the top when the sun's glinting
down on it it lights up like a Christmas
Tre so if you're in a fighter suddenly
your target is very clear and now here
you are in your German plane trying to
dodge so as your wings heat up silos
warps hard and so suddenly now your
plane's unstable and okay you get hit
you're going down for a crash what's the
other thing about sayos incredibly
flammable so the second your plane hits
the ground just a fireball so they
backed away from that idea yeah and I
think this highlights this interesting
Dynamic um especially with the materials
for this application is you know you
could maybe find the best stealth
material the most transparent invisible
material but you still have to work with
the the rest of the aircraft like you
can't compromise those performance
metrics either and so there's a
trade-off here yeah all materials and
things in life have a trade-off and I
think this is such a great example of
one of them and so you showed that okay
for optical inspection you know we can
paint it colors that's kind of probably
the best we can do um and operating at
night you know a black aircraft probably
is hard to detect but we came up with
with other ways of seeing things beyond
our eyes yeah so the next one we'll talk
about is IR and so IR is very effective
on aircraft because especially in jet
aircraft they have exhaust plumes that
are incredibly noticeable in really high
temperature compared to the air so how
do you disguise exhaust plumes there's
three different ways you can go about it
the most interesting one to me is
actually putting fuel additives uh
there's a very interesting one mentioned
in the book that I read and it's
referred to as
pantheris it's a bit of a crude term but
essentially what it would do is ionize
the exhaust plume in a blackbird
aircraft and it would cause the enemy
infrared detector to sort of break up
incoherently and not work and this
actually makes it really effective for
keeping the aircraft stealthy another
one which they use in the f-17 Nighthawk
mentioned earlier was just picking a
smaller engine because if your engines
aren't supersonic they don't give off as
much Heat usually because they can you
can make a more efficient
engine and then finally you put the
engine on top of it so you can't see it
from underneath and you put some sort of
plates to help dissipate the
heat okay so that's thermal detection
that makes a lot of sense there seems to
be some ways we can kind of Disguise
that probably an ongoing problem but
there's one we're missing one of the big
ones and the main topic of this episode
and that's radar or using um
electromagnetic waves kind of in that
microwave Spectrum to send um a signal
and then have it bounce back and receive
that and that can tell you a lot of
information um and the origin story of
it are quite interesting it seems a bit
confused a little bit muddied Yeah so
everyone agrees on where the initial
idea came from it came from Hinrich Herz
you know he's got a a whole unit named
after him so you know he did some
important science what he did was he
basically sought out to prove something
that James Maxwell had said who's a
Scottish physicist he had said that both
light and radio waves are waves that are
governed by the same kinds of laws and
so that if light reflects theoretically
radio waves should reflect and they set
out to do that and he actually proved it
turns out radio waves can be reflected
from metallic objects and this sort of
creates the ground for radar but its
actual prominence as we know it doesn't
come up till the 30s and that is where
it gets muddy essentially every major
player in World War II came up with
radar independently of each other
there's some claims that Britain did
provide some of its information to uh
Allied Nations to help them build theirs
but it kind of sounds like a lot of them
sort of created their own which is why a
lot of them actually operate at
different frequency levels too but the
British one which is probably the most
well-known one because they had theirs
done by 1938 and fully ready to go was
created by Robert watt who again he's
got a whole unit named after him so you
know he knows his stuff but the reason
that they built there so quickly is they
weren't really worried about how precise
the technology was because they were so
terrified of German Air Raids they
wanted something up immediately that
could just do a crude job because some
information was better than nothing
radar at its most basic form is
essentially sending out an
electromagnetic wave it travels until
either it dissipates or it hits
something and if it hits something it
boun bounces back and you get some
information which is essentially just
what got bounc back in the time lapse
and so what got bounce back gives you a
general idea of the size which we're
going to from now on refer to as the RCs
which means the radar cross section and
you're thinking radar crosssection is
going to be the size of the aircraft
it's not RCS is kind of complicated and
it is not a perfect reflection of the
size of an aircraft so really the best
way to understand is it's just what the
radar sees as the size of the aircraft
you know something I I noticed when I
was doing reading for this is that the
the band the range of what qualifies as
a radar is is quite large is there a
difference between like maybe the like
higher or lower frequency versions yeah
so uh radar goes basically from 50 MHz
all up to 12 gigahertz and essentially
these lower ones are all about long
range surveillance so over the horizon
you're seeing what you can see but as
you get more power you're actually
getting closer and closer so essentially
the highest ones are usually used for
short range tracking like checking on
missiles and stuff because these these
higher frequencies allow for a lot
higher Fidelity and so it's better for
close range stuff and giving as much
info as humanly possible yeah I mean
also with these higher frequency
electromagnetic waves you'll actually
get a lot more atmospheric scattering
compared to the longer wavelength mhm I
think that um a lot of the highest ones
are used for Airborne intercept when it
comes to Knocking missiles out of the
