You should eat low carb if you have a thyroid problem like hypothyroidism and want to lose weight, right? No!
Cutting your carbohydrates has been shown to REDUCE thyroid function by negatively impacting thyroid lab tests like free T3 and reverse T3.
The change that we see in people who go low carb for long periods of time mimics the same thyroid lab tests we see in chronically ill patients and in those who starve themselves.
In other words, if you want better thyroid function and better thyroid lab tests, you need to eat more carbs.
This applies if you have hypothyroidism, Hashimoto's, and even if your thyroid has been removed.
But how many carbs do you need?
The answer? At least 100 grams per day.
These carbs should be consumed as whole food sources, NOT processed foods like pastries, cookies, cakes, donuts, etc.
And don't be stingy on fruits or 100% fruit juice either as both of these are healthy options and will not cause weight gain.
Don't worry about carbs causing weight gain either, because that's not the case (see the studies in the video for proof).
Cutting your carbs is a big mistake that thyroid patients make when trying to lose weight and if you want to see the others then check out this video: https://youtu.be/vxtia4SlX7g?si=pSJD9niICtyVMk9y
The 100-gram/day minimum even applies to those thyroid patients who have insulin resistance and the number only goes up from here depending on your activity level.
Download my free thyroid resources here (including hypothyroid symptoms checklist, the complete list of thyroid lab tests + optimal ranges, foods you should avoid if you have thyroid disease, and more): https://www.restartmed.com/start-here/
Recommended thyroid supplements to enhance thyroid function:
- Supplements that everyone with hypothyroidism needs: https://bit.ly/3tekPej
- Supplement bundle to help reverse Hashimoto's: https://bit.ly/3gSY9eJ
- Supplements for those without a thyroid and for those after RAI: https://bit.ly/3tb36nZ
- Supplements for active hyperthyroidism: https://bit.ly/3t70yHo
See ALL of my specialized supplements including protein powders, thyroid supplements, and weight loss products here:
https://www.restartmed.com/shop/
Want more from my blog? I have more than 400+ well-researched blog posts on thyroid management, hormone balancing, weight loss, and more. See all blog posts here:
https://www.restartmed.com/blog/
Prefer to listen via podcast? Download all of my podcast episodes here: https://apple.co/3kNYTCS
Disclaimer:
Dr. Westin Childs received his Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine from Rocky Vista University College of Osteopathic medicine in 2013. His use of “doctor” or “Dr.” in relation to himself solely refers to that degree. Dr. Childs is no longer practicing medicine and does not hold an active medical license so he can focus on helping people through videos, blog posts, research, and supplement formulation. To read more about why he is no longer licensed please see this page: https://www.restartmed.com/what-happened-to-my-medical-license/
This video is for general informational, educational, and entertainment purposes only. It should not be used to self-diagnose and it is not a substitute for a medical exam, treatment, diagnosis, prescription, or recommendation. It does not create a doctor-patient relationship between Dr. Childs and you. You should not make any changes to your medications or health regimens without first consulting a physician. If you have any questions please consult with your current primary care provider. Restart Medical LLC and Dr. Westin Childs are not liable or responsible for any advice, course of treatment, diagnosis, or any other information, services, or product you obtain through this website or video.
#thyroid #hypothyroidism #hashimoto's
there are two things that thyroid
patients pay way too much attention to
the first is their weight as measured on
a scale and the second is their intake
of carbohydrates I've already explained
before why measurements on the scale are
so misleading so today I want to focus
on the carbohydrate part both of these
topics tend to be top of mind for
thyroid patients because thyroid
dysfunction leads to weight gain but the
attention is still misplaced the truth
is that carbohydrates are essential for
thyroid function and avoiding them may
actually make your thyroid worse but
this then begs the question why do so
many experts recommend that you avoid
carbohydrates and how many should you
eat each day as a thyroid patient let's
answer both right now there are three
different ways to think about
carbohydrates and most people including
experts will fall into one of these
three camps group number one believes
that carbohydrates are dangerous because
they are non-essential and because
consuming them leads to insulin
resistance which is a major driver of
diseases like heart attack and stroke
those who fit into this category usually
recommend eating diets like carnivore
and keto which makes a lot of sense
group number two on the other hand
recognizes the importance of insulin
resistance as a driver of disease but
suggests that the real problem has to do
with refined and processed carbohydrates
not the carbohydrates found in real
sources of Whole Foods those who fit
into this category tend to recommend
diets like Whole 30 or other Whole Food
based diets group number three believes
that all sources of carbohydrates are
equal and healthy so you can pretty much
just eat whatever you want we don't even
really need to entertain group three
because you should know by now that
processed foods are dangerous to your
body and to your thyroid so there's no
possible way that this philosophy can be
correct this just leaves us with group
number one and group number two group
number one is highly attracted to
thyroid patients because of the thyroid
weight gain connection and the fact that
low carbohydrate diets are thought to be
associated with better and more rapid
weight weight loss compared to other
diets while it is certainly true that
you can lose weight on a low carb diet
there's nothing magical about it and the
rapid weight loss associated with going
low carb is almost always related to
fluid Mass not to Fat Mass the problem
with this philosophy is twofold while
carbohydrates are not technically
essential for life they happen to be
essential if you want your thyroid to
function optimally and number two is
that reducing your carbohydrate intake
can lower T3 levels which would can
ultimately make your thyroid function
worse this is not some theoretical or
hypothetical problem either it's been
shown in several studies and I'll share
