Elected Sheriffs, Unelected Removal — New Law Explained

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
Apr 7, 2026
At 1:20 a.m., on March 6, after nearly eight hours of heated debate with House Republicans, Democrats passed Senate Bill 5974, which allows an unelected state board to effectively remove a sheriff from office in Washington state.
Gov. Bob Ferguson signed the bill into law on April 1.
Hi, State Representative Jim Walsh here on the floor of the House of Representatives in Olympia
with my good colleague Brian Burnett. And we just debated and voted off the floor Senate Bill 5974,
the anti-sheriff bill. Very controversial, very bad and intense debate. Brian, a little bit about
this bill. Oh, indeed, Jim. And the fact that I served in law enforcement for over 25 years
and 12 years as a Chelan County elected sheriff. I mean, what they're saying about this is that
this is to set new standards. This is 100 years plus old. It's antiquated, it's outdated,
it's police matrons. But what it's about, it's about taking away the power of the elected
sheriff by the people from their county. And it's so important because this is setting this up
to be a political disaster and a witch hunt. I really do believe that. It may be, okay,
in a perfect situation, it wouldn't become that, but it exposes to that, Jim. And it makes it
very, very dangerous that the attorney general, a specific governor can appoint people and put
them in place to actually remove a sheriff from office when it's an elected position protected
by the constitution and it's your constitution. And that's the one thing that's always bothered
me is the fact that the constitution that one person would complain about is the same
constitution that actually protects them. Exactly. Well, we're going to cut now to
our floor debate excerpts where the real action on this bad bill took place.
The bill constitutes three distinct and independent failures. First, it constitutes a
failure of necessity. This bill is not necessary. Madam Speaker, there's nothing wrong with the
state of our sheriffs here in Washington. They can't be fixed at the next ballot box if the
voters choose to put somebody else in that position. Second, this bill fails the constitutional
question. It raises novel questions about the ability to remove a sheriff from their duly
elected position, a position that's described in article 11, section five of our Washington
state constitution, creating an entirely new route to remove them separate and apart from
the vacancy route that has existed since our state's inception. Third, it fails the question
of public trust. When voters send an individual to a position of trust, whether it's you or me,
Madam Speaker, they anticipate that we will be able to fill out our position without being
removed arbitrarily by an unaccountable bureaucracy often located hundreds of miles away.
A critical part of being a good sheriff is having the judgment, the discernment,
the discretion to reflect local values, and this proposal destroys that. And I stand before you a
proud past sheriff that has sworn an oath many times each time I was elected, but prior to that,
Madam Speaker, as a law enforcement officer, I swore that same oath. But when you step in
to swear the oath as sheriff, Madam Speaker, it's a surreal thing, and you're face to face
with how are you going to react to provide training, equipment, policy, and reduce liability
for the citizens, the visitors, the victims, the offenders, and all the pieces that go with that
and the responsibility. For those opposed to this bill, there's only one movie that comes to mind,
Support Your Local Sheriff, 1969, starring James Garner. A wonderful movie, Madam Speaker,
but in this case, Support Your Local Sheriff doesn't star James Garner. It stars the thousands
and thousands of ordinary Washingtonians who reached out to us and said, do not take away
the independence of our local elected sheriffs. We need them as a bulwark for our liberties.
I ask that you join me in voting down this bill. Thank you.
That was one of the most intense floor debates of this legislative session, and Brian,
with his experience as a sheriff, was key to our arguments. Brian, sum up what you think about this
bad bill. I mean, Jim, we had so many amendments. We could have talked till
10 o'clock in the morning. We literally could have went over 16 hours with this,
and our points were very, very well spoken. It's not like we were just throwing out there
willy-nilly ideas. This is stuff that is logic to the Constitution, to the protection of the voters
themselves, and I just can't believe that what we're seeing is all but just a handful of Democrats
pushing this down for why. Yeah, it's taking away the voice
of the people to choose their sheriff. And Brian, you're right. It was a mix of mostly
the Republicans, and a few Democrats voted no. It was all Democrats supporting this bad idea.
Share this video below. Let's get the word out about this bad bill that takes away the people's
voice when it comes to electing their sheriffs. Brian, last word.
Don't take our word for it, Jim. I mean, go watch this video and see how your
Republican representatives fought so hard for your constitutional rights and your voting protection.