sky because you need such high fidelity
for that stuff yeah it's like a question
of precision yeah so radar gets a little
better obviously as time goes on because
we start moving away from having these
mechanical dishes that move to a phased
array which is essentially multiple Ms
and they form like a search light that
you can actually aim and it leads to
faster and more accurate stuff and so
radar becomes a huge concern for how do
you avoid it and there's a few different
ways the first way that we approached
this was actually overloading the radar
easiest way to do that is something
called chaff so what chaff does is
basically dropping a bunch of aluminum
strips these aluminum strips are highly
reflective and they reflect radar waves
back and it covers the entire screen in
little dots and so you don't really know
what the airplane is as our radar has
gotten better it started using the
Doppler effect and you can tell
essentially the speed and shift out
lower speed items and because of that
this chaff which has which has a
relatively lightweight and kind of fall
slowly it it doesn't move fast and you
can filter out your incredibly fast
airplane from this slow falling item but
it still is used somewhat against like
radar guided missiles and other things
and there's different techniques for
trying to make it more effective but
essentially it is losing its
Effectiveness so the next idea was
utilized by the U2 spy plane this is
something that you really do not see a
lot of because it is not incredibly
useful for wartime but the idea is fly
over the radar at the time America
thought that Russian radar could only go
so high because that was about how high
ours could go and they didn't think that
Rush had dumped so much money into
increasing this and so they created the
U2 now the thing that made the YouTu
special is that it had a service ceiling
of 70,000 ft most aircraft could never
touch that height and so they built this
aircraft and they started overflying it
in Russia
and they weren't shot down but what they
realized is that Russia knew what they
were doing because Russia themselves had
increased their radar range but their
surface to air missiles could not hit
that high so they started flying their
Fighters under it they would try to
block the camera on the surveillance
plane from seeing anything on the ground
and what Kelly Johnson who was the
president of skunkworks at the time
would actually call aluminum clouds huh
interesting yeah it's a I would love to
see a picture of that I'm sure there
must be one somewhere yeah there they're
probably are there's always those really
fun kind of photos I actually have a a
sort of fondness for wartime photos
taken on film oh yeah there was a I mean
there's a incredibly interesting thing
about the type of camera they used
because at 70,000 feet getting a picture
that accurate that you can actually like
you know pick out planes and things on
is really hard and so they I think
worked with Kodak to develop a special
camera just for this
plane that would have been a fun project
to be on I'm sure it was very
interesting especially the film types
and everything they used so when you're
go when it comes to a fighter jet or
other planes you know you can't fly that
high so what else do you use you use
what's known as ew or electronic warfare
now the main way we do this is basically
you have a transmitter in your plane
that transmits the same signal as the
radar and it kind of muddles the radar
wave because it receives this large
signal back much more powerful than a
reflection the issue with this can be
though which did happen with uh some of
the uos that we gave to Taiwan is that
if you transmit the wrong signal back it
basically paints a huge Target on you
and what happened was is three of the
four u2s in this flight were shot down
and the fourth guy came back and said
like wow I'm so lucky I didn't get shot
down because I forgot to turn on my
radar jammer and at that moment Kelly
Johnson realized oh the radar jammer is
the problem it turns out the radar
frequency was changed and they didn't
know
it okay so hearing all these These are
more or less just maybe like
countermeasure Maneuvers or things that
you can maybe add to an aircraft but you
know what about the fundamental design
of the aircraft in general right the
principle behind radar is that you have
to send a signal and then receive
something back but what happens if you
don't receive something back that is the
exact idea that led to the creation of
the first really true stealth plane
known as the F-117 now the U2 was
considered to be stealth for a little
bit cuz it could fly so high the SR71
because of its speed and height was also
considerably stealth but the first plane
that flew to normal ceiling that
operated normally that was stealth was
known as the F-117 Nighthawk and its
birth came from skunkworks as well and
what actually had happened was this
radar technician came into Ben Richard's
office one day and said hey I've got
this book published by a Russian
scientist named P Ulf Mev called method
of edge waves in the physical theory of
defraction and it has every equation you
would need to calculate the radar
cross-section of something so what if we
built an aircraft that we could minimize
this as much as possible computers at
the time
were you know not the best and so how
they did this was they took a bunch of
2D shapes that could not be rounded
because the computer could not compute
round edges and they basically built a
plane out of these 2D shapes and then
they did test on them individually and
then compounded the RCs number together
and they came up with the shape that
they thought was perfect and what's
interesting is there's some claims that
maybe other countries and other people
knew about the importance of this paper
but no one could figure out how to make
a shape fly because the technology
didn't exist now I'm not sure if that's
true or not but essentially the f-17 is
the first thing that really utilizes
this idea and it's funny because at some
point down the line uh this Russian
scientist moves to America I think he
teaches at a California school and Ben