one with you below right now one
crossover study evaluated 11 healthy
patients to see the impact that the
ketogenic diet and a high carbohydrate
lowfat diet had unresting metabolic rate
and thyroid function this study found
that people using the ketogenic diet saw
more weight loss compared to the high
carbohydrate group but they also found
the following changes in thyroid
function plasma T3 levels were
significantly lower there was an
increase in free T4 and the TSH level
remained the same if you're familiar
with thyroid lab testing analysis then
you'll know that a rise in T4 and a drop
in T3 is consistent with a thyroid
conversion problem this reduction in
thyroid conversion is thought to be used
by the body as a defense mechanism to
preserve metabolism it's also the very
same pattern that is seen in people who
are chronically ill and in those who are
undergoing starvation while this is just
one study there are plenty of other
studies and they all point in the same
direction while suggesting that reducing
carbohydrates negatively impacts thyroid
function to illustrate this point
further let's take a look at a real
world example the first is of a popular
carnivore promoting YouTuber named Paul
saladino MD as an expert in online
personality he has shared his
experiences throughout the year
including a list of his lab tests more
recently his journey has included the
reintroduction of carbohydrates to the
tune of about 200 to 300 G per day after
having avoided them for several years
some of the changes that he seen in his
own lab work after the reintroduction of
these carbohydrates in the form of
fruits fruit juice and honey include the
following a significant decrease in sex
hormone binding globulin by about 1/
half a significant rise in free
testosterone a decrease in his TSH which
was previously a high normal and a rise
in his fre T3 subjectively he's also
noted an increase in his energy levels
around this time as well as objectively
a rise in his basil body temperature
what makes this case study so
interesting is that all of these
positive changes occurred without
impacting his insulin which remained
undetectable both before and after the
change this appears to throw a massive
wrench in the philosophy of those who
follow the carnivore diet which suggests
that all carbohydrates but especially
those from fruit juices and fruits
always result in insulin resistance and
damage to the body while this is just a
simple case report and an N of one his
experience does support the idea which
is supported in the studies that we
referenced previously that carbohydrates
are needed for thyroid function and by
consuming them you can actually see a
change in your thyroid hormone levels we
can't use his data to make bold claims
about every individual but we can use it
to make some general recommendations
which is what I want to do next so how
many carbohydrates does your thyroid
need if you want it to function
optimally and the answer here depends on
a few factors
the first is whether or not you have
insulin resistance if you do you're
going to want to start on the lower end
the second has to do with your activity
level in general the more active you are
the more tolerant you are to
carbohydrates and the last has to do
with your genetics which is a wild card
there will always be some people who
just don't fit the mold and they'll be
able to get by with excessively high
doses of carbohydrates or excessively
low doses of carbohydrates Without
Really impacting their physiology but
these people represent the exception not
the rule each of these variables will
impact how many carbohydrates you should
have but at Baseline my recommendation
is that all thyroid patients should have
at least 100 G of carbohydrates each day
and this includes by the way even those
with pre-diabetes diabetes and any form
of insulin resistance to put this 100 G
recommendation into context here's a
list of foods and their corresponding
carbohydrate content one cup of
blueberries contains 21 g 1 cup of
orange juice contains 26 g 1 tbspoon of
Honey contains 17 G one mediumsized
potato with the skin on contains about
26 G and one banana contains 27 G this
means that on the low end you should
have no problem hitting your daily
recommended intake of three to five
servings of fruit each day and the
number just goes up from here depending
on how active you are and whether or not
you have insulin resistance but before
you run out and start pounding down
carbohydrates you need to know this one
thing the source of your carbohydrates
matters having a budget of 100 gram of
carbohydrates each day doesn't give you
free rain to go run out there and start
pounding down things like candy bars
pizzas pastries cakes and any other
processed foods yes these foods do
contain carbohydrates but they contain
processed and refined sources that
should be avoided instead of these
sources here are the types of
carbohydrates you should be consuming
Whole Foods of all types fresh or frozen
fruits fresh or frozen vegetables
including by the way starchy vegetables
natural sweeteners such as honey Agave
date syrup and Maple syr syrup and 100%
fresh squeezed fruit juice including
juices like orange juice apple juice
pomegranate juice and so on some thyroid
patients have an immediate knee-jerk
reaction when they hear this to
automatically assume that eating this
way will somehow cause them to gain
weight but I can assure you that it
won't and I have several studies to
prove it here's one that shows that
fruit has an anti-obesity effect here's
another showing that fruit intake is
inversely associated with weight gain
over four years in other words the more
fruit you eat the leaner you are here
here's one showing the consumption of
fruit juices does not cause weight gain
in children and is not associated with
type 2 diabetes in adults and here's one
showing that adult consumers of 100%
fruit juices such as orange juice have a
lower BMI and better metabolic markers
compared to those who do not consume
them the bottom line don't be afraid of
carbohydrates if you have hypothyroidism
even if you have diabetes or insulin
resistance while it may seem
counterintuitive at first consuming more
carbohydrates will help you lose weight
by increasing and optimizing your
thyroid function the better your thyroid
is operating the higher your metabolism
will be and the easier it will be to
stay lean avoiding carbohydrates is one
of the most common mistakes that I see
thyroid patients make when they're
trying to lose weight and if you want to
see the other mistakes that thyroid
patients make then I'd recommend
checking out this video next