Economic expert discusses new caps on federal student loans

Loan Solutions
2 followers
3 Video Views·Jul 20, 2025
Lesley Turner, Associate Professor at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy, discusses how President Trump's Big Beautiful Bill affects federal student loans.
President Trump's massive tax and spending package will bring sweeping changes to federal
student loans.
It sets a cap on how much people can borrow from the federal government to pay for college
and graduate school.
Economic experts predict it will have lifetime consequences for higher education.
So what does this mean for borrowers?
Well, to break it all down, we're joined by Leslie Turner.
She's an economics and public policy associate professor at the University of Chicago.
Thank you for being with us this morning.
Oh, it's my pleasure.
Yeah.
So let's start with what these new limits are.
Can you explain some of the major changes here?
Right.
So this bill eliminates the grad plus federal loan program, which was created almost two
decades ago.
And grad plus allowed students to borrow up to the total cost of attendance.
So this is tuition fees and estimated living expenses completely through federal loan programs.
Grad students will still have access to federal loans, but they will face strict limits on
the amount they can borrow, both on an annual basis and on a lifetime basis.
Going forward, students will be grouped into two categories.
So those who are attending graduate programs can borrow $20,500 on an annual basis.
And those who are in professional programs can borrow $50,000 on an annual basis.
And lifetime caps are $100,000 and $200,000, respectively.
Okay.
So this is what I'm having trouble with.
So lawyers, doctors, and dentists are most likely to be impacted by the new limits.
We already are seeing foreign students not going to be able or don't want to come over
into higher education in a lot of those fields.
So now if our Americans cannot afford to do this, how is this going to reshape higher
education in these fields where we definitely need people?
Right.
So students will still be able to go to private student loans, but in contrast to federal
loan programs, not all students will be able to take out private student loans, and many
of them will face higher interest rates.
And so to the extent that doctors, dentists, veterinary students are not able to afford
will see reductions in the number of professionals coming out of these programs.
Okay.
And then what options do student borrowers have once this goes into effect?
Is it just that if you can't afford to borrow enough, then you can't choose to be a doctor
or lawyer, or there's some wiggle room somewhere?
So as I mentioned, students may have access to private student loans, but access will
likely depend on their credit history, their credit score, and they aren't guaranteed access,
which is in contrast to federal student loan programs where there's either no or very minimal
credit checks.
So in addition to looking at private student loan options, the other thing that prospective
students should really consider is shopping around for lower priced options.
There's a huge amount of variation in the cost of graduate programs, and this information
is maybe harder to see than typical prices for undergraduates.
So an example that I like to give is in your area, University of Southern California's
Masters in Social Work programs, students leave with typical debt of about $125,000
and have typical earnings of about $70,000 a year.
But if you go about 10 miles down the road to Cal State Los Angeles and look at students
completing the Masters in Social Work program there, their typical debt is $30,000 and their
typical earnings are about $88,000.
And so these are two programs that, at least on their face, lead to pretty similar earnings,
but have dramatically different levels of debt, likely due to differences in the cost
of these programs.
And so to the extent that there are other options available, this may not always be
the case, but in large metropolitan areas it often is, it will now really be important
for students to consider all of those options and their costs.
It is interesting to see the differences, as you said, just a few miles.
But some say there could be a benefit to these limits and that universities will have to
really take a look at those sky-high tuition costs.
Could some schools actually end up having to lower tuition or increase aid?
So that is definitely something that could happen.
I have a research study that actually looks at the creation of the Grad Plus Loan Program
in 2006.
And we do find that in graduate programs where borrowing increased by relatively more when
students got access to this new loan program, prices also increased by relatively more.
I would be cautious, though, to take these findings and apply them to the current situation
for two main reasons.
The first is that this new law doesn't just take us back to 2006 by eliminating Grad Plus.
The limits that graduate students face are actually quite a bit lower than the limits
faced by students in 2006, after you account for inflation.
So students pursuing a medical degree in 2006, before Grad Plus existed, could borrow almost
$300,000 on a lifetime basis once you account for inflation.
Whereas going forward, these students will only be able to borrow $200,000.
The other big difference is private student loans.
Private student loans were much more prevalent back at the start of the century.
Almost 25% of total loans granted to students in a given year were coming from private lenders,
whereas in recent years, this was less than 15%.
And so while it is possible that schools will choose to lower the prices of their programs,
another possibility is that schools will just decide to eliminate programs altogether.
All right, Leslie Turner, there's so much to consider here and see how this will change
the education landscape.
Thank you for being with us this morning.
My pleasure.