Rich visited him and said hey I want you
to know like your papers what shaped my
entire aircraft he tells him this in the
1990s by the time the aircraft is
Declassified but it's kind of a funny
thing to at the time the Soviet
mathematician had no idea he was
creating an enemy aircraft so the thing
that really changed everything and
showed people how powerful the stealth
was they're going to a stealth test a
few different companies had come up with
their designs and they start pinging the
locked skunkworks design and they're
reading the poll and so they say okay we
need a poll with a smaller RCS so they
give money to locked and say hey can you
make one and locked makes such a drastic
reduction in the radar cross-section
that the other companies go wow if they
can do that to a poll what are they
doing to the aircraft it turns out that
the aircraft didn't get picked up the
first time until a bird landed on it and
bird droppings like in were such a large
effect on it that it doubled the size of
radar crosssection they had built this
shape that was insane so they get the
contract they build the plane and this
thing it looks like a pyramid it has
this odd shape if you look at where UFOs
were cited in the 80s and then you look
at the shape of this aircraft you may
think hey some of those UFOs may have
been f-117's because they were flying a
while before we actually publicly
announced them but this technology was
actually attempted to be moved to
something Beyond PLS Andrew do you know
what they moved it to want to talk about
it that's right they thought well if we
can do this in the air one at the sea
and so they invented the sea Shadow a
stealth boat borrowing these same
principles right very angular design the
idea to deflect radar waves and what's
better than that is it's for sale Yes
actually uh what had happened was they
had really wanted to push this idea of a
Stealth Destroyer and they built it up
on a catamaran hole in it it's just such
an oddl looking ship and we were talking
about it and we were like going back and
forth and I sent him a picture goes oh
that's so weird and he looked it up and
there it was listed an article that said
the sea Shadow is for sale and the price
was pretty modest well it went up for
auction and then it there seemed to be
some price drops and then somebody
bought it and they dismantled it yeah
and that that crushed our hearts because
just for a brief fleeting moment we had
envisioned a floating podcast Studio we
would come to the guest on the boat and
interview them there you know we may not
have had uh the money to purchase it but
we would have done something we have
taken a loan out but sadly you can only
get so far off mechanical engineering
you know I love I love it obviously I
majored in it but Ben rich said at the
time that the f117 was 70% shape 30%
materials so sadly now materials have to
come into play yeah the inevitable end
of all mechanical engineering Pursuits
is materials especially when you need to
push performance Beyond you know your
average levels and in this case they
came up with these radar absorbing
paints that could coat the surface of
the aircraft and help Beyond just the
shape of it to attenuate or absorb
electromagnetic radiation and these
paints fall into a class of materials
known as radar absorbing materials or
Rams uh but before we can get to how
exactly they work we should probably
establish an understanding of what
happens when an electromagnetic wave
actually hits a
material and it's going to there's going
to be basically three things that emerge
you're it's going to be split into
reflected power transmitted power and
absorbed power the reflected is what's
going to be well reflected like the name
implies transmitted is going to be that
what goes through the material and
absorbed is going to refer to um power
energy that's dissipated in the material
into some other form of energy maybe
that's heat maybe it's
electricity and when it comes to
designing a material to absorb we want
to min minimize the amount of signal
that's reflected back right that's the
whole idea of hiding from radar you
don't want any reflection and that
starts with this idea of impedance
matching what is impedance matching
Andrew when an electromagnetic wave
enters a material it has a certain
impedance or resistance to uh entering
into that material so free space or air
has a impedance of about 377 ohms and so
if you have a material right if you have
an electromagnetic wave moving through
free space or air and hits material with
a different impedance that's going to
result in reflection and so you can
think of impedance as defining an amount
of admittance and so if the admittance
of air and your material are different
that means that something's not getting
admitted right you're going to have some
reflection and uh that's not what we
want and so impedance matching refers
the idea of having your material match
the impedance of free space so that you
maximize the amount of um absorption or
transmission into that material and so
this can happen by just matching the
impedance um but it can also happen by
uh causing two properties of your
material to be equal to one another
those are the permitivity and the
permeability but that's actually a much
harder problem and one that's
continuously you know at the Forefront
of research in this area
and one that we'll get into in the next
couple sections but one question is how
do we actually measure these materials
right shoot a rer wave and see what
comes back I guess well there's a couple
different ones and they they give you
different amounts of information the
first one is known as a vector Network
analyzer and that is this idea so you
put your material in this chamber and
you you send signal through it and you
can measure you know um the reflection
characteristics the transmission
characteristics you can get the um the
phase and the magnitude of the wave as
it uh under those different
modes and it's it's essential for
characterizing the performance of these
materials especially in terms of
impedance matching reflection loss um
and things like bandwidth but it's not
you know because of the the way that the
experiment is structured it's not really
a real test right like you you don't
have some distance you don't have medium
through which the the radar is going to
travel and so the naval research lab
came up with this alternative test
called the arch test and it's called
that because the material is essentially
placed on a some sort of platform under
an arch and on one side of the arch you
have your transmitter of radar and then
on the other at a I don't know what how
would you call this angle where it a
different angle at a at a different
angle sure but it's a complimentary
angle at a 90° angle from the at a 90°
angle from the transmitter you have a
receiver and so you're going to try to
strike the material and have it reflect
back and in that case it's it's much
closer to a real test and um this is
also just a very common of way of
getting practical kind of real world
results from this and when you perform
these measurements what they're really
looking for is reflection loss or um you
know a loss in the amount you know input
versus output how do quantify that it's
measured in decb but usually at this
point it's so low it's in negative
decb and now for the real reason you're
all here how do you actually design a
radar absorbing material what what makes
it radar absorbing see I'm here for the
fun stories now you're here for the real
explanations in the
science and to do that we have to talk
about those things I mentioned earlier
permitivity and permeability we can
start with permitivity and dialectric
loss permitivity describes a material's
ability to polarize under an electric
field
so this means a material with a high
permitivity will polarize more um but
what does it mean for a material to
polarize under an electric field charged
particles in a material will try to
align themselves to that field uh that
is negatively charged electrons and
positively charged Atomic nuclei will
undergo a charge separation um for a
molecule this can actually result in
them reorienting themselves to have
their dipoles align to the field a
dialectric material is a material that's
electric electrically insulating so it
means it doesn't have any like free or
loose electrons and so in an applied
electric field um charge carriers in
this material can only undergo that
charge separation so that means they
shift from their average equilibrium
positions and so electrons basically
become displaced opposite the direction
of the field and the nuclear displaced
in the direction of the field and that
creates sort of
polarization um if a dialectric is
composed of weakly bonded molecules then
like I mentioned earlier they can
actually reorient themselves to align to
the field but that requires a certain uh
viscosity of the material for that to
actually happen compare this with like a
conductor where electrons are free to
float like copper right they're they're
they're not just going to be displaced
from their average positions they're
actually going to flow um in relation to
the electric
field this sounds pretty complex indeed
it is and it only gets worse because
while there's something that known as
permitivity there's also complex
permitivity and this describes
polarization under an alternating
electric field like an Electro magnetic
wave or AC current and in this case
complex permitivity is split into a real
and an imaginary component this is where
math lost me the day they introduced
imaginary numbers I was out oh yeah I
was taking an electrical engineering
course it was required for our major and
as soon as we got into the imaginary
components I was pretty solidified in my
choice not to do electrical engineering
I think that's fair I think that all the
math you do should be real and if
there's fake stuff in it what's the
point of doing
it well unfortunately we live in the
real world and that means we have to do
imaginary math and so when we're this
split right you see you have the real
and the imaginary component the real
component tells us about like the
magnitude of the storage capability um
this is basically just what we've heard
before the imaginary component tells us
the amount of energy that's lost to
other processes what kind of processes
are these well there's three big ones
but there's actually a lot of different
ones and there's a lot of dispute within
the literature of uh the nature and the
mechanisms by which some of these occur
but we'll boil down to the top three
that's all you need to know uh the first
of these is conduction so if you have a
conducting material then current can be
induced within that material and as
current is Flowing along that material
you're going to have some met of
resistance and resistance generates heat
and so you'll basically have a certain
amount of that energy that's lost as
heat and that's a way of consuming uh EM
wave energy and so you might think well
great we'll just make a super conductive
material but not so fast too much
conductivity actually creates an
impedance match because if a material is
super conductive you'll actually end up
increasing the amount of
reflection so it ends up being kind of a
interesting problem where you want
enough conduction uh to help you absorb
the wave but you don't want too much and
this relates to this idea of a
percolation threshold um and the way you
can think about this is Imagine like a
random array of conducting materials
right if you have a few of them and
they're well spread out you're not going
to be conducting to them but if you
continuously place them up to a certain
point you might be able to form a bridge
between them and that's kind of what
you're looking for a point when a set of
disordered sort of discrete units starts
to exhibit long range connectivity so
that's
conduction the one thing we have to know
is that the permitivity will actually
change with the frequency of our
electric field and what that actually
means is that a change in polarization
is non-instantaneous it doesn't happen
uh it doesn't match the frequency of the
the wave which means that there's a lag
and this brings up the idea of
relaxation so materials where molecules
can realign themselves
the realignment takes some amount of
time right there's other molecules
around them um there's various other
forces at play and so there ends up
being a little bit of a time lag right
it can't keep Pace with the frequency of
the the wave and this lag actually
results in energy loss due to friction
and various other uh mechanisms that are
happening and the last one is resonance
so atoms ions electrons they have these
characteristic absorption frequencies
and those are essentially the
frequencies that they natur really
oscillate in the absence of any external
force and so when your electromagnetic
wave frequency matches that it actually
causes the material to absorb that and
oscillate at a a higher amplitude and so
that's also a big uh method of
absorption and the other thing is aside
from these so these are all to some
extent intrinsic material properties but
aside from those things like defects and
interfaces in the micr structure can
also serve as polarization sites defects
can often have loose or dangling bonds
those things will try to reorient um
interfaces will also have two different
materials with different properties on
either side those end up being
polarization sites and so when designing
these materials things like defects or
or or interfaces things that maybe would
be seen as bad in other materials design
applications end up being a
positive cool story Andrew I literally
could not care less about the science
give me some materials and some examples
go well early on carbon materials were
recognized as is having high e
absorption capability um in fact late
War German uots had their snorkel and
periscopes treated with rubber graphite
mixtures uh called s and shortsteen
figure oh I know this
one because the Germans did the exact
same thing to some of their bombers they
would put carbon and impregnated into
the plywood that they use no no this is
fake really yeah I I went and I I did a
deep dive cuz I found this too and then
I I found this interesting thread on
Reddit where a historian who this was
like his PhD dissertation M basically
went through and said like the guy who
made it claimed it yeah but there is
literally no evidence of this wild
yeah hello everyone this is future Jared
Here Andrew and I right after this have
a discussion in which we talk about
whether or not this was actually a real
story I cut that out and I'm going to
give you the answer interestingly enough
the guy who designed designed the plane
that we're talking about who is uh
Walter Horton not a very German name
surprisingly he claimed that the plane
which is known as the Horton
ho229 V3 which is one of the German
Wonder waffas or Wonder Weapons that
they were designing which is this crazy
looking jet he actually claimed that it
was one of the first stealth planes this
Smithsonian Institute got the plane and
they took a bunch of special devices
such as electron microscopes and other
things and looked over it and all they
could find was plywood no special
Coatings yeah so it turns out he's a
liar anyways back to the
episode These materials that the Germans
were using uh the ones that I'm not
going to pronounce again um they had a
layered structure and so uh and but
apparently the the big problem with them
uh was they they were actually really
hard to apply like the manufacturing
technology there was just not up to
Snuff and they also degraded in seawater
it's worth noting we're not not going to
get into this at all I don't want to
explain this stuff but it's interesting
because German OTS were also the first
people to use an aoic tiles which are
great at reducing sonar Reflections why
how all that don't worry about it
another episode
maybe boats the boat
episode one day you're you're on you're
on probation from episode
recommendations
sorry um but these these materials were
difficult to apply but the Germans were
on the right track um carbon is a good
material for radar absorption owing to
its low density High uh and tunable
conductivities uh anti-corrosion
properties um across many different
types of allotropes of carbons and these
allotropes will include things like
carbon black carbon fibers carbon nanot
tubes graphite reduced graphine um and
we'll get into these but there were some
other materials explored kind of in the
similar dialectric space such as
Ceramics things like barium titanate
magnesium oxide um titanium oxide silica
zinc oxide or even some like crazy stuff
like or even silicon nitride or silicon
carbide but in addition to Ceramics uh
you also have things like polymers
besides just the epoxies and the rubbers
that they would use as a matrix material
um there are a number of conducting
polymers uh that have been studied
including things like polyaniline and
poly pyro um poly pyal specifically
tends to be unstable so it's often mixed
with things but within these they have
um these these polymers have partial
oxidation or doping and that causes the
polymer to become conducting through the
formation of things called polarons and
bipolarons basically these are the
charge carriers along the chains and
conductivity occurs through a phonon
assist through a phonon assisted hopping
between these randomly distributed
States carb materials and polymer
composits are they're promising for
absorption applications mainly because
of their relatively easy processing
design flexibility low density the
things I've already mentioned however
these materials actually tend to have
have poor performance at lower
thicknesses uh like less than 2 mm which
is not great for maybe aircraft where
you're trying to make a paint uh and
they tend to also be confined to a
narrow band range remember we talked
about all these different bands earlier
in the episode you want to be able to
absorb across a lot of those and if
you're you're only targeting a few for a
military application that's not great um
so in the interest of pushing absorption
capabilities further we then see the
development of magnetic Rams and this
brings us to the property known as
permeability and from that magnetic loss
permeability is a word I do recognize
Andrew I know that that is the ability
to magnetize in response to magnetic
field but that is about the extent of my
knowledge in any of this do you know how
magnetization Works uh yeah positive
attracts negative and negative repels
negative well that'll help you stick
things on the refrigerator but in order
to understand magnetic Rams we're going
to need to go a little bit deeper
magnetization in a material tends to be
derived from things like magnetic
moments um of a material's electron
ordinarily you have basically a bunch of
electrons in a material that are
arranged such that their magnetic
moments uh cancel out right like imagine
like a bunch of randomly arrange signals
that ends up just being kind of a null
um this is actually due to the poly
Exclusion Principle but even when you
have unpaired electrons that aren't
going to be confined uh in this way um
these will actually also tend to be
oriented in random directions but
sometimes these can be aligned to allow
the material to produce a strong
magnetic field on its own this
propensity and ability actually are what
Define different types of magnetic
materials the ones that you're familiar
with the Positive attract negative are
known as ferromagnets so these are
materials with unpaired electrons that
have achieved a lower energy state by
Orting orienting themselves parallel to
one another so there's just a
thermodynamic energetic driving force to
actually make them align themselves um
typically you'll actually see like large
regions of alignment where all these
magnetic moments have lined up and these
form what they call magnet magnetic
domains the biggest lie about pherom
magnets is that I always thought that it
meant that it had to have some amount of
iron in it cuz ferof feritic I didn't
realize till later that it meant more
than one material sometimes it's
probably because the first magnet they
found was iron yeah based but what do
they use now what kind of materials we
got the common materials tend to be Iron
Cobalt nickel and their Alloys so I
don't feel as stupid then as a kid at
least I was somewhat close one out of
three is okay but there's more Beyond
this if we include things like rare
earth
magnets what are the so what are the
other kinds of magnets we're worried
about then I don't know about worried
about but you also have things like
paramagnets okay these materials they
have those unpaired electrons but
they're still randomly oriented right
the difference is that they can still
align themselves when they're subject to
a magnetic field up to what we call a
saturation point this is like the
maximum amount of alignment that these
can endure so this is something like
aluminum where even though it's not
magnetic on its own you can still induce
a magnetic response in it under a
magnetic field pretty
cool the next kind are D magnets these
tend to resist a magnetic field so under
them they're repelled a lot of materials
have this property um but it actually
takes a strong enough magnetic field to
really observe it common materials that
you'll see with this are actually carbon
and copper okay so getting back to
permeability just like permitivity it
also has real and complex components
when subject to an alternating magnetic
field uh where this complex component uh
is going to represent
losses Andrew I just went on a whole
entire rant about how I did not like
complex numbers why are you bringing
them back again because we have to so
what are the losses in magnetism look
like
then okay so in this case there are
maybe four primary loss mechanisms this
is where it started to get a little bit
complicated in the literature but we'll
start up with the main ones the first is
Eddie current loss so
current can be induced within a
conducting material in the presence of
an alternating magnetic field and just
like conductive losses in um maybe a
dialectric material or conducting
material um you're also going to have a
resistive heating um resulting in some
losses but then you'll also get
something known as ferromagnetic
resonance this is also somewhat similar
to the permitivity case uh ferromagnetic
materials have a procession frequency
and this this kind of refers to the
rotation of those magnetic moments uh
and when the frequency matches that
procession frequency um you're going to
you know similarly get a sense of
absorption and an amplitude increase and
similarly you're going to get energy
that's absorbed lost as heat and this uh
ferromagnetic resonance frequency can
actually be tuned based on the particle
size of the magnetic materials which is
kind of
cool next you'll have another form of
resonance known as domain wall resonance
um we mentioned the different domains
and between them there are walls or kind
of like odd energy barriers you can
think of these as grain boundaries
actually um well you can think of these
as being like grain boundaries um and
these domain walls actually have their
own resonance frequency that can lead
and be a mechanism for absorption and
this can similarly be tuned and lastly
we have hysteresis loss which is a very
common wellknown well
understood lastly we have hysteresis
loss and this is basically the lagging
of magnetization behind a magnetizing
force think of it like the energy spent
ATT in to realign the magnetic moments
of electrons and domains you can maybe
compare this to to friction right like
you align the moment the magnetic
moments of a material and then all of a
sudden your magnetic field changes you
now have to break those out of their
alignment to try to realign them and in
doing that it's going to cost some
energy to break it out there's an energy
barrier
there so once again sign's done let's
talk about it actually being used so
here's something going going all the way
back to the f117 the f117 uses a very
special kind of paint but it is referred
to as iron ball paint a little bit of a
silly name does not actually get through
how difficult it was to make first of
all in case you wondering it is not
literally just balls of iron yeah it is
no it was actually a product of a
decomposition of iron pentac carbonal
and so while they are flakes of iron
they're actually obtaining a very speci
way and so what you do is you then take
so they are iron balls but they're
special iron balls they're not like you
can't like go and like machine a ball of
iron it's special iron balls yeah yeah
it's a carbonal iron yeah special iron
so they take the special iron and they
disperse it in an epoxy and then it is a
cool little special pan and it does
magnetic resonance stuff all the cool
sign stuff he explained but here's a fun
story about it so they're building a
test aircraft for the f17
and actually just after they announced
the official one they decide to retire
one of the test aircraft and so they're
going to send it for the big home in the
sky I don't know what museum is was
going to but the paint's classified at
the moment you know we're talking this
is the 1980s 1990s so they can't
actually let the paint get out there and
so they sand blast they media blast they
get all of the paint off it and this a
process that is very not great great to
be the guy doing it it's very dangerous
they're covered in this protective gear
and when it's all said and done they've
got this now bare metal plane they
thought it'd be really funny to go on
the side of it and write toxic death on
the side in spray paint because the
plane was already going to get repainted
just a normal black when they put on
display and so they took this blank
canvas and they put skull and crossbones
they weree toxic death there were a few
other things because I guess they were
annoyed with the job they had to do and
they thought it was funny and so you can
see clips of this this plane actually
flying in the sky with just toxic death
written on the side of it and it looks a
little silly obviously you know I'm sure
it went black
again uh for those who can't see Jared
has rotated his laptop um to show me the
screen with an image of an f-17
Nighthawk without paint on it with the
words toxic death presumably flying and
something else I don't know what that
says I can't read it's very low low low
quality for back in the day but iron
ball paint
is somewhat of a class of materials too
like it it's not it had some variations
to it and it probably still does um that
are probably still classified but you'll
get things like core shell structures
with those iron balls um you'll also get
a density gradient in the size of the
balls remember we told you that some of
these loss mechanisms actually depend on
the particle size and so if you want to
have Broadband absorption you're going
to have a a gradient maybe or or changes
in the the the particle size as as a
function of depth so the f117 uses
carbonal iron like we talked about but
what else can you use well like I
mentioned earlier right there are those
three kind of main pherom magnetic
materials like iron nickel Cobalt and
then I mentioned their oxides so you'll
commonly see um Iron oxides uh nickel
ferite or even nickel oxides as well but
the thing is especially if you look at
Trends in the research it turns out that
size Matters electromagnetic
interactions tend to increase with
decreasing particle size
and so due to the unique size surface
and Quantum tunneling effect nanoscale
materials uh actually have excellent
electronic and magnetic properties and
past a critical size ferromagnetic
materials actually exhibit something
known as super
paramagnetism um that is they display um
super high magnetic saturation and low
coercivity that essentially just means
they have a high saturation Point
meaning under an electric magnetic field
they'll get a lot of alignment they can
align to a very high degree but the low
cority means that once that magnetic
field is removed these magnetic moments
are going to just randomize again and so
what this means is that there's less
sort of sticking in place of alignment
of these dipoles so if you have a high
frequency um electromagnetic field it
can adapt to have that real component of
absorption um quite a bit better so as
we've learned in numerous episodes at
this point Andrew there's no such thing
as a perfect solution so is a way to
combine these approaches and get the
best of each yeah and and you can
there's a number of composite approaches
in the literature and that's from the
literature's perspective that seems to
be where a lot of research in Rams is
going surveying the literature there's
way too many different variations of
this to really cover um extensively or
in detail so I've grouped things and
I've I've picked a few case studies and
examples that I think are particularly
interesting um and and novel and in some
cases just kind of wacky the first one I
want to highlight is and one that you
see quite a bit is the idea of creting a
composite with carbon nanot tubes and
then you know sprinkled in magnetic
nanop particles um and the carbon nanot
tubes are used for their electrical
conductivity they have great mechanical
properties low density and a large
surface area and then you combine that
with the properties of magnetic
materials and you start to get the best
of both worlds but what's really cool is
that you actually get um interaction
effects that no one solution would have
achieved alone the inclusion of the
nanoparticles actually contributes to
additional interfaces and defects within
the carbon nanot tubes and the material
at large and these serve for further
sites for polarization
losses Additionally the conductive
networks that form can promote lots of
internal Reflections within the material
or scattering and this is just another
way of maybe prolonging the time that
the electromagnetic wave is in the
material or at least reorienting it from
The Source furthermore a lot of the Eddy
currents that are induced within the
magnetic particles have a means of
transfer and resistive loss through the
carbon nanot tubes and um if you
continue to survey the literature we saw
we see several variations and
improvements on this approach such as
using multi-walled carbon nanot tubes
carbon nanot tubes with metallic Nano
wires inside them um one person used a
coating of poly anene on top of carbon
nanot tubes to try to make sure that to
limit the conductivity a little bit
there's also use of core shell nanop
particles an esotropic particles with
weird shapes like flowers is one of them
I saw um and other things basically a
lot of attempts based on Trends in
nanotechnology and nanoscience to try to
affect the
attenuation so that's one class you see
a lot of kind of variations on a theme
there the next are these these like 3D
what they call graphine like networks um
so a graphine network refers to a
structure where you basically have two
dimensional graphine sheets um and these
are interconnected to form a
three-dimensional highly conductive
Network um and these struct tend to be
characterized by not only having uh you
know conductivity but also having ultra
high paracity a low density and high
surface area these are then loaded with
Magnetic nanop particles that not only
have their own loss mechanisms but form
interfaces with the walls of these um
that can serve as additional
polarization sites um and with the high
paracity both on a micro meso and macro
scale it basically T allows for a ton of
um scattering and uh multiple
Reflections inside of the material and I
thought this was kind of an interesting
approach of just kind of filling
basically like a sponge almost with um
the magnetic Nano
particles and the last one I saw that I
thought was just kind of Novel or
interesting uh were the use of fish
skins as precursors for the materials in
this case they took nickel Cobalt and
nickel Cobalt oxide um nanop particles
and they mixed these with a sort of and
they create a hybrid Nano composite is
what they're calling it um and they
synthesized this actually using fish
skin derived porous carbon um basically
through a hydrothermal treatment um the
process basically involved cleaning and
dry the fish skin cutting it into pieces
and then mixing it with a potassium
hydroxide solution uh the mixture was
then you know subject to these
hydrothermal treatments and finally a
carbonizing process um basically just
created a super porous carbon uh that
could then be impregnated with all these
different um magnetic nanop particles
almost you can think of this as like
forming a foam and their whole idea was
that it creates something that's maybe
more environmentally sustainable but I
don't know that the military-industrial
complex has ever really cared
sustainable warfare that's a new
one and I I just thought these were cool
you know you'll see a lot of different
kind of variations of this where it's
some dialectric material mixed with some
magnetic material and lots of attempts
to to tweak these and their interactions
in the interfaces and the shapes and
then measuring the response a lot of
what you see is cook and look um but
there is quite a bit of work now with
simulating radar response um in various
um simulation tools and and and FEA
programs and I think these hold a lot of
Promise in the future but if you go back
to our modeling episode they're still
running into the same problem where you
have macroscale interactions but you
know based on these examples you also
have mesoscale and microscale
interactions as well so it becomes
actually a difficult problem to simulate
as well and it may be that one composite
approach uh isn't your only solution
you're probably going to have um
gradients where you have different
layers that are designed to absorb
different
materials and this is a very timely
episode because the B21 which is our new
stealth bomber well ours being the US in
this case new stealth bomber just took
its first flight and already we know of
that we know of and already I see so
many people speculating oh what's this
what does this do for stealth what's
this do so it's very interesting to see
where stealth technology is at from what
we know where it's at academically and
perhaps where it goes in the future and
as we begin to learn stuff as things get
to classified it'll be very interesting
to see if some of these things we've
talked about as possibilities are
actually being used and we just don't
know
it yeah and as usual we really only
scratch the surface on radar absorption
microwave absorption which is kind of
contained in here and also somewhat
different is very Broad and there's a
lot of uh geometries and techniques
things like adaptive radar absorption
that we just really couldn't cover in
one episode
um but hopefully this can serve as a
strong primer to let you dive into the
literature because there's lot of
interesting stuff out there and maybe
you're inspired to hop in there I think
there's a lot of room for development
still because it mean you know that's
classified yeah well anyways thank you
so much for joining us this podcast is
sponsored by El severe or materials
today they're a great publishing company
they got a lot of really good articles
and they also have some great
conferences and they're just someone
that where H fan of and so you can check
them out at el.com or
material.com Yeah we actually referenced
a few of their articles for this episode
you can find them in the show notes in
addition to the many other articles that
we have referenced we can't guarantee
that all of them are consistent with one
another but that just adds to the
mystery and you can really see the
difference between Andrew being very
science heavy and mine being like
military military
guys.com we'd also like to give a big
thanks to you for listening
you can go to your favorite podcasting
platform and if you really like the show
or if you think there's ways that we can
improve you should leave us a review
we've been doing this for about five
years at this point and we're always
looking to improve and make the next
five years even better so if you have
any ideas maybe for a topic or for maybe
maybe there's a quality aspect maybe our
audio is a little bit off let us know in
a review or reach out to us you can find
us on Instagram at materialism. podcast
or through our email at materialism.
podcast gmail.com also we want to give a
huge shout out to people make the music
thank you kaby thank you alphabot you
can find them on Spotify and YouTube and
we will have the links to that in the
show
notes catch you next time thank you guys
bye The Adventures of fire electricity
magnetism iron lead glass silk cotton
the makers of tools the captors of
lightning the architect the engineer the
musician are all beneficiaries of the
material materal of this world and are
bound only by their imaginations in
manipulating those
materials